DOJ v. McNutt and Colorado Home Distilling: What Changes for Hobbyists and Distillers

Shelves of old glass bottles for sale against a log wall in the former mining town of Granite, Lake County, Colorado

Marcus has pressed apples and fermented hard cider in his Salida garage for years. He read that a federal appeals court struck down the home distilling ban, and now he wants to run a few gallons through a small pot still and age it as apple brandy. A friend who owns a licensed craft distillery in town asks the other half: if the ban falls, does her federal permit or quarterly excise tax change?

For Marcus, nothing he read makes a garage still lawful in Colorado. For his friend, nothing turns on the case. The reasons matter, because Department of Justice v. McNutt, now at the Supreme Court, turns on a question about the taxing power that reaches well past whiskey.

Is home distilling legal in Colorado after the Fifth Circuit’s McNutt ruling?

No. Under 26 U.S.C. § 5178(a)(1)(B), no distilled spirits plant may be located “in any dwelling house, in any shed, yard, or inclosure connected with any dwelling house.” The Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB) regulation at 27 C.F.R. § 19.51 is blunter: “A person may not produce distilled spirits at home for personal use.”

The ruling protects people, not a region. The government’s cert petition describes the injunction entered in Hobby Distillers Ass’n v. Alcohol & Tobacco Tax & Trade Bureau, 740 F. Supp. 3d 509 (N.D. Tex. 2024), as running “against McNutt, the association, and the association’s members.” Colorado sits in the Tenth Circuit, which has not ruled on the ban. Unless Marcus is a plaintiff or a Hobby Distillers Association member, the ban still binds him, and membership would not fix his state law problem.

What did the Fifth and Sixth Circuits hold, and what is the Supreme Court deciding in DOJ v. McNutt?

In McNutt v. U.S. Department of Justice, 173 F.4th 204 (5th Cir. 2026), decided April 10, 2026, the panel held that the ban collects nothing, so it falls outside the taxing power, and is not “necessary and proper” either. It leaned on NFIB v. Sebelius, 567 U.S. 519, 574 (2012), which limits the taxing power to “requiring an individual to pay money into the Federal Treasury, no more.” It refused to read United States v. Comstock, 560 U.S. 126 (2010) as a rational basis test, and warned that the government’s logic had no stopping point.

Eleven days later, Ream v. U.S. Department of the Treasury, 174 F.4th 480 (6th Cir. 2026) agreed the taxing power alone could not carry the ban but upheld it as necessary and proper. Judge Kethledge pointed to the “stupendous frauds” Congress documented in 1867 and to how much harder a house is to inspect, concluding that “empirically, alcohol is sui generis, or very close to it.”

The docket in No. 26-204 shows certiorari granted October 19, 2026, on whether the location ban “is necessary and proper for carrying into execution Congress’s enumerated power to lay and collect taxes.” As of November 6, 2026, no argument date is listed. Ream’s petition, No. 26-93, remains pending. Ohio and 14 other states filed an amicus brief there; Colorado did not join.

What federal penalties does a Colorado home distiller face under 26 U.S.C. 5601?

Several; McNutt challenged one. Section 5601(a) makes each of these a felony carrying up to $10,000 and five years per offense: possessing an unregistered still (paragraph (1)), distilling in a dwelling or connected shed or yard (paragraph (6)), making a wash fit for distillation off a qualified plant (paragraph (7)), and producing spirits without being “a distiller authorized by law” (paragraph (8)). Sections 5602 (fraud) and 5604 (closures and marks) add more.

Forfeiture is the harsher piece. Under § 5615, an unregistered still is forfeited with nearby personal property, and someone distilling without bond can lose his interest “in the lot or tract of land on which the distillery is situated.” The tax attaches “as soon as this substance is in existence” under § 5001(b), and § 5006(c)(2) makes it “due and payable immediately upon production” for spirits made outside a qualified plant. Marcus would owe $13.50 per proof gallon on brandy he never sold.

What would a Supreme Court win for McNutt change for a Colorado hobbyist?

Less than headlines suggest. A win removes the location ban and paragraph (6). Registration under § 5171, still registration under § 5179, the permit requirement and the tax all stay. The Fifth Circuit said a home distiller would then stand “on the same level as current licensees,” paperwork included.

For beer and wine, Pub. L. 95-458 (1978) shaped today’s household exemptions in § 5042(a)(2) and § 5053(e): 200 gallons a calendar year with two or more adults, 100 with one. Congress never wrote a spirits counterpart, and no court can.

Colorado law runs separately. A manufacturer’s license under C.R.S. § 44-3-402 goes to persons “distilling, rectifying, or brewing within this state,” and the home exception in C.R.S. § 44-3-106(2) reaches only malt and vinous liquors made in conformity with federal law. I found no Colorado exception for home spirits; Colorado licensed counsel should confirm for any specific plan.

So Marcus can keep making cider, which federal law treats as wine (§ 5041(g)), within the household limit. A lawful still means a fuel alcohol plant under § 5181, with the product used only as fuel. Beverage brandy would still need federal qualification and a Colorado license after a McNutt win in 2027.

What does a licensed Colorado craft distillery owe in federal excise tax and Colorado distillery tax?

TTB’s list of permittees showed 178 Colorado distilled spirits plant permits as of November 2, 2026, tenth among the states, each registered on TTB F 5110.41 (27 C.F.R. § 19.73). Section 5001(c) cuts the $13.50 rate to $2.70 on the first 100,000 proof gallons a plant distills or processes and removes each calendar year, and $13.34 on the next 22,130,000. Those rates became permanent in December 2020 (Pub. L. 116-260, div. EE), and related companies share one allotment under § 5001(c)(2).

Illustrative example: Marcus’s friend removes 4,000 proof gallons of her own spirits in 2027. At $2.70 she owes $10,800; at the full rate it would be $54,000. Because she expects no more than $50,000 for 2027 and owed no more than that in 2026, § 5061(d)(4) and 27 C.F.R. § 19.235(c) let her file TTB F 5000.24 quarterly, and § 5551(d) excuses a bond. Under § 19.236(b), her first quarter return and payment are due April 14, 2027. At the full rate she would cross $50,000 and lose both benefits.

Colorado’s excise is 60.26 cents per liter under C.R.S. § 44-3-503, per the Legislative Council’s March 2026 issue brief. At 80 proof, 4,000 proof gallons is 5,000 gallons (about 18,927 liters), roughly $11,405 if all of it sells in Colorado. For income tax, the excise is a cost of goods, and § 263A capitalization applies unless she meets the § 448(c) gross receipts test. Late TTB returns draw § 6651 additions, with the usual reasonable cause defense. On entity choice, see our 2026 LLC, S corporation and C corporation comparison.

Why should Colorado taxpayers who never distill care about the taxing power question?

Much of the Code is not tax but machinery for collecting it. The government’s petition says the ban works by “channeling taxable conduct into locations where tax evasion is more difficult.” The respondents’ brief calls that “a federal police power in all but name.” Sonzinsky v. United States, 300 U.S. 506, 513 (1937) held that a tax does not stop being a tax because it regulates. McNutt asks how far a rule that collects nothing may go in collection’s name.

My read: if the Court adopts the Fifth Circuit’s view, expect challenges to other criminal rules justified as collection aids; Ohio’s brief says a Texas federal court has already carried McNutt into firearm rules. If it follows the Sixth Circuit, the fallout stays narrow. Recordkeeping tied to a taxed item looks safe either way; the Fifth Circuit itself distinguished rules aimed at “the very articles” taxed. For another federal excise regime, see dyed diesel relief for Colorado truckers and farmers.

Activity in Colorado Federal permit and tax Colorado license After a hypothetical McNutt win
Home beer, wine or cider for personal use No permit; tax exempt up to 100 or 200 gallons a year None within the § 44-3-106(2) exception No change
Home fuel alcohol § 5181 fuel plant permit; product used only as fuel Confirm with Colorado counsel Little practical change
Home beverage distilling Barred by § 5178(a)(1)(B); tax due on production Manufacturer’s license required; no home exception found Location ban gone; registration, permit, tax and state license remain
Licensed craft distillery Registration and permit; $2.70 or $13.50 per proof gallon Manufacturer’s license; 60.26 cents per liter No change

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I legally distill spirits at home in Colorado right now?

No. The federal location ban still applies to anyone outside the McNutt injunction, which covers the plaintiffs and Hobby Distillers Association members. Colorado’s home production exception covers beer and wine, not spirits.

Does the Fifth Circuit decision apply in Colorado?

Not as precedent. The Tenth Circuit has not ruled, and the Sixth Circuit went the other way. The Supreme Court will decide, probably before its 2027 summer recess.

If McNutt wins, can I sell spirits I make at home?

No. Selling still requires federal registration and a permit, the excise tax, and a Colorado manufacturer’s license. The case concerns only where a still may sit.

Do I owe federal excise tax on spirits I make just for myself?

Yes. The tax attaches when the spirits exist and is due immediately when made outside a qualified plant. Spirits have no personal use exemption.

Does a small Colorado distillery need a bond?

Not if it expects no more than $50,000 in federal excise tax for the year and owed no more than $50,000 the year before. Those taxpayers file quarterly and, under section 5551(d), are treated as bonded.

How North Star Law Firm Can Help

North Star Law Firm advises Colorado distillers and other producers on federal excise and income tax questions, entity selection, and penalty abatement when a return or payment slips. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

To have your distillery’s excise filing, bond status and reduced rate allotment reviewed before the 2027 returns, contact North Star Law Firm.