Colorado Plan Releases After Purdue: What the Tenth Circuit Decided in 1990

Front of the Pueblo County Courthouse in Pueblo, Colorado

When the Supreme Court decided Harrington v. Purdue Pharma L.P., 603 U.S. 204 (2024), commentators called it a rupture in Chapter 11 practice. For a Pueblo or Grand Junction company reorganizing in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado, the change was small. Since 1990 the Tenth Circuit has read 11 U.S.C. § 524(e) to stop a confirmed plan from permanently shielding a non-debtor from its own liability on the debtor’s debts.

The live questions concern exculpation clauses and an August 2026 Voyager Digital ruling on post-confirmation conduct. Owners usually ask something simpler: can a Subchapter V plan deal with their bank guaranty?

What did the Tenth Circuit decide in Western Real Estate Fund?

In Landsing Diversified Properties-II v. First National Bank & Trust Co. of Tulsa (In re Western Real Estate Fund, Inc.), 922 F.2d 592 (10th Cir. 1990) (per curiam), an Oklahoma Chapter 11 debtor fired its litigation lawyer, and the bankruptcy court enjoined him from collecting his unpaid fee from a non-debtor in state court.

The Tenth Circuit vacated most of it. “Congress did not intend to extend such benefits to third-party bystanders,” the court wrote, and “the stay may not be extended post-confirmation in the form of a permanent injunction that effectively relieves the nondebtor from its own liability to the creditor.” On rehearing in Abel v. West, 932 F.2d 898 (10th Cir. 1991), the panel limited the surviving injunction to the period “pending confirmation of a reorganization plan.”

Did Purdue change the rules for Colorado Chapter 11 plans?

Less than elsewhere. Purdue barred any plan release that “effectively seeks to discharge claims against a nondebtor without the consent of affected claimants,” and its circuit-split footnote grouped Western Real Estate Fund with the Fifth and Ninth Circuit decisions refusing such releases.

Purdue did close one door. In In re Midway Gold US, Inc., 575 B.R. 475 (Bankr. D. Colo. 2017), Chief Judge Michael E. Romero read Western Real Estate Fund as “limited in scope” to co-debtor and guarantor releases and would have allowed others under 11 U.S.C. § 105(a) in “very limited” circumstances. Purdue forecloses that, reading the catchall in 11 U.S.C. § 1123(b)(6) to reach only debtor-focused provisions.

Why can’t a Subchapter V plan release the owner’s personal guaranty?

Here is a hypothetical. A Pueblo metal fabrication shop in Subchapter V owes $1.1 million to a local bank, which the owner guaranteed, and $400,000 to trade creditors. The collateral is worth $700,000, and the plan pays unsecured claims, including the bank’s $400,000 deficiency, 20 cents on the dollar. Ignoring interest, the bank collects $780,000. The owner wants the plan to release him on the remaining $320,000.

That is the release Western Real Estate Fund forbids. Section 524(e) says discharge “does not affect the liability of any other entity on, or the property of any other entity for, such debt.” The Chapter 11 discharge in 11 U.S.C. § 1141(d)(1)(A) and the Subchapter V discharge in 11 U.S.C. § 1192 both run only to the debtor. Even Midway Gold said a guarantor release would be “expressly barred by § 524(e).” After confirmation the bank can sue him, and if he has $310,000 of equity in a Pueblo West house, the homestead exemption in C.R.S. § 38-41-201 ($250,000, or $350,000 for elderly or disabled owners) leaves part of it exposed.

How is exculpation different from a third-party release?

A release wipes out creditors’ claims against someone else. Exculpation sets a standard of care for estate fiduciaries during the case, excepting gross negligence, willful misconduct, and fraud.

Midway Gold refused to exculpate secured lenders, who were not estate fiduciaries, struck an advice-of-counsel shield, and confined protection to acts during the case. In In re Rocking M Media, LLC, No. 22-20242 (Bankr. D. Kan. Aug. 2, 2024), a Kansas bankruptcy court noted that “[t]he Tenth Circuit has not addressed the validity of exculpation clauses,” followed Midway Gold, and refused to carve a liquidating trustee’s future conduct out of the clause.

The Fifth Circuit reads Tenth Circuit law more strictly; in NexPoint Advisors, L.P. v. Highland Capital Management, L.P. (In re Highland Capital Management, L.P.), 48 F.4th 419 (5th Cir. 2022), it said it and “the Tenth Circuit hold § 524(e) categorically bars third-party exculpations absent express authority in another provision of the Bankruptcy Code.” One such provision is 11 U.S.C. § 1125(e), which protects good-faith plan solicitation and plan securities transactions.

What does the Voyager ruling add about future conduct?

Voyager Digital’s 2023 cryptocurrency plan required large coin trades before in-kind distributions and exculpated the people executing them. On an appeal by the United States and the U.S. Trustee, in In re Voyager Digital Holdings, Inc., No. 23-CV-2171 (LTS) (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 6, 2026) (amended opinion), Chief Judge Laura Taylor Swain vacated the clause, concluding that “[n]othing in the Bankruptcy Code or the doctrine of quasi-judicial immunity empowered the Bankruptcy Court to approve the Exculpation Provision.” She also held that 11 U.S.C. § 1142(a) displaces only nonbankruptcy law “relating to financial condition,” and that quasi-judicial immunity belongs in a later suit as a defense, not in an advance grant.

Voyager does not bind Colorado courts, but it fits 28 U.S.C. § 959(b), which requires a debtor in possession to operate “according to the requirements of the valid laws of the State.” A Weld County oilfield service company in Subchapter V cannot use its plan to pre-clear future dealings with regulators. Voyager’s real addition is the government-enforcement limit.

Does an opt-out ballot count as consent in Colorado?

Purdue declined “to express a view on what qualifies as a consensual release,” and courts have split. In re Smallhold, Inc., No. 24-10267 (CTG) (Bankr. D. Del. Sept. 25, 2024), held silence is not consent, while In re Spirit Airlines, Inc., No. 24-11988 (SHL) (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. Mar. 7, 2025), approved an opt-out. We have found no Tenth Circuit appellate ruling. Midway Gold adds that consent “does not confer this Court with jurisdiction” over disputes among non-debtors. In Subchapter V, the guaranteed lender simply signs a release or does not.

What options does a Pueblo or Greeley owner-guarantor have?

A § 105(a) injunction protects the owner only until confirmation under Abel v. West. A gatekeeper clause fares no better: the Barton doctrine, which the Tenth Circuit applied to trustees in Satterfield v. Malloy, 700 F.3d 1231 (10th Cir. 2012), protects court officers, and an owner sued on a guaranty is not acting as one.

The cleanest path is the owner’s own case. An owner holding 20 percent or more of the company’s outstanding voting securities is an “affiliate” under 11 U.S.C. § 101(2)(A), and Fed. R. Bankr. P. 1015(b) permits joint administration. He then gets his own stay and discharge, subject to the usual exceptions and Colorado’s exemptions.

The other route is paying for consent. Suppose a Greeley HVAC contractor’s owner puts $150,000 of outside money into the plan, and the bank signs a release effective when plan payments finish. A signed agreement satisfies every court’s test for consent. Front-loading payments on the guaranteed debt also shrinks exposure.

Plan provision What it does Status in the Tenth Circuit after Purdue Leading authority
Nonconsensual guarantor release Ends creditor claims against a non-debtor Barred since 1990 Western Real Estate Fund; Purdue
Signed or opt-in release Creditor affirmatively releases a non-debtor Permitted; Purdue reserved the issue Purdue; Midway Gold
Opt-out “deemed consent” release Treats silence as consent Unsettled; no circuit ruling located Smallhold; Spirit Airlines
Exculpation of estate fiduciaries Limits fiduciaries’ in-case liability Approved when limited to fiduciaries Midway Gold; Rocking M Media
Exculpation of future conduct Pre-clears post-confirmation acts Vulnerable under § 959(b) and persuasive authority Voyager (S.D.N.Y. 2026)
Section 105(a) injunction for the owner Stays suits against a non-debtor Temporary, until confirmation Western Real Estate Fund; Abel v. West

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Colorado Chapter 11 plan release my personal guaranty without the bank’s consent?

No. The Tenth Circuit held in 1990 that Section 524(e) bars a confirmed plan from permanently relieving a non-debtor of its own liability on the debtor’s debt, and Purdue reached the same result nationally in 2024. A guarantor is released only by the lender’s agreement or in the guarantor’s own bankruptcy.

Is exculpation the same thing as a release?

No. A release extinguishes creditors’ claims against a non-debtor. Exculpation protects estate fiduciaries, such as the debtor in possession and its officers, for conduct during the case, excepting gross negligence, willful misconduct, and fraud. The leading Colorado decision limits it to true fiduciaries.

Does the Voyager decision apply in Colorado?

It does not bind the District of Colorado, because it is a Southern District of New York ruling. Colorado bankruptcy judges can still find it persuasive on shielding future conduct from government enforcement, and federal law already requires a debtor in possession to follow valid state law.

Will not returning my ballot count as consenting to a release?

It depends on the court and the plan’s wording. Some courts accept opt-outs with clear disclosure, while others require an affirmative act such as voting or checking an opt-in box. We have not found a Tenth Circuit appellate ruling, so read every ballot and notice carefully.

Can the bankruptcy court stop my bank from suing me on the guaranty while the company reorganizes?

Possibly, for a limited time. The Tenth Circuit has allowed a temporary Section 105 injunction protecting a non-debtor when it helps the reorganization, but on rehearing it limited that protection to the period before plan confirmation. After confirmation, the lender can generally pursue the guarantor.

Should the owner of a small Colorado business file bankruptcy alongside the company?

Sometimes. If the guaranty exceeds what the owner can pay, his own case provides a stay and a discharge the company’s plan cannot, and the cases can often be jointly administered. The answer turns on Colorado’s exemptions and what the lender will accept.

How North Star Law Firm Can Help

North Star Law Firm represents Colorado businesses and their owners in Subchapter V reorganizations and Chapter 11 cases, including plan drafting and guaranty negotiations tied to SBA loans and other business debt. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. District Court and the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado and can weigh the tax side of guaranty settlements and debt forgiveness. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

If your company is heading toward Subchapter V and you signed a personal guaranty, plan for it before the petition is filed. To discuss your situation, contact North Star Law Firm.