Category: Tax Law

  • Liberty Global Is Now Tenth Circuit Law: Economic Substance Risk for Colorado Tax Strategies

    Liberty Global Is Now Tenth Circuit Law: Economic Substance Risk for Colorado Tax Strategies

    Stella owns a civil engineering firm in Golden. It is an S corporation netting about $1.4 million a year, and that profit lands on her personal return. In October 2026 her wealth adviser introduced a promoter with a year end “structure”: a $95,000 fee, documents signed before December 31, and a $1.2 million deduction for 2026, with a law firm opinion letter included. Her CPA is uneasy and cannot say why in one sentence.

    Here it is. If the IRS decides the structure lacks economic substance, the deduction disappears and a 20 or 40 percent penalty applies with no reasonable cause defense, opinion letter or not. For a Colorado owner, the rules come from a Tenth Circuit decision that went against the taxpayer this year.

    Listen to this post

    North Star Tax and Legal Briefing: Liberty Global Is Now Tenth Circuit Law: Economic Substance Risk for Colorado Tax Strategies

    A five minute briefing on the economic substance doctrine after the Tenth Circuit's Liberty Global decision: why a packaged year end deduction can cost a Colorado owner the deduction plus a 20 or 40 percent penalty, and what to ask a promoter before signing.

    Download the MP3 · Episode page on Podbean

    Show / hide the episode transcript

    A Colorado business owner gets a pitch in October. Call her Stella. She is fictional, but her problem is not. Stella owns a civil engineering firm in Golden, an S corporation netting about one point four million dollars a year. A promoter offers her a year end structure: a ninety five thousand dollar fee, documents signed before December thirty first, and a one point two million dollar deduction, with a law firm opinion letter included. Her CPA is uneasy and cannot say why in one sentence. Here is the sentence. If the I R S decides the structure has no economic substance, the deduction disappears, and a penalty of twenty or forty percent applies that no opinion letter can excuse.

    The economic substance doctrine lets the I R S disregard a transaction that has no real effect apart from saving tax. Since two thousand ten, the test has been written into the tax code, and it has two parts. First, the transaction has to change your economic position in a meaningful way, setting the federal income tax savings aside. Second, you need a substantial purpose for doing it other than tax. The I R S requires both. Passing one is not enough.

    Here is the distinction to hold on to. An ordinary deduction that gets disallowed is usually an argument about facts and records. An economic substance disallowance is different in kind. The I R S is saying the arrangement changed nothing except the tax bill, and harsher penalty rules follow.

    For Colorado, the rules now come from the Tenth Circuit, the federal appeals court that covers the state. In April of this year, in the Liberty Global case, a divided panel ruled against the taxpayer. A four step plan had been built so that a two point four billion dollar internal gain could be offset by a dividend deduction, supporting a refund claim of close to one hundred ten million dollars. The majority held that the doctrine applies when a taxpayer uses tax code provisions mechanically to get a benefit Congress did not intend. The full court declined to rehear the case in August, and Liberty Global has until December fifteenth to ask the Supreme Court to take it. For now, the decision binds the federal courts in Colorado.

    And this is not only a problem for multinationals. Years earlier, the same court threw out a loss of roughly sixty million dollars that an individual had claimed through his S corporation.

    Now the other side. One judge dissented, worried about a business that uses a provision exactly as written. And the explanation prepared for Congress says the law was not meant to disturb basic choices, like financing with debt or with equity. An S election or a retirement plan contribution sits far closer to that list than a purchased deduction, though nothing is immune.

    Back to Stella. Suppose she claims the one point two million dollars and the I R S disallows it. Using simplified math, that adds four hundred forty four thousand dollars of federal tax, plus fifty two thousand eight hundred dollars to Colorado, because the state return starts from federal taxable income. Then the penalty. Eighty eight thousand eight hundred dollars at twenty percent, or one hundred seventy seven thousand six hundred dollars at forty percent if the facts were not adequately disclosed on the return. Add the promoter’s fee, and the undisclosed version costs about seven hundred sixty nine thousand four hundred dollars before interest.

    And the usual defense is gone. With most accuracy penalties, relying on professional advice can show reasonable cause. For this penalty, the law removes that defense. The opinion letter may help her argue for the deduction itself. It does not protect her from the penalty. And Tax Court probably offers no better rule. For a Colorado resident, it follows the Tenth Circuit.

    So what do you do this week? First, make the promoter answer one question: if the tax benefit were zero, what changes in my company’s economic position? Second, ask what profit is expected before tax, and whether it is substantial next to the tax savings. Third, ask how many other people bought the same structure, and whether the fee is refundable if the deduction fails. A fee like that carries its own disclosure requirement. And if a strategy is already going on a return, know that adequate disclosure on a timely return drops the penalty from forty percent to twenty. It does not save the deduction.

    That’s what we do at North Star Law Firm. The initial consultation is free, and the full written analysis with citations is at c o dash legal dot net.

    What did the Tenth Circuit decide in Liberty Global, and is it final?

    The economic substance doctrine lets the IRS disregard a transaction with no real effect apart from tax savings. Since 2010, 26 U.S.C. § 7701(o) says a transaction to which the doctrine is “relevant” passes only if it changes the taxpayer’s economic position in a meaningful way, apart from federal income tax effects, and the taxpayer had a substantial nontax purpose. The IRS requires both (Notice 2010-62).

    Commentary from late 2025 called the Colorado case a pending appeal. In Liberty Global, Inc. v. United States, 174 F.4th 1208 (10th Cir. 2026), decided April 21, 2026, a divided panel affirmed the District of Colorado. A four step plan had created foreign earnings so that a $2.4 billion internal gain could be offset by a § 245A dividend deduction, supporting a refund claim of close to $110 million. Judge Murphy’s majority called the dispute over a separate threshold relevance test “a red herring” on these facts and held the doctrine relevant when a taxpayer uses Code provisions mechanically “to obtain a benefit not intended by Congress.” Judge Eid dissented.

    The court denied rehearing en banc on August 17, 2026, with Judges Hartz, Tymkovich and Eid voting to rehear. On November 5, 2026 Justice Gorsuch extended the time to petition for certiorari from November 15 to December 15, 2026 (Application No. 26A628). No petition was docketed as of November 13, so the panel opinion binds the federal courts in Colorado.

    Does the economic substance doctrine reach a Colorado business owner, or only multinationals?

    It reaches owners like Stella. Sala v. United States, 613 F.3d 1249 (10th Cir. 2010) came up from the federal court in Denver, where an individual had won on a roughly $60 million loss from a currency options program run through his S corporation. The Tenth Circuit reversed for lack of objective economic substance. The statute excludes an individual’s personal transactions, but only those outside a trade or business or investment activity (§ 7701(o)(5)(B)), and a series of steps counts as one transaction (§ 7701(o)(5)(D)).

    In my experience, what reaches a closely held business is the packaged product: one design sold to many buyers, each getting a deduction sized to their income. The microcaptive insurance case discussed below is one. Syndicated conservation easements are another; the IRS’s 2026 Dirty Dozen (IR-2026-30) flags inflated easement appraisals, and § 170(h)(7) now denies the deduction entirely when a partnership’s or S corporation’s easement contribution exceeds 2.5 times the owners’ relevant basis, with limited exceptions. Colorado has its own easement credit under C.R.S. § 39-22-522, with certificates from the Division of Conservation; the state credit and the federal doctrine are separate questions.

    The Joint Committee on Taxation’s 2010 explanation (JCX-18-10, at 152 to 53) says the law was not meant to disturb basic choices like debt versus equity financing, a subchapter C reorganization, or a related party deal priced at arm’s length under § 482. An S election or a retirement plan contribution sits far closer to that list than a purchased deduction, though nothing is immune.

    Why can’t an opinion letter stop the 40 percent economic substance penalty?

    Section 6662(b)(6) imposes a 20 percent penalty on an underpayment from a transaction lacking economic substance, and § 6662(i) makes it 40 percent if the relevant facts were not adequately disclosed on the return. Under Notice 2010-62 that means Form 8275 or 8275-R, plus the Form 8886 statement under Treas. Reg. § 1.6011-4 for a reportable transaction. An amended return filed after the IRS first contacts you does not count.

    Reasonable cause, often shown by relying on professional advice, is the usual defense to accuracy penalties. Section 6664(c)(2) removes it for this penalty, and § 6676(c) does the same for refund claims. An opinion letter may help on the merits but not on this penalty.

    What remains is procedure: § 6751(b) requires written supervisory approval of the initial penalty determination, as the IRS manual repeats for these penalties (IRM Exhibit 4.46.4-4). The old executive signoff was reportedly dropped in 2022.

    Would a Colorado taxpayer get a better rule in Tax Court under Patel?

    Probably not. In Patel v. Commissioner, 165 T.C. 171 (2025), a reviewed opinion filed November 12, 2025, the Tax Court held that § 7701(o) requires a relevance determination drawn from the earlier case law, as § 7701(o)(5)(C) directs. It then found the doctrine relevant to the Patels’ microcaptive insurance arrangements, found both prongs failed, and sustained the 20 percent penalty for 2014 through 2016 and the 40 percent rate for 2014 and 2015. The Patels have appealed to the Fifth Circuit.

    Under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), the Tax Court follows a court of appeals decision squarely in point when the appeal lies to that court. Golsen is itself a Tenth Circuit case, affirmed at 445 F.2d 985 (10th Cir. 1971), where life insurance loan interest was disallowed for lack of economic substance. An individual’s appeal goes to the circuit of legal residence when the petition is filed (§ 7482(b)(1)), absent a written stipulation. Stella gets the Tenth Circuit’s standard. Forum still matters for other reasons; see my post on Tax Court versus a refund suit.

    The conflict is narrower than it sounds. The majority never cites Patel or expressly rejects a threshold step; relevance is met when a taxpayer pursues a benefit Congress did not intend. Patel requires a separate step but still applied the doctrine to a marketed product. For a purchased deduction, I would expect both tests to find relevance. The gap matters more for a business using a provision exactly as written, which is Judge Eid’s concern.

    What would a disallowed year end strategy cost a Golden engineering firm owner?

    Illustrative only, with simplified math. Stella claims the $1.2 million deduction on her 2026 return and files on April 15, 2027. The IRS generally has until April 15, 2030 to assess (§ 6501(a)). The six year rule in § 6501(e) targets omitted income, not an overstated deduction, but an undisclosed listed transaction stays open until one year after the information is furnished (§ 6501(c)(10)).

    Treating the whole amount as taxed at the 37 percent top rate for 2026, which slightly overstates it, (IR-2025-103), disallowance adds $444,000 of federal tax. Colorado’s 4.40 percent tax for 2026 starts from federal taxable income (C.R.S. § 39-22-104), adding $52,800. The penalty is $88,800 at 20 percent or $177,600 at 40 percent, plus interest from April 15, 2027 under § 6601(a). With the $95,000 fee, the undisclosed version costs about $769,400 before interest. A notice of deficiency gives her 90 days to petition the Tax Court (§ 6213(a)), which tries Colorado cases in Denver; see choosing a Colorado place of trial.

    What should a Colorado owner ask before signing up for a packaged tax strategy?

    Make the promoter answer the statute. If the tax benefit were zero, what changes in my firm’s economic position? What profit is expected before tax, and is it substantial next to the tax savings? Section 7701(o)(2) counts profit potential only on that comparison and treats fees as expenses. Colorado savings do not help: § 7701(o)(3) treats related state tax effects like federal ones.

    Then ask how many others bought it and whether it needs a Form 8886. A fee refundable if the deduction fails, or tied to the tax saved, makes it a reportable transaction with contractual protection under Treas. Reg. § 1.6011-4(b)(4). The Supreme Court framed the core question in 1935 in Gregory v. Helvering, 293 U.S. 465: what was done “apart from the tax motive.”

    Issue Ordinary disallowed deduction Economic substance disallowance
    Penalty rate 20 percent, if negligent or a substantial understatement 20 percent of any underpayment; 40 percent if undisclosed
    Reasonable cause Available under § 6664(c)(1) Barred by § 6664(c)(2)
    Opinion letter Can support reasonable cause No penalty protection
    Disclosure Can reduce the understatement penalty under § 6662(d)(2)(B) Avoids only the 40 percent rate
    Forum for a Coloradan Appeals, then Tax Court in Denver Same, or a refund suit in the District of Colorado (Tenth Circuit law) or the Court of Federal Claims (Federal Circuit law)

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is Liberty Global final?

    The Tenth Circuit’s decision stands, and rehearing en banc was denied on August 17, 2026. Liberty Global has until December 15, 2026 to petition the Supreme Court.

    Does Patel help a Colorado taxpayer in Tax Court?

    Only where it does not conflict with the Tenth Circuit. Under Golsen, the Tax Court follows the circuit that hears the appeal, for a Colorado resident the Tenth Circuit.

    Can reasonable cause excuse the economic substance penalty?

    No. Section 6664(c)(2) removes that exception, so the defenses are that the transaction had substance, that the doctrine is not relevant, or that the IRS skipped a required step such as written supervisory approval.

    Does disclosing the strategy on my return help?

    Adequate disclosure on a timely return drops the penalty from 40 to 20 percent. It does not save the deduction.

    How long does the IRS have to challenge a 2026 deduction?

    Generally three years after the return is filed. An undisclosed listed transaction stays open until one year after the required information reaches the IRS.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm reviews proposed tax strategies for Colorado business owners before they sign, defends IRS audits of strategies already claimed, challenges penalties, and handles Tax Court litigation at the Denver trial session. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If a promoter is offering you a year end deduction, or the IRS is already asking about one, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Changing an Irrevocable Trust in Colorado: Decanting, Settlement Agreements and Tax

    Changing an Irrevocable Trust in Colorado: Decanting, Settlement Agreements and Tax

    Beatriz lives in Steamboat Springs and is the successor trustee of an irrevocable trust her father signed in Illinois in 2009. It holds about $3.1 million, mostly a rental duplex in town and a brokerage account. Her mother gets the income for life; then the principal splits between Beatriz and her brother, each taking outright at 30. Her brother is 27 and has a gambling problem, and the trust has no spendthrift clause.

    She wants to hold his share in a discretionary trust for his lifetime, rewrite trustee succession, and run the trust from Colorado. Colorado law offers ways to do that without a judge. My job, as a tax lawyer, is the federal bill that can come with each one.

    Can you modify an irrevocable trust in Colorado without going to court?

    Often, yes. A trustee with broad discretion over principal can decant under the Colorado Uniform Trust Decanting Act, C.R.S. §§ 15-16-901 to -930. The people whose interests are affected can sign a nonjudicial settlement agreement under C.R.S. § 15-5-111. A trust director can act if the document names one.

    That last route is narrow. Under C.R.S. § 15-16-806, a director holds the powers the trust terms grant and little more; Colorado has no freestanding statutory trust protector power. If nothing works out of court, a judge can modify with all beneficiaries’ consent (§ 15-5-411), for circumstances the settlor did not anticipate (§ 15-5-412), or to meet the settlor’s tax objectives, even retroactively (§ 15-5-416).

    How does Colorado trust decanting work, and does it fit this trust?

    Under C.R.S. § 15-16-911, a trustee whose power to distribute principal is not limited to an ascertainable standard may pour the trust into a second trust with new terms. It cannot add beneficiaries or “reduce or eliminate a vested interest.” A trustee held to a standard such as health and support must give each beneficiary “substantially similar” interests (§ 15-16-912).

    Here is the catch. If the 2009 trust gives the trustee no discretion over principal, there is no decanting power at all, and a fixed right to principal at termination is a vested interest unless someone could distribute that property elsewhere. Decanting works for Beatriz only if the instrument lets the trustee invade principal for her mother, and only if her brother’s descendants already appear in it as contingent takers.

    Notice under § 15-16-907 must go out at least 63 days before the trustee acts, not the 60 days often quoted, unless everyone waives in writing. Court approval is optional under § 15-16-909, which also lets a court appoint a special fiduciary when the trustee is a beneficiary too. The tax limits in § 15-16-919(2) protect marital and charitable deductions, the annual exclusion, S corporation eligibility, and a zero inclusion ratio under 26 U.S.C. § 2642(c). None of them stops a beneficiary from making a gift.

    Is a beneficiary’s consent to a Colorado nonjudicial settlement agreement a taxable gift?

    It can be. When the brother signs away an outright share for a discretionary interest, he gives something up for nothing. Treas. Reg. § 25.2511-1(c)(1) taxes gratuitous transfers “regardless of the means or device employed,” and § 25.2512-8 reaches transfers for less than full value.

    In Chief Counsel Advice 202352018 (released Dec. 29, 2023), beneficiaries consented to a court modification adding a tax reimbursement clause, and Chief Counsel said it “will constitute a taxable gift” by them. The memo adds that the answer is the same when “a beneficiary fails to exercise their right to object” under a notice statute. Colorado’s decanting act gives notice and a path to court, so I do not call decanting automatically gift free. A trustee acting on discretion the beneficiaries cannot veto stands on better ground, but nothing published settles it, and Rev. Proc. 2026-3, section 4.01(55), says the IRS will not ordinarily rule on the question.

    There is a second trap. Because the brother’s new trust benefits his family, 26 U.S.C. § 2702 can value the interest he keeps at zero unless the gift is drafted to be incomplete.

    How large could the brother’s gift be in a Steamboat Springs example?

    Illustrative only. Assume Beatriz’s mother is 70 and the brother’s remainder is half of $3.1 million, or $1,550,000. At the November 2026 § 7520 rate of 6.20 percent (Rev. Rul. 2026-21), the IRS Table S remainder factor for age 70 is 0.44035, so his remainder is worth about $682,543. If he gives up roughly half, Route A (a settlement agreement he signs) produces a gift near $341,271. If § 2702 zeroes out what he keeps, the IRS could argue for $682,543.

    Either way he files Form 709. A future interest gets no annual exclusion ($19,000 for 2026 under Rev. Proc. 2025-32), so § 6019 requires a return, due April 15, 2027 for a 2026 signing (§ 6075(b)). Tax is unlikely against the $15,000,000 basic exclusion for 2026, but he uses some of it. For 2027, IR-2026-133 (Nov. 5, 2026) and Rev. Proc. 2026-35 set $20,000 and $15,480,000; our Colorado 2026 year end estate and gift guide covers the exclusion in more detail.

    Route B, a decanting after notice, gives the brother nothing to sign. If the trustee’s discretion supports it and her file shows a fiduciary reason, the gift case against him is weaker, subject to the notice point above.

    Can changing a trust trigger income tax, GST tax, or estate tax for a beneficiary?

    Under Cottage Savings Ass’n v. Commissioner, 499 U.S. 554 (1991), swapping property for something “materially different” is a realization event under 26 U.S.C. § 1001. Beneficiaries trading interests can fall inside that rule; a new trustee or a new place of administration does not. With her father dead, no grantor is left to be taxed under 26 U.S.C. §§ 671 and following, so the second trust stays a nongrantor trust unless someone receives owner powers.

    The trust was never GST exempt, so its inclusion ratio under § 2642 is presumably one, meaning no allocated exemption shelters it. A lifetime trust passing to the brother’s children creates a taxable termination at his death unless the property is in his estate, which makes him the transferor under § 2652(a)(1). A testamentary general power does that through § 2041 and earns a new basis, which Rev. Rul. 2023-2 ties to estate inclusion. If he ever serves as trustee, distributions to himself should stay within Treas. Reg. § 20.2041-1(c)(2)‘s health, education, support and maintenance standard. The grandfathered trust safe harbor in Treas. Reg. § 26.2601-1(b)(4)(i)(D), applied in PLR 202518009 (2025), does not reach this trust.

    Route A also raises an estate tax question. If consenting makes the brother a partial settlor of a trust that can pay him, § 2036 and § 2038 come into play. And under C.R.S. § 15-5-505(1)(b), a settlor’s creditors can reach the most that could be distributed to him. For a gambler, the portion he funded may be the portion his creditors take.

    What happens when you move a trust to Colorado for administration?

    Under C.R.S. § 15-5-108(5), qualified beneficiaries get at least 60 days’ notice, and a timely objection suspends the move. Governing law does not change on its own; under § 15-5-107, the law the trust designates generally controls, so Illinois law may still govern this 2009 instrument.

    Under C.R.S. § 39-22-103(10), a trust “administered in this state” is a resident trust, and the Colorado Department of Revenue requires Form 105. The duplex rents are Colorado source income either way, so the trust already files as a nonresident. If it keeps $50,000 of capital gains in principal in 2026, Colorado tax at 4.40 percent is $2,200 (illustrative). Amendment 87, a graduated rate measure on the November 3, 2026 ballot, would replace the flat rate beginning in 2027 if it is certified as approved; as of November 6, 2026 the count was close and no result had been certified. Leaving Illinois needs an Illinois opinion.

    Route Who acts, Colorado statute Typical gift tax exposure Income or GST issue
    Settlement agreement All materially affected parties; § 15-5-111 High for a beneficiary whose share shrinks Possible exchange; signer may become partial transferor
    Decanting Trustee after 63 days’ notice; § 15-16-911 Lower; “failure to object” theory remains Later taxable termination absent estate inclusion
    Trust director Director, if the instrument grants it; § 15-16-806 Turns on who holds the power Same GST planning as decanting
    Court order Judge; §§ 15-5-411, -412, -416 Consent under § 15-5-411 carries the agreement risk The order does not bind the IRS

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can a Colorado trustee change an irrevocable trust without the beneficiaries’ signatures?

    Sometimes. A trustee with discretion over principal can decant after at least 63 days’ notice. Without that discretion, an agreement or a court order is usually needed.

    Does moving a trust to Colorado make it a Colorado taxpayer?

    Yes. A trust administered in Colorado is a resident trust and files Form 105. Colorado real estate produces Colorado source income wherever the trust is run.

    Will the IRS issue a private ruling approving a decanting?

    Not ordinarily, if beneficial interests change. Rev. Proc. 2026-3 lists the gift question as an area where rulings will not ordinarily issue.

    Do I report my consent to a trust change on a gift tax return?

    If your interest shrinks and someone else’s grows, the IRS may treat your consent as a gift. Because it is a future interest, the annual exclusion usually does not apply, so Form 709 is generally required even when no tax is due.

    Does Colorado tax gifts or estates when a trust is changed?

    No. Colorado has no gift, estate or inheritance tax, so the transfer tax exposure is federal. Colorado’s role is fiduciary income tax and the trust law that decides validity.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm advises Colorado trustees and beneficiaries on the federal tax side of trust changes, including gift returns, GST exposure and Colorado fiduciary filings, through its trust and estate tax planning and real estate tax strategy work, and represents clients in IRS examinations when a gift return is questioned. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    The tax analysis belongs in the file before anyone signs an agreement or mails a decanting notice. If you are a trustee or beneficiary thinking about rewriting an irrevocable trust, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • NIL and Revenue Share Taxes for Colorado College Athletes and Their Parents

    NIL and Revenue Share Taxes for Colorado College Athletes and Their Parents

    Jada is 19 and a sophomore on a volleyball roster in Boulder. Her Texas parents claim her as a dependent. In 2026 she signed with a Boulder outdoor brand and a Denver car dealer for $38,000, her school paid her $14,000 of revenue share, the brand shipped her about $3,000 of gear, and a collective covered the lease on a used SUV. Nobody withheld a dollar, and her father is worried about April.

    Most of it carries income tax plus self-employment tax, Colorado gets a slice, and her parents’ return is now in play. A first year earner often gets one pass on federal estimated tax penalties; Colorado’s pass is narrower.

    Is NIL money taxable in Colorado, and is it self-employment income?

    Usually yes. A brand paying for posts, shoots and appearances is buying services, reported on Schedule C. Self-employment tax under 26 U.S.C. § 1401 is 12.4 percent for Social Security plus 2.9 percent for Medicare, applied to 92.35 percent of net earnings under § 1402(a)(12). The Social Security piece stops at the 2026 wage base of $184,500 (SSA notice), and half the tax is deductible under § 164(f).

    Gear and the car count. When services are paid in property, Treas. Reg. § 1.61-2(d)(1) puts the fair market value in income, and the IRS’s NIL page agrees. A collective that pays an athlete’s lease is paying her.

    For payments after December 31, 2025, the 1099-NEC trigger in § 6041(a) rose from $600 to $2,000 (Pub. L. 119-21, § 70433), so a $1,500 appearance may come with no form. It is still income.

    Are House settlement revenue share payments taxable, and why did the school send two 1099s?

    The settlement in In re College Athlete NIL Litigation, No. 4:20-cv-03919-CW (N.D. Cal. June 6, 2025) lets Division I schools pay athletes from a capped pool; the order is silent on tax. Colorado moved first: HB25-1041, signed March 28, 2025, amended C.R.S. § 23-16-301 so Colorado schools may pay athletes for their name, image and likeness.

    The payments are taxable; the label varies. CU’s athletics department told families it treats athletes as independent contractors, withholds nothing, and may issue both a 1099-NEC and a 1099-MISC because the payment is partly a license fee (CU guidance). The split matters: the IRS page says a payment purely for use of a likeness, with no personal services, is a Schedule E royalty outside self-employment tax. As of November 6, 2026 I found no ruling, notice or regulation on revenue share, and the web page is not precedent.

    In AM 2023-004, Chief Counsel found that many collectives serve athletes’ private interests, which threatens their charity status. It does not make Jada’s lease a gift.

    Does a Texas athlete at a Colorado school owe Colorado income tax?

    On part of it. Under C.R.S. § 39-22-103(8)(a), a resident is someone domiciled here, or someone who keeps a permanent place of abode here and spends more than six months of the year here. Jada plans to return to Texas, so her domicile stays there, but watch the second test if she rents in Boulder year round; the Department of Revenue’s nonresident guidance does not address students.

    As a nonresident she owes tax only on Colorado source income. C.R.S. § 39-22-109 reaches a business carried on here, and the Department treats personal service income as Colorado source when the person did the work here. Form 104PN computes tax as if she were a resident, at the 4.40 percent rate in § 39-22-104(1.7)(c), then multiplies by Colorado AGI over federal AGI. Intangible income is Colorado source for a nonresident only if tied to a Colorado business, so the royalty slice deserves a second look.

    California requires a nonresident with California income to file once worldwide gross income tops $22,941 for a single filer under 65 in 2025 (FTB instructions). Texas has no income tax. A Colorado domiciled athlete playing in Oregon owes Colorado on everything, with a capped credit for Oregon’s tax under C.R.S. § 39-22-108.

    Nonresident aliens owe no self-employment tax under § 1402(b), but U.S. source royalties face 30 percent tax and withholding under § 871(a) and § 1441 absent a treaty, and student visas restrict paid work. See our post on the substantial presence test in Colorado.

    What does a Boulder athlete’s 2026 NIL tax bill look like, and when are estimated payments due?

    Jada’s year, illustrative and rounded: assume the school reports all $14,000 on a 1099-NEC, the lease runs $550 a month ($6,600), and the brand deal includes $4,000 for two California appearances and $1,500 for one in Texas. Gross receipts are $61,600. After a 15 percent agent fee ($5,700), training ($1,800), travel ($1,600) and phone and content costs ($1,200), net profit is $51,300.

    Self-employment tax is about $7,248, and the $3,624 deduction leaves AGI at $47,676. The 2026 dependent cap in Rev. Proc. 2025-32 (the greater of $1,350 or earned income plus $450) does not bite, so her standard deduction is the full $16,100. The § 199A deduction is capped at 20 percent of taxable income, here $6,315. Endorsement income is a specified service business under Treas. Reg. § 1.199A-5(b)(2)(xiv), which matters only above the 2026 threshold of $201,750. Taxable income is about $25,261, income tax $2,783, and the federal total about $10,032.

    For Colorado, $1,111 of full year tax times a 94 percent apportionment ($48,225 of her net is Colorado work) gives roughly $1,045. California’s share sits on about $2,300 of net.

    Federal installments under § 6654(c) fall on April 15, June 15, September 15 and January 15. If Jada, a U.S. citizen, owed nothing for 2025, § 6654(e)(2) erases any 2026 penalty, so paying $10,032 on April 15, 2027 works once. In 2027 the required payment becomes the lesser of 90 percent of 2027 tax or 100 percent of 2026 tax: about $2,508 a quarter, the first due the same April 15 as her 2026 balance.

    C.R.S. § 39-22-605 uses the same dates and a $1,000 floor, but its zero prior year exception requires Colorado residence throughout the prior year, and its prior year safe harbor requires a Colorado return for that year. A Texan filing here for the first time gets neither. With $1,045 of tax, she should have paid 70 percent during 2026; the charge is figured as interest on the shortfall. Under § 6654(h) and § 39-22-605(9), filing and paying in full by January 31, 2027 cures the January installment.

    Can parents still claim an NIL athlete as a dependent?

    Maybe not. A qualifying child under § 152(c)(1)(D) must not provide more than half of her own support, and § 152(f)(5) leaves scholarships out of the count. Spending decides it. If Jada pays $12,000 of rent and food, the $6,600 lease counts as support she provided, and her parents spend $9,000, they lose her as a dependent.

    The kiddie tax in § 1(g) reaches only unearned income, such as a royalty slice, and skips a student 18 to 23 whose earned income exceeds half of her support, as Jada’s does. The American Opportunity Credit under § 25A phases out between $160,000 and $180,000 of joint income and needs expenses the scholarship did not cover. Under § 117, scholarship money for tuition, fees and required books is excluded, and Rev. Rul. 77-263 lets athletic scholarships qualify; room and board is taxable.

    Should a college athlete form an LLC or S corp for NIL income?

    Usually not. An S corporation saves payroll tax only on profit above a reasonable salary. At a $32,000 salary, payroll tax would be about $4,896 against roughly $7,248 now. Payroll service, a Form 1120-S and the Secretary of State’s $50 LLC filing and $25 periodic report (fee schedule) eat much of that, and her school’s W-9 runs to her personally. A single member LLC alone changes nothing for tax. See our post on LLC vs S corp vs C corp tax math in Colorado.

    As of November 6, 2026, no federal NIL bill is law; the SCORE Act (H.R. 4312) has not passed the House, and the Senate’s Protect College Sports Act is pending.

    Payment Federal character and form Self-employment tax Colorado, nonresident athlete
    Brand NIL deal Schedule C; 1099-NEC at $2,000 or more for 2026 Yes Taxed on work done in Colorado; apportioned on Form 104PN
    School revenue share Schedule C for services, Schedule E for a pure royalty; 1099-NEC, 1099-MISC or both Yes on services; no on a true royalty Service part taxed; royalty sourcing is an open question
    Collective paid car lease Fair market value is compensation; often no form Yes Taxed if the services were performed in Colorado
    Free gear Fair market value is compensation Yes Taxed if tied to Colorado work

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Do I owe tax on NIL money if I never got a 1099?

    Yes. The 1099 is an information return, not the source of the tax. For 2026 payments a 1099-NEC is required only at $2,000 or more.

    Are House settlement revenue share payments subject to self-employment tax?

    The part paid for services generally is. The IRS says a payment purely for use of your likeness is a royalty outside self-employment tax. Check which forms your school issued.

    I am an out of state athlete living in Colorado. Do I file a Colorado return?

    If you earned Colorado source income, you likely file Form 104 with Form 104PN. Keeping a Colorado home and spending over six months here can make you a resident.

    When is my first estimated tax payment due if I start getting NIL money?

    Federal and Colorado installments are due April 15, June 15, September 15 and January 15. Owing no federal tax the year before can excuse a first year federal penalty. Colorado’s exception requires prior Colorado residence.

    Can my parents still claim me if I earn NIL income?

    Only if you did not provide over half of your own support. Scholarships are left out of that count; rent and food paid from NIL money are not.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm helps athletes and families with federal tax planning, Colorado state tax questions, entity choices and returns that were never filed. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If your athlete’s deals came in this fall and January 15 is close, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • DOJ v. McNutt and Colorado Home Distilling: What Changes for Hobbyists and Distillers

    DOJ v. McNutt and Colorado Home Distilling: What Changes for Hobbyists and Distillers

    Marcus has pressed apples and fermented hard cider in his Salida garage for years. He read that a federal appeals court struck down the home distilling ban, and now he wants to run a few gallons through a small pot still and age it as apple brandy. A friend who owns a licensed craft distillery in town asks the other half: if the ban falls, does her federal permit or quarterly excise tax change?

    For Marcus, nothing he read makes a garage still lawful in Colorado. For his friend, nothing turns on the case. The reasons matter, because Department of Justice v. McNutt, now at the Supreme Court, turns on a question about the taxing power that reaches well past whiskey.

    Is home distilling legal in Colorado after the Fifth Circuit’s McNutt ruling?

    No. Under 26 U.S.C. § 5178(a)(1)(B), no distilled spirits plant may be located “in any dwelling house, in any shed, yard, or inclosure connected with any dwelling house.” The Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB) regulation at 27 C.F.R. § 19.51 is blunter: “A person may not produce distilled spirits at home for personal use.”

    The ruling protects people, not a region. The government’s cert petition describes the injunction entered in Hobby Distillers Ass’n v. Alcohol & Tobacco Tax & Trade Bureau, 740 F. Supp. 3d 509 (N.D. Tex. 2024), as running “against McNutt, the association, and the association’s members.” Colorado sits in the Tenth Circuit, which has not ruled on the ban. Unless Marcus is a plaintiff or a Hobby Distillers Association member, the ban still binds him, and membership would not fix his state law problem.

    What did the Fifth and Sixth Circuits hold, and what is the Supreme Court deciding in DOJ v. McNutt?

    In McNutt v. U.S. Department of Justice, 173 F.4th 204 (5th Cir. 2026), decided April 10, 2026, the panel held that the ban collects nothing, so it falls outside the taxing power, and is not “necessary and proper” either. It leaned on NFIB v. Sebelius, 567 U.S. 519, 574 (2012), which limits the taxing power to “requiring an individual to pay money into the Federal Treasury, no more.” It refused to read United States v. Comstock, 560 U.S. 126 (2010) as a rational basis test, and warned that the government’s logic had no stopping point.

    Eleven days later, Ream v. U.S. Department of the Treasury, 174 F.4th 480 (6th Cir. 2026) agreed the taxing power alone could not carry the ban but upheld it as necessary and proper. Judge Kethledge pointed to the “stupendous frauds” Congress documented in 1867 and to how much harder a house is to inspect, concluding that “empirically, alcohol is sui generis, or very close to it.”

    The docket in No. 26-204 shows certiorari granted October 19, 2026, on whether the location ban “is necessary and proper for carrying into execution Congress’s enumerated power to lay and collect taxes.” As of November 6, 2026, no argument date is listed. Ream’s petition, No. 26-93, remains pending. Ohio and 14 other states filed an amicus brief there; Colorado did not join.

    What federal penalties does a Colorado home distiller face under 26 U.S.C. 5601?

    Several; McNutt challenged one. Section 5601(a) makes each of these a felony carrying up to $10,000 and five years per offense: possessing an unregistered still (paragraph (1)), distilling in a dwelling or connected shed or yard (paragraph (6)), making a wash fit for distillation off a qualified plant (paragraph (7)), and producing spirits without being “a distiller authorized by law” (paragraph (8)). Sections 5602 (fraud) and 5604 (closures and marks) add more.

    Forfeiture is the harsher piece. Under § 5615, an unregistered still is forfeited with nearby personal property, and someone distilling without bond can lose his interest “in the lot or tract of land on which the distillery is situated.” The tax attaches “as soon as this substance is in existence” under § 5001(b), and § 5006(c)(2) makes it “due and payable immediately upon production” for spirits made outside a qualified plant. Marcus would owe $13.50 per proof gallon on brandy he never sold.

    What would a Supreme Court win for McNutt change for a Colorado hobbyist?

    Less than headlines suggest. A win removes the location ban and paragraph (6). Registration under § 5171, still registration under § 5179, the permit requirement and the tax all stay. The Fifth Circuit said a home distiller would then stand “on the same level as current licensees,” paperwork included.

    For beer and wine, Pub. L. 95-458 (1978) shaped today’s household exemptions in § 5042(a)(2) and § 5053(e): 200 gallons a calendar year with two or more adults, 100 with one. Congress never wrote a spirits counterpart, and no court can.

    Colorado law runs separately. A manufacturer’s license under C.R.S. § 44-3-402 goes to persons “distilling, rectifying, or brewing within this state,” and the home exception in C.R.S. § 44-3-106(2) reaches only malt and vinous liquors made in conformity with federal law. I found no Colorado exception for home spirits; Colorado licensed counsel should confirm for any specific plan.

    So Marcus can keep making cider, which federal law treats as wine (§ 5041(g)), within the household limit. A lawful still means a fuel alcohol plant under § 5181, with the product used only as fuel. Beverage brandy would still need federal qualification and a Colorado license after a McNutt win in 2027.

    What does a licensed Colorado craft distillery owe in federal excise tax and Colorado distillery tax?

    TTB’s list of permittees showed 178 Colorado distilled spirits plant permits as of November 2, 2026, tenth among the states, each registered on TTB F 5110.41 (27 C.F.R. § 19.73). Section 5001(c) cuts the $13.50 rate to $2.70 on the first 100,000 proof gallons a plant distills or processes and removes each calendar year, and $13.34 on the next 22,130,000. Those rates became permanent in December 2020 (Pub. L. 116-260, div. EE), and related companies share one allotment under § 5001(c)(2).

    Illustrative example: Marcus’s friend removes 4,000 proof gallons of her own spirits in 2027. At $2.70 she owes $10,800; at the full rate it would be $54,000. Because she expects no more than $50,000 for 2027 and owed no more than that in 2026, § 5061(d)(4) and 27 C.F.R. § 19.235(c) let her file TTB F 5000.24 quarterly, and § 5551(d) excuses a bond. Under § 19.236(b), her first quarter return and payment are due April 14, 2027. At the full rate she would cross $50,000 and lose both benefits.

    Colorado’s excise is 60.26 cents per liter under C.R.S. § 44-3-503, per the Legislative Council’s March 2026 issue brief. At 80 proof, 4,000 proof gallons is 5,000 gallons (about 18,927 liters), roughly $11,405 if all of it sells in Colorado. For income tax, the excise is a cost of goods, and § 263A capitalization applies unless she meets the § 448(c) gross receipts test. Late TTB returns draw § 6651 additions, with the usual reasonable cause defense. On entity choice, see our 2026 LLC, S corporation and C corporation comparison.

    Why should Colorado taxpayers who never distill care about the taxing power question?

    Much of the Code is not tax but machinery for collecting it. The government’s petition says the ban works by “channeling taxable conduct into locations where tax evasion is more difficult.” The respondents’ brief calls that “a federal police power in all but name.” Sonzinsky v. United States, 300 U.S. 506, 513 (1937) held that a tax does not stop being a tax because it regulates. McNutt asks how far a rule that collects nothing may go in collection’s name.

    My read: if the Court adopts the Fifth Circuit’s view, expect challenges to other criminal rules justified as collection aids; Ohio’s brief says a Texas federal court has already carried McNutt into firearm rules. If it follows the Sixth Circuit, the fallout stays narrow. Recordkeeping tied to a taxed item looks safe either way; the Fifth Circuit itself distinguished rules aimed at “the very articles” taxed. For another federal excise regime, see dyed diesel relief for Colorado truckers and farmers.

    Activity in Colorado Federal permit and tax Colorado license After a hypothetical McNutt win
    Home beer, wine or cider for personal use No permit; tax exempt up to 100 or 200 gallons a year None within the § 44-3-106(2) exception No change
    Home fuel alcohol § 5181 fuel plant permit; product used only as fuel Confirm with Colorado counsel Little practical change
    Home beverage distilling Barred by § 5178(a)(1)(B); tax due on production Manufacturer’s license required; no home exception found Location ban gone; registration, permit, tax and state license remain
    Licensed craft distillery Registration and permit; $2.70 or $13.50 per proof gallon Manufacturer’s license; 60.26 cents per liter No change

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can I legally distill spirits at home in Colorado right now?

    No. The federal location ban still applies to anyone outside the McNutt injunction, which covers the plaintiffs and Hobby Distillers Association members. Colorado’s home production exception covers beer and wine, not spirits.

    Does the Fifth Circuit decision apply in Colorado?

    Not as precedent. The Tenth Circuit has not ruled, and the Sixth Circuit went the other way. The Supreme Court will decide, probably before its 2027 summer recess.

    If McNutt wins, can I sell spirits I make at home?

    No. Selling still requires federal registration and a permit, the excise tax, and a Colorado manufacturer’s license. The case concerns only where a still may sit.

    Do I owe federal excise tax on spirits I make just for myself?

    Yes. The tax attaches when the spirits exist and is due immediately when made outside a qualified plant. Spirits have no personal use exemption.

    Does a small Colorado distillery need a bond?

    Not if it expects no more than $50,000 in federal excise tax for the year and owed no more than $50,000 the year before. Those taxpayers file quarterly and, under section 5551(d), are treated as bonded.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm advises Colorado distillers and other producers on federal excise and income tax questions, entity selection, and penalty abatement when a return or payment slips. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    To have your distillery’s excise filing, bond status and reduced rate allotment reviewed before the 2027 returns, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Walk-Away Money in Colorado: Forfeited Deposits, Break Fees and Section 1234A After AbbVie

    Walk-Away Money in Colorado: Forfeited Deposits, Break Fees and Section 1234A After AbbVie

    Lucas runs a ranch-supply and feed business in Montrose. In April 2026 the buyer of his 40-acre commercial parcel at the edge of town, where he stores hay and parks trucks, walked away before closing, and Lucas kept the $150,000 earnest money. In July his lender pulled financing for his purchase of a competing feed store in Delta, and he paid that owner $60,000 to terminate their letter of intent. His bookkeeper wants to net the two.

    Short answer: the $150,000 is very likely ordinary income. The $60,000 is an ordinary deduction or a capital loss depending on what he signed, and as a capital loss only $3,000 of it offsets the deposit in 2026.

    Is forfeited earnest money ordinary income or capital gain for a Colorado seller?

    It turns on what the property is in the seller’s hands. 26 U.S.C. § 1234A says a gain or loss on the “cancellation, lapse, expiration, or other termination” of a right or obligation “with respect to property which is (or on acquisition would be) a capital asset in the hands of the taxpayer” is taxed as if a capital asset had been sold. A 1997 amendment, Pub. L. 105-34, § 1003, extended it from personal property to all property, including real estate.

    But § 1221(a)(2) says depreciable property and “real property used in his trade or business” are not capital assets. Held over a year, they are § 1231 property, which gets capital gain rates on a net sale gain but is not a capital asset. In CRI-Leslie, LLC v. Commissioner, 147 T.C. 217 (2016), aff’d, 882 F.3d 1026 (11th Cir. 2018), a Tampa hotel owner kept a $9.7 million deposit after its buyer defaulted. The hotel was § 1231 property, so § 1234A did not apply and the deposit was ordinary income. The Eleventh Circuit called the result odd but not absurd.

    Investment land is the opposite case: it is a capital asset, so a kept deposit is § 1234A capital gain. I found no Tenth Circuit decision on § 1234A or forfeited deposits. A Colorado individual’s Tax Court case goes to the Tenth Circuit under § 7482(b)(1)(A), and I expect the Tax Court to follow its own CRI-Leslie opinion.

    Does the liquidated damages box in a Colorado real estate contract change the tax result?

    Many Colorado commercial sales use the Real Estate Commission’s Contract to Buy and Sell Real Estate (Commercial), adopted August 5, 2025 and mandatory on and after January 1, 2026. Under § 20.1.2, which applies unless the § 20.1.1 box is checked, a seller facing a buyer’s default may cancel and keep the earnest money as liquidated damages, “SELLER’S ONLY REMEDY.” Checking the § 20.1.1 “Specific Performance” box instead lets the seller keep the deposit and seek more damages, or enforce the contract.

    Which box to check is a contract question for the parties and their Colorado counsel. For tax purposes, it mostly decides whether a sale happens. If the seller compels the sale, the earnest money is part of the price on a § 1231 sale. If the seller cancels and keeps the deposit under either box, nothing is sold, and the CRI-Leslie analysis governs.

    What did AbbVie v. Commissioner decide, and does it still stand in 2026?

    In AbbVie Inc. & Subsidiaries v. Commissioner, 164 T.C. No. 10 (June 17, 2025), AbbVie deducted a roughly $1.635 billion fee paid to Shire after its board withdrew support for their combination, and the IRS called it a § 1234A capital loss. Judge Toro read the statute as reaching only contracts under which property would actually change hands, and not promises to do work that merely relates to property. AbbVie’s co-operation agreement was mainly services, like seeking regulatory approval and recommending the deal. Neither company owned the shares, so AbbVie could never compel a purchase of Shire stock, and the withdrawn recommendation, not a failed transfer, triggered the fee.

    The court did not decide whether the fee qualified under § 162 or § 165, and it agreed § 1234A can reach conditional deals between parties with “complete authority” to buy and sell. The Tax Court docket (No. 2597-23) shows an IRS notice of appeal filed September 11, 2025, and a February 9, 2026 Seventh Circuit mandate dismissing it under Rule 42(b), the voluntary dismissal rule. As of October 30, 2026, the IRS action on decision list shows nothing on AbbVie. No court of appeals has reviewed it.

    Kept or Paid a Forfeited Deposit This Year? Contact Us Now

    Is a break fee under a small-business letter of intent a capital loss or a tax deduction?

    Many letters of intent make the price terms nonbinding but the fee clause binding. If Lucas never had an enforceable right to buy the Delta store, he looks like AbbVie, and § 1234A should not apply.

    A signed asset purchase agreement is different. The Delta owner owned the assets and could commit to sell them, so that contract is a right to acquire property, and AbbVie does not help. The statute still asks whether the property would be a capital asset in the buyer’s hands. Feed inventory is excluded by § 1221(a)(1); trucks, shelving and the building would be business property under § 1221(a)(2); and purchased goodwill is a § 197 intangible that § 197(f)(7) treats as depreciable. The rule that hurts sellers in CRI-Leslie may help a buyer of operating assets, making an ordinary loss under § 165(c)(1) the stronger position.

    The capital loss risk is real when the deal was for LLC interests or stock, or included land he would have held as an investment. Pilgrim’s Pride Corp. v. Commissioner, 779 F.3d 311 (5th Cir. 2015) read § 1234A as covering contractual rights to buy or sell capital assets, which a terminated stock purchase agreement fits. No court has applied this to a small asset deal.

    Deal costs follow Treas. Reg. § 1.263(a)-5. Costs to facilitate buying a business are capitalized, but investigatory costs before the letter of intent generally are not, unless “inherently facilitative,” like an appraisal (§ 1.263(a)-5(e)). Its examples let capitalized costs of an abandoned deal be deducted under § 165.

    How does Colorado’s flat income tax treat walk-away money?

    Colorado has no separate capital gains rate. C.R.S. § 39-22-104(1.7)(c) taxes federal taxable income at 4.40 percent, subject to TABOR-triggered reductions under § 39-22-627. Legislative Council staff’s September 2026 forecast reports no TABOR refund obligation for fiscal year 2025-26, so the 2026 rate is 4.40 percent. C corporations pay 4.40 percent under C.R.S. § 39-22-301(1)(d)(I)(K).

    So the character fight is federal: a capital loss trapped by § 1211 cuts Colorado tax only in the year it is deducted federally. The capital gain subtraction in C.R.S. § 39-22-518 will not help: since 2022 it is limited to Schedule F filers selling Colorado agricultural land acquired between May 9, 1994 and June 4, 2009 and held five years, capped at $100,000. A kept deposit is not gain from selling land anyway.

    What does the character mismatch cost a Montrose owner in 2026?

    Illustrative example (hypothetical; 32 percent federal marginal rate assumed, ignoring self-employment tax and § 199A). Lucas is a sole proprietor, and the parcel, titled to him and used in the business for years, is § 1231 property, so the $150,000 is ordinary income.

    If the fee is an ordinary deduction, taxable income rises $90,000: $28,800 federal and $3,960 Colorado. If it is a § 1234A capital loss and he has no 2026 capital gains, § 1211(b) allows $3,000, taxable income rises $147,000, and he owes $47,040 federal and $6,468 Colorado, $20,748 more. The other $57,000 carries forward under § 1212(b), short-term if he held the contract right under a year, usable against future gains plus $3,000 a year: 19 more years if he has none.

    The twist: had the parcel been investment land, the deposit would be § 1234A capital gain and the $60,000 loss would offset it dollar for dollar. A C corporation is boxed in further: § 1211(a) allows capital losses only against capital gains, carried back three years and forward five under § 1212(a). See LLC vs. S corporation vs. C corporation in Colorado.

    Payment Governing authority Character and where reported Colorado effect
    Seller keeps deposit on business real estate §§ 1221(a)(2), 1231, 1234A; CRI-Leslie Ordinary income; IRS instructions name no specific line Taxed at 4.40 percent
    Seller keeps deposit on investment land or a residence § 1234A Capital gain; Form 8949 and Schedule D 4.40 percent; § 39-22-518 does not apply
    Buyer forfeits deposit on property that would be a capital asset §§ 1234A, 1211, 1212 Capital loss; $3,000 a year against ordinary income Saves tax only when deducted federally
    Buyer ends a binding deal for operating assets §§ 1221(a)(1), (a)(2), 197(f)(7), 165(c)(1) Likely ordinary loss; untested Full 4.40 percent benefit if ordinary
    Buyer pays a break fee under a services-type agreement AbbVie; §§ 162, 165 Ordinary deduction Full 4.40 percent benefit

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is forfeited earnest money ordinary income for a Colorado seller?

    If the property was used in the seller’s business, yes, under CRI-Leslie. If it was investment land or a residence, § 1234A makes it capital gain.

    Can I deduct a fee I paid to back out of buying a business?

    Often, as an ordinary loss, especially under a nonbinding letter of intent or for operating assets. If you were bound to buy stock or LLC interests, § 1234A may make it a capital loss.

    Did the IRS appeal the AbbVie break fee decision?

    It appealed to the Seventh Circuit in September 2025, and the appeal was voluntarily dismissed, with the mandate issued February 9, 2026. No action on decision had issued as of October 30, 2026.

    Does choosing liquidated damages in the Colorado contract make the deposit capital gain?

    No. A kept deposit on business real estate is ordinary income under CRI-Leslie whichever box is used.

    What is Colorado’s income tax rate for 2026?

    4.40 percent of federal taxable income. No TABOR refund obligation arose for fiscal year 2025-26, so no temporary reduction applies.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm advises Colorado owners on real estate tax strategy, business sale tax structuring, and IRS audit defense Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If you kept or paid walk-away money on a property or business deal this year and want the documents read before your 2026 return is filed, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Catholic Charities v. Wisconsin and Colorado’s Religious Unemployment Tax Exemption

    Catholic Charities v. Wisconsin and Colorado’s Religious Unemployment Tax Exemption

    Tomás runs a faith-based nonprofit in Pueblo that serves as the social services arm of a regional church body. It has a food pantry, a job-training program, a thrift store and 22 employees, and it has paid Colorado unemployment insurance premiums for years. After reading about a Supreme Court case out of Wisconsin, his board chair asked whether the organization ever owed those premiums and, if it does, whether there is a cheaper way to carry the risk.

    Both questions turn on the Colorado unemployment tax religious exemption in C.R.S. § 8-70-140 and on how much Colorado case law survived the Wisconsin ruling.

    Does Catholic Charities v. Wisconsin change Colorado’s religious exemption from unemployment tax?

    It changes how the exemption may be applied, not its text. In Catholic Charities Bureau, Inc. v. Wisconsin Labor & Industry Review Commission, 605 U.S. 238 (2025), a unanimous Court held on June 5, 2025 that Wisconsin violated the First Amendment. The state had conceded that the Diocese of Superior controlled the charities, then denied the exemption because they did not proselytize and served people of every faith.

    That, the Court said, is a denominational preference resting on “inherently religious choices,” so strict scrutiny applied under Larson v. Valente, 456 U.S. 228 (1982). Recasting the test as “distinctively religious activity” like worship did not help; that choice is theological too. The Court did not hold that every church-affiliated charity is exempt; it rejected one line Wisconsin drew. Justice Thomas added that the charities were an arm of the diocese however incorporated. Justice Jackson read the federal model language as asking what an organization does, not why, and called it “perfectly consistent” with the ruling for states to use that function test. On remand, the Wisconsin Supreme Court ordered the exemption granted on December 15, 2025.

    Why does a Colorado 501(c)(3) owe unemployment premiums when it owes no FUTA?

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 3306(c)(8), work for a 501(c)(3) is outside federal unemployment tax. But § 3309(a), enforced through the approval rules in § 3304(a)(6), makes each state cover those workers and offer nonprofits a reimbursement option. Every Colorado employer’s federal credit depends on that approval. Section 3309(b) then lets states exclude churches, church-controlled organizations run “primarily for religious purposes,” religious schools and ministers. Colorado copied that list into C.R.S. § 8-70-140(1), carving it out of C.R.S. § 8-70-118, which covers a 501(c)(3) with four or more workers in each of 20 weeks.

    Federal payroll taxes are untouched: the organization still withholds and pays FICA under § 3121, thrift store clerks included. Ministers have dual status: ministry pay is outside FICA under § 3121(b)(8)(A), and they owe self-employment tax computed under § 1402(a)(8) unless they hold a § 1402(e) exemption. Intact 501(c)(3) status matters too; see the earlier post on automatic revocation and the Section 7428 deadline. A companion post this week addresses board exposure for unpaid payroll taxes.

    What did Young Life, Samaritan Institute, Harbert and A Child’s Touch decide about C.R.S. 8-70-140?

    The first major case involved a Colorado Springs ministry. In Young Life v. Division of Employment & Training, 650 P.2d 515 (Colo. 1982), the Colorado Supreme Court agreed Young Life was not a “church” because it had no membership, no congregation and no official tie to any denomination. It relied on Gillette v. United States and the absence of invidious motive. A footnote left the church-controlled organization clause undecided.

    Samaritan Institute v. Prince-Walker, 883 P.2d 3 (Colo. 1994) then held that “the type of activity actually engaged in, rather than the motivation and impetus for the activity, is dispositive,” and noted the counseling network’s office did not “evangelize or proselytize.” Harbert v. Industrial Claim Appeals Office, 2012 COA 23, 272 P.3d 1190 applied that test to an Evergreen outreach founded by 21 churches. Its food bank, clothing help and resale shop were “not religious per se,” so the shop employee was covered.

    A Child’s Touch v. Industrial Claim Appeals Office, 2015 COA 182, 411 P.3d 990 accepted that a Christian child care center had religious purposes and denied the exemption anyway. It was not “principally supported” by churches when it cut a maintenance worker in September 2013; the center had to show it “could not exist” without that support, and earlier audits finding it exempt did not help once its church closed.

    Can CDLE still deny a church-affiliated charity the exemption because its work looks secular?

    No published Colorado appellate decision has answered that since June 2025. The one later ruling I found, Christ’s Body Ministries v. Industrial Claim Appeals Office, No. 25CA0757 (Colo. App. Aug. 21, 2025) (unpublished), affirmed dismissal of a ministry’s appeal filed 24 days late. It had skipped the hearing on a former worker’s claim, believing its status settled since 2017. Appeals to the Panel must arrive within 20 calendar days under C.R.S. § 8-74-104(1).

    My read: Harbert and Samaritan are the most exposed. Asking whether a church-controlled charity’s services are themselves religious, and counting the absence of proselytizing against it, is close to what the Supreme Court struck. Young Life leaned on Gillette, which the Court called “inapposite” when lines follow theology, so a church definition built on membership and rites is harder to defend.

    The control and support prong is sturdier. Asking who appoints the board or whether the entity could survive without the church is structural, not theological. A Child’s Touch turned on it, and Young Life would likely still fail it. Justice Jackson’s function reading offers CDLE another path, but no majority has adopted it. The Tenth Circuit has no authority on § 8-70-140; these disputes move from a CDLE deputy to a hearing officer, the Panel and the Colorado Court of Appeals.

    Can a Colorado religious nonprofit choose coverage or become a reimbursable employer?

    Exemption is not a one-way door. Under C.R.S. § 8-76-107, an employer whose work is not “employment” may elect, with division approval, to be covered for at least two calendar years, so laid-off staff can draw benefits.

    A covered 501(c)(3) can also choose under C.R.S. § 8-76-110 to reimburse the fund for regular benefits and half of any extended benefits its former workers draw, instead of paying premiums. The switch takes written notice at least 30 days before the calendar year and locks in for that year and the next. CDLE bills quarterly, due in 30 days, and may require a bond or deposit within 15 days, generally between 0.1 and 3.6 percent of prior-year covered payroll. Reimbursing employers sit outside § 8-76-102.5, home of the solvency surcharge. Whether an organization that opts in under § 8-76-107 may also reimburse is something I would confirm with CDLE in writing.

    For past premiums, C.R.S. § 8-79-108 refunds amounts “paid erroneously,” without interest, but nothing paid before January 1 of the first of the five calendar years preceding the application. A November 2026 application reaches back to January 1, 2021. If CDLE refuses or sits on it for six months, the employer may sue in Denver District Court.

    What would premiums, reimbursement and exemption cost a 22-employee Pueblo nonprofit in 2026?

    Illustrative example (hypothetical facts, assumed rate). Payroll is $820,000: 18 full-time staff paid $750,000, each above the wage base, and four part-time thrift store clerks paid $70,000, each below it. The 2026 base is the first $30,600 per worker under C.R.S. § 8-70-103(6.5)(a)(VI), so chargeable wages are $550,800 plus $70,000, or $620,800. The 2027 base is indexed to average weekly earnings; I had not seen CDLE’s 2027 figure as of October 30, 2026.

    Combined 2026 rates for positive-rated employers were reported at 0.72 to 4.58 percent. At an assumed 2.0 percent, premiums are $12,416, layoffs or not.

    Under reimbursement, suppose two trainers are laid off when a grant ends, each drawing an assumed $560 a week for 20 weeks. CDLE bills $22,400, about $10,000 more than premiums. With no layoffs the bill is zero, so reimbursement rewards a stable payroll.

    Exempt, the cost is zero and so is the coverage: the trainers would have no state claim on these wages.

    Question Exempt religious organization (§ 8-70-140) Covered 501(c)(3) paying premiums Covered 501(c)(3) reimbursing (§ 8-76-110)
    Who decides CDLE, often in a former worker’s benefit claim, subject to appeal Default for a covered nonprofit The organization, by notice at least 30 days before the year
    What the organization pays Nothing Rate plus surcharges on chargeable wages ($12,416 in the example) Benefits drawn plus half of extended benefits ($22,400 in the layoff year); possible bond
    What laid-off employees receive No state benefits based on those wages Regular state benefits The same state benefits
    Risk if CDLE disagrees Back premiums with interest and penalties Low; if later found exempt, refunds reach back about five years Election can be terminated for a missed bond or late payment

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Does Catholic Charities v. Wisconsin apply in Colorado?

    Yes. The First Amendment ruling binds Colorado agencies and courts, and C.R.S. 8-70-140 uses the same federal language. No published Colorado decision has applied it yet.

    Is a church-run thrift store exempt from Colorado unemployment tax?

    In Harbert (2012), the Colorado Court of Appeals said no for a church-founded outreach’s resale store. That activity-based reasoning is now in doubt, so church control and support facts matter more.

    Can a Colorado nonprofit switch from premiums to reimbursement?

    A covered 501(c)(3) can, by written notice at least 30 days before the calendar year. The election is locked for that year and the next, and CDLE may require a bond or deposit.

    How far back can a Colorado nonprofit recover unemployment premiums it did not owe?

    To January 1 of the first of the five calendar years before the refund application, under C.R.S. 8-79-108. Refunds carry no interest.

    Does the unemployment exemption change FICA or federal withholding?

    No. A 501(c)(3) still withholds income tax and pays FICA, and ministers follow their own self-employment tax rules.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm helps Colorado nonprofits and their boards with tax law questions, Colorado state tax matters, IRS employment tax audits and penalty abatement. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    The reimbursement election and the refund lookback both run on calendar-year deadlines. If your Colorado ministry is sorting out its unemployment tax status, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Colorado Year-End 2026: $15 Million Exemption, Charitable Floor, and State Deductions

    Colorado Year-End 2026: $15 Million Exemption, Charitable Floor, and State Deductions

    Harriet and her husband have run cattle outside Glenwood Springs for thirty years. The ranch cost about $600,000 and would bring perhaps $4 million now; with savings and the house in town, their estate is roughly $9.2 million. A neighbor says the new federal law means “give the ranch to the kids now.” Their church expects a December check, and two grandchildren have Colorado 529 accounts.

    Little of their December 31, 2026 to-do list turns on the estate tax. The new charitable rules matter more, along with Colorado’s own subtractions and basis.

    Does Colorado have an estate tax in 2026, and what is the federal exemption?

    Not in any practical sense. C.R.S. § 39-23.5-103(1) imposes a tax “in the amount of the federal credit,” and § 39-23.5-102(6) defines that credit as the maximum state death tax credit under 26 U.S.C. § 2011, which Congress has since repealed. The tax computes to zero; Legislative Council Staff confirms no Colorado filing is required for deaths after December 31, 2004. Colorado has no inheritance or gift tax.

    The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), Pub. L. 119-21, § 70106, amended 26 U.S.C. § 2010(c)(3) to set the federal basic exclusion at $15,000,000 for deaths and gifts after 2025, indexed after 2026, with no sunset. Rev. Proc. 2025-32, § 3.14, confirms that figure for 2026 and an equal generation-skipping exemption under § 2631(c). As of October 23, 2026, the IRS had not published 2027 figures. With a portability election under § 2010(c)(4) and (5), a couple can shelter $30 million; see the post on Estate of Rowland.

    Families with New York ties should not assume this answer travels: New York taxes estates above $7,350,000 in 2026 and drops the credit entirely past 105 percent of that figure (N.Y. Tax Law § 952(c)(1)).

    How does the 2026 charitable deduction floor work for Colorado itemizers?

    Starting in 2026, 26 U.S.C. § 170(b)(1)(I), added by OBBBA § 70425, allows an itemizer’s gifts only to the extent they exceed 0.5 percent of the contribution base, generally adjusted gross income. Under § 170(d)(1)(C), the trimmed amount carries forward only from a year in which the donor also exceeded a percentage-of-income ceiling, such as the 60 percent limit on cash gifts to public charities. Most donors simply lose it.

    A retired couple in Colorado Springs with large stock gains should still usually give shares: long-term stock given to a public charity is generally deductible at fair market value (§ 170(e)(1)), subject to a 30 percent ceiling (§ 170(b)(1)(C)), and the gain is never taxed.

    The OBBBA also rewrote 26 U.S.C. § 68, cutting itemized deductions by 2/37 of the lesser of the deductions or taxable income above the start of the 37 percent bracket, which for 2026 is $768,700 on a joint return (Rev. Proc. 2025-32, § 4.01). A deduction that saved 37 cents now saves about 35.

    Under § 170(p), as amended by OBBBA § 70424, non-itemizers can deduct up to $1,000, or $2,000 jointly, of cash given directly to public charities on top of the standard deduction ($32,200 jointly for 2026). Gifts to donor-advised funds and supporting organizations do not count.

    Should a Colorado family bunch 2026 gifts into a donor-advised fund?

    Bunching stacks two years of giving into one itemized year, so the 0.5 percent toll is paid once. A donor-advised fund gives the 2026 deduction while grants go out later.

    Illustrative example (hypothetical facts). Harriet and her husband, both 63, expect 2026 adjusted gross income of $260,000 and $18,000 of state income and property taxes. If they give their usual $38,000 in cash, the floor is $1,300, so $36,700 is deductible and itemized deductions total $54,700. Taxable income of $205,300 sits in the 22 percent bracket, which runs to $211,400 for 2026. The floor costs about $286 federally and $57 in Colorado, and since they are far below their $156,000 cash ceiling, the $1,300 is gone.

    Suppose instead they put $76,000 into a donor-advised fund before December 31, 2026. Their 2026 itemized deductions become $92,700 ($74,700 of charity after the same floor, plus taxes). For 2027, whose standard deduction is not yet published, I use 2026’s $32,200. Over two years they deduct $124,900 instead of $109,400. With similar income, the extra $15,500 is worth about $3,400 federally and $680 in Colorado. In 2027, direct checks to the church can still earn the § 170(p) deduction of up to $2,000. The fund’s grants are not new contributions by them.

    Year-End Gift or Charitable Planning in Colorado? Contact Us Now

    How do Colorado’s charitable contribution subtraction and high-income addback work in 2026?

    Colorado taxes federal taxable income at 4.40 percent under C.R.S. § 39-22-104(1.7)(c); the September 2026 Legislative Council Staff forecast reports no TABOR refunds for tax year 2026, so the temporary rate cut in § 39-22-627 does not apply. A federal deduction is therefore usually worth another 4.40 percent.

    Two state rules change that. C.R.S. § 39-22-104(4)(m) gives standard-deduction filers a subtraction for the charitable deduction they could have claimed, above $500. Department of Revenue guidance (June 2024) allowed it alongside the temporary 2020 and 2021 federal non-itemizer deduction, but nothing addresses 2026, when the borrowed § 170 deduction has its own floor; I treat that as unsettled.

    The bigger issue is C.R.S. § 39-22-104(3)(p.7), enacted by House Bill 25-1274 and approved by voters as Proposition MM in November 2025. Starting in 2026, a taxpayer with federal adjusted gross income of $300,000 or more adds back any itemized or standard deduction above $1,000 (single) or $2,000 (joint); the older § 39-22-104(3)(p) cap ($60,000 jointly at $400,000 of AGI) is now the milder rule. Above $300,000, a December gift saves federal tax and almost nothing in Colorado. Harriet’s $260,000 is under that line, but a ranch-parcel sale or large IRA withdrawal in the bunching year could push her over.

    How much can Colorado grandparents give in 2026, and what does the Colorado 529 deduction add?

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 2503(b) and Rev. Proc. 2025-32, § 4.42(1), each person may give $19,000 to any number of people in 2026 without using exemption, so Harriet and her husband can move $38,000 to each grandchild. A 529 contribution counts, and § 529(c)(2)(B) lets a donor elect to spread a larger one over five years.

    Colorado lets you subtract CollegeInvest and other qualifying Colorado 529 contributions up to an indexed per-beneficiary cap (C.R.S. § 39-22-104(4)(i)(II)). CollegeInvest lists the 2026 cap as $39,200 per beneficiary on a joint return. If the couple puts $38,000 into each grandchild’s account by December 31, the $76,000 subtraction saves about $3,344 of Colorado tax, subject to recapture on a nonqualified withdrawal (§ 39-22-104(4)(i)(III)).

    Should we give the ranch or low-basis stock to our children before the year ends?

    Below $15 million, usually not. A gift carries the donor’s basis under 26 U.S.C. § 1015(a); an inheritance takes date-of-death value under § 1014(a)(1). Deeded over this December, the ranch carries Harriet’s $600,000 basis and $3.4 million of built-in gain, and she reports a $4 million gift. Inherited, that gain disappears. A $9.2 million estate owes no federal or Colorado estate tax for the gift to save.

    Title matters at the first death. Colorado is not a community property state (C.R.S. § 14-10-113 divides marital property equitably), so the § 1014(b)(6) step-up for a survivor’s community half is unavailable. If the spouses hold the ranch in joint tenancy with right of survivorship, 26 U.S.C. § 2040(b) includes half in the first estate, and only that half gets a new basis under § 1014(b)(9). The survivor’s basis would be about $2.3 million: $2 million inherited plus the survivor’s own $300,000.

    Lifetime gifts still pay for a Front Range business owner well above $15 million ($30 million for a couple using portability), especially gifts of assets likely to outgrow the indexing. A non-grantor trust administered here is a Colorado resident trust under C.R.S. § 39-22-103(10), taxed at 4.40 percent on federal taxable income (§ 39-22-401(1)), computed after the distribution deduction in 26 U.S.C. § 661. Federally, income the trust keeps above $16,000 is taxed at 37 percent in 2026.

    Item 2025 rule 2026 rule (OBBBA) Colorado treatment
    Basic exclusion amount $13,990,000 per person $15,000,000 per person, indexed after 2026 No Colorado estate tax or return
    Annual exclusion $19,000 per donee $19,000 per donee No Colorado gift tax
    Non-itemizer charitable deduction None Up to $1,000 ($2,000 joint), cash to public charities only Subtraction above $500 for non-itemizers; 2026 interaction unsettled
    Itemizer charitable floor None 0.5 percent of contribution base, usually lost Follows federal taxable income
    Top-bracket charitable benefit cap None (old § 68 suspended) 2/37 cut above the 37 percent bracket AGI of $300,000 or more: deductions over $1,000/$2,000 added back
    State estate or inheritance tax No federal credit since 2005 Unchanged None
    529 contributions Annual exclusion gift; five-year election Same Subtraction up to $38,100 (2025) and $39,200 (2026) per beneficiary, joint

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Does Colorado have an estate tax or inheritance tax in 2026?

    No. Colorado’s estate tax equals a federal credit that no longer exists, so no Colorado return is required for deaths after 2004. There is no inheritance or gift tax.

    What is the charitable deduction floor for 2026?

    Itemizers deduct charitable gifts only to the extent they exceed 0.5 percent of their contribution base, generally adjusted gross income. Unless you also exceed a percentage-of-income ceiling, the disallowed amount does not carry forward.

    Can I claim the new $1,000 charitable deduction for a gift to a donor-advised fund?

    No. The non-itemizer deduction covers cash given directly to public charities and excludes donor-advised funds and supporting organizations.

    What is the annual exclusion gift amount for 2026?

    It is $19,000 per recipient from each donor. A married couple can give $38,000 to each grandchild, 529 contributions included.

    Should I give my Colorado ranch to my children to avoid estate tax?

    Below the $15 million federal exclusion, a lifetime gift usually saves no estate tax and costs your children the basis step-up at death. Run the numbers with your actual values and title first.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm advises Colorado families on trust and estate tax planning, year-end Colorado tax planning under federal tax law, and the Colorado state tax adjustments that follow a federal return. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    Annual exclusion gifts and a bunched charitable gift must be made by December 31, 2026. To have your numbers run first, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Colorado LLLP and LLC Owners: Self-Employment Tax After Soroban and K Alain

    Colorado LLLP and LLC Owners: Self-Employment Tax After Soroban and K Alain

    Caleb and one other partner run a registered investment adviser in Boulder. The firm is a Colorado limited liability limited partnership; a third partner put in capital and never comes to the office. For years the CPA has reported zero self-employment earnings on every K-1. The 2025 return went in on extension on October 15, 2026, a month after a federal appeals court ruled against a New York investment manager that had done the same thing.

    Is the CPA still right? For the two working partners, probably not. For the capital partner, mostly yes. Here is how I would work through it in Colorado.

    Do limited partners in a Colorado LLLP or LLC pay self-employment tax?

    Self-employment tax reaches a partner’s share of partnership business income (26 U.S.C. § 1402(a)). Section 1402(a)(13) excludes “the distributive share of any item of income or loss of a limited partner, as such,” but not guaranteed payments for services. Everything turns on what “limited partner, as such” means.

    The rates under 26 U.S.C. § 1401 are 12.4 percent for Social Security, up to a wage base the Social Security Administration sets at $184,500 for 2026, and 2.9 percent for Medicare with no cap. Another 0.9 percent applies above $200,000 for a single filer or $250,000 jointly (§ 1401(b)(2)). Half the tax, minus that 0.9 percent, is deductible under 26 U.S.C. § 164(f).

    Why does the IRS test Colorado LLC members differently?

    Because a Colorado LLC has no limited partners. Every member is shielded from company debts (C.R.S. § 7-80-705), and in a member-managed LLC each member can bind the company (C.R.S. § 7-80-405(2)). Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.1402(a)-2(h), 62 Fed. Reg. 1702 (Jan. 13, 1997), would treat an owner as a limited partner unless the owner has personal liability, has authority to contract for the entity, or works more than 500 hours a year. It would deny the exclusion outright to service partners in health, law, engineering, architecture, accounting, actuarial and consulting firms, which reaches a Denver Tech Center engineering firm or a dental group.

    Congress then barred final rules before July 1, 1998 (Pub. L. 105-34, § 935, 111 Stat. 788, 882 (1997)), and Treasury never finalized them. In Renkemeyer, Campbell & Weaver, LLP v. Commissioner, 136 T.C. 137 (2011), the Tax Court taxed three Kansas law partners who had paid $110 each for their interests, since their income came from legal work, not investment.

    A Colorado limited partnership becomes an LLLP by filing a statement of registration under C.R.S. § 7-64-1002, and C.R.S. § 7-62-303(2) lets a limited partner even work as an employee without “participating in control.” That settles liability, not federal tax. S corporations sit outside all this: owners pay payroll tax on reasonable wages, and the IRS can recharacterize distributions as wages. Our Colorado entity-choice post runs the comparison.

    What did Soroban and K Alain decide about the limited partner exception?

    In Soroban Capital Partners LP v. Commissioner, 161 T.C. 310 (2023), the Tax Court held that the exception “does not apply to a partner who is limited in name only.” Its follow-up, T.C. Memo. 2025-52, found principals who worked 2,300 to 2,500 hours a year, sat on the management committees and put in little capital were not limited partners. The court used the same factors in Denham Capital Management LP v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2024-114, involving an adviser to energy funds, now on appeal in the First Circuit.

    The Fifth Circuit first went the other way. Sirius Solutions, a Houston consulting LLLP, took stipulated Tax Court decisions on February 20, 2024, appealed, and won a rule that any limited partnership partner with limited liability qualifies. Sirius Solutions, L.L.L.P. v. Commissioner, 165 F.4th 374 (5th Cir. 2026). The panel withdrew that opinion on rehearing. In K Alain, L.L.L.P. v. Commissioner, No. 24-60240 (5th Cir. Aug. 12, 2026), the renamed partnership’s case, it held that the term means “a partner who plays no significant role in managing or running a business,” called the Tax Court’s rule too strict, and remanded. Reports say K Alain sought full-court rehearing on September 28; I found no ruling as of October 23.

    The Second Circuit affirmed on September 17. Soroban Capital Partners LP v. Commissioner, Nos. 25-2079, 25-2250 (2d Cir. 2026). A limited partner is “one who has limited liability and who does not run, manage, or otherwise exert control.” It held the issue a partnership item under the old TEFRA audit rules and saw little daylight between its test and the Fifth Circuit’s.

    Which rule applies in Colorado if the Tenth Circuit has not ruled?

    I found no Tenth Circuit or District of Colorado decision on § 1402(a)(13), and no appeal from Renkemeyer, a Kansas case. So Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), aff’d, 445 F.2d 985 (10th Cir. 1971), controls. Golsen, itself an Oklahoma case, followed a Tenth Circuit decision squarely in point; the Tax Court defers only to the circuit where the appeal lies. For a Colorado individual that is the Tenth Circuit (26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(A)); for a partnership-level case, the circuit of the partnership’s principal place of business (§ 7482(b)(1)(E)).

    So a Colorado case in Tax Court gets the Tax Court’s own Soroban test and Denham factors; the Second and Fifth Circuit opinions are only persuasive. A refund suit in Colorado federal district court under 28 U.S.C. § 1346(a)(1) would read the statute fresh, and either forum’s appeal reaches a court with a clean slate.

    How much self-employment tax is at stake for a Boulder LLLP partner?

    Illustrative example (hypothetical figures). Each Boulder partner’s 2026 distributive share is $240,000, and Caleb is single with no wages. As self-employment income, his net earnings are $221,640 (92.35 percent, under § 1402(a)(12)). Social Security tax on the first $184,500 is $22,878.00. Medicare at 2.9 percent is $6,427.56, and the extra 0.9 percent on $21,640 adds $194.76. Total: $29,500.32, with a $14,652.78 deduction under § 164(f). For the two working partners, about $59,000 a year rides on the label.

    Under any of the three tests, Caleb and his co-manager look like Soroban‘s principals. The capital partner looks like the investor Congress had in mind, so her exclusion likely survives. Passive income, though, often meets the 3.8 percent net investment income tax instead (26 U.S.C. § 1411(c)(2)) once modified AGI passes $200,000 single or $250,000 joint, which here means up to $9,120. Section 1411(c)(6) prevents taxing the same item both ways. The IRS target is a working partner whose income escapes both. A changed position also shifts the § 199A math, because the § 164(f) deduction reduces qualified business income (Treas. Reg. § 1.199A-3(b)(1)(vi)).

    What happens in a partnership self-employment tax audit, and should I amend my 2025 return?

    Partnership audits for 2018 onward generally use the centralized regime of 26 U.S.C. § 6221(a), with any imputed underpayment paid by the partnership (§ 6225(a)). But Treas. Reg. § 301.6241-6(a)(1) confines that regime to chapter 1 income tax; self-employment tax is chapter 2, so I would expect the bill to land on the partners. Each partner’s assessment period generally runs three years from filing (26 U.S.C. § 6501(a)), so a 2025 return filed October 15, 2026 stays open until October 15, 2029.

    No statute requires an amended return, which the Supreme Court called “a creature of administrative origin and grace.” Badaracco v. Commissioner, 464 U.S. 386 (1984). Waiting still costs interest, plus a possible 20 percent penalty under 26 U.S.C. § 6662(a) unless reasonable cause and good faith are shown (§ 6664(c)(1)). I start with facts, not labels: hours, titles, signing authority and capital at risk. A partner who fails every test gains little by waiting. A partner with a real investor profile can defend the return as filed.

    The fourth 2026 estimated payment is due January 15, 2027 (26 U.S.C. § 6654(c)(2)) and must cover self-employment tax (§ 6654(f)(2)). Partners whose 2025 AGI topped $150,000 can rely on paying 110 percent of 2025 tax (§ 6654(d)(1)(C)).

    Partner profile Role facts Tax Court test (Soroban) Fifth Circuit test (K Alain) Practical note
    Passive capital partner in an LLLP Capital only; no work or management Likely excluded Likely excluded Watch the 3.8% investment income tax
    Managing partner of an LLLP Title, full-time work, signs contracts Likely taxed Likely taxed The label does not control
    LLC member-manager in a service business Serves clients, over 500 hours, binds the LLC Taxed Taxed Fails the 1997 proposed tests too
    LLC member who only contributed capital Manager-managed LLC; no agency or services Likely excluded Likely excluded Document the passive role yearly
    General partner of a limited partnership Personal liability; runs the business Taxed Taxed Never qualifies

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is a Colorado LLLP partner’s K-1 income taxed as self-employment income?

    It depends on what the partner does, not the title in the agreement. A partner who manages or runs the business is likely taxed under every current test; a true capital investor likely is not.

    Has the Tenth Circuit decided the limited partner exception?

    Not that I could find. Under Golsen, a Colorado case in Tax Court gets the Tax Court’s own Soroban test, and an appeal would go to a circuit with no precedent on the point.

    Are guaranteed payments ever excluded from self-employment tax?

    No. Section 1402(a)(13) keeps guaranteed payments for services in self-employment income, even for a true limited partner.

    Does the 1997 proposed regulation’s 500-hour test still matter?

    It was never finalized and binds no one. Hours still matter, because the Tax Court weighs time devoted to the business.

    When is my last 2026 estimated tax payment due?

    January 15, 2027. Self-employment tax counts toward the required payment, so a partner rethinking the position should revisit that installment now.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm advises Colorado partners and LLC members on entity structure and self-employment tax, defends partnership and partner positions in IRS audits, and handles Tax Court litigation when a dispute does not settle. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    A partner’s role can change from one year to the next, and so can the answer. If your K-1 shows zero self-employment earnings but you help run the business, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Colorado Divorce Taxes: Maintenance After the TCJA, Property Division, and Joint Tax Debt

    Colorado Divorce Taxes: Maintenance After the TCJA, Property Division, and Joint Tax Debt

    Renata’s permanent orders hearing in Castle Rock is in December. The proposal gives her guideline maintenance and the brokerage account, gives him his 401(k), and has him promise to pay what they owe on their 2023 joint return. It looks even. After tax it is not, and that promise may not protect her.

    I do a lot of divorce forensic work, and Colorado’s statutes assume you know the federal answers.

    Does the IRS have to follow a Colorado decree that assigns our joint tax debt to my spouse?

    No. A joint return makes each spouse liable for the whole tax under 26 U.S.C. § 6013(d)(3), and IRS Publication 971 warns that the IRS can still collect from you even if the decree makes your ex solely responsible. Your later refunds can be applied to the joint balance under § 6402(a).

    Relief lives in 26 U.S.C. § 6015. Subsection (b) covers an understatement from your spouse’s erroneous items you had no reason to know about. Subsection (c) allocates a deficiency as if you had filed separately, but only if you are divorced or legally separated, or lived apart for the 12 months before electing. Both are due within two years after the IRS begins collection activities against you (§ 6015(b)(1)(E), (c)(3)(B)); Publication 971 says a refund offset can start that clock.

    A balance reported but never paid is reachable only by equitable relief under § 6015(f), which may be requested until the 10-year collection period in § 6502(a)(1) runs, the timing Rev. Proc. 2013-34 also uses. Its § 4.03(2)(d) counts a decree putting the debt solely on your ex in favor of relief, unless you knew your ex would not pay.

    The Tax Court reviews a denial de novo under § 6015(e)(7); Colorado appeals go to the Tenth Circuit (§ 7482(b)(1)(F)), where I found no published opinion applying that standard. Form 8379 does not help: its instructions limit it to your share of a joint refund taken for your spouse’s own debt, and a joint-year balance is yours too.

    Is spousal maintenance taxable in Colorado after the 2017 tax law?

    Not under a 2026 decree. Pub. L. 115-97, § 11051, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, repealed former 26 U.S.C. §§ 71 and 215 for divorce or separation instruments executed after December 31, 2018. The payer deducts nothing and the recipient reports nothing. An older order keeps the old treatment unless a post-2018 modification expressly adopts the new rule (§ 11051(c)(2)).

    Colorado taxes federal taxable income under C.R.S. § 39-22-104, and I found no modification for maintenance. The statutory rate is 4.40 percent, subject to temporary TABOR cuts; confirm the final 2026 rate.

    How does Colorado’s maintenance guideline adjust for the lost alimony deduction?

    If the marriage lasted at least three years and combined annual adjusted gross income is $240,000 or less, C.R.S. § 14-10-114(3)(b) starts with 40 percent of combined monthly adjusted gross income, minus the lower earner’s monthly income. That formula assumes deductible alimony. For a nondeductible order the statute takes 80 percent of the result when combined monthly income is $10,000 or less, and 75 percent above $10,000 up to $20,000.

    So the lost deduction is already priced in; a payer seeking a further cut because maintenance “isn’t deductible anymore” is counting it twice. The court still makes a deductibility finding under (3)(a)(I)(E) and may adjust “to equitably allocate the tax burden” under (3)(c)(XII). Under (5)(c), the federal change alone does not justify modifying a pre-TCJA order.

    Note that “adjusted gross income” in § 14-10-114(8) is not the AGI line on Form 1040. Subsection (8)(c)(III)(B) disallows the accelerated component of depreciation, so a business owner’s bonus-depreciation loss can badly understate income for maintenance; I rebuild it from the books.

    Divorcing With Tax Debt or a Business in Colorado? Contact Us Now

    Is dividing property in a Colorado divorce taxable, and whose tax basis carries over?

    Colorado is not a community property state. Under C.R.S. § 14-10-113(1), the court sets apart separate property and divides marital property “in such proportions as the court deems just.” Subsection (4) makes a premarital asset’s growth during the marriage marital.

    That framework once drove the federal answer: in Imel v. United States, 523 F.2d 853 (10th Cir. 1975), the Tenth Circuit treated a 1965 Colorado transfer of appreciated stock as a nontaxable division between co-owners, because the Colorado Supreme Court had found the wife held “a species of common ownership” once the case was filed. Since 1984, 26 U.S.C. § 1041 treats every state alike: no gain or loss on a transfer incident to divorce, and the transferor’s basis carries over (§ 1041(b)). Treas. Reg. § 1.1041-1T, Q&A-7, covers transfers under the decree within six years; § 1041(d) excludes nonresident alien spouses.

    Carryover basis is why equal dollars are not equal value. The court weighs “the economic circumstances of each spouse” under § 14-10-113(1)(c), and whether that reaches tax the decree does not trigger is a question for Colorado counsel. A negotiated settlement can price it; I put it on the balance sheet.

    For the house, § 121(d)(3)(B) credits an owner with use while a former spouse is granted use under the divorce instrument, so the spouse who moves out can keep the $250,000 exclusion alive.

    Should I take the 401(k) by QDRO, an IRA, or the brokerage account?

    An IRA moves tax-free under § 408(d)(6) and becomes the recipient’s own. Withdrawals before 59½ generally owe the 10 percent additional tax in § 72(t), because § 72(t)(3)(A) denies IRAs the domestic relations exception.

    A 401(k) split by a qualified domestic relations order under § 414(p) is different. Section 72(t)(2)(C) exempts distributions to the alternate payee, who is taxed as the distributee under § 402(e)(1); the plan withholds 20 percent under § 3405(c) unless the payee elects a direct rollover. Once the money lands in an IRA, the exception is gone.

    What filing status and child tax benefits apply in the year of a Colorado divorce?

    Marital status is fixed on December 31 under § 7703(a). A December 2026 decree rules out a joint 2026 return; a January decree leaves the couple married for 2026, though § 7703(b) can treat a separately filing parent who keeps up the child’s home and lived apart the last six months as unmarried. Head of household (§ 2(b)) follows where the child lives.

    Child support payments “aren’t deductible by the payer and aren’t taxable to the payee,” says IRS Publication 504; Colorado sets the amount under C.R.S. § 14-10-115. The parent with more overnights claims the child unless that parent signs a release under § 152(e)(2), which must be unconditional and does not carry head of household status.

    What do the numbers look like for a Castle Rock divorce in 2026?

    Illustrative, as of October 2026, with assumed rates. Renata earns $3,000 a month and her husband $11,000, for $14,000 combined. Forty percent of $14,000 is $5,600; minus her $3,000 leaves $2,600; at 75 percent the guideline is $1,950 a month. For their 144-month marriage, the duration table in the Colorado Judicial Branch’s form FCF 425 gives 71 months. Under the old rules, at an assumed 28.4 percent combined rate, $2,600 would have cost him about $1,862 after tax; at 16.4 percent she would have kept about $2,174. Now both figures are $1,950.

    Assume she is 46. The $300,000 brokerage account holds $110,000 of gain; at an assumed 19.4 percent its built-in tax is $21,340. The $300,000 401(k) is all pre-tax; at 26.4 percent it carries $79,200, a $57,860 gap before credit for deferral. If she needs $40,000 at closing, a $50,000 QDRO distribution nets $40,000 after withholding and owes no 10 percent additional tax; through an IRA first, that tax adds $5,000. Assume the $2,900 from 2023 was reported but unpaid: only § 6015(f) fits, and paying it from marital funds before the decree is the cleanest fix I know.

    Item Federal treatment (2026) Colorado treatment (2026) What the decree can and cannot do
    Maintenance, 2026 instrument Not deductible; not income Follows federal Can apply the 80 or 75 percent guideline; cannot make it deductible
    Child support Not deductible; not income Follows federal Can order a Form 8332 release; cannot substitute for it
    Property transfer under § 1041 No gain or loss; carryover basis Follows federal Can price embedded tax; cannot change basis
    IRA transfer Tax-free; 10 percent on withdrawals before 59½ Follows federal Can order the transfer; cannot waive the 10 percent
    401(k) by QDRO No 10 percent to alternate payee; 20 percent withheld Follows federal Can issue the order; the plan decides qualification
    Sale of marital home § 121 exclusion; § 121(d)(3)(B) use credit Follows federal Can grant one spouse use of the home
    Prior-year joint tax balance Joint and several; § 6015 relief Not covered here Can allocate it; cannot bind the IRS

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is spousal maintenance taxable in Colorado in 2026?

    Not under a decree or agreement signed after 2018. The payer cannot deduct it and the recipient does not report it, on either return.

    Why is the Colorado maintenance guideline lower than the 40 percent formula?

    The formula was written for deductible alimony. Nondeductible orders get 80 percent of the result at combined monthly income of $10,000 or less, and 75 percent up to $20,000.

    Can the IRS collect a joint tax debt from me if my decree assigns it to my ex?

    Yes. Joint return liability is joint and several, and a state decree does not bind the IRS. You can seek relief under § 6015 or enforce the decree against your ex.

    How long do I have to request innocent spouse relief?

    Innocent spouse and separation of liability elections are due within two years after IRS collection against you begins. Equitable relief on an unpaid balance can be requested until the collection period expires.

    Is it better to take an IRA or a 401(k) in a Colorado divorce?

    A QDRO distribution from a 401(k) avoids the 10 percent additional tax before 59½; an IRA withdrawal does not. Both are ordinary income.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm helps Colorado spouses and family lawyers with innocent spouse relief, the tax analysis behind a property division, and retirement account transfers. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    Embedded tax is easiest to price before anyone signs. If a joint tax balance or retirement account is in your Colorado divorce, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Lending to Your Child in Colorado: AFR Family Loans, Galli, and the Note at Death

    Lending to Your Child in Colorado: AFR Family Loans, Galli, and the Note at Death

    A retired engineer in Boulder has two things on her kitchen table: a statement for the brokerage account she inherited, and a listing for a house in Louisville. Her daughter and son-in-law found the place, and she would rather lend them $900,000 than see them take a jumbo mortgage. Her question to me is how to write it down so the IRS sees a loan and not a $900,000 gift.

    The answer is a real promissory note charging the applicable federal rate, paid the way it reads.

    Listen to this post

    North Star Tax and Legal Briefing: Colorado Family Loans at the AFR: Gift and Estate Tax

    A Boulder parent lends her daughter $900,000 for a house. We cover the applicable federal rate, what the Galli order did and did not decide, the Maxwell forgiveness trap, and the insider preference risk if the child files bankruptcy.

    Download the MP3 · Episode page on Podbean

    Show / hide the episode transcript

    A retired engineer in Boulder wants to lend her daughter and son-in-law nine hundred thousand dollars toward a house in Louisville, Colorado, rather than watch them sign a jumbo mortgage. Her worry is simple. If she writes the check, does the I R S see a loan, or a nine hundred thousand dollar gift? The difference matters. A gift that size eats into her lifetime exclusion and requires a gift tax return. Get the paperwork wrong, forgive the interest the wrong way, or let the note sit unpaid, and the loan quietly turns into the very gift she was trying to avoid. A recent Tax Court case shows exactly how to get it right.

    Here is the rule. Back in nineteen eighty-four the Supreme Court held that an interest-free loan to a family member is a taxable gift, because the free use of money has value. Congress answered that same year with a statute on below-market loans. For a term loan, the gift equals the amount lent minus the present value of the required payments, discounted at a rate the government publishes every month, the applicable federal rate. Charge at least that rate and the gap is zero. No gift. The rate depends on the length of the loan. For October two thousand twenty-six, the annual rates are four point two five percent for three years or less, four point six one percent for over three and up to nine years, and five point two two percent beyond nine. A term loan locks in the rate for the month it is made. And that rate is enough even when no bank would match it. The Tax Court held years ago that Congress replaced market valuation with this discounting formula.

    Which brings us to the Galli case. In February two thousand thirteen, Barbara Galli lent her son two point three million dollars on an unsecured note at one point zero one percent, that month’s mid-term rate, with interest due yearly and principal due within nine years. He paid the interest every year until she died in March two thousand sixteen. Her estate reported the note at one million six hundred twenty-four thousand dollars, well under face. The I R S said the whole thing had been a partial gift back in two thousand thirteen, to the tune of eight hundred sixty-nine thousand dollars. In a March two thousand twenty-five order, the judge sided with the estate. The son produced the transfer record, the signed note, his interest payments, and his mother’s returns reporting that interest. Under the statute, the transaction was not a gift at all. Now the part that cuts the other way. Some commentators read Galli as blessing a date-of-death discount on the note. It did not. The order said the estate value was not before the court, and that case later closed on a private stipulated decision. It is an order, not a published opinion. A Colorado executor claiming a discount because rates went up should expect a fight, and an appraisal bill.

    For most Colorado families, the estate side is modest. The federal exclusion is fifteen million dollars for two thousand twenty-six, and Colorado has no gift tax, no inheritance tax, and an estate tax tied to a federal credit that no longer exists. What Colorado does take is income tax on the parent’s interest, at a flat four point four zero percent. The real danger is forgiveness on a schedule. In the Maxwell case, a mother forgave twenty thousand dollars of her son’s note every year, no principal was ever paid, and the Tax Court held the note worthless because nobody ever intended payment. Then there is bankruptcy. If the child files, the parent is an insider, so payments made in the year before the filing can be clawed back as preferences, against ninety days for ordinary creditors. If the parent files, forgiveness by an insolvent parent can be unwound.

    So, three things this week. First, write a real note. A fixed rate at or above the applicable federal rate for the month you fund it, a maturity date, and signatures, drafted the way a bank would draft it. Second, record a deed of trust on the house. Security is optional for gift tax, but without it the kids cannot deduct the interest as home mortgage interest. Third, make the payments real. From the child’s own account, on time, and reported on the parent’s return every year, even when part of the interest is forgiven within the annual exclusion. That’s what we do at North Star Law Firm. The initial consultation is free, and the full written analysis with citations is at c o dash legal dot net.

    Is a loan to my child a gift if I charge the applicable federal rate?

    Not under the statute. Dickman v. Commissioner, 465 U.S. 330 (1984), held that interest-free demand loans to family members were taxable gifts of the reasonable value of the use of the money. Congress responded that year with 26 U.S.C. § 7872. For a term loan, the gift equals the amount loaned minus the present value of the required payments, discounted using the applicable federal rate, or AFR (§ 7872(b)(1), (d)(2), (e)(1)(B)). Charge at least the AFR and that difference is zero.

    AFRs are set monthly under 26 U.S.C. § 1274(d): short-term for three years or less, mid-term for over three and not over nine, long-term beyond nine. For October 2026, Rev. Rul. 2026-19 puts the annual rates at 4.25, 4.61 and 5.22 percent. A term loan uses the rate in effect the day it is made (§ 7872(f)(2)(A)), so a November closing needs November’s ruling, not yet posted as I write.

    Is the AFR enough when no bank would match it? Frazee v. Commissioner, 98 T.C. 554 (1992), says yes: in § 7872, “Congress displaced the traditional fair market methodology of valuation of below-market loans by substituting a discounting methodology.” Neither the $10,000 de minimis rule in § 7872(c)(2) nor the § 7872(d)(1) income cap, which stops applying once loans exceed $100,000, helps with a house-sized loan.

    What did the Tax Court actually decide in Galli?

    Barbara Galli lent her son $2.3 million in February 2013 on an unsecured note at 1.01 percent, that month’s mid-term AFR, with yearly interest and principal due within nine years. He paid interest each year until she died in March 2016. The estate reported the note at $1,624,000; the IRS asserted an $869,000 gift in 2013.

    In a March 5, 2025 order in Estate of Galli v. Commissioner, Docket Nos. 7003-20 and 7005-20, Judge Mark V. Holmes granted the estate’s motions. The IRS offered no facts showing more than a partial gift; the son produced the transfer record, the signed note, his interest payments, and his mother’s returns reporting that interest. Under § 7872 and Frazee, “this transaction was not a gift at all.” The gift-tax docket closed April 3, 2025, with a stipulated decision of no deficiency.

    On the estate value, the order says: “There is a dispute about its reported value, but that’s not the subject of this motion.” Some commentary reads Galli as approving a date-of-death discount. It did not rule on one. The estate-tax docket ended March 25, 2026, with a stipulated decision of no deficiency and no overpayment, stated as a net amount, on terms that are not public. It is an order, not a published opinion.

    How is a promissory note valued for estate tax when interest rates have gone up?

    The note is in the lender’s gross estate under 26 U.S.C. § 2033. Treas. Reg. § 20.2031-4 presumes its value is unpaid principal plus accrued interest “unless the executor establishes that the value is lower,” names the interest rate and maturity date as reasons, and demands “satisfactory evidence,” in practice an appraisal.

    A 1.01 percent note is worth less than face once rates rise. The IRS notices led with consistency: discount the note at death and the 2013 transfer must have been a partial gift. Their alternative discounted at the AFR alone and added $544,000 to the gross estate, about $2,168,000 by my arithmetic. Even the government’s fallback sat below the $2.3 million face.

    I found no Tenth Circuit decision on either point and no published Tax Court opinion resolving the consistency theory, so a Colorado executor claiming a discount should expect a fight. For most families the stakes are modest. The basic exclusion amount is $15,000,000 for 2026 under 26 U.S.C. § 2010(c)(3), indexed after 2026. Colorado adds nothing: C.R.S. § 39-23.5-103 taxes an estate only “in the amount of the federal credit” for state death taxes, and Congress phased that credit, former 26 U.S.C. § 2011, down to zero for deaths after 2004 and repealed the section in 2014. Surviving spouses should also read our post on portability and Form 706.

    How should Colorado parents document an intrafamily loan at the AFR?

    Copy the Galli record: a signed note with a fixed rate and maturity, a traceable transfer, and payments on time from the child’s own account, reported on the parent’s return. A promissory note is a contract under Colorado law, so draft it as a bank would.

    Security is optional for gift tax but not for the borrowers’ income tax. Interest is qualified residence interest only on debt “secured by such residence” under 26 U.S.C. § 163(h)(3), with acquisition debt capped at $750,000. A recorded deed of trust on the Louisville house can make most of the interest deductible.

    Colorado is not a community property state, so a loan from one spouse’s separate account is that spouse’s note and lands in that spouse’s estate. Colorado taxes the interest at the flat 4.40 percent rate in C.R.S. § 39-22-104(1.7)(c); the Legislative Council’s September 2026 forecast reports no TABOR refund obligation for fiscal 2025-26, so no temporary cut applies for 2026.

    What sinks these loans is forgiveness on a schedule. In Estate of Maxwell v. Commissioner, 98 T.C. 594 (1992), a mother forgave $20,000 of her son’s mortgage note yearly, no principal was ever paid, and the court held the note worthless because nobody intended payment.

    What does a $900,000 family loan for a Louisville home look like in numbers?

    Illustrative example (hypothetical facts; rates as of October 16, 2026): in November 2026 the Boulder mother lends $900,000 from her separate account to her daughter and son-in-law as co-borrowers, on a nine-year, interest-only note with a November 2035 balloon, secured by the house. Nine years is mid-term. Using October’s 4.61 percent in place of November’s unpublished rate, interest runs $41,490 a year and the gift at signing is zero.

    Say she forgives $38,000 of each year’s interest and the couple pays $3,490. That is $19,000 to each co-borrower, the 2026 annual exclusion under 26 U.S.C. § 2503(b) and Rev. Proc. 2025-32, so 26 U.S.C. § 6019 requires no gift tax return. I would still have her report all $41,490 (about $1,826 of Colorado tax), since a planned forgiveness lets the IRS treat the interest as never payable and impute it under § 7872(a). Now she dies in November 2031 with four payments left and comparable rates at 7 percent; at that rate the remaining payments are worth about $827,000, roughly $73,000 under face. Claiming it takes an appraisal, and below $15,000,000 it changes no federal tax.

    What happens to a family loan in a Colorado bankruptcy?

    If the parent files, the note is estate property under 11 U.S.C. § 541(a)(1), and forgiveness by an insolvent parent within two years can be avoided under 11 U.S.C. § 548(a)(1)(B). Through 11 U.S.C. § 544(b) the trustee can also use the four-year reach of C.R.S. § 38-8-105 and C.R.S. § 38-8-110. If the child files, the parent is a relative and so an insider under 11 U.S.C. § 101(31)(A)(i), and payments within one year before the petition face preference recovery under 11 U.S.C. § 547(b)(4)(B), against 90 days for other creditors. See also our post on Kittrell and children’s trusts.

    How the parent helpsGift at signingParent’s income taxValue in parent’s estateBankruptcy exposure
    Outright giftTaxable above the annual exclusion, using lifetime exclusionNoneOut of the estateAvoidable if the parent was insolvent
    Interest-free term loanPresent-value gap under § 7872(b)(1)Imputed interest under § 7872Face presumedNote is an estate asset; insider payments reachable for one year
    AFR loan, paid as writtenNoneInterest taxed federally and at 4.40% in ColoradoFace presumed; discount needs an appraisalSame as above
    AFR loan with scheduled forgivenessEach forgiven amount is a giftReport the full interestNote may be attacked as no real debtForgiveness can be an avoidable transfer

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What interest rate do I have to charge on a loan to my child in Colorado?

    At least the AFR for the note’s term in the month the loan is made. For October 2026, Rev. Rul. 2026-19 sets 4.25 percent short-term, 4.61 percent mid-term and 5.22 percent long-term.

    Did Galli decide that a family note can be discounted in the lender’s estate?

    No. The order said the reported estate value was not before the court, and the estate-tax case closed by stipulated decision on March 25, 2026.

    Does Colorado have a gift or estate tax on family loans?

    No. Colorado’s estate tax depends on a federal credit that no longer exists, and Colorado has no gift or inheritance tax. It does tax the parent’s interest at 4.40 percent for 2026.

    Can I forgive the interest each year as a gift?

    Forgiveness within the $19,000 per-person exclusion for 2026 is not a taxable gift. A fixed yearly pattern invites the argument from Maxwell that the note was never meant to be paid.

    What happens to the note if my child files bankruptcy?

    The parent is an insider, so payments within one year before filing can be recovered as preferences. Other creditors face a 90-day window.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm advises Colorado families on trust and estate tax planning and real estate tax strategy, handles gift and estate tax disputes in Tax Court litigation, and defends preference and clawback claims. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If you are lending a child money for a house, or an estate you manage holds a family note, contact North Star Law Firm.