Category: Tax Defense

  • Colorado IRS Penalties: Stacked Math, Which Relief to Request First, and Bankruptcy

    Colorado IRS Penalties: Stacked Math, Which Relief to Request First, and Bankruptcy

    Joanna, a relief veterinarian in Fort Collins who works for herself, lost months to a parent’s illness while her accountant stopped returning calls. She filed her 2022 and 2023 Forms 1040 together in March 2025, filed 2024 on time, and went on a payment plan for $38,000 of 2022 tax and $24,000 of 2023 tax. She made no estimated payments for either year. Her November 2026 notices show penalties and interest approaching three quarters of the tax.

    She needs the math behind those numbers and an order of operations. Bankruptcy belongs in that answer too, and in Colorado it turns on two Tenth Circuit decisions that pull in opposite directions.

    How do the failure to file and failure to pay penalties stack on a late Colorado return?

    The failure to file penalty under 26 U.S.C. § 6651(a)(1) is 5 percent of the unpaid tax for each month late, counting a partial month as a full one, capped at 25 percent. The failure to pay penalty under § 6651(a)(2) is 0.5 percent a month, also capped at 25 percent. For months when both apply, § 6651(c)(1) reduces the filing penalty by the payment penalty, so the filing penalty stops at 22.5 percent after five months while the payment penalty can run for 50.

    Interest on the filing penalty runs from the return’s due date, but interest on the payment penalty starts only at notice and demand (§ 6601(e)(2)). The rate is the federal short term rate plus 3 points, compounded daily (§ 6621(a)(2), § 6622(a)). The IRS rate table shows 8 percent from October 2023 through 2024 and 7 percent otherwise, except 6 percent in the second quarter of 2026.

    Illustration, computed from the statute: Joanna’s 2022 return was due April 18, 2023 and her 2023 return April 15, 2024. Filed in mid March 2025, both hit the 22.5 percent ceiling, $8,550 for 2022 and $5,400 for 2023. By early November 2026 the 2022 payment penalty has run 43 months ($8,170) and the 2023 penalty 31 months ($3,720). Total: $25,840 of penalties on $62,000 of tax, plus roughly $19,600 of interest on the tax and filing penalties. I ignored her small plan payments and left out the separate estimated tax penalty under § 6654.

    Her plan does not slow the meter: § 6651(h) halves the payment penalty during an installment agreement only for someone who filed on time, and § 6651(d) doubles it to 1 percent after a notice of intent to levy.

    Should she ask for first time penalty abatement or reasonable cause relief, and for which year?

    First time abatement is an administrative waiver in IRM 20.1.1.3.3.2.1. It removes filing, payment and deposit penalties for one tax period if the three prior years show the same return filed and no unreversed penalties other than estimated tax penalties, and the IRS applies it before reasonable cause.

    Only 2022 can qualify, assuming 2019 through 2021 were clean, because the 2023 lookback includes penalized 2022. Abating 2022 removes $16,720 plus related interest, though the payment penalty keeps accruing on unpaid tax until the balance is paid.

    That leaves reasonable cause for 2023. Treas. Reg. § 301.6651-1(c) asks whether she used ordinary business care and prudence and still could not comply. The silent accountant will not carry it: United States v. Boyle, 469 U.S. 241 (1985) holds that relying on an agent to file on time is not reasonable cause, and the Tenth Circuit applied the standard strictly in In re Craddock, 149 F.3d 1249 (10th Cir. 1998). A documented illness is stronger, but the IRS will ask why filing waited until March 2025.

    The IRS eligibility page does not hold a penalty abated for reasonable cause against a later year. My read: if 2022 were relieved that way, 2023 might qualify for the waiver under the IRM, which asks only that prior returns were filed. The web page says “timely filed,” so do not count on it.

    For later years, IR-2026-83 (July 8, 2026) announced an Automatic Exemption from Penalty for eligible original returns beginning with tax year 2025; it replaces first time abatement for eligible returns originally due on or after January 1, 2027.

    IRS Penalty Notice in Hand? Contact Us Now

    Where does an IRS penalty appeal go if relief is denied?

    The IRS penalty appeal page gives a taxpayer generally 30 days from the rejection letter to ask for Appeals, with the letter controlling the exact date. Know the cost first. Under § 6330(c)(2)(B), a collection due process hearing can address the liability only if there was no notice of deficiency or other opportunity to dispute it. Treas. Reg. § 301.6330-1(e)(3), Q&A-E2, counts an offered Appeals conference as that opportunity, and the Tenth Circuit upheld it in Keller Tank Services II, Inc. v. Commissioner, 854 F.3d 1178 (10th Cir. 2017), used or not. After a penalty appeal, assume that Tax Court route is closed.

    Nor are these penalties part of a Tax Court deficiency case. Section 6665(b) keeps § 6651 and § 6654 additions out of deficiency procedures except the part tied to a deficiency. See my post on the Tax Court versus a refund suit.

    The other route is pay and sue. A refund claim on Form 843 is due within three years of filing the return or two years of payment, whichever is later (§ 6511(a)). Suit may start six months after the claim, or sooner if the IRS rules, and no later than two years after a disallowance notice (§ 6532(a)(1)), in the District of Colorado under 28 U.S.C. § 1346(a)(1) and 26 U.S.C. § 7422(a). Flora v. United States, 362 U.S. 145 (1960) requires full payment first, which is hard on a payment plan.

    Are IRS penalties discharged in bankruptcy in Colorado?

    Often, even when the tax survives. Under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(7), a tax penalty survives Chapter 7 only if it relates to a nondischargeable tax under subparagraph (A) and is not saved by subparagraph (B), which covers a transaction or event more than three years before the petition. Roberts v. United States (In re Roberts), 906 F.2d 1440 (10th Cir. 1990) read the two as alternatives and discharged penalties for the 1982 and 1983 tax years while the tax survived.

    Mallo v. IRS (In re Mallo), 774 F.3d 1313 (10th Cir. 2014), which came out of Colorado, held that a late Form 1040 is not a “return” for discharge purposes unless prepared under § 6020(a). The Supreme Court denied review of the circuit split in Salvador v. United States, No. 24-108 (Nov. 4, 2024). Interest on a surviving tax survives too (In re Burns, 887 F.2d 1541 (11th Cir. 1989)).

    For Joanna, the tax would likely survive a Colorado Chapter 7, but the penalties differ. Roberts treated the tax year as the event; using the later and safer anchor of the due date, the three years ran for 2022 on April 18, 2026 and run for 2023 on April 15, 2027. I found no Tenth Circuit decision dating a payment penalty that grows monthly, so recent months may be argued to fall inside the window.

    Chapter 13 differs. The discharge in § 1328(a)(2) excepts late return taxes under § 523(a)(1)(B) but not § 523(a)(7), so on my reading the penalties, as general unsecured claims, are discharged at completion. They get no priority under § 507(a)(8)(G), which covers only penalties compensating actual loss, and § 726(a)(4) pays them only after general unsecured creditors in Chapter 7.

    Does an IRS abatement change what Colorado says she owes?

    No. Colorado assesses its own additions under C.R.S. § 39-22-621, which caps the late filing and late payment penalties at 12 percent, charges only the larger when both apply, and lets the executive director waive penalties for good cause. A federal abatement can support that request, but Colorado decides it separately.

    Relief route Penalties it reaches What you must show Where a denial goes
    First time abatement, by request (a separate automatic exemption covers eligible 2025 and later returns) Failure to file, pay or deposit; one tax period Same return filed for three prior years, no unreversed penalties Appeals, usually within 30 days of the letter
    Reasonable cause Filing, payment, deposit and accuracy penalties, not § 6654 Ordinary business care and prudence Appeals, then a refund claim and suit
    Statutory waiver or IRS error Penalties caused by written IRS advice; some estimated tax penalties Advice answering your written request (§ 6404(f)); disaster, retirement or disability (§ 6654(e)(3)) Refund claim on Form 843
    Refund claim and suit Any penalty paid Full payment, timely claim, six months’ wait District of Colorado, then the Tenth Circuit
    Bankruptcy discharge after three years Noncompensatory tax penalties Penalty event more than three years before the petition Bankruptcy court; the late return tax itself may survive

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Will the IRS remove my penalties automatically now?

    Only for eligible returns starting with tax year 2025. Older years still need a request.

    Is my accountant missing the deadline reasonable cause?

    Usually not. Boyle holds that relying on an agent to file is not reasonable cause, and the Tenth Circuit applied the reasonable cause standard strictly in Craddock.

    Can the Tax Court hear a failure to pay penalty dispute?

    Not in a deficiency case for tax you reported. A collection due process appeal reaches it only if you had no earlier chance to dispute it.

    Is a trust fund recovery penalty the same as a late deposit penalty?

    No. The deposit penalty is § 6656. The § 6672 penalty is a personal liability equal to the unpaid withheld taxes, owed by responsible people who acted willfully; see my post on board members and trust fund penalties.

    Does the supervisory approval rule help with late filing penalties?

    No. Section 6751(b)(2)(A) exempts § 6651 and § 6654. For audit penalties, an unpublished Tenth Circuit order, Minemyer v. Commissioner, No. 21-9006 (Jan. 19, 2023), accepted approval given by the notice of deficiency.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm prepares penalty abatement requests for Colorado taxpayers, handles IRS Appeals and collection due process hearings, and evaluates which tax debts and penalties a bankruptcy can discharge. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If your notices show penalties growing faster than your plan payments, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Colorado PPP and EIDL Borrowers: How DOJ’s New Directive Turns a Loan File Into a Tax Case

    Colorado PPP and EIDL Borrowers: How DOJ’s New Directive Turns a Loan File Into a Tax Case

    Gideon runs a trucking and ag hauling S corporation in Greeley with about nine drivers. The company took PPP loans of $187,000 in 2020 and $150,000 in 2021, both forgiven, plus a $200,000 SBA COVID EIDL that is now 14 months behind. A dispatcher he fired in 2024 keeps posting “fraud” about the company online. Meanwhile his bookkeeper has spotted a real problem: the payroll on the PPP applications is higher than the Forms W-3 the company filed, and the 2020 and 2021 Forms 941 and 1120-S were all late.

    Most coverage this fall has been about the Justice Department paying tipsters. For a borrower like Gideon, the bigger change is a memo telling fraud prosecutors to look for a tax case every time. That is where I would start.

    Why would a PPP loan fraud investigation in Colorado turn into an IRS criminal case?

    The Justice Department created its National Fraud Enforcement Division by an Acting Attorney General memo dated April 7, 2026. In October the division opened a tip rewards pilot that, according to its published FAQs, pays $10,000 to $30,000 once charges are unsealed, and SBA program fraud is covered.

    The more important document is Directive 26-13, “A Comprehensive Approach in the Fight Against Fraud” (Oct. 7, 2026). It tells prosecutors to assess “in every case” whether “a violation of the internal revenue laws has occurred,” and to invite IRS Criminal Investigation to evaluate the tax side when tax charges would advance the case or asset recovery. It also targets unpaid tax on “fraudulently obtained or unreported income.” The memo never mentions PPP or EIDL. It does not need to.

    Colorado already has the machinery. The U.S. Attorney’s Office here was picked on July 11, 2023 to lead one of five national COVID-19 Fraud Strike Force teams, and the IRS-CI Denver Field Office investigates local PPP cases. In United States v. Nieto, No. 22-cr-00262-WJM (D. Colo.), a Morrison contractor got 46 months in June 2025; the IRS release says he fabricated Forms 941 that did not match the returns he had actually filed. That mismatch is what a tax agent hunts for.

    Which tax charges can a PPP or EIDL file pull in with IRS Criminal Investigation?

    On the loan side the usual charges are 18 U.S.C. § 1014 (false statements to the SBA or an FDIC insured lender), wire fraud and conspiracy under § 1343 and § 1349, § 1001, theft of government money under § 641, and money laundering under § 1957 for transactions over $10,000. Nieto and a Colorado Springs borrower sentenced in January 2025 were both convicted of wire fraud and laundering.

    Directive 26-13 adds the tax column. A Form 941 or 1120-S the owner knew was false supports a count under 26 U.S.C. § 7206(1), and a bookkeeper who helped faces § 7206(2). Withheld payroll tax never paid over fits § 7202; years with no return fit § 7203; a pattern of hiding income becomes evasion under § 7201.

    The facts that create this exposure are familiar. Application payroll above the 941s means either an inflated application or wages paid off the books. EIDL money spent on the owner’s mortgage was income to someone and often never reported. Forgiven PPP is tax exempt under 15 U.S.C. § 636m(i), as amended by section 276 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021, with the deductions preserved, but if prosecutors treat the excess as money obtained by fraud rather than a loan, nobody should assume that treatment survives.

    Worried About Your PPP or EIDL File? Contact Us Now

    What is the statute of limitations for PPP fraud, and when does the tax side close?

    Ten years on the loan. The PPP and Bank Fraud Enforcement Harmonization Act of 2022 put that deadline in 15 U.S.C. § 636(a)(36)(W) and (a)(37)(P), and the COVID-19 EIDL Fraud Statute of Limitations Act of 2022 did the same in § 636(b)(16) and § 9009(e)(9), for criminal and civil cases alike.

    Most criminal tax charges get six years under 26 U.S.C. § 6531. Civil assessment usually ends three years after filing under § 6501(a), but a fraudulent return can be assessed “at any time” under § 6501(c)(1), with a 75 percent penalty under § 6663.

    On one calendar: if Gideon signed his first application in April 2020, it can be charged until April 2030. If his late 2020 Form 1120-S was filed in December 2021, a § 7206(1) count on it expires in December 2027. The criminal tax window can close years before the loan window, while civil fraud on that same year never closes. The post on Colorado limitations periods after Murrin covers how fraud keeps old years open.

    How does an EIDL fraud whistleblower read my file against public data?

    The FAQs say original information can come from “independent analysis of public or private data.” For PPP, much of it is public. The SBA’s PPP FOIA dataset shows borrower name, lender, amounts approved and forgiven, and jobs reported, and ProPublica publishes a searchable copy. A former employee can lay those numbers beside Secretary of State records, job postings and what he saw in the yard. Just assume your file will be read against public numbers by someone who wants it to look bad.

    What does a payroll gap mean for a Greeley trucking company’s PPP file?

    An illustrative version of Gideon’s numbers: first and second draw loans were capped at 2.5 times average monthly payroll under 15 U.S.C. § 636(a)(36)(E) and (a)(37)(C). To support $187,000 and $150,000, his applications claimed about $74,800 and $60,000 a month. Assume his Forms 941 show about $45,000 a month in 2019 and 2020 ($540,000 for 2020). On those filings each loan tops out near $112,500, leaving roughly $112,000 of the $337,000 unexplained. In United States v. Joseph, 108 F.4th 1273 (10th Cir. 2024), a Colorado Springs PPP case, the Tenth Circuit upheld counting an earlier failed application as intended loss, so a sentencing loss figure can exceed what was received.

    A counsel led review rebuilds payroll from bank records, 941s and W-2s first. The innocent explanation I see most is owner pay that never ran through payroll. That helps less than people hope, because payroll costs under § 636(a)(36)(A)(viii) mean compensation to employees, and S corporation draws are not wages. If he worked full time on no salary, the IRS may recast part of the draws as wages, and the trust fund recovery penalty under § 6672 can reach him personally.

    The EIDL comes after that. A hardship plan or offer requires sworn financial statements, so it waits for the exposure review. Any compromised balance is also debt cancellation income under 26 U.S.C. § 61(a)(11) unless a § 108(a) exclusion, such as bankruptcy or insolvency, applies.

    Should I amend returns or ask the SBA for relief before a lawyer reviews the file?

    No. Under IRM 25.1.2.2, an examiner who sees badges of fraud brings in a fraud enforcement advisor, develops “affirmative acts” of fraud, suspends the exam once they are found, and refers the case to Criminal Investigation when criminal criteria are met. After CI opens a case, IRM 9.5.1.2.1 has the agent ask civil functions to suspend their work. An amended return filed midstream is a signed admission.

    The tax practitioner privilege in 26 U.S.C. § 7525 applies only in noncriminal matters, so what you tell your CPA is unprotected if the case turns criminal. The fix is for the lawyer to hire the accountant, as in United States v. Kovel, 296 F.2d 918 (2d Cir. 1961). Kovel is a Second Circuit case, and I did not locate a Tenth Circuit opinion deciding the point, so the engagement terms matter. The Fifth Amendment protects what you say; a first call from an agent is not the time to explain.

    My order is criminal exposure, then civil tax compliance, then SBA or Treasury resolution or bankruptcy. For collection, see SBA demand letters, Treasury offset and bankruptcy in Colorado.

    Colorado borrower profile Likely civil tax issue Potential criminal exposure First step
    Clean loan file, late 941s and 1120-S Late filing and payment penalties Low; § 7203 only if willful Confirm filings support the applications, then catch up
    Application payroll above the 941s Unreported wages, employment tax, § 6672 § 1014, § 1343, § 7206(1) Payroll reconstruction through counsel
    EIDL spent on personal bills Unreported distributions or wages § 641, § 1957, false returns Trace the EIDL before any hardship request
    Forgiven PPP, no real operations Whether § 636m(i) applies; civil fraud penalty Highest: loan, laundering and tax counts Criminal defense counsel before any contact

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Does the DOJ WHIP whistleblower program cover PPP and EIDL fraud?

    Yes. The FAQs list fraud on Small Business Administration programs as covered. Rewards of $10,000 to $30,000 are paid after charges are unsealed, not after conviction.

    Can IRS Criminal Investigation open a case over a PPP loan?

    Yes. IRS-CI investigates tax crimes and money laundering and has worked Colorado PPP cases. Directive 26-13 now has fraud prosecutors ask about tax charges in every case.

    How long can the government charge PPP fraud?

    Ten years from the offense under the 2022 amendments to 15 U.S.C. § 636. An application signed in 2021 can be charged into 2031.

    Is a forgiven PPP loan taxable income?

    Legitimately forgiven PPP is excluded from gross income by 15 U.S.C. § 636m(i), and the related deductions stay. A loan forgiven on false certifications is an unsettled question.

    Should I file amended returns to fix the payroll numbers?

    Not before a lawyer reviews your exposure. An amended return is sworn, and if a fraud referral is underway it becomes evidence.

    Is my CPA’s advice on the PPP file privileged?

    Not in a criminal case. Section 7525 stops at noncriminal matters, so when criminal exposure is possible the CPA should be retained through counsel.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm reviews PPP and EIDL files for Colorado business owners, handles IRS audit defense and unfiled and late tax returns, and works on SBA loans and business debt once the tax picture is clear. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If your PPP applications and payroll filings do not agree, have the file reviewed before anyone signs a new form. To start, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Colorado Nonprofit IRS Audit: When Volunteer Board Members Owe the Payroll Taxes

    Colorado Nonprofit IRS Audit: When Volunteer Board Members Owe the Payroll Taxes

    Owen is the volunteer treasurer of a youth-mentoring 501(c)(3) in Colorado Springs with 14 employees and a $1.4 million budget. He co-signs checks over $5,000 and sees the bank statements before each board meeting. In October an IRS exempt organizations examiner asked for the 2023 and 2024 Forms 990, board minutes and payroll records. Pulling them, Owen learned the executive director had skipped federal payroll tax deposits for two quarters of 2025 to make payroll.

    His question for me was whether he could personally owe the money. He can. Whether he will depends on what he knew, when, and what he signs from here on.

    Can a volunteer board member personally owe a Colorado nonprofit’s unpaid payroll taxes?

    Yes. Income tax and the employee’s share of Social Security and Medicare withheld from a paycheck are “a special fund in trust for the United States” under 26 U.S.C. § 7501(a). If they are not paid over, 26 U.S.C. § 6672(a) imposes a penalty equal to the unpaid amount on any person “required to collect, truthfully account for, and pay over” the tax who “willfully fails” to do it. This is the trust fund recovery penalty, or TFRP.

    Section 6672(a) has no carve-out for charities. The IRS’s employment tax page for exempt organizations names “a member of a board of trustees of a tax-exempt organization” as a possible target. Colorado Springs hosts an unusual concentration of national ministries and youth organizations with large unpaid boards.

    How does an IRS exam of a Colorado nonprofit become a collection case against board members?

    The IRS says an exempt organization audit may cover employment tax returns and whether employment taxes were paid. The examiners’ manual is blunter: IRM 4.70.12.3.6.2.1 calls employment tax “an integral part of the examination of an exempt organization,” and tells the agent to consider § 6672. The TE/GE Program Letter for fiscal year 2027 again lists worker classification and “various employment tax related issues.”

    So an exam of 2023 and 2024 returns can surface a 2025 deposit gap. Under IRM 5.7.3.5.1, an examiner who sees a possible TFRP refers it to Collection on Form 6238, and a revenue officer investigates the individuals. Insider pay and other organization-level issues run separately; see Section 4958 excess benefit taxes for Colorado nonprofits.

    Nonprofit Got an IRS Exam Letter? Contact Us Now

    Does the Section 6672(e) volunteer exception protect a board treasurer who signs checks?

    Usually not. Section 6672(e) bars the penalty against an “unpaid, volunteer member” of an exempt organization’s board who serves “solely” in an honorary capacity, “does not participate in the day-to-day or financial operations,” and lacks “actual knowledge of the failure.” All three must hold, and the exception falls away if it would leave no one liable. IRS Policy Statement 5-14, at IRM 1.2.1.6.3, tracks the statute.

    A treasurer who co-signs checks is not honorary. In Jefferson v. United States, 546 F.3d 477 (7th Cir. 2008), the unpaid board president of an Illinois day care co-signed checks, approved financial statements and could borrow; he was not serving “solely in an honorary capacity,” and his claimed lack of knowledge did not help. I have found no Tenth Circuit decision applying § 6672(e).

    Muck v. United States, 3 F.3d 1378 (10th Cir. 1993), a Thornton hotel case, held that “significant, though not necessarily exclusive, authority” counts “irrespective of whether that authority is actually exercised.” Denbo v. United States, 988 F.2d 1029 (10th Cir. 1993) held a director willful who relied on his co-owner’s assurances instead of investigating. Taylor v. IRS, 69 F.3d 411 (10th Cir. 1995) found a board member with no stock responsible because he had “effective power” to pay, and Bradshaw v. United States, 83 F.3d 1175 (10th Cir. 1996) rejected a lender-control excuse. The narrow opening is Finley v. United States, 123 F.3d 1342 (10th Cir. 1997) (en banc): reasonable cause can negate willfulness, but only when efforts to protect the trust funds were frustrated by circumstances beyond the person’s control.

    What deadlines does a nonprofit director face after a Letter 1153?

    The revenue officer will seek a Form 4180 interview with each potentially responsible person. If the officer recommends the penalty, Letter 1153 follows. Section 6672(b)(2) requires at least 60 days before notice and demand, and IRM 5.7.4.7 extends that to 75 days for a letter addressed outside the United States. A timely protest goes to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals.

    For Form 941 periods, § 6501(b)(2) treats an early return as filed April 15 of the next year, and § 6501(a) gives three years from then to assess. Under § 6672(b)(3), a Letter 1153 mailed in time keeps it open until the later of 90 days after mailing or 30 days after Appeals finishes. With no return filed, § 6501(c)(3) leaves it open.

    After assessment, § 6330(a) requires notice of a hearing right at least 30 days before levy, and the hearing must be requested within that 30-day period. Someone who already had the Letter 1153 protest opportunity generally cannot reargue liability there, under § 6330(c)(2)(B). The court route is a refund suit. Flora v. United States, 362 U.S. 145 (1960) normally requires full payment, but in Boynton v. United States, 566 F.2d 50 (9th Cir. 1977), involving a nonprofit’s staff, the court said a TFRP taxpayer “need only pay the divisible amount” tied to one employee’s withholding. You then file Form 843 and sue in district court or the Court of Federal Claims, the forums § 6672(c) names.

    How would this play out for a Colorado Springs youth nonprofit in 2026?

    Illustrative example (hypothetical facts). Owen’s organization paid about $444,000 of wages in the second and third quarters of 2025 and filed both Forms 941 without paying. The $96,000 owed splits into about $34,000 of employer Social Security and Medicare, $34,000 of employee share and $28,000 of withheld income tax. Under IRM 5.7.4.3 the TFRP equals the employee share plus withholding, roughly $62,000. Because both returns were filed before April 15, 2026, the IRS has until April 15, 2029 to assess.

    The revenue officer will interview the executive director, Owen, the board chair and the bookkeeper. A director who never sees bank records and learned of the gap from the exam letter fits § 6672(e), and the exception works because the executive director stays liable. Owen’s best argument is lack of knowledge, which goes to willfulness. His bigger risk is ahead of him: Muck requires a responsible person who learns of the delinquency to send unencumbered funds to the IRS before other creditors, so every vendor check he co-signs this November counts.

    If the organization can raise cash, paperwork matters. Policy Statement 5-14 applies an undesignated payment to the employer’s share first; a written designation to the trust fund portion shrinks what any individual can be charged. The same statement says that, absent statute concerns, assertion recommendations are normally withheld while a business installment agreement is current. An earlier post covers the contractor version of this trust fund problem.

    Do Colorado’s nonprofit liability shields or a bankruptcy filing protect a director?

    Not against the IRS. C.R.S. § 13-21-115.7 gives uncompensated 501(c)(3) directors civil immunity absent willful and wanton conduct, and C.R.S. § 7-128-402 lets the articles limit damages owed to the corporation or its members. None stops a federal § 6672 assessment. Colorado treats withheld state income tax as held in trust under C.R.S. § 39-22-604(7), and C.R.S. § 39-21-116.5 adds a 150 percent penalty on corporate officers who willfully fail to pay over taxes they must collect. Unemployment premiums are an employer cost, not withheld from wages (C.R.S. § 8-76-101), so they raise no trust fund issue.

    Bankruptcy helps less than people expect. The TFRP is a priority tax under 11 U.S.C. § 507(a)(8)(C), so § 523(a)(1)(A) keeps it alive after a director’s own Chapter 7 discharge. The organization’s Chapter 11 does not shield him, though United States v. Energy Resources Co., 495 U.S. 545 (1990) lets the court direct plan payments to trust fund taxes first when the plan’s success requires it.

    Person Responsible person and § 6672(e) What the Form 4180 interview probes Likely exposure
    Honorary volunteer director Usually not responsible; exception available if unpaid, outside finances and unaware Board role, access to bank records, when the gap became known Low
    Volunteer treasurer who co-signs checks Likely responsible under Muck and Taylor; exception rarely fits Signature authority, which bills got paid, knowledge of missed deposits High if willful
    Executive director Responsible; paid staff, so no exception Who chose wages over deposits Highest
    Outside bookkeeper Usually not, if paying bills as directed (IRM 5.7.3.4.1.2) Whether he or she picked which creditors got paid Low to moderate

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can the IRS go after a Colorado nonprofit’s board members for unpaid payroll taxes?

    Yes, for the withheld trust fund portion, if a member was responsible and acted willfully. Unpaid volunteers serving in a purely honorary role without knowledge are protected by section 6672(e).

    Does a nonprofit’s IRS audit cover payroll taxes?

    It can. The IRS manual treats employment tax as an integral part of an exempt organization exam, and examiners check whether Forms 941 were filed and paid.

    How long do I have to appeal a proposed trust fund recovery penalty?

    Letter 1153 gives 60 days, or 75 days if addressed outside the United States. A timely protest goes to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals.

    Is a board treasurer who signs checks a responsible person?

    Often. Check-signing alone is not decisive under IRM 5.7.3.4.1.1, but the Tenth Circuit counts authority whether or not it is used.

    Can I discharge a trust fund recovery penalty in bankruptcy?

    Not in Chapter 7. It is a priority tax under section 507(a)(8)(C), and section 523(a)(1)(A) excepts it from discharge.

    Does Colorado’s volunteer immunity statute stop the IRS penalty?

    No. C.R.S. 13-21-115.7 addresses state civil liability and does not bar a federal tax assessment.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents Colorado nonprofit directors and organizations in IRS audit defense, trust fund penalty appeals and CDP hearings, and installment agreements for unpaid payroll taxes. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    What a board member says in the Form 4180 interview, and signs after the exam letter arrives, can decide the case. If your organization has an IRS exam letter and payroll deposits are behind, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Dyed Diesel Tax Relief in Colorado: What the IRS Waived and What Truckers Still Owe

    Dyed Diesel Tax Relief in Colorado: What the IRS Waived and What Truckers Still Owe

    Tobias farms 900 acres of wheat and sugar beets outside Fort Morgan and runs four grain trucks along I-76. In mid-October, with diesel prices climbing, he asked his bookkeeper about filling the trucks from the red-dyed tank behind the shop. She had seen a headline that Washington lifted the dyed diesel rules, but nothing on what it meant for the Form 720 she files, or for Colorado.

    As of October 23, 2026, the IRS has dropped the penalty and most of the paperwork, but not the tax. Colorado has told its troopers to stand down but said nothing about the state fuel tax.

    What did the IRS waive for dyed diesel used on the highway in 2026?

    IR-2026-122 (October 14, 2026) says the IRS will not impose a penalty when dyed diesel is sold for use or used on highways nationwide from October 1 through December 31, 2026. Federal inspections of on-road dyed fuel are suspended, and sellers need not document end use. Deposit and recordkeeping penalties are covered too.

    The penalty switched off is 26 U.S.C. § 6715: the greater of $1,000 or $10 per gallon for each act, with a higher floor for repeat offenders under § 6715(b)(2). It applies when a seller or user knew or had reason to know the fuel was dyed or bound for a taxable use. “Willfully” appears only in the tampering clause and in § 6715(d), which makes an officer or employee who willfully took part jointly liable.

    Next, IR-2026-125 (October 21, 2026) said the IRS will not challenge a failure to file Form 720 solely to report § 4041(a) liability from taxable uses of dyed diesel between October 1, 2026 and January 1, 2027, or to keep records of it, and will not require later filing. Other Form 720 liabilities must still be reported.

    Is the federal diesel excise tax deferred or forgiven under Executive Order 14435?

    Neither, yet. Executive Order 14435, signed October 5, 2026 (91 Fed. Reg. 64747), gave the Treasury Secretary five days to decide if 26 U.S.C. § 7508A allows relief, including whether a qualifying event occurred. If so, Treasury is to defer payment of the taxes imposed by § 4041(a)(1)(A) and § 4041(b)(1)(B) incurred October 5 through December 31, 2026, without interest or penalties. Section 4 only tells Treasury to explore eliminating the deferred amounts. The order’s window opens October 5; the IRS’s opens October 1.

    Most diesel is taxed at the terminal rack at 24.3 cents a gallon under § 4081(a)(2)(A)(iii), plus 0.1 cent under § 4081(a)(2)(B), and Treas. Reg. § 48.4081-2 puts it on the position holder. The order leaves it alone. Dyed fuel escapes the rack tax under § 4082(a). Put in a highway vehicle, § 4041(a)(1)(A) imposes a back-up tax at the regular rate, owed by the retail seller or, for farm-tank fuel, the vehicle operator.

    As of October 23, I found no § 7508A notice in the Internal Revenue Bulletin and no revised Form 720 instructions. Section 7508A lets Treasury disregard up to one year for taxpayers affected by a federally declared disaster, a significant fire, or a terroristic or military action under § 692(c)(2). It postpones; it cannot forgive. The order’s nod to the Secretary of War, and Colorado’s own order blaming U.S. strikes on Iran that began February 28, 2026, point to the military-action prong; whether a price shock makes a Fort Morgan farmer “affected,” Treasury has not said.

    Got a Dyed Diesel or Form 720 Penalty Notice? Contact Us Now

    Does Colorado allow dyed diesel on state highways this fall?

    C.R.S. § 42-4-1414(1) still bars driving on a Colorado highway using dyed diesel, a class B traffic infraction. What changed is enforcement. Executive Order D 2026 020 (October 9, 2026) tells the Department of Public Safety not to enforce the ban through December 31, 2026, and to skip inspections or citations based “solely upon the presence or use of dyed diesel fuel.”

    The order never mentions the Department of Revenue or the special fuel tax, which is 20.5 cents a gallon under C.R.S. § 39-27-102(1)(a)(II)(B), plus a 6-cent road usage fee for fiscal year 2026-27 under C.R.S. § 43-4-217(4)(b)(I)(E). Dyed fuel is exempt, but C.R.S. § 39-27-102.5(1.5) allows taxable use only as federal law permits, “with such fuel being subject to the excise tax.” Section 42-4-1414(3) also exposes a violator to a fuel tax audit. I found no Department of Revenue announcement of tax relief.

    So a trucker running dyed fuel on I-76 this quarter has federal penalty relief and a State Patrol stand-down, and may still owe Colorado fuel tax on those gallons. IFTA returns for interstate carriers (C.R.S. § 39-27-301(5)) still run; the Department of Revenue lists the third quarter as due October 31, a Saturday, so Monday, November 2, 2026.

    What changes for Form 720 deposits and farm fuel refund claims?

    Treas. Reg. § 40.6302(c)-1 requires semimonthly deposits covering 95 percent of each period’s net liability (or a look-back safe harbor), due by the 14th day of the next period, and none for a quarter at or under $2,500. Late deposits cost 2 to 15 percent under § 6656. The relief covers only the dyed diesel highway tax; other deposits continue.

    Under § 6427(l), the buyer of taxed clear diesel used in farming (§ 4041(f)) or in off-road equipment gets the tax back, usually on Form 4136 at $.243 a gallon, or on Form 8849 Schedule 1 once $750 is owed for a quarter (§ 6427(i)(2)). Dyed gallons earn nothing because no tax was paid, and IR-2026-125 leaves refund recordkeeping in place.

    What does the relief mean for a Fort Morgan farm with grain trucks?

    An illustration, with hypothetical numbers. From October 1 to December 31, 2026, Tobias puts 1,800 gallons of farm-tank dyed diesel into trucks that never leave Colorado. Before the relief, a roadside sample finding 150 dyed gallons could have meant a $1,500 penalty. Now there is none, but the § 4041(a)(1)(A)(ii) tax at 24.3 cents is still $437.40, unreported under IR-2026-125 and pending deferral guidance. Under $2,500 for the quarter, he never had deposits.

    Troopers have been told not to cite him, yet on my reading of § 39-27-102.5(1.5) he owes $369 of special fuel tax, plus $108 if the road usage fee applies. Also, 2,500 gallons of clear diesel burned in his combine during July harvest support a $607.50 Form 4136 credit for 2026, and § 39-27-102.5(2)(a) lets him seek the state tax back. I would run the truck tanks low by late December.

    If deferred diesel tax is never forgiven, how does the IRS collect it?

    Like any excise debt: assessment, notice and demand within 60 days under § 6303(a), then a lien under § 6321. But the three-year assessment period in § 6501(a) runs from a filed return, and with no return, § 6501(c)(3) leaves it open. Because IR-2026-125 excuses the return, I tell clients to keep a gallon log anyway.

    The trust fund penalty in § 6672 reaches a person “required to collect, truthfully account for, and pay over any tax.” Slodov v. United States, 436 U.S. 238 (1978), limits it to “third-party taxes” collected from others. Because the rack tax falls on the position holder and the § 4041 tax on the seller or user, I read § 6672 as not reaching owners for them. I found no Tenth Circuit case applying § 6672 to fuel excise tax; § 6715(d) is the exposure to watch.

    In bankruptcy, a pre-petition excise tax is a priority claim under 11 U.S.C. § 507(a)(8)(E) if its return was last due within three years before filing, or, where no return is required, if the transaction falls within those three years. Which branch fits an excused Form 720 is untested. An individual cannot discharge it under § 523(a)(1)(A), and Chapter 12 and 13 plans must pay it in full (§§ 1222(a)(2), 1322(a)(2)). See also selling farmland in a Colorado Chapter 12 case.

    Item Federal rule before the order Federal rule Oct. 1 to Dec. 31, 2026 Colorado rule
    Dyed diesel on the highway (penalty) § 6715: greater of $1,000 or $10 per gallon, per act Not imposed; no federal inspections Class B infraction; not enforced through Dec. 31
    Dyed diesel on the highway (tax) § 4041 back-up tax at 24.3 cents Still imposed; reporting excused; deferral pending 20.5-cent special fuel tax appears to apply
    Semimonthly Form 720 deposits 95 percent rule or look-back; § 6656 penalty No penalty for dyed diesel tax only Not applicable
    Recordkeeping Required Excused for dyed diesel highway liability Fuel tax audit possible
    Off-highway refund claims § 6427(l); Form 4136 or 8849 Unchanged; records still required State refund for clear farm fuel
    State fuel tax and IFTA Not federal Not federal Q3 IFTA due Nov. 2, 2026

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Did the IRS forgive the federal tax on dyed diesel used on the road?

    No. As of October 23, 2026, the IRS has waived only penalties and reporting for October 1 through December 31, 2026. Payment awaits promised Section 7508A guidance, which can postpone but not erase the tax.

    Can I get a dyed diesel penalty for fuel in my truck this fall?

    Not a federal one through December 31, 2026, and Colorado troopers have been told not to enforce the state ban until then. Dye left in the tank on January 1, 2027 is a separate risk the IRS is still studying.

    Does the relief lower the diesel tax built into the pump price?

    No. The 24.4-cent federal rack tax on clear diesel is unchanged. The order covers only the Section 4041 taxes.

    Do I still owe Colorado fuel tax on dyed diesel used on the highway?

    Probably. The Governor’s order is silent on the special fuel tax, and Colorado law taxes dyed fuel used for a taxable purpose.

    Can I still claim a refund for clear diesel used on my farm?

    Yes. The Section 6427(l) refund through Form 4136 or Form 8849 is unchanged. Keep your purchase records; the relief does not excuse them.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm helps Colorado farmers and truckers with penalty abatement for Form 720 and dyed fuel penalties, installment agreements for excise balances, and Colorado state tax questions. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    These rules may shift again before the fourth-quarter Form 720 is due; if you have a dyed diesel notice or a fuel tax balance you cannot pay, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Colorado Nonprofit Insider Payments: Section 4958 Excess Benefit Taxes After Jagannath

    Colorado Nonprofit Insider Payments: Section 4958 Excess Benefit Taxes After Jagannath

    A new board member of a Lakewood youth soccer club is reconciling old bank statements. One line stops her: a $120,000 wire in December 2024 to an event company the board president owns, with no contract or board minute behind it and nothing showing what it bought. Her question is the one I hear most: is this the club’s problem or the president’s?

    Federally, mostly his. Section 4958 of the Internal Revenue Code taxes the insider, and the Tax Court’s September 24, 2026 decision in Jagannath v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-92, shows 25 percent becoming 225 percent when nobody corrects. The board has work too, some under Colorado law.

    What is an excess benefit transaction for a Colorado nonprofit?

    It is a deal in which a 501(c)(3) public charity gives an economic benefit to a “disqualified person” and gets less value back. 26 U.S.C. § 4958(c)(1)(A), (e). A disqualified person is anyone in a position to exercise substantial influence over the organization at any time in the prior five years (§ 4958(f)(1)(A)), which by rule includes voting directors, the president and the treasurer (Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-3(c)). Their family members count, and so does any entity they own more than 35 percent of (§ 4958(f)(3), (f)(4)).

    A real loan on fair terms is not automatically an excess benefit for a public charity. Jagannath was not close: a Tennessee charity’s president signed a $590,000 interest-free note as both lender and borrower for his own LLC, 11 days after the cash left, and the court rejected his story that a later $600,000 wire repaid it. Colorado goes further than the Code. C.R.S. § 7-128-501(2) bars a Colorado nonprofit corporation from lending to its directors or officers, and any who assent to or participate in such a loan are liable for it until repaid.

    How much does the section 4958 excise tax cost the insider personally?

    The first-tier tax is 25 percent of the excess benefit, owed by the disqualified person (§ 4958(a)(1)). An officer or director who knowingly participates owes 10 percent unless the participation was not willful and was due to reasonable cause, capped at $20,000 per transaction (§ 4958(a)(2), (d)(2)). Leave the benefit uncorrected through the “taxable period” and a 200 percent tax follows (§ 4958(b)).

    In Jagannath that meant $147,500 plus $1,180,000, or $1,327,500 on $590,000. The court also sustained additions under 26 U.S.C. § 6651(a)(1) and (a)(2); he never filed or paid, and he never argued reasonable cause.

    The insider files his own Form 4720 (Treas. Reg. § 53.6011-1(b)), due the 15th day of the fifth month after his tax year, usually May 15 (Treas. Reg. § 53.6071-1(f)(1)). Under the Form 4720 instructions, the charity may not pay his tax.

    When can an insider still avoid the 200 percent tax?

    The taxable period ends when the IRS mails a notice of deficiency for the 25 percent tax or assesses it (§ 4958(f)(5)); correcting before then prevents the 200 percent tax. Under Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-7, the insider repays the excess plus interest, compounded annually at no less than the applicable federal rate (AFR) for the transaction month, in cash or its equivalent, “excluding payment by a promissory note.”

    Even the mailing date is not quite the end. 26 U.S.C. § 4961(a) abates the second-tier tax if correction comes within the “correction period,” which § 4963(e) ends 90 days after the notice for that tax, extended while a Tax Court case bars assessment (see Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-1(c)(2)(iii)). The Jagannath opinion never mentions § 4961; on October 16, 2026 the docket showed Rule 155 computations due December 27 and no decision entered.

    The 25 percent tax is stickier. Section 4962 abates it only if the transaction was due to reasonable cause rather than willful neglect and was corrected in time; § 4962(b) covers subchapter D of chapter 42, where § 4958 sits. A president who paid his own company without a vote has a weak reasonable-cause case.

    Insider Payment on Your Nonprofit’s Books? Contact Us Now

    How does a Colorado board use the rebuttable presumption of reasonableness?

    Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-6 presumes pay reasonable, and a property transfer at fair market value, when board members with no conflict approve it in advance, relying on comparability data and documenting their basis at the time. For an event contract, I want competing vendor quotes in the file, and minutes written before the later of the next meeting or 60 days after the vote.

    Colorado runs a parallel test. A contract with an entity in which a director has a financial interest is a “conflicting interest transaction” (§ 7-128-501(1)), and it is not voidable solely for that reason if disinterested directors approve or ratify it in good faith after disclosure, if members do, or if it is fair (§ 7-128-501(3)). Colorado accepts after-the-fact ratification; the federal presumption needs advance approval, so a 2026 vote cannot create it for 2024. Applying these rules and the director duties in C.R.S. § 7-128-401 is work for a Colorado nonprofit tax attorney or other Colorado-licensed counsel.

    Under Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-4(c), services count as consideration only if the charity showed at payment that it meant compensation, usually by a W-2, 1099, Form 990 report or written contract. Otherwise they are ignored, an “automatic” excess benefit in practitioners’ shorthand.

    What could the IRS assess against a Lakewood board president?

    Illustrative example (hypothetical facts): on December 2, 2024, the club wires $120,000 to the president’s single-member LLC for two tournaments. Nobody signed a contract or called a vote, and the club issued no Form 1099. If all of it is excess benefit under § 53.4958-4(c), his first-tier tax is $30,000. If the work counts and a comparable vendor would have charged $50,000, the excess is $70,000 and the tax $17,500. A treasurer who knowingly approved the wire faces $12,000 of manager tax.

    His 2024 Form 4720 was due May 15, 2025, so § 6651 additions are accruing. Correcting on December 2, 2026, two years later, uses the short-term rate under 26 U.S.C. § 1274(d)(1)(A), 4.30 percent compounded annually for December 2024 (Rev. Rul. 2024-26). At that floor he repays $130,541.88, including $10,541.88 of interest. If a notice of deficiency comes first, $240,000 more is at stake until correction within the § 4961 period, or $270,000 in all.

    How long does the IRS have, and which court hears a Colorado section 4958 case?

    The clock runs from the charity’s return. 26 U.S.C. § 6501(l)(1) points to the organization’s return for the transaction year, and Treas. Reg. § 301.6501(e)-1(c)(3)(ii) allows three years if that return adequately discloses the transaction, six if not. The Schedule L instructions put payments over $100,000 to an interested person in Part IV and every excess benefit transaction in Part I. Jagannath‘s charity left Schedule L off, and the court used those returns against him.

    The IRS asserts these chapter 42 taxes by notice of deficiency (26 U.S.C. § 6212(a)), and the insider has 90 days to petition the Tax Court before assessment (§ 6213(a)). Colorado residents appeal to the Tenth Circuit (§ 7482(b)(1)(A)), whose only § 4958 ruling I found is Farr v. Commissioner, 738 F. App’x 969 (10th Cir. 2018). That unpublished order affirmed both tiers against a Kansas taxpayer who had used charity funds for personal expenses. With no published Tenth Circuit law, the Tax Court applies its own precedent under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970).

    Can intermediate sanctions and 501(c)(3) revocation both hit a Colorado nonprofit?

    Yes. Congress added § 4958 in 1996 (Pub. L. 104-168, § 1311) because, as Jagannath recounts, revocation had been the IRS’s only remedy and it fell on the charity rather than the insider. Treas. Reg. § 1.501(c)(3)-1(f)(2) keeps revocation available, weighing size, repetition, safeguards and correction, and correction after IRS discovery “by itself, is never a sufficient basis” to keep exemption. Last week’s post covers 501(c)(3) revocation in Colorado.

    The Colorado Secretary of State’s charity registration can require the Form 990 with every schedule except donor lists (C.R.S. § 6-16-104(2)(f)). A Charitable Solicitations Act violation is also a Consumer Protection Act violation (§ 6-16-111(5)), which the Attorney General can enforce (§ 6-1-103), and C.R.S. § 7-134-301 allows dissolution suits over abuse of authority or misapplied assets.

    Layer Who owes it Example ($120,000) Way out
    First-tier tax, 25% President $30,000 § 4962: reasonable cause plus correction
    Manager tax, 10% Knowing managers $12,000 (cap $20,000) No knowing participation
    Second-tier tax, 200% President $240,000 Timely correction (§ 4961)
    Correction payment President, to the club $130,541.88 (Dec. 2, 2026) Cash; AFR or higher
    § 6651 additions President Up to 25% each Timely Form 4720; reasonable cause

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is a nonprofit loan to a director legal in Colorado?

    Not for a Colorado nonprofit corporation. C.R.S. § 7-128-501(2) bars loans to directors and officers and makes those who assent to one liable until it is repaid. Federal excess benefit treatment is a separate question.

    Can the nonprofit pay the president’s section 4958 tax?

    No. The Form 4720 instructions forbid it. A reimbursement is itself an excess benefit unless it was part of reasonable compensation.

    Does signing a promissory note correct an excess benefit?

    No. Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-7(b)(1) requires cash or cash equivalents and excludes notes. Returning the property itself requires the organization’s agreement.

    Who files Form 4720, and when?

    The disqualified person and each liable manager file separately, by the 15th day of the fifth month after their tax year. The organization reports the transaction on Schedule I of its own Form 4720.

    Can the 200 percent tax be removed after a notice of deficiency?

    Yes, by correction within the § 4961 correction period: 90 days after the notice for that tax, extended while a Tax Court case bars assessment. Waiting is risky, since interest keeps growing.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents Colorado nonprofit insiders and organizations in IRS examinations of excess benefit transactions, penalty and excise tax abatement, and Tax Court litigation of section 4958 deficiencies. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    Fixing an insider payment gets costlier once the IRS mails a notice of deficiency. If your board has found a payment it cannot explain, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Colorado Tax Court Place of Trial: Denver, Albuquerque, or Remote After the 2026 Changes

    Colorado Tax Court Place of Trial: Denver, Albuquerque, or Remote After the 2026 Changes

    A Durango outfitter who runs fall elk hunts opens a notice of deficiency in October: $38,000 of additional 2024 income tax, plus a penalty. She wants to fight it in the U.S. Tax Court, and the petition asks something unexpected. Where should the trial be held? Her instinct says Denver, about 335 road miles away. Albuquerque is more than a hundred miles closer.

    The Tax Court reworked its trial locations on September 8, 2026. For a La Plata or Montezuma County taxpayer, the city, the small-or-regular choice and a remote trial now get weighed together, before filing.

    Where is a Colorado Tax Court case tried, and do I have to choose Denver?

    Denver is Colorado’s only Tax Court place of trial. The court’s places of trial list puts the courtroom in the Byron Rogers Federal Building, 1961 Stout Street, Room C502. Albuquerque and Salt Lake City are places of trial too, with “no permanent courtroom.”

    Under Tax Court Rule 140(a), a petitioner files a separate request for place of trial with the petition. On paper that is Form 5, revised in September 2026: “You may choose any location that is convenient to you.” Residence does not limit the choice. In DAWSON, the court’s e-filing system, it is step 4 of the petition process, “Case Procedure and Trial Location,” with a city dropdown.

    All of this happens inside the 90 days after the notice is mailed under 26 U.S.C. § 6213(a); a related post covers a missed Tax Court 90-day deadline in Colorado. The city can change later. Rule 140(b) allows a motion to change the place of trial “stating fully the reasons therefor,” but one filed after the notice setting the case for trial “may be deemed dilatory” unless the reason arose later or there was good reason to wait.

    What changed in the Tax Court trial locations in 2026?

    The September 8, 2026 announcement added Austin, Charlotte, Newark, Orlando and Sacramento, “bringing the total to 79.” It also opened every city to regular cases, which “eliminates the restriction on certain trial locations, which could be designated solely for small tax cases.” The announcement does not name those cities, and the court’s definitions page still says S-case trials are held in “several additional cities.”

    The change I would watch is the pilot. Beginning “no earlier than for the Fall 2027 term,” the court may put cases on a “reporting calendar.” Instead of a trial date, it “will assign a judge and issue a standing scheduling order governing pretrial proceedings,” with trial dates set “if necessary.” Traditional calendars continue.

    Can a Durango or Cortez taxpayer be tried in Albuquerque or Salt Lake City?

    Yes. By my estimates from OpenStreetMap routing (not court figures), Durango is about 216 road miles from Albuquerque and 335 from the Denver courthouse. Cortez is roughly 253 from Albuquerque, 348 from Salt Lake City and 379 from Denver. Western Slope readers should not assume Utah wins: Grand Junction and Montrose are both closer to Denver than to Salt Lake City.

    Frequency matters as much as miles. Across the five posted terms, Fall 2025 through Winter 2027, Albuquerque has one session, the week of May 4, 2026. Salt Lake City has three. Denver has five, including a November 2025 session canceled in the government shutdown. A city that rarely sits can mean a longer wait for trial.

    The trial city does not move your appeal. Under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(A), an individual appeals in the circuit of legal residence, fixed when the petition is filed, so a Coloradan goes to the Tenth Circuit (New Mexico and Utah sit there anyway under 28 U.S.C. § 41). The Tax Court therefore applies Tenth Circuit law. Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), aff’d, 445 F.2d 985 (10th Cir. 1971), follows an appellate decision “squarely in point where appeal from our decision lies to that Court of Appeals.” Golsen itself applied a Tenth Circuit decision.

    Tax Court Petition Due Soon? Contact Us Now

    Should a Colorado taxpayer elect a small tax case under $50,000?

    26 U.S.C. § 7463(a) allows small tax case procedure when the disputed deficiency stays within “$50,000 for any one taxable year” for income tax, and § 7463(e) counts penalties and additions to tax. Rules 170 through 174 supply the procedure; under Rule 174(b) trials run “as informally as possible.” Rule 172 lets a petitioner appear alone or with any admitted practitioner, such as a Colorado Tax Court attorney.

    The price is finality. An S decision “shall not be reviewed in any other court” and “shall not be treated as a precedent for any other case,” per § 7463(b). The IRS cannot appeal your win either.

    You elect by checking the small-case box on the petition form or in DAWSON; leave it blank and the case is regular. Rule 171(c) permits a request any time before trial, and the IRS may oppose. Leaving is harder. Before trial, Rule 171(d) lets the court remove the designation on its own or on motion; afterward, § 7463(d) allows discontinuance only on reasonable grounds to believe the amount exceeds the limit.

    Think twice when the case turns on law rather than receipts. Favorable Tenth Circuit precedent does its work through Golsen in a regular case, and an open question can be won on appeal only in a regular case. I see S cases fit best where the fight is substantiation: mileage logs, cash receipts, who paid for what.

    When does the Tax Court grant a remote trial?

    The court holds trials and hearings by Zoomgov under the same rules of decorum, and recording is prohibited. A party asks by filing a Motion to Proceed Remotely, due 31 days before the session under the court’s sample standing pretrial order.

    I have not found a published standard for granting it. The form shows what the judge weighs: reasons such as “distance from Courthouse, job/ caregiver constraints, health concerns,” whether everyone has a camera-equipped computer, and whether the other side objects. Each term also lists dedicated remote sessions, in Winter 2027 the weeks of March 8 (small) and March 22 (regular). Still, when credibility is the whole case or the judge needs original logbooks, the drive can be worth it.

    What happens at a Tax Court Denver trial session?

    The court’s trial session schedules show Denver sessions the weeks of February 2, April 6 (a swing session with Cheyenne) and June 15, 2026, none in Fall 2026, and a regular calendar the week of February 8, 2027. Spring 2027 was not posted when I checked on October 16, 2026.

    Under Rule 131(b), the trial notice comes with a standing pretrial order. The sample order counts back from opening day: pretrial memoranda at 21 days and the stipulation of facts at 14, with continuances sought by day 31 and granted “only in exceptional circumstances.” An expert’s report in a regular case needs a motion for leave 30 days out; a related post covers expert witnesses at the Denver trial session.

    Rule 91(a) requires stipulation “to the fullest extent to which complete or qualified agreement can or fairly should be reached.” I treat that stipulation as where the case gets built. The session opens with the calendar call under Rule 131(c), normally on Monday, when parties estimate trial time and cases are then tried “in due course, but not necessarily in the order listed.”

    Illustrative example (hypothetical facts): the outfitter’s notice shows a $38,000 deficiency plus a $7,600 accuracy-related penalty, 20 percent under 26 U.S.C. § 6662(a). With $45,600 in dispute for one year, an S case is available. Most of it is documented camp and livestock expenses; one smaller item turns on how a multi-year federal permit fee is deducted. An S case in Albuquerque saves about 120 miles each way, but it is final, and that city sat once in five terms. A regular case in Denver keeps a Tenth Circuit appeal. A remote motion saves the drive but puts her credibility on a screen. If the permit-fee point will recur, I would lean regular; if the fight is receipts, an S case with a remote request deserves a hard look.

    Option Miles from Durango Posted sessions, Fall 2025 to Winter 2027 Appeal Fits best when
    S case, Albuquerque About 216 One None; not precedent The dispute is documents and receipts
    Regular case, Denver About 335 Five, one canceled Tenth Circuit A legal question is worth preserving
    Either procedure, Salt Lake City About 393 (348 from Cortez) Three Tenth Circuit if regular A Cortez filer wants to avoid Denver
    Remote (Zoomgov) None Remote sessions each term Follows the procedure elected Distance or a busy season

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Do I have to live near the city I choose for my Tax Court trial?

    No. Form 5 says you may choose any location that is convenient to you. Your appeal still follows your legal residence.

    Can I change my Tax Court place of trial after filing?

    Yes, by a Rule 140(b) motion that states your reasons fully. File it before the notice setting the case for trial if you can, because a later motion may be treated as dilatory.

    Does the $50,000 small tax case limit include penalties?

    Yes. Section 7463(e) counts penalties and additions to tax as part of the deficiency in dispute, and for income tax the limit applies per taxable year.

    Can the IRS appeal if I win a small tax case?

    No. A decision under § 7463 cannot be reviewed in any other court, so neither side can appeal, and it is not precedent for other cases.

    When does the Tax Court reporting calendar pilot start?

    No earlier than the Fall 2027 term. Those cases get an assigned judge and a standing scheduling order instead of a trial date.

    If my Colorado case is tried in Salt Lake City, which court hears the appeal?

    The Tenth Circuit, because § 7482(b)(1)(A) looks to legal residence when the petition is filed. The trial city does not control it.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents Colorado taxpayers and their businesses in Tax Court litigation, IRS audit defense, penalty abatement, and IRS Appeals. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    The city and the S-or-regular choice are made in the petition, inside the 90-day window. If a notice of deficiency just reached you in southwest Colorado, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Form 872 in Colorado: Should You Sign the IRS Statute Extension After Fine?

    Form 872 in Colorado: Should You Sign the IRS Statute Extension After Fine?

    An S corporation owner in Colorado Springs has been under IRS examination for most of a year on her 2023 return. In October the revenue agent emails her a Form 872, Consent to Extend the Time to Assess Tax: the statute runs in April, the work is not done, and a signature by month’s end would help. Her bookkeeper says everyone signs these. Her business partner says never sign anything the IRS mails you. Each of them is half right.

    A Tax Court opinion from September raises the stakes, because it holds that the fixed-date form has no early exit once signed. Here is how I walk a Colorado client through the choice.

    Should I sign the Form 872 my IRS agent in Colorado sent me?

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 6501(a), the IRS must assess tax within three years after the return was filed. For an income tax deficiency, assessment generally waits until a notice of deficiency has gone out and the 90-day window to petition the Tax Court under 26 U.S.C. § 6213(a) has run, so agents ask months ahead.

    Section 6501(c)(4)(A) allows an extension when “both the Secretary and the taxpayer have consented in writing” before the period expires, and later written agreements can extend it again. Section 6501(c)(4)(B) requires the IRS, “on each occasion” it asks, to tell the taxpayer of the right to refuse, or to limit the extension “to particular issues or to a particular period of time.” IRM 25.6.22.3 says those rights are printed on Form 872 itself.

    Signing admits nothing about the tax. It keeps the case with the agent, where many audits resolve, and gives up your power to force a decision. I first ask whether the date can be earlier than the one typed in and whether the consent can be restricted. A restricted consent keeps the year open only for listed issues and lets the statute run on the rest. Under IRM 25.6.22.8.1, though, the taxpayer only has a right to request one; IRM 25.6.22.8.2 says the IRS generally agrees when the open issues can be described precisely and everything else is settled.

    What happens if I refuse to extend the IRS statute of limitations during an audit?

    Expect a notice of deficiency before the deadline, built on whatever is in the file. Mailing it suspends the assessment period under 26 U.S.C. § 6503(a)(1) for the 90-day petition window and, if you petition, until the Tax Court decision becomes final, plus 60 days. Refusing does not close the year; an earlier post compares Tax Court, a refund suit, and bankruptcy for a Colorado notice of deficiency.

    The quieter cost is Appeals. Under IRM 8.21.3.2.1, the IRS Independent Office of Appeals “will not accept a proposed deficiency case” when fewer than 365 days remain on the statute. Appeals is not lost entirely, though: under Rev. Proc. 2016-22, § 3.01, IRS Counsel generally refers a docketed Tax Court case to Appeals unless Appeals issued the notice. You just negotiate with a petition on file and a trial calendar ahead.

    So refusal is a tactic. I consider it when the agent’s theory is thin and our documents are already in the file; when the agent has not seen the records that would win the case, it usually hurts.

    IRS Asking You to Sign Form 872? Contact Us Now

    Can a Form 872-T end a Form 872 early?

    No, under Fine v. Commissioner, 167 T.C. No. 13 (Sept. 30, 2026). The taxpayers had signed Forms 872 extending 2015 (twice, finally to December 31, 2021) and 2016 (to June 30, 2021). After Appeals talks failed, their lawyer faxed Forms 872-T on September 11, 2020, checking the form’s only box, which is for a Form 872-A. The IRS mailed notices dated April 15, 2021, long after 90 days from the fax but inside the agreed dates.

    Granting the IRS partial summary judgment, Judge Ashford explained that Form 872 runs to a stated date. Form 872-A runs indefinitely and ends 90 days after an event printed on it, such as the IRS getting a Form 872-T from the taxpayer. Form 872-T names only Form 872-A; Form 872, for its part, never mentions Form 872-T. The court tied that design to § 6501(c)(4)(B): the protection is the right to limit or refuse each request, not a unilateral exit later. In its words, “only the passage of time can terminate Form 872.” The order issued October 5, 2026; the merits are still pending, so no appeal is possible yet.

    In Grunwald v. Commissioner, 86 T.C. 85 (1986), an Appeals officer’s letter warning that a notice was coming did not end a Form 872-A, because only the termination form or an actual notice could. Fine borrows its line: “A deal is after all a deal.”

    Has the Tenth Circuit decided a Form 872 or Form 872-A case?

    On the open-ended form, yes. In Wall v. Commissioner, 875 F.2d 812 (10th Cir. 1989), the taxpayer signed a Form 872-A in 1980 and received a notice in late 1985. Rejecting his argument that the consent lapsed after a reasonable time, the court followed Estate of Camara v. Commissioner, 91 T.C. 957 (1988), and noted that Form 872-A “provides a simple and effective method of terminating the waiver by requiring the use of Form 872-T.” Wall never filed one. The court left room for an “egregious case,” such as twenty years with no IRS contact.

    I found no Tenth Circuit decision on the Fine question. A Colorado individual’s case would be appealable there under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(A), and under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), aff’d, 445 F.2d 985 (10th Cir. 1971), the Tax Court defers only to circuit precedent squarely on point. With none, a Colorado taxpayer gets Fine, and Wall‘s insistence on the exit printed on the form points the same way.

    How do you calculate the IRS assessment statute of limitations on a Colorado return?

    Under § 6501(b)(1), an early return counts as filed on the due date. The period stretches to six years if the return omits gross income exceeding 25 percent of the gross income it reports (§ 6501(e)(1)(A)). A fraudulent return filed to evade tax, or no return, has no limit under § 6501(c)(1) and (c)(3); a separate post covers the fraud exception when a preparer did the cheating. For an S corporation owner, the clock on her personal tax runs from her own Form 1040, not the corporation’s return. Bufferd v. Commissioner, 506 U.S. 523 (1993).

    Illustrative example (hypothetical facts). Our Colorado Springs owner files her 2023 Form 1040 on April 8, 2024. It is treated as filed on the April 15, 2024 due date, so the § 6501(a) period ends April 15, 2027. On October 16, 2026, 181 days remain, too few for Appeals. In November she signs a Form 872 extending the period to December 31, 2027. Under Fine, a later Form 872-T changes nothing. Had she signed a Form 872-A instead, and the IRS office handling her case received her Form 872-T on March 3, 2027, the IRS would have through June 1, 2027, the 90th day, to assess or mail a notice. A notice in that window starts the § 6503(a) suspension.

    Does a federal Form 872 keep the Colorado tax year open too?

    It appears so. Under C.R.S. § 39-21-107(2), Colorado must assess income tax “within one year after the expiration of the time provided for assessing a deficiency in federal income tax.” Because the state date is keyed to the federal one, a federal consent should move Colorado’s date too; in the example, from April 15, 2028 to December 31, 2028.

    The federal result must also be reported. C.R.S. § 39-22-601.5(2) requires a federal adjustments report, with payment, within 180 days after the final determination date. If it is timely, subsection (5)(a) gives the Department of Revenue until the later of the § 39-21-107(2) date or one year after filing. If it is skipped or understated, (5)(b) adds an outer date six years after the final determination date, absent fraud.

    Choice When the extra time ends Taxpayer’s early exit Appeals before a notice
    Form 872 (fixed date) The date on the form None; Form 872-T does not work (Fine) Available if 365 days remain
    Form 872-A (open-ended) 90 days after an event printed on the form Form 872-T, counted from IRS receipt Available
    Restricted consent The agreed date, for listed issues only Same as the form used Available for listed issues
    Refuse to sign Original § 6501 date, then suspended by a notice Not needed Usually lost; docketed referral possible

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Does signing Form 872 mean I agree with the IRS adjustments?

    No. A Form 872 only gives the IRS more time. You keep every argument on the merits, including the right to petition the Tax Court.

    Can I send Form 872-T to cancel a fixed-date Form 872?

    Not under Fine v. Commissioner. The Tax Court held that only the passage of time ends a Form 872, and the Tenth Circuit has not said otherwise.

    How long does the IRS have after it receives my Form 872-T on a Form 872-A?

    Ninety days after the IRS office considering the case receives it. A letter or phone call does not count, so keep proof of delivery.

    Will IRS Appeals take my case if the statute is close to expiring?

    Generally not before a notice if fewer than 365 days remain. After a Tax Court petition, IRS Counsel usually refers the case to Appeals unless Appeals issued the notice.

    Does extending the federal statute also extend Colorado’s?

    Colorado’s income tax period ends one year after the federal period, so a federal extension appears to carry Colorado along. A final federal change also triggers a Colorado report within 180 days.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents Colorado taxpayers and their businesses in IRS audit defense, including consent negotiations, IRS Appeals, Tax Court litigation, and the Colorado follow-on to a federal change. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    The terms of a consent are easiest to shape before anyone signs. If an agent has asked you for a Form 872 or Form 872-A, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Colorado 501(c)(3) Revocation: The 90-Day Section 7428 Deadline and Automatic Revocation

    Colorado 501(c)(3) Revocation: The 90-Day Section 7428 Deadline and Automatic Revocation

    The treasurer of a youth ski club in Steamboat Springs signs for a certified IRS letter saying the club no longer qualifies under section 501(c)(3) and the revocation is final. In Durango, a volunteer soccer coach hears from the city that her league shows as “revoked” in the IRS database, though nobody ever audited it.

    Both boards will say their nonprofit lost tax-exempt status. The two problems have different deadlines, and one has no court remedy at all. Start with which letter you are holding.

    Did the IRS revoke your Colorado nonprofit’s 501(c)(3) status, or did the law revoke it automatically?

    A 501(c)(3) revocation in Colorado usually comes one of two ways. The first is an examination that ends in a final adverse determination letter, which opens the door to a court case under 26 U.S.C. § 7428.

    The second is automatic revocation under 26 U.S.C. § 6033(j)(1). If an organization fails to file its Form 990, 990-EZ, or 990-N for three consecutive years, its exemption is “considered revoked” as of the due date of the third missed filing. Section 7428(b)(4) bars any section 7428 action over that kind of revocation, and section 12.02 of Rev. Proc. 2026-5 denies those organizations Appeals consideration. The IRS’s automatic revocation page says the law prohibits it from undoing a proper automatic revocation.

    In my experience the automatic version is far more common in Colorado: a volunteer-run mountain-town club whose treasurer filed the 990-N for years, then moved on. Those boards often hunt for a court remedy they do not have. Their path is reinstatement.

    When does the 90-day section 7428 clock start, and what has to happen first?

    Section 7428(b)(3) requires the pleading to be filed “before the 91st day after the date of such mailing” when the IRS sends its determination by certified or registered mail. The mailing date controls, not the opening date. If the last day falls on a weekend or a District of Columbia holiday, 26 U.S.C. § 7503 moves it to the next business day.

    The court must also find that the organization exhausted its administrative remedies under section 7428(b)(2). IRS Publication 892 gives an audited organization 30 days from the proposed revocation letter to protest and ask for Appeals, and it warns that skipping the protest can defeat exhaustion. A withdrawn protest does not count either, and a board arguing against retroactive revocation must put its request under 26 U.S.C. § 7805(b) in writing to the agent before the final letter issues (Rev. Proc. 2026-5, sections 9.09 and 12.04).

    The 270-day rule in section 7428(b)(2) mostly helps applicants the IRS has not acted on, and section 10.06 of the 2026 procedure stops that count while an IRS information request is outstanding.

    Nonprofit Revocation Letter from the IRS? Contact Us Now

    Which court should a Colorado nonprofit choose for a section 7428 declaratory judgment?

    Only three courts can hear it: the U.S. Tax Court, the Court of Federal Claims (28 U.S.C. § 1507), and the federal district court in Washington, D.C. Because 28 U.S.C. § 2201(a) excludes tax disputes other than section 7428 actions, the District of Colorado is out. The choices differ for an individual’s Colorado notice of deficiency.

    A Tax Court section 7428 decision is reviewed in the circuit where the group keeps its principal office or agency on the day the petition is filed, under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(D). For a club in Routt or La Plata County, that is the Tenth Circuit; the other two forums appeal to the Federal Circuit and the D.C. Circuit. The Tax Court has a Denver location, and its Rule 212 lets the petitioner request a place for submission.

    I found no Tenth Circuit decision reviewing a section 7428 judgment. Christian Echoes National Ministry, Inc. v. United States, 470 F.2d 849 (10th Cir. 1972), upheld a retroactive revocation in a payroll tax refund suit, since section 7428 did not yet exist. Church of World Peace, Inc. v. IRS, 715 F.2d 492 (10th Cir. 1983), dismissed a suit to block an IRS records demand, noting the organization would keep its section 7428 rights. Since Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), has the Tax Court follow the appellate circuit’s precedent and there is none here, the Tax Court’s own section 7428 case law would govern.

    Evidence rules favor the Tax Court in a revocation. Under Tax Court Rule 217, an initial-application case is ordinarily decided on the administrative record (the file built at the IRS), and new evidence needs good cause. Colorado State Chiropractic Society v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1989-8, refused to add an affidavit the society could have supplied during 31 months of IRS review. A revocation case is decided on the record alone only if both sides agree it is complete, and the court may find different facts. I still treat the protest stage as the trial record.

    What happens to donors, income tax, and Colorado filings while the case is pending?

    Filing does not freeze the revocation, but section 7428(c) protects donors within limits. If the organization files on time and loses, gifts made from publication of the revocation until the court first rules against it stay deductible, capped at $1,000 per individual for that period (a married couple counts as one). Gifts from other exempt charities are covered; individuals responsible for the conduct behind the revocation are not.

    A corporation that loses exemption is taxed at 21 percent under 26 U.S.C. § 11(b) and must file a return under 26 U.S.C. § 6012(a)(2), which means Form 1120. Colorado follows: C.R.S. § 39-22-112 exempts an organization from state income tax only in years it meets the federal requirements, and C.R.S. § 39-22-301 sets a 4.40 percent corporate rate for 2025 and later, before any temporary TABOR reduction.

    Two state items belong with Colorado counsel. Secretary of State registration under C.R.S. § 6-16-104 does not depend on 501(c)(3) status, but it reports that status and changes. For sales tax, the Department of Revenue’s charitable organization guidance treats an IRS 501(c)(3) letter as a provisional presumption of qualifying, so a revoked organization loses that footing.

    How does automatic revocation reinstatement work for a Colorado nonprofit that stopped filing?

    Rev. Proc. 2014-11 sets out four routes. The streamlined route in section 4 covers a first-time revoked organization that was eligible to file the 990-EZ or 990-N each missed year. It must apply within 15 months after the later of the revocation letter or the date its name was posted on the IRS list, and approval restores exemption back to the revocation date.

    Section 5 covers other organizations applying inside those 15 months; they need a reasonable cause statement for at least one of the three years plus paper annual returns for the missed years. After 15 months, section 6 requires reasonable cause for all three years. Section 7 reinstates only from the new filing date. Under Rev. Proc. 2026-5, sections 4 and 7 can use Form 1023-EZ ($275 fee) if the organization meets its limits, while sections 5 and 6 require Form 1023 ($600).

    How would the deadlines play out for a hypothetical Steamboat Springs or Durango youth-sports club?

    Illustrative only. The Steamboat Springs club lost in Appeals, and its final adverse determination letter went out by certified mail on Wednesday, September 2, 2026. The 90th day, the last day to petition the Tax Court, is Tuesday, December 1, 2026. A family giving $2,500 after the IRS publishes the revocation keeps only $1,000 of the deduction if the club loses.

    The Durango league, a calendar-year group with about $30,000 a year in receipts, skipped its 990-N for 2022, 2023 and 2024. The third filing was due May 15, 2025, so revocation took effect that day. Assume the IRS posted its name on August 12, 2025. The streamlined window closes November 12, 2026. If the league meets the 1023-EZ limits, a 1023-EZ marked for streamlined retroactive reinstatement and filed by then would reach back to May 15, 2025, with no back 990-N filings required. Miss it, and the league is into section 6.

    Issue Examination revocation Automatic revocation, § 6033(j)
    Trigger Audit and final adverse determination letter Three straight years with no 990, 990-EZ, or 990-N
    IRS Appeals Yes, protest within 30 days of the proposed letter No
    Court remedy Section 7428 petition: Tax Court, Court of Federal Claims, or D.D.C. None; § 7428(b)(4) bars it
    Key deadline Before the 91st day after certified mailing 15 months from letter or list posting for the easier retroactive routes
    Donors Up to $1,000 per individual under § 7428(c) if timely filed Gifts made before the list posting stay deductible
    Appeal path for a Colorado organization Tenth Circuit from Tax Court Not applicable

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can a Colorado nonprofit sue over a revocation in Denver federal district court?

    No. Section 7428 allows only the Tax Court, the Court of Federal Claims, and the district court for the District of Columbia. The Tax Court does sit in Denver, with appeals to the Tenth Circuit.

    Is the 90-day deadline in section 7428 flexible?

    Treat it as fixed. The petition must be filed before the 91st day after the certified or registered mailing, with a next-business-day rule only for weekends and legal holidays.

    Can we appeal an automatic revocation for not filing the 990-N?

    No court or Appeals remedy exists. The organization applies for reinstatement under Rev. Proc. 2014-11, and timing decides whether reinstatement reaches back to the revocation date.

    Are donations deductible after a nonprofit lost tax-exempt status in Colorado?

    It depends on timing. Gifts made before an automatically revoked organization appears on the IRS list remain deductible, and in a timely section 7428 case individual donors are protected up to $1,000 each.

    Does a revoked club owe income tax?

    It can. A revoked corporation generally files Form 1120, and Colorado follows federal status. Retroactive reinstatement can remove that exposure for the gap years.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents nonprofit boards facing revocation, from the protest through IRS Appeals and Tax Court litigation, and helps organizations clean up the unfiled returns behind automatic revocation. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    Whether the clock is 90 days or 15 months, the date on the IRS letter drives the options. If your organization has a revocation letter or has turned up on the IRS list, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Missed the Tax Court 90-Day Deadline in Colorado? Equitable Tolling After Kings Road

    Missed the Tax Court 90-Day Deadline in Colorado? Equitable Tolling After Kings Road

    A landscaping contractor moves from Grand Junction to Fort Collins in May and never tells the IRS. In October a balance-due letter reaches the new house, citing a notice of deficiency she never saw. That notice went to her old Mesa County address in June, and the 90-day window to petition the U.S. Tax Court closed weeks ago. Her first question is the one I hear most in this spot: can a missed Tax Court deadline be forgiven?

    In September the Tax Court said yes for partnerships under the 2015 audit rules. For a Colorado individual holding an ordinary notice of deficiency, that court’s answer is still no. The reasons point to the routes that remain open after day 91.

    Can equitable tolling save a missed Tax Court deadline for a Colorado taxpayer?

    Equitable tolling lets a court accept a late filing when the filer acted diligently and something extraordinary beyond its control got in the way. It is unavailable if the deadline is “jurisdictional,” a limit on the court’s power to hear the case at all. Boechler, P.C. v. Commissioner, 596 U.S. 199 (2022), held the 30-day deadline for appealing a collection hearing nonjurisdictional because Congress never clearly said otherwise.

    The Tax Court declined to carry that over to the deficiency deadline in 26 U.S.C. § 6213(a). In Hallmark Research Collective v. Commissioner, 159 T.C. 126 (2022), a petition filed on day 91 stayed dismissed, and the court held the limit jurisdictional and closed to tolling.

    Under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), aff’d, 445 F.2d 985 (10th Cir. 1971), the Tax Court follows a court of appeals decision squarely in point when the appeal lies to that court. An individual appeals in the circuit of legal residence under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(A), which for Colorado is the Tenth Circuit. I found no Tenth Circuit decision on § 6213(a) since Boechler. Its published precedent, Foster v. Commissioner, 445 F.2d 799 (10th Cir. 1971), affirmed dismissal of a late petition for lack of jurisdiction. So a Colorado petitioner gets Hallmark today. Tolling requires preserving the argument and persuading the Tenth Circuit that Foster no longer controls.

    Which federal appeals courts allow tolling of the deficiency deadline?

    Four do. Culp v. Commissioner, 75 F.4th 196 (3d Cir. 2023), came first, then Buller v. Commissioner, 160 F.4th 266 (2d Cir. 2025), and Oquendo v. Commissioner, 148 F.4th 820 (6th Cir. 2025). On August 11, 2026, Maniktala v. Commissioner, No. 25-1366 (8th Cir.), joined them, setting aside a 1977 precedent that never analyzed the question. Pre-Boechler Seventh and Ninth Circuit decisions still call it jurisdictional.

    Six days after Maniktala, Kyick Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner, No. 25-1429 (1st Cir. Aug. 17, 2026), took a third path: not jurisdictional, but mandatory and immune from tolling. It relied on Enbridge Energy, LP v. Nessel, 146 S. Ct. 1074 (2026), which refused to toll the federal removal deadline. A Tenth Circuit win on jurisdiction would not guarantee tolling.

    The Supreme Court denied the government’s petition in Culp on June 24, 2024, and as of October 9, 2026, I found no grant on § 6213(a). The House passed H.R. 5349, the Tax Court Improvement Act, which would let the Tax Court toll the deficiency deadline for filings after enactment. It went to Senate Finance in December 2025, and I found no later action.

    Why can a Colorado partnership get equitable tolling when an individual cannot?

    Big Apple Tompkins Realty LLC v. Commissioner, 167 T.C. No. 7 (Aug. 5, 2026), treats the 90-day deadline in 26 U.S.C. § 6234(a), which governs partnerships under the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2015 (BBA), as nonjurisdictional. Section 6234(a) says only that a partnership “may file,” and the court’s grant of power sits in a separate subsection, so Boechler‘s clear-statement test was not met.

    History explains the different result. Hallmark leaned on nearly a century of courts reading the deficiency deadline as jurisdictional while Congress kept the words. The BBA replaced the old TEFRA regime outright, and TEFRA’s layered partner deadlines were a main reason North Wall Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner, 165 T.C. 143 (2025), kept those deadlines jurisdictional.

    Kings Road Property, LLC v. Commissioner, 167 T.C. No. 11 (Sept. 21, 2026), then tolled a BBA petition filed 16 days late. Counsel had pulled a transcript showing nothing and called the IRS, which said no final notice had gone out. It had been mailed March 25, 2025, and both copies came back undeliverable. Returned mail alone, the court said, might not have sufficed. A Colorado partnership appeals to the Tenth Circuit under § 7482(b)(1)(E), and absent a ruling there on the BBA deadline, Kings Road controls.

    Missed a Tax Court Deadline? Contact Us Now

    How do you count the Tax Court 90-day deadline in Colorado?

    Count 90 days from the mailing date, or 150 if the notice was addressed to someone outside the United States. A last day falling on a weekend or a District of Columbia legal holiday rolls forward under § 6213(a) and 26 U.S.C. § 7503. The notice also prints a last day, and a petition filed by that printed date is timely even if the IRS miscounted.

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 7502, a Postal Service postmark by the last day counts as filing; I want a certified mail receipt. Private carriers count only for IRS-designated services; anything else is filed when it arrives. Electronic filing is safer, and Tax Court Rule 22(d) treats it as timely through 11:59 p.m. eastern time, which is 9:59 p.m. in Colorado.

    What if the notice of deficiency went to an old Colorado address?

    It is probably still valid. Under 26 U.S.C. § 6212(b)(1), a notice mailed to the last known address is sufficient. Treas. Reg. § 301.6212-2 treats that as the address on the latest properly processed return unless the IRS got clear and concise notice of a new one, such as Form 8822 or a postal change-of-address record. Receipt is immaterial. Armstrong v. Commissioner, 15 F.3d 970 (10th Cir. 1994), held that the IRS’s duty of diligence ends when the notice is mailed. That is why Kings Road needed the misinformation, not just the returned envelopes.

    Illustrative example (hypothetical facts): our contractor files her 2025 return from Grand Junction in April 2026, moves in May, and files no Form 8822. A notice of deficiency for 2023 is dated Monday, June 22, 2026. Day 90 is Sunday, September 20, so her last day is Monday, September 21. She petitions on Tuesday, October 13, 113 days after the notice and 22 days late. Grand Junction was her last known address, the notice stands, and under Hallmark the case is dismissed. Even in a tolling circuit, an unreported move looks weak beside Kings Road‘s record.

    What are the options after a missed Tax Court deadline in Colorado?

    Whether the adviser is a Colorado tax attorney or an enrolled agent, the first job is sequencing. Audit reconsideration under IRM 4.13.1 covers an unpaid assessment where the taxpayer moved and missed the IRS’s letters, and a jurisdictional dismissal does not bar it.

    Once collection begins, a hearing under 26 U.S.C. § 6330 allows a challenge to the tax itself if the person “did not receive” the notice, with Tax Court review afterward. Someone with the cash can pay in full, as Flora v. United States, 362 U.S. 145 (1960) requires (it came up through the Tenth Circuit), claim a refund within 26 U.S.C. § 6511, wait six months under 26 U.S.C. § 6532(a)(1), and sue in the District of Colorado or the Court of Federal Claims. A doubt-as-to-liability offer under Treas. Reg. § 301.7122-1(b)(1) needs a real dispute about the amount. A related post compares Tax Court, a refund suit, and bankruptcy for a Colorado notice of deficiency.

    Colorado follows the federal result: C.R.S. § 39-22-601.5 requires a report of final federal adjustments within 180 days after the final determination date.

    Route after day 90 Pay first? Contest the amount? Main limit
    Late Tax Court petition seeking tolling No Only if the petition is accepted Hallmark and Foster govern Colorado for now
    Audit reconsideration No Yes, with new documentation IRS discretion; needs new information or an IRS error
    Collection due process hearing No Yes, if the notice was not received Only after a collection notice; 30 days to seek review
    Refund suit, D. Colo. or Court of Federal Claims Yes, in full Yes § 6511 claim window and six-month wait
    Doubt-as-to-liability offer No Yes, by negotiation Needs a real dispute about the amount

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is the Tax Court 90-day deadline jurisdictional for Colorado taxpayers?

    In the Tax Court, yes. That court follows Hallmark Research Collective, and the Tenth Circuit has not ruled on the question since Boechler.

    Has the Supreme Court agreed to decide whether the deficiency deadline can be tolled?

    Not as of October 9, 2026. It denied review in Culp in 2024, and the circuits now take three different positions on jurisdiction and tolling.

    Does Kings Road help an individual with a late deficiency petition?

    Not directly. Kings Road applies to partnership petitions under § 6234(a), and the Tax Court still treats § 6213(a) differently. Its facts do show what a strong tolling record looks like.

    What time is the e-filing cutoff on the last day for a Colorado filer?

    Tax Court Rule 22(d) sets the cutoff at 11:59 p.m. eastern time. In Colorado that is 9:59 p.m. Mountain time.

    Is a notice of deficiency valid if I never received it?

    Usually, if the IRS mailed it to your last known address. Non-receipt can still let you contest the tax at a collection due process hearing.

    Do I have to tell Colorado about a federal deficiency?

    Generally yes. C.R.S. § 39-22-601.5 requires a report of final federal adjustments within 180 days after the final determination date.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents Colorado taxpayers and their businesses in Tax Court litigation, IRS Appeals and CDP hearings, audit defense and reconsideration, and offers in compromise. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    Each route after a missed petition runs on its own clock, so the order matters. If a notice of deficiency slipped past you, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Tax Court Expert Witnesses at the Denver Trial Session: What Airbnb and Rule 143(g) Mean for Colorado Taxpayers

    Tax Court Expert Witnesses at the Denver Trial Session: What Airbnb and Rule 143(g) Mean for Colorado Taxpayers

    Picture a Boulder software company, a Littleton family partnership fighting over the discount on a gifted interest, or a Western Slope ranch whose conservation easement the IRS values at a fraction of the deduction. Each of those disputes can land at the Tax Court’s Denver trial session, and each will turn on whose expert the judge believes. A precedential opinion issued September 2, 2026 changes how experts can be used before trial.

    The opinion is Airbnb, Inc. & Subsidiaries v. Commissioner, 167 T.C. No. 9 (2026), Docket No. 12423-24, by Judge Emin Toro. It is a $4.2 billion transfer pricing fight, but its procedural rule applies just as well to a Colorado S corporation.

    What did the Tax Court decide in Airbnb about expert declarations?

    Both sides sought a discovery protective order under Rule 103 governing access to Airbnb’s source code. The Commissioner wanted the secured review room in Austin, Texas, where his software consultant worked, and attached two declarations from that consultant attacking Airbnb’s proposed terms. Airbnb moved to strike them as noncompliant expert reports.

    The court refused. Rule 143(g)’s report requirements, it held, do not reach declarations filed to support a pretrial discovery motion. Rule 143 sits in the Title of the rules headed “Trials,” and subsection (g) is triggered only for a party “who calls an expert witness.” No trial had taken place, the IRS had not firmly chosen its trial experts, and the declarations dealt with discovery procedure rather than the merits. A footnote added that Rule 143(g)(3) can excuse a written report for testimony limited to industry practice, which described most of what the consultant said. Any legal opinion in the declarations, the court said, it would simply disregard.

    What does Rule 143(g) require of a trial expert at the Denver Tax Court trial session?

    At trial the rule is strict. Under Tax Court Rule 143(g), a retained expert must sign a written report containing every opinion with its basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, supporting exhibits, qualifications with publications from the past 10 years, cases from the past 4 years in which the expert testified, and the compensation being paid. The report is received as the expert’s direct testimony.

    Timing is where Colorado petitioners get hurt. Once the case is calendared, reports must be served and submitted no later than 30 days before the call of the trial calendar. Late testimony is “excluded altogether” unless the party shows good cause and the opponent is not unduly prejudiced. And Rule 143(g)(3) says the court ordinarily will not excuse a report where the opinion rests on comparable sales or statistical data, which covers nearly every valuation or compensation study.

    How far can an expert go on legal questions when appeal lies to the Tenth Circuit?

    For a Colorado resident, or a corporation with its principal place of business here, 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1) sends the appeal to the Tenth Circuit. Under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), aff’d, 445 F.2d 985 (10th Cir. 1971), the Tax Court follows controlling precedent of that circuit, and 26 U.S.C. § 7453 makes the Federal Rules of Evidence govern regular Tax Court cases.

    The Tenth Circuit’s leading case is Specht v. Jensen, 853 F.2d 805 (10th Cir. 1988) (en banc). A lawyer-expert in a civil rights trial explained search and seizure law, then told the jury the searches were illegal. That exceeded Rule 702. The court drew a narrow line: an expert may refer to the law and use legal terms to explain facts, but “[i]n no instance can a witness be permitted to define the law of the case.” Since Rule 704(a) allows opinions on ultimate factual issues, a CPA can say a founder’s market pay was $150,000. Testifying that the pay “was reasonable under section 162” is a different matter.

    Specht was a jury case, and the Tax Court sits alone. Airbnb quoted United States v. Brown, 415 F.3d 1257, 1269 (11th Cir. 2005): there is “less need for the gatekeeper to keep the gate when the gatekeeper is keeping the gate only for himself.” It also relied on Nationwide Transport Finance v. Cass Information Systems, Inc., 523 F.3d 1051 (9th Cir. 2008) and Torres v. County of Oakland, 758 F.2d 147 (6th Cir. 1985), which asks whether a witness’s word carries a legal meaning distinct from ordinary usage.

    Does filing a consultant’s declaration give up the consulting-expert shield?

    Rule 70(c)(4)(C) generally bars discovery of facts known or opinions held by a retained expert who is not expected to testify, absent exceptional circumstances. That lets a taxpayer test a position privately with a forensic accountant.

    Airbnb did not rule on waiver. But a declaration on the public docket discloses exactly the opinions that rule protects, and the IRS will argue the door is open. If the consultant is later designated for trial, the declaration becomes cross-examination material, and Rule 70(c)(4)(B) already leaves discoverable any facts, data, or assumptions counsel gave a testifying expert. The safer course is to support a discovery motion with a fact witness or a second consultant and keep the trial expert off the motion papers. A Rule 103 order can then control how trade secrets, customer lists, or code are disclosed, including when and where.

    Issue Trial expert report (Rule 143(g)) Declaration on a discovery motion (Airbnb) Consulting expert (Rule 70(c)(4)(C))
    Required contents Opinions and reasons, data, exhibits, qualifications, publications, testimony list, compensation No Rule 143(g) checklist Nothing filed
    Timing 30 days before calendar call With the motion or response Any time
    Discoverability Drafts protected; counsel-supplied facts, data, assumptions are not Public once filed Generally barred absent exceptional circumstances
    Impeachment risk High on cross High if declarant later testifies Low while undisclosed
    Who decides Trial judge under Rules 702 and 143(g) Motion judge, who may disregard legal opinion Not offered as evidence

    What makes a forensic accountant’s Tax Court report hold up?

    Since its 2023 amendment, Rule 702 requires the proponent to show it is “more likely than not” that the testimony rests on sufficient facts and reliable methods reliably applied. The Tax Court policed this before the amendment. In Boltar, L.L.C. v. Commissioner, 136 T.C. 326 (2011), a conservation easement case, it excluded the taxpayer’s appraisal entirely for skipping the before-and-after method, ignoring contiguous parcels, and assuming infeasible development, rather than admitting it and then giving it no weight.

    From the accountant’s side, the reports that hold up list every assumption and say which came from counsel. Each number traces to a document the IRS can check. The writer applies the legal standard without arguing its meaning, and fees and prior testimony are disclosed plainly. Conceding a weak point openly often buys more credibility than any chart.

    How would the pretrial calendar run for a Boulder S corporation?

    Hypothetical. A Boulder software S corporation (call it the company) paid its founder no W-2 wages for 2023 and 2024 while distributing $420,000 each year. The IRS issues a notice of employment tax determination treating $195,000 a year as wages. The company petitions under 26 U.S.C. § 7436, which lets the court decide status and the proper amount of tax. Because the tax is under $50,000 per quarter, small case procedure is available, but § 7436(c) decisions cannot be appealed and need not follow the Federal Rules of Evidence. The company files as a regular case.

    Say calendar call at the Denver session is Monday, June 7, 2027. The IRS demands every customer contract and the commit logs. Rule 70(a)(2) requires discovery motions at least 45 days before calendar call, so the protective order motion goes in by Friday, April 23, supported by the engineering manager’s declaration rather than the CPA expert’s. Reports are due 30 days out, a Saturday, so counsel serves Friday, May 7. The CPA puts market pay for the founder’s coding and management mix at $110,000 against the IRS expert’s $195,000, and stays on facts.

    Tax Court Case With Expert Issues? Contact Us Now

    For the earlier forum decision, see holding a Colorado notice of deficiency: Tax Court, refund suit, or bankruptcy.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Where does the Tax Court hold trials in Denver?

    The court lists the Byron Rogers Federal Building, 1961 Stout Street, as its Denver place of trial. The notice of trial confirms the courtroom for each session.

    Is a declaration attached to a discovery motion evidence at trial?

    No. Rule 143(c) says ex parte affidavits and declarations do not constitute evidence, and Airbnb ruled that the Rule 143(g) report requirements do not apply to them.

    Can my CPA testify that my position is correct under the tax code?

    Not in that form. In a case appealable to the Tenth Circuit, Specht v. Jensen bars an expert from defining the law of the case, though the CPA can give factual opinions such as market compensation or value.

    What happens if my expert report is served late?

    Rule 143(g)(2) excludes the testimony altogether unless you show good cause and the delay does not unduly prejudice the IRS.

    Can an industry practice witness testify without a report?

    Possibly. Rule 143(g)(3) lets the court allow that for testimony limited to industry practice or rebuttal, but rarely for opinions built on comparable sales or statistical data.

    Can a protective order keep my source code or customer list away from the IRS?

    Rule 103 lets the court limit how a trade secret is disclosed and set the time and place of review, but it rarely blocks relevant discovery entirely.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm handles Tax Court litigation for Colorado individuals and closely held businesses, from the audit through expert discovery and trial, along with related tax defense work. The firm sees expert problems start well before trial, often when a consultant’s work gets filed without a plan, and Phillip’s forensic accounting and expert witness background shapes how reports are built and attacked. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If a valuation or compensation study will decide your Tax Court case, the deadlines run from the trial notice, not from when you feel ready. To review your calendar and expert plan, contact North Star Law Firm.