Joanna, a relief veterinarian in Fort Collins who works for herself, lost months to a parent’s illness while her accountant stopped returning calls. She filed her 2022 and 2023 Forms 1040 together in March 2025, filed 2024 on time, and went on a payment plan for $38,000 of 2022 tax and $24,000 of 2023 tax. She made no estimated payments for either year. Her November 2026 notices show penalties and interest approaching three quarters of the tax.
She needs the math behind those numbers and an order of operations. Bankruptcy belongs in that answer too, and in Colorado it turns on two Tenth Circuit decisions that pull in opposite directions.
How do the failure to file and failure to pay penalties stack on a late Colorado return?
The failure to file penalty under 26 U.S.C. § 6651(a)(1) is 5 percent of the unpaid tax for each month late, counting a partial month as a full one, capped at 25 percent. The failure to pay penalty under § 6651(a)(2) is 0.5 percent a month, also capped at 25 percent. For months when both apply, § 6651(c)(1) reduces the filing penalty by the payment penalty, so the filing penalty stops at 22.5 percent after five months while the payment penalty can run for 50.
Interest on the filing penalty runs from the return’s due date, but interest on the payment penalty starts only at notice and demand (§ 6601(e)(2)). The rate is the federal short term rate plus 3 points, compounded daily (§ 6621(a)(2), § 6622(a)). The IRS rate table shows 8 percent from October 2023 through 2024 and 7 percent otherwise, except 6 percent in the second quarter of 2026.
Illustration, computed from the statute: Joanna’s 2022 return was due April 18, 2023 and her 2023 return April 15, 2024. Filed in mid March 2025, both hit the 22.5 percent ceiling, $8,550 for 2022 and $5,400 for 2023. By early November 2026 the 2022 payment penalty has run 43 months ($8,170) and the 2023 penalty 31 months ($3,720). Total: $25,840 of penalties on $62,000 of tax, plus roughly $19,600 of interest on the tax and filing penalties. I ignored her small plan payments and left out the separate estimated tax penalty under § 6654.
Her plan does not slow the meter: § 6651(h) halves the payment penalty during an installment agreement only for someone who filed on time, and § 6651(d) doubles it to 1 percent after a notice of intent to levy.
Should she ask for first time penalty abatement or reasonable cause relief, and for which year?
First time abatement is an administrative waiver in IRM 20.1.1.3.3.2.1. It removes filing, payment and deposit penalties for one tax period if the three prior years show the same return filed and no unreversed penalties other than estimated tax penalties, and the IRS applies it before reasonable cause.
Only 2022 can qualify, assuming 2019 through 2021 were clean, because the 2023 lookback includes penalized 2022. Abating 2022 removes $16,720 plus related interest, though the payment penalty keeps accruing on unpaid tax until the balance is paid.
That leaves reasonable cause for 2023. Treas. Reg. § 301.6651-1(c) asks whether she used ordinary business care and prudence and still could not comply. The silent accountant will not carry it: United States v. Boyle, 469 U.S. 241 (1985) holds that relying on an agent to file on time is not reasonable cause, and the Tenth Circuit applied the standard strictly in In re Craddock, 149 F.3d 1249 (10th Cir. 1998). A documented illness is stronger, but the IRS will ask why filing waited until March 2025.
The IRS eligibility page does not hold a penalty abated for reasonable cause against a later year. My read: if 2022 were relieved that way, 2023 might qualify for the waiver under the IRM, which asks only that prior returns were filed. The web page says “timely filed,” so do not count on it.
For later years, IR-2026-83 (July 8, 2026) announced an Automatic Exemption from Penalty for eligible original returns beginning with tax year 2025; it replaces first time abatement for eligible returns originally due on or after January 1, 2027.
IRS Penalty Notice in Hand? Contact Us Now
Where does an IRS penalty appeal go if relief is denied?
The IRS penalty appeal page gives a taxpayer generally 30 days from the rejection letter to ask for Appeals, with the letter controlling the exact date. Know the cost first. Under § 6330(c)(2)(B), a collection due process hearing can address the liability only if there was no notice of deficiency or other opportunity to dispute it. Treas. Reg. § 301.6330-1(e)(3), Q&A-E2, counts an offered Appeals conference as that opportunity, and the Tenth Circuit upheld it in Keller Tank Services II, Inc. v. Commissioner, 854 F.3d 1178 (10th Cir. 2017), used or not. After a penalty appeal, assume that Tax Court route is closed.
Nor are these penalties part of a Tax Court deficiency case. Section 6665(b) keeps § 6651 and § 6654 additions out of deficiency procedures except the part tied to a deficiency. See my post on the Tax Court versus a refund suit.
The other route is pay and sue. A refund claim on Form 843 is due within three years of filing the return or two years of payment, whichever is later (§ 6511(a)). Suit may start six months after the claim, or sooner if the IRS rules, and no later than two years after a disallowance notice (§ 6532(a)(1)), in the District of Colorado under 28 U.S.C. § 1346(a)(1) and 26 U.S.C. § 7422(a). Flora v. United States, 362 U.S. 145 (1960) requires full payment first, which is hard on a payment plan.
Are IRS penalties discharged in bankruptcy in Colorado?
Often, even when the tax survives. Under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(7), a tax penalty survives Chapter 7 only if it relates to a nondischargeable tax under subparagraph (A) and is not saved by subparagraph (B), which covers a transaction or event more than three years before the petition. Roberts v. United States (In re Roberts), 906 F.2d 1440 (10th Cir. 1990) read the two as alternatives and discharged penalties for the 1982 and 1983 tax years while the tax survived.
Mallo v. IRS (In re Mallo), 774 F.3d 1313 (10th Cir. 2014), which came out of Colorado, held that a late Form 1040 is not a “return” for discharge purposes unless prepared under § 6020(a). The Supreme Court denied review of the circuit split in Salvador v. United States, No. 24-108 (Nov. 4, 2024). Interest on a surviving tax survives too (In re Burns, 887 F.2d 1541 (11th Cir. 1989)).
For Joanna, the tax would likely survive a Colorado Chapter 7, but the penalties differ. Roberts treated the tax year as the event; using the later and safer anchor of the due date, the three years ran for 2022 on April 18, 2026 and run for 2023 on April 15, 2027. I found no Tenth Circuit decision dating a payment penalty that grows monthly, so recent months may be argued to fall inside the window.
Chapter 13 differs. The discharge in § 1328(a)(2) excepts late return taxes under § 523(a)(1)(B) but not § 523(a)(7), so on my reading the penalties, as general unsecured claims, are discharged at completion. They get no priority under § 507(a)(8)(G), which covers only penalties compensating actual loss, and § 726(a)(4) pays them only after general unsecured creditors in Chapter 7.
Does an IRS abatement change what Colorado says she owes?
No. Colorado assesses its own additions under C.R.S. § 39-22-621, which caps the late filing and late payment penalties at 12 percent, charges only the larger when both apply, and lets the executive director waive penalties for good cause. A federal abatement can support that request, but Colorado decides it separately.
| Relief route | Penalties it reaches | What you must show | Where a denial goes |
|---|---|---|---|
| First time abatement, by request (a separate automatic exemption covers eligible 2025 and later returns) | Failure to file, pay or deposit; one tax period | Same return filed for three prior years, no unreversed penalties | Appeals, usually within 30 days of the letter |
| Reasonable cause | Filing, payment, deposit and accuracy penalties, not § 6654 | Ordinary business care and prudence | Appeals, then a refund claim and suit |
| Statutory waiver or IRS error | Penalties caused by written IRS advice; some estimated tax penalties | Advice answering your written request (§ 6404(f)); disaster, retirement or disability (§ 6654(e)(3)) | Refund claim on Form 843 |
| Refund claim and suit | Any penalty paid | Full payment, timely claim, six months’ wait | District of Colorado, then the Tenth Circuit |
| Bankruptcy discharge after three years | Noncompensatory tax penalties | Penalty event more than three years before the petition | Bankruptcy court; the late return tax itself may survive |
Frequently Asked Questions
Will the IRS remove my penalties automatically now?
Only for eligible returns starting with tax year 2025. Older years still need a request.
Is my accountant missing the deadline reasonable cause?
Usually not. Boyle holds that relying on an agent to file is not reasonable cause, and the Tenth Circuit applied the reasonable cause standard strictly in Craddock.
Can the Tax Court hear a failure to pay penalty dispute?
Not in a deficiency case for tax you reported. A collection due process appeal reaches it only if you had no earlier chance to dispute it.
Is a trust fund recovery penalty the same as a late deposit penalty?
No. The deposit penalty is § 6656. The § 6672 penalty is a personal liability equal to the unpaid withheld taxes, owed by responsible people who acted willfully; see my post on board members and trust fund penalties.
Does the supervisory approval rule help with late filing penalties?
No. Section 6751(b)(2)(A) exempts § 6651 and § 6654. For audit penalties, an unpublished Tenth Circuit order, Minemyer v. Commissioner, No. 21-9006 (Jan. 19, 2023), accepted approval given by the notice of deficiency.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm prepares penalty abatement requests for Colorado taxpayers, handles IRS Appeals and collection due process hearings, and evaluates which tax debts and penalties a bankruptcy can discharge. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.
If your notices show penalties growing faster than your plan payments, contact North Star Law Firm.
