Colorado Nonprofit Insider Payments: Section 4958 Excess Benefit Taxes After Jagannath

The Impossible Players community theatre building, a former 1930 church, in Pueblo, Colorado

A new board member of a Lakewood youth soccer club is reconciling old bank statements. One line stops her: a $120,000 wire in December 2024 to an event company the board president owns, with no contract or board minute behind it and nothing showing what it bought. Her question is the one I hear most: is this the club’s problem or the president’s?

Federally, mostly his. Section 4958 of the Internal Revenue Code taxes the insider, and the Tax Court’s September 24, 2026 decision in Jagannath v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-92, shows 25 percent becoming 225 percent when nobody corrects. The board has work too, some under Colorado law.

What is an excess benefit transaction for a Colorado nonprofit?

It is a deal in which a 501(c)(3) public charity gives an economic benefit to a “disqualified person” and gets less value back. 26 U.S.C. § 4958(c)(1)(A), (e). A disqualified person is anyone in a position to exercise substantial influence over the organization at any time in the prior five years (§ 4958(f)(1)(A)), which by rule includes voting directors, the president and the treasurer (Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-3(c)). Their family members count, and so does any entity they own more than 35 percent of (§ 4958(f)(3), (f)(4)).

A real loan on fair terms is not automatically an excess benefit for a public charity. Jagannath was not close: a Tennessee charity’s president signed a $590,000 interest-free note as both lender and borrower for his own LLC, 11 days after the cash left, and the court rejected his story that a later $600,000 wire repaid it. Colorado goes further than the Code. C.R.S. § 7-128-501(2) bars a Colorado nonprofit corporation from lending to its directors or officers, and any who assent to or participate in such a loan are liable for it until repaid.

How much does the section 4958 excise tax cost the insider personally?

The first-tier tax is 25 percent of the excess benefit, owed by the disqualified person (§ 4958(a)(1)). An officer or director who knowingly participates owes 10 percent unless the participation was not willful and was due to reasonable cause, capped at $20,000 per transaction (§ 4958(a)(2), (d)(2)). Leave the benefit uncorrected through the “taxable period” and a 200 percent tax follows (§ 4958(b)).

In Jagannath that meant $147,500 plus $1,180,000, or $1,327,500 on $590,000. The court also sustained additions under 26 U.S.C. § 6651(a)(1) and (a)(2); he never filed or paid, and he never argued reasonable cause.

The insider files his own Form 4720 (Treas. Reg. § 53.6011-1(b)), due the 15th day of the fifth month after his tax year, usually May 15 (Treas. Reg. § 53.6071-1(f)(1)). Under the Form 4720 instructions, the charity may not pay his tax.

When can an insider still avoid the 200 percent tax?

The taxable period ends when the IRS mails a notice of deficiency for the 25 percent tax or assesses it (§ 4958(f)(5)); correcting before then prevents the 200 percent tax. Under Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-7, the insider repays the excess plus interest, compounded annually at no less than the applicable federal rate (AFR) for the transaction month, in cash or its equivalent, “excluding payment by a promissory note.”

Even the mailing date is not quite the end. 26 U.S.C. § 4961(a) abates the second-tier tax if correction comes within the “correction period,” which § 4963(e) ends 90 days after the notice for that tax, extended while a Tax Court case bars assessment (see Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-1(c)(2)(iii)). The Jagannath opinion never mentions § 4961; on October 16, 2026 the docket showed Rule 155 computations due December 27 and no decision entered.

The 25 percent tax is stickier. Section 4962 abates it only if the transaction was due to reasonable cause rather than willful neglect and was corrected in time; § 4962(b) covers subchapter D of chapter 42, where § 4958 sits. A president who paid his own company without a vote has a weak reasonable-cause case.

Insider Payment on Your Nonprofit’s Books? Contact Us Now

How does a Colorado board use the rebuttable presumption of reasonableness?

Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-6 presumes pay reasonable, and a property transfer at fair market value, when board members with no conflict approve it in advance, relying on comparability data and documenting their basis at the time. For an event contract, I want competing vendor quotes in the file, and minutes written before the later of the next meeting or 60 days after the vote.

Colorado runs a parallel test. A contract with an entity in which a director has a financial interest is a “conflicting interest transaction” (§ 7-128-501(1)), and it is not voidable solely for that reason if disinterested directors approve or ratify it in good faith after disclosure, if members do, or if it is fair (§ 7-128-501(3)). Colorado accepts after-the-fact ratification; the federal presumption needs advance approval, so a 2026 vote cannot create it for 2024. Applying these rules and the director duties in C.R.S. § 7-128-401 is work for a Colorado nonprofit tax attorney or other Colorado-licensed counsel.

Under Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-4(c), services count as consideration only if the charity showed at payment that it meant compensation, usually by a W-2, 1099, Form 990 report or written contract. Otherwise they are ignored, an “automatic” excess benefit in practitioners’ shorthand.

What could the IRS assess against a Lakewood board president?

Illustrative example (hypothetical facts): on December 2, 2024, the club wires $120,000 to the president’s single-member LLC for two tournaments. Nobody signed a contract or called a vote, and the club issued no Form 1099. If all of it is excess benefit under § 53.4958-4(c), his first-tier tax is $30,000. If the work counts and a comparable vendor would have charged $50,000, the excess is $70,000 and the tax $17,500. A treasurer who knowingly approved the wire faces $12,000 of manager tax.

His 2024 Form 4720 was due May 15, 2025, so § 6651 additions are accruing. Correcting on December 2, 2026, two years later, uses the short-term rate under 26 U.S.C. § 1274(d)(1)(A), 4.30 percent compounded annually for December 2024 (Rev. Rul. 2024-26). At that floor he repays $130,541.88, including $10,541.88 of interest. If a notice of deficiency comes first, $240,000 more is at stake until correction within the § 4961 period, or $270,000 in all.

How long does the IRS have, and which court hears a Colorado section 4958 case?

The clock runs from the charity’s return. 26 U.S.C. § 6501(l)(1) points to the organization’s return for the transaction year, and Treas. Reg. § 301.6501(e)-1(c)(3)(ii) allows three years if that return adequately discloses the transaction, six if not. The Schedule L instructions put payments over $100,000 to an interested person in Part IV and every excess benefit transaction in Part I. Jagannath‘s charity left Schedule L off, and the court used those returns against him.

The IRS asserts these chapter 42 taxes by notice of deficiency (26 U.S.C. § 6212(a)), and the insider has 90 days to petition the Tax Court before assessment (§ 6213(a)). Colorado residents appeal to the Tenth Circuit (§ 7482(b)(1)(A)), whose only § 4958 ruling I found is Farr v. Commissioner, 738 F. App’x 969 (10th Cir. 2018). That unpublished order affirmed both tiers against a Kansas taxpayer who had used charity funds for personal expenses. With no published Tenth Circuit law, the Tax Court applies its own precedent under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970).

Can intermediate sanctions and 501(c)(3) revocation both hit a Colorado nonprofit?

Yes. Congress added § 4958 in 1996 (Pub. L. 104-168, § 1311) because, as Jagannath recounts, revocation had been the IRS’s only remedy and it fell on the charity rather than the insider. Treas. Reg. § 1.501(c)(3)-1(f)(2) keeps revocation available, weighing size, repetition, safeguards and correction, and correction after IRS discovery “by itself, is never a sufficient basis” to keep exemption. Last week’s post covers 501(c)(3) revocation in Colorado.

The Colorado Secretary of State’s charity registration can require the Form 990 with every schedule except donor lists (C.R.S. § 6-16-104(2)(f)). A Charitable Solicitations Act violation is also a Consumer Protection Act violation (§ 6-16-111(5)), which the Attorney General can enforce (§ 6-1-103), and C.R.S. § 7-134-301 allows dissolution suits over abuse of authority or misapplied assets.

Layer Who owes it Example ($120,000) Way out
First-tier tax, 25% President $30,000 § 4962: reasonable cause plus correction
Manager tax, 10% Knowing managers $12,000 (cap $20,000) No knowing participation
Second-tier tax, 200% President $240,000 Timely correction (§ 4961)
Correction payment President, to the club $130,541.88 (Dec. 2, 2026) Cash; AFR or higher
§ 6651 additions President Up to 25% each Timely Form 4720; reasonable cause

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a nonprofit loan to a director legal in Colorado?

Not for a Colorado nonprofit corporation. C.R.S. § 7-128-501(2) bars loans to directors and officers and makes those who assent to one liable until it is repaid. Federal excess benefit treatment is a separate question.

Can the nonprofit pay the president’s section 4958 tax?

No. The Form 4720 instructions forbid it. A reimbursement is itself an excess benefit unless it was part of reasonable compensation.

Does signing a promissory note correct an excess benefit?

No. Treas. Reg. § 53.4958-7(b)(1) requires cash or cash equivalents and excludes notes. Returning the property itself requires the organization’s agreement.

Who files Form 4720, and when?

The disqualified person and each liable manager file separately, by the 15th day of the fifth month after their tax year. The organization reports the transaction on Schedule I of its own Form 4720.

Can the 200 percent tax be removed after a notice of deficiency?

Yes, by correction within the § 4961 correction period: 90 days after the notice for that tax, extended while a Tax Court case bars assessment. Waiting is risky, since interest keeps growing.

How North Star Law Firm Can Help

North Star Law Firm represents Colorado nonprofit insiders and organizations in IRS examinations of excess benefit transactions, penalty and excise tax abatement, and Tax Court litigation of section 4958 deficiencies. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

Fixing an insider payment gets costlier once the IRS mails a notice of deficiency. If your board has found a payment it cannot explain, contact North Star Law Firm.