Gideon runs a trucking and ag hauling S corporation in Greeley with about nine drivers. The company took PPP loans of $187,000 in 2020 and $150,000 in 2021, both forgiven, plus a $200,000 SBA COVID EIDL that is now 14 months behind. A dispatcher he fired in 2024 keeps posting “fraud” about the company online. Meanwhile his bookkeeper has spotted a real problem: the payroll on the PPP applications is higher than the Forms W-3 the company filed, and the 2020 and 2021 Forms 941 and 1120-S were all late.
Most coverage this fall has been about the Justice Department paying tipsters. For a borrower like Gideon, the bigger change is a memo telling fraud prosecutors to look for a tax case every time. That is where I would start.
Why would a PPP loan fraud investigation in Colorado turn into an IRS criminal case?
The Justice Department created its National Fraud Enforcement Division by an Acting Attorney General memo dated April 7, 2026. In October the division opened a tip rewards pilot that, according to its published FAQs, pays $10,000 to $30,000 once charges are unsealed, and SBA program fraud is covered.
The more important document is Directive 26-13, “A Comprehensive Approach in the Fight Against Fraud” (Oct. 7, 2026). It tells prosecutors to assess “in every case” whether “a violation of the internal revenue laws has occurred,” and to invite IRS Criminal Investigation to evaluate the tax side when tax charges would advance the case or asset recovery. It also targets unpaid tax on “fraudulently obtained or unreported income.” The memo never mentions PPP or EIDL. It does not need to.
Colorado already has the machinery. The U.S. Attorney’s Office here was picked on July 11, 2023 to lead one of five national COVID-19 Fraud Strike Force teams, and the IRS-CI Denver Field Office investigates local PPP cases. In United States v. Nieto, No. 22-cr-00262-WJM (D. Colo.), a Morrison contractor got 46 months in June 2025; the IRS release says he fabricated Forms 941 that did not match the returns he had actually filed. That mismatch is what a tax agent hunts for.
Which tax charges can a PPP or EIDL file pull in with IRS Criminal Investigation?
On the loan side the usual charges are 18 U.S.C. § 1014 (false statements to the SBA or an FDIC insured lender), wire fraud and conspiracy under § 1343 and § 1349, § 1001, theft of government money under § 641, and money laundering under § 1957 for transactions over $10,000. Nieto and a Colorado Springs borrower sentenced in January 2025 were both convicted of wire fraud and laundering.
Directive 26-13 adds the tax column. A Form 941 or 1120-S the owner knew was false supports a count under 26 U.S.C. § 7206(1), and a bookkeeper who helped faces § 7206(2). Withheld payroll tax never paid over fits § 7202; years with no return fit § 7203; a pattern of hiding income becomes evasion under § 7201.
The facts that create this exposure are familiar. Application payroll above the 941s means either an inflated application or wages paid off the books. EIDL money spent on the owner’s mortgage was income to someone and often never reported. Forgiven PPP is tax exempt under 15 U.S.C. § 636m(i), as amended by section 276 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021, with the deductions preserved, but if prosecutors treat the excess as money obtained by fraud rather than a loan, nobody should assume that treatment survives.
Worried About Your PPP or EIDL File? Contact Us Now
What is the statute of limitations for PPP fraud, and when does the tax side close?
Ten years on the loan. The PPP and Bank Fraud Enforcement Harmonization Act of 2022 put that deadline in 15 U.S.C. § 636(a)(36)(W) and (a)(37)(P), and the COVID-19 EIDL Fraud Statute of Limitations Act of 2022 did the same in § 636(b)(16) and § 9009(e)(9), for criminal and civil cases alike.
Most criminal tax charges get six years under 26 U.S.C. § 6531. Civil assessment usually ends three years after filing under § 6501(a), but a fraudulent return can be assessed “at any time” under § 6501(c)(1), with a 75 percent penalty under § 6663.
On one calendar: if Gideon signed his first application in April 2020, it can be charged until April 2030. If his late 2020 Form 1120-S was filed in December 2021, a § 7206(1) count on it expires in December 2027. The criminal tax window can close years before the loan window, while civil fraud on that same year never closes. The post on Colorado limitations periods after Murrin covers how fraud keeps old years open.
How does an EIDL fraud whistleblower read my file against public data?
The FAQs say original information can come from “independent analysis of public or private data.” For PPP, much of it is public. The SBA’s PPP FOIA dataset shows borrower name, lender, amounts approved and forgiven, and jobs reported, and ProPublica publishes a searchable copy. A former employee can lay those numbers beside Secretary of State records, job postings and what he saw in the yard. Just assume your file will be read against public numbers by someone who wants it to look bad.
What does a payroll gap mean for a Greeley trucking company’s PPP file?
An illustrative version of Gideon’s numbers: first and second draw loans were capped at 2.5 times average monthly payroll under 15 U.S.C. § 636(a)(36)(E) and (a)(37)(C). To support $187,000 and $150,000, his applications claimed about $74,800 and $60,000 a month. Assume his Forms 941 show about $45,000 a month in 2019 and 2020 ($540,000 for 2020). On those filings each loan tops out near $112,500, leaving roughly $112,000 of the $337,000 unexplained. In United States v. Joseph, 108 F.4th 1273 (10th Cir. 2024), a Colorado Springs PPP case, the Tenth Circuit upheld counting an earlier failed application as intended loss, so a sentencing loss figure can exceed what was received.
A counsel led review rebuilds payroll from bank records, 941s and W-2s first. The innocent explanation I see most is owner pay that never ran through payroll. That helps less than people hope, because payroll costs under § 636(a)(36)(A)(viii) mean compensation to employees, and S corporation draws are not wages. If he worked full time on no salary, the IRS may recast part of the draws as wages, and the trust fund recovery penalty under § 6672 can reach him personally.
The EIDL comes after that. A hardship plan or offer requires sworn financial statements, so it waits for the exposure review. Any compromised balance is also debt cancellation income under 26 U.S.C. § 61(a)(11) unless a § 108(a) exclusion, such as bankruptcy or insolvency, applies.
Should I amend returns or ask the SBA for relief before a lawyer reviews the file?
No. Under IRM 25.1.2.2, an examiner who sees badges of fraud brings in a fraud enforcement advisor, develops “affirmative acts” of fraud, suspends the exam once they are found, and refers the case to Criminal Investigation when criminal criteria are met. After CI opens a case, IRM 9.5.1.2.1 has the agent ask civil functions to suspend their work. An amended return filed midstream is a signed admission.
The tax practitioner privilege in 26 U.S.C. § 7525 applies only in noncriminal matters, so what you tell your CPA is unprotected if the case turns criminal. The fix is for the lawyer to hire the accountant, as in United States v. Kovel, 296 F.2d 918 (2d Cir. 1961). Kovel is a Second Circuit case, and I did not locate a Tenth Circuit opinion deciding the point, so the engagement terms matter. The Fifth Amendment protects what you say; a first call from an agent is not the time to explain.
My order is criminal exposure, then civil tax compliance, then SBA or Treasury resolution or bankruptcy. For collection, see SBA demand letters, Treasury offset and bankruptcy in Colorado.
| Colorado borrower profile | Likely civil tax issue | Potential criminal exposure | First step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clean loan file, late 941s and 1120-S | Late filing and payment penalties | Low; § 7203 only if willful | Confirm filings support the applications, then catch up |
| Application payroll above the 941s | Unreported wages, employment tax, § 6672 | § 1014, § 1343, § 7206(1) | Payroll reconstruction through counsel |
| EIDL spent on personal bills | Unreported distributions or wages | § 641, § 1957, false returns | Trace the EIDL before any hardship request |
| Forgiven PPP, no real operations | Whether § 636m(i) applies; civil fraud penalty | Highest: loan, laundering and tax counts | Criminal defense counsel before any contact |
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the DOJ WHIP whistleblower program cover PPP and EIDL fraud?
Yes. The FAQs list fraud on Small Business Administration programs as covered. Rewards of $10,000 to $30,000 are paid after charges are unsealed, not after conviction.
Can IRS Criminal Investigation open a case over a PPP loan?
Yes. IRS-CI investigates tax crimes and money laundering and has worked Colorado PPP cases. Directive 26-13 now has fraud prosecutors ask about tax charges in every case.
How long can the government charge PPP fraud?
Ten years from the offense under the 2022 amendments to 15 U.S.C. § 636. An application signed in 2021 can be charged into 2031.
Is a forgiven PPP loan taxable income?
Legitimately forgiven PPP is excluded from gross income by 15 U.S.C. § 636m(i), and the related deductions stay. A loan forgiven on false certifications is an unsettled question.
Should I file amended returns to fix the payroll numbers?
Not before a lawyer reviews your exposure. An amended return is sworn, and if a fraud referral is underway it becomes evidence.
Is my CPA’s advice on the PPP file privileged?
Not in a criminal case. Section 7525 stops at noncriminal matters, so when criminal exposure is possible the CPA should be retained through counsel.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm reviews PPP and EIDL files for Colorado business owners, handles IRS audit defense and unfiled and late tax returns, and works on SBA loans and business debt once the tax picture is clear. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.
If your PPP applications and payroll filings do not agree, have the file reviewed before anyone signs a new form. To start, contact North Star Law Firm.
