Beatriz lives in Steamboat Springs and is the successor trustee of an irrevocable trust her father signed in Illinois in 2009. It holds about $3.1 million, mostly a rental duplex in town and a brokerage account. Her mother gets the income for life; then the principal splits between Beatriz and her brother, each taking outright at 30. Her brother is 27 and has a gambling problem, and the trust has no spendthrift clause.
She wants to hold his share in a discretionary trust for his lifetime, rewrite trustee succession, and run the trust from Colorado. Colorado law offers ways to do that without a judge. My job, as a tax lawyer, is the federal bill that can come with each one.
Can you modify an irrevocable trust in Colorado without going to court?
Often, yes. A trustee with broad discretion over principal can decant under the Colorado Uniform Trust Decanting Act, C.R.S. §§ 15-16-901 to -930. The people whose interests are affected can sign a nonjudicial settlement agreement under C.R.S. § 15-5-111. A trust director can act if the document names one.
That last route is narrow. Under C.R.S. § 15-16-806, a director holds the powers the trust terms grant and little more; Colorado has no freestanding statutory trust protector power. If nothing works out of court, a judge can modify with all beneficiaries’ consent (§ 15-5-411), for circumstances the settlor did not anticipate (§ 15-5-412), or to meet the settlor’s tax objectives, even retroactively (§ 15-5-416).
How does Colorado trust decanting work, and does it fit this trust?
Under C.R.S. § 15-16-911, a trustee whose power to distribute principal is not limited to an ascertainable standard may pour the trust into a second trust with new terms. It cannot add beneficiaries or “reduce or eliminate a vested interest.” A trustee held to a standard such as health and support must give each beneficiary “substantially similar” interests (§ 15-16-912).
Here is the catch. If the 2009 trust gives the trustee no discretion over principal, there is no decanting power at all, and a fixed right to principal at termination is a vested interest unless someone could distribute that property elsewhere. Decanting works for Beatriz only if the instrument lets the trustee invade principal for her mother, and only if her brother’s descendants already appear in it as contingent takers.
Notice under § 15-16-907 must go out at least 63 days before the trustee acts, not the 60 days often quoted, unless everyone waives in writing. Court approval is optional under § 15-16-909, which also lets a court appoint a special fiduciary when the trustee is a beneficiary too. The tax limits in § 15-16-919(2) protect marital and charitable deductions, the annual exclusion, S corporation eligibility, and a zero inclusion ratio under 26 U.S.C. § 2642(c). None of them stops a beneficiary from making a gift.
Is a beneficiary’s consent to a Colorado nonjudicial settlement agreement a taxable gift?
It can be. When the brother signs away an outright share for a discretionary interest, he gives something up for nothing. Treas. Reg. § 25.2511-1(c)(1) taxes gratuitous transfers “regardless of the means or device employed,” and § 25.2512-8 reaches transfers for less than full value.
In Chief Counsel Advice 202352018 (released Dec. 29, 2023), beneficiaries consented to a court modification adding a tax reimbursement clause, and Chief Counsel said it “will constitute a taxable gift” by them. The memo adds that the answer is the same when “a beneficiary fails to exercise their right to object” under a notice statute. Colorado’s decanting act gives notice and a path to court, so I do not call decanting automatically gift free. A trustee acting on discretion the beneficiaries cannot veto stands on better ground, but nothing published settles it, and Rev. Proc. 2026-3, section 4.01(55), says the IRS will not ordinarily rule on the question.
There is a second trap. Because the brother’s new trust benefits his family, 26 U.S.C. § 2702 can value the interest he keeps at zero unless the gift is drafted to be incomplete.
How large could the brother’s gift be in a Steamboat Springs example?
Illustrative only. Assume Beatriz’s mother is 70 and the brother’s remainder is half of $3.1 million, or $1,550,000. At the November 2026 § 7520 rate of 6.20 percent (Rev. Rul. 2026-21), the IRS Table S remainder factor for age 70 is 0.44035, so his remainder is worth about $682,543. If he gives up roughly half, Route A (a settlement agreement he signs) produces a gift near $341,271. If § 2702 zeroes out what he keeps, the IRS could argue for $682,543.
Either way he files Form 709. A future interest gets no annual exclusion ($19,000 for 2026 under Rev. Proc. 2025-32), so § 6019 requires a return, due April 15, 2027 for a 2026 signing (§ 6075(b)). Tax is unlikely against the $15,000,000 basic exclusion for 2026, but he uses some of it. For 2027, IR-2026-133 (Nov. 5, 2026) and Rev. Proc. 2026-35 set $20,000 and $15,480,000; our Colorado 2026 year end estate and gift guide covers the exclusion in more detail.
Route B, a decanting after notice, gives the brother nothing to sign. If the trustee’s discretion supports it and her file shows a fiduciary reason, the gift case against him is weaker, subject to the notice point above.
Can changing a trust trigger income tax, GST tax, or estate tax for a beneficiary?
Under Cottage Savings Ass’n v. Commissioner, 499 U.S. 554 (1991), swapping property for something “materially different” is a realization event under 26 U.S.C. § 1001. Beneficiaries trading interests can fall inside that rule; a new trustee or a new place of administration does not. With her father dead, no grantor is left to be taxed under 26 U.S.C. §§ 671 and following, so the second trust stays a nongrantor trust unless someone receives owner powers.
The trust was never GST exempt, so its inclusion ratio under § 2642 is presumably one, meaning no allocated exemption shelters it. A lifetime trust passing to the brother’s children creates a taxable termination at his death unless the property is in his estate, which makes him the transferor under § 2652(a)(1). A testamentary general power does that through § 2041 and earns a new basis, which Rev. Rul. 2023-2 ties to estate inclusion. If he ever serves as trustee, distributions to himself should stay within Treas. Reg. § 20.2041-1(c)(2)‘s health, education, support and maintenance standard. The grandfathered trust safe harbor in Treas. Reg. § 26.2601-1(b)(4)(i)(D), applied in PLR 202518009 (2025), does not reach this trust.
Route A also raises an estate tax question. If consenting makes the brother a partial settlor of a trust that can pay him, § 2036 and § 2038 come into play. And under C.R.S. § 15-5-505(1)(b), a settlor’s creditors can reach the most that could be distributed to him. For a gambler, the portion he funded may be the portion his creditors take.
What happens when you move a trust to Colorado for administration?
Under C.R.S. § 15-5-108(5), qualified beneficiaries get at least 60 days’ notice, and a timely objection suspends the move. Governing law does not change on its own; under § 15-5-107, the law the trust designates generally controls, so Illinois law may still govern this 2009 instrument.
Under C.R.S. § 39-22-103(10), a trust “administered in this state” is a resident trust, and the Colorado Department of Revenue requires Form 105. The duplex rents are Colorado source income either way, so the trust already files as a nonresident. If it keeps $50,000 of capital gains in principal in 2026, Colorado tax at 4.40 percent is $2,200 (illustrative). Amendment 87, a graduated rate measure on the November 3, 2026 ballot, would replace the flat rate beginning in 2027 if it is certified as approved; as of November 6, 2026 the count was close and no result had been certified. Leaving Illinois needs an Illinois opinion.
| Route | Who acts, Colorado statute | Typical gift tax exposure | Income or GST issue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Settlement agreement | All materially affected parties; § 15-5-111 | High for a beneficiary whose share shrinks | Possible exchange; signer may become partial transferor |
| Decanting | Trustee after 63 days’ notice; § 15-16-911 | Lower; “failure to object” theory remains | Later taxable termination absent estate inclusion |
| Trust director | Director, if the instrument grants it; § 15-16-806 | Turns on who holds the power | Same GST planning as decanting |
| Court order | Judge; §§ 15-5-411, -412, -416 | Consent under § 15-5-411 carries the agreement risk | The order does not bind the IRS |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a Colorado trustee change an irrevocable trust without the beneficiaries’ signatures?
Sometimes. A trustee with discretion over principal can decant after at least 63 days’ notice. Without that discretion, an agreement or a court order is usually needed.
Does moving a trust to Colorado make it a Colorado taxpayer?
Yes. A trust administered in Colorado is a resident trust and files Form 105. Colorado real estate produces Colorado source income wherever the trust is run.
Will the IRS issue a private ruling approving a decanting?
Not ordinarily, if beneficial interests change. Rev. Proc. 2026-3 lists the gift question as an area where rulings will not ordinarily issue.
Do I report my consent to a trust change on a gift tax return?
If your interest shrinks and someone else’s grows, the IRS may treat your consent as a gift. Because it is a future interest, the annual exclusion usually does not apply, so Form 709 is generally required even when no tax is due.
Does Colorado tax gifts or estates when a trust is changed?
No. Colorado has no gift, estate or inheritance tax, so the transfer tax exposure is federal. Colorado’s role is fiduciary income tax and the trust law that decides validity.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm advises Colorado trustees and beneficiaries on the federal tax side of trust changes, including gift returns, GST exposure and Colorado fiduciary filings, through its trust and estate tax planning and real estate tax strategy work, and represents clients in IRS examinations when a gift return is questioned. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.
The tax analysis belongs in the file before anyone signs an agreement or mails a decanting notice. If you are a trustee or beneficiary thinking about rewriting an irrevocable trust, contact North Star Law Firm.
