Owen is the volunteer treasurer of a youth-mentoring 501(c)(3) in Colorado Springs with 14 employees and a $1.4 million budget. He co-signs checks over $5,000 and sees the bank statements before each board meeting. In October an IRS exempt organizations examiner asked for the 2023 and 2024 Forms 990, board minutes and payroll records. Pulling them, Owen learned the executive director had skipped federal payroll tax deposits for two quarters of 2025 to make payroll.
His question for me was whether he could personally owe the money. He can. Whether he will depends on what he knew, when, and what he signs from here on.
Can a volunteer board member personally owe a Colorado nonprofit’s unpaid payroll taxes?
Yes. Income tax and the employee’s share of Social Security and Medicare withheld from a paycheck are “a special fund in trust for the United States” under 26 U.S.C. § 7501(a). If they are not paid over, 26 U.S.C. § 6672(a) imposes a penalty equal to the unpaid amount on any person “required to collect, truthfully account for, and pay over” the tax who “willfully fails” to do it. This is the trust fund recovery penalty, or TFRP.
Section 6672(a) has no carve-out for charities. The IRS’s employment tax page for exempt organizations names “a member of a board of trustees of a tax-exempt organization” as a possible target. Colorado Springs hosts an unusual concentration of national ministries and youth organizations with large unpaid boards.
How does an IRS exam of a Colorado nonprofit become a collection case against board members?
The IRS says an exempt organization audit may cover employment tax returns and whether employment taxes were paid. The examiners’ manual is blunter: IRM 4.70.12.3.6.2.1 calls employment tax “an integral part of the examination of an exempt organization,” and tells the agent to consider § 6672. The TE/GE Program Letter for fiscal year 2027 again lists worker classification and “various employment tax related issues.”
So an exam of 2023 and 2024 returns can surface a 2025 deposit gap. Under IRM 5.7.3.5.1, an examiner who sees a possible TFRP refers it to Collection on Form 6238, and a revenue officer investigates the individuals. Insider pay and other organization-level issues run separately; see Section 4958 excess benefit taxes for Colorado nonprofits.
Nonprofit Got an IRS Exam Letter? Contact Us Now
Does the Section 6672(e) volunteer exception protect a board treasurer who signs checks?
Usually not. Section 6672(e) bars the penalty against an “unpaid, volunteer member” of an exempt organization’s board who serves “solely” in an honorary capacity, “does not participate in the day-to-day or financial operations,” and lacks “actual knowledge of the failure.” All three must hold, and the exception falls away if it would leave no one liable. IRS Policy Statement 5-14, at IRM 1.2.1.6.3, tracks the statute.
A treasurer who co-signs checks is not honorary. In Jefferson v. United States, 546 F.3d 477 (7th Cir. 2008), the unpaid board president of an Illinois day care co-signed checks, approved financial statements and could borrow; he was not serving “solely in an honorary capacity,” and his claimed lack of knowledge did not help. I have found no Tenth Circuit decision applying § 6672(e).
Muck v. United States, 3 F.3d 1378 (10th Cir. 1993), a Thornton hotel case, held that “significant, though not necessarily exclusive, authority” counts “irrespective of whether that authority is actually exercised.” Denbo v. United States, 988 F.2d 1029 (10th Cir. 1993) held a director willful who relied on his co-owner’s assurances instead of investigating. Taylor v. IRS, 69 F.3d 411 (10th Cir. 1995) found a board member with no stock responsible because he had “effective power” to pay, and Bradshaw v. United States, 83 F.3d 1175 (10th Cir. 1996) rejected a lender-control excuse. The narrow opening is Finley v. United States, 123 F.3d 1342 (10th Cir. 1997) (en banc): reasonable cause can negate willfulness, but only when efforts to protect the trust funds were frustrated by circumstances beyond the person’s control.
What deadlines does a nonprofit director face after a Letter 1153?
The revenue officer will seek a Form 4180 interview with each potentially responsible person. If the officer recommends the penalty, Letter 1153 follows. Section 6672(b)(2) requires at least 60 days before notice and demand, and IRM 5.7.4.7 extends that to 75 days for a letter addressed outside the United States. A timely protest goes to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals.
For Form 941 periods, § 6501(b)(2) treats an early return as filed April 15 of the next year, and § 6501(a) gives three years from then to assess. Under § 6672(b)(3), a Letter 1153 mailed in time keeps it open until the later of 90 days after mailing or 30 days after Appeals finishes. With no return filed, § 6501(c)(3) leaves it open.
After assessment, § 6330(a) requires notice of a hearing right at least 30 days before levy, and the hearing must be requested within that 30-day period. Someone who already had the Letter 1153 protest opportunity generally cannot reargue liability there, under § 6330(c)(2)(B). The court route is a refund suit. Flora v. United States, 362 U.S. 145 (1960) normally requires full payment, but in Boynton v. United States, 566 F.2d 50 (9th Cir. 1977), involving a nonprofit’s staff, the court said a TFRP taxpayer “need only pay the divisible amount” tied to one employee’s withholding. You then file Form 843 and sue in district court or the Court of Federal Claims, the forums § 6672(c) names.
How would this play out for a Colorado Springs youth nonprofit in 2026?
Illustrative example (hypothetical facts). Owen’s organization paid about $444,000 of wages in the second and third quarters of 2025 and filed both Forms 941 without paying. The $96,000 owed splits into about $34,000 of employer Social Security and Medicare, $34,000 of employee share and $28,000 of withheld income tax. Under IRM 5.7.4.3 the TFRP equals the employee share plus withholding, roughly $62,000. Because both returns were filed before April 15, 2026, the IRS has until April 15, 2029 to assess.
The revenue officer will interview the executive director, Owen, the board chair and the bookkeeper. A director who never sees bank records and learned of the gap from the exam letter fits § 6672(e), and the exception works because the executive director stays liable. Owen’s best argument is lack of knowledge, which goes to willfulness. His bigger risk is ahead of him: Muck requires a responsible person who learns of the delinquency to send unencumbered funds to the IRS before other creditors, so every vendor check he co-signs this November counts.
If the organization can raise cash, paperwork matters. Policy Statement 5-14 applies an undesignated payment to the employer’s share first; a written designation to the trust fund portion shrinks what any individual can be charged. The same statement says that, absent statute concerns, assertion recommendations are normally withheld while a business installment agreement is current. An earlier post covers the contractor version of this trust fund problem.
Do Colorado’s nonprofit liability shields or a bankruptcy filing protect a director?
Not against the IRS. C.R.S. § 13-21-115.7 gives uncompensated 501(c)(3) directors civil immunity absent willful and wanton conduct, and C.R.S. § 7-128-402 lets the articles limit damages owed to the corporation or its members. None stops a federal § 6672 assessment. Colorado treats withheld state income tax as held in trust under C.R.S. § 39-22-604(7), and C.R.S. § 39-21-116.5 adds a 150 percent penalty on corporate officers who willfully fail to pay over taxes they must collect. Unemployment premiums are an employer cost, not withheld from wages (C.R.S. § 8-76-101), so they raise no trust fund issue.
Bankruptcy helps less than people expect. The TFRP is a priority tax under 11 U.S.C. § 507(a)(8)(C), so § 523(a)(1)(A) keeps it alive after a director’s own Chapter 7 discharge. The organization’s Chapter 11 does not shield him, though United States v. Energy Resources Co., 495 U.S. 545 (1990) lets the court direct plan payments to trust fund taxes first when the plan’s success requires it.
| Person | Responsible person and § 6672(e) | What the Form 4180 interview probes | Likely exposure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Honorary volunteer director | Usually not responsible; exception available if unpaid, outside finances and unaware | Board role, access to bank records, when the gap became known | Low |
| Volunteer treasurer who co-signs checks | Likely responsible under Muck and Taylor; exception rarely fits | Signature authority, which bills got paid, knowledge of missed deposits | High if willful |
| Executive director | Responsible; paid staff, so no exception | Who chose wages over deposits | Highest |
| Outside bookkeeper | Usually not, if paying bills as directed (IRM 5.7.3.4.1.2) | Whether he or she picked which creditors got paid | Low to moderate |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the IRS go after a Colorado nonprofit’s board members for unpaid payroll taxes?
Yes, for the withheld trust fund portion, if a member was responsible and acted willfully. Unpaid volunteers serving in a purely honorary role without knowledge are protected by section 6672(e).
Does a nonprofit’s IRS audit cover payroll taxes?
It can. The IRS manual treats employment tax as an integral part of an exempt organization exam, and examiners check whether Forms 941 were filed and paid.
How long do I have to appeal a proposed trust fund recovery penalty?
Letter 1153 gives 60 days, or 75 days if addressed outside the United States. A timely protest goes to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals.
Is a board treasurer who signs checks a responsible person?
Often. Check-signing alone is not decisive under IRM 5.7.3.4.1.1, but the Tenth Circuit counts authority whether or not it is used.
Can I discharge a trust fund recovery penalty in bankruptcy?
Not in Chapter 7. It is a priority tax under section 507(a)(8)(C), and section 523(a)(1)(A) excepts it from discharge.
Does Colorado’s volunteer immunity statute stop the IRS penalty?
No. C.R.S. 13-21-115.7 addresses state civil liability and does not bar a federal tax assessment.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm represents Colorado nonprofit directors and organizations in IRS audit defense, trust fund penalty appeals and CDP hearings, and installment agreements for unpaid payroll taxes. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.
What a board member says in the Form 4180 interview, and signs after the exam letter arrives, can decide the case. If your organization has an IRS exam letter and payroll deposits are behind, contact North Star Law Firm.
