Stella owns a civil engineering firm in Golden. It is an S corporation netting about $1.4 million a year, and that profit lands on her personal return. In October 2026 her wealth adviser introduced a promoter with a year end “structure”: a $95,000 fee, documents signed before December 31, and a $1.2 million deduction for 2026, with a law firm opinion letter included. Her CPA is uneasy and cannot say why in one sentence.
Here it is. If the IRS decides the structure lacks economic substance, the deduction disappears and a 20 or 40 percent penalty applies with no reasonable cause defense, opinion letter or not. For a Colorado owner, the rules come from a Tenth Circuit decision that went against the taxpayer this year.
Listen to this post
North Star Tax and Legal Briefing: Liberty Global Is Now Tenth Circuit Law: Economic Substance Risk for Colorado Tax Strategies
A five minute briefing on the economic substance doctrine after the Tenth Circuit's Liberty Global decision: why a packaged year end deduction can cost a Colorado owner the deduction plus a 20 or 40 percent penalty, and what to ask a promoter before signing.
Download the MP3 · Episode page on Podbean
Show / hide the episode transcript
A Colorado business owner gets a pitch in October. Call her Stella. She is fictional, but her problem is not. Stella owns a civil engineering firm in Golden, an S corporation netting about one point four million dollars a year. A promoter offers her a year end structure: a ninety five thousand dollar fee, documents signed before December thirty first, and a one point two million dollar deduction, with a law firm opinion letter included. Her CPA is uneasy and cannot say why in one sentence. Here is the sentence. If the I R S decides the structure has no economic substance, the deduction disappears, and a penalty of twenty or forty percent applies that no opinion letter can excuse.
The economic substance doctrine lets the I R S disregard a transaction that has no real effect apart from saving tax. Since two thousand ten, the test has been written into the tax code, and it has two parts. First, the transaction has to change your economic position in a meaningful way, setting the federal income tax savings aside. Second, you need a substantial purpose for doing it other than tax. The I R S requires both. Passing one is not enough.
Here is the distinction to hold on to. An ordinary deduction that gets disallowed is usually an argument about facts and records. An economic substance disallowance is different in kind. The I R S is saying the arrangement changed nothing except the tax bill, and harsher penalty rules follow.
For Colorado, the rules now come from the Tenth Circuit, the federal appeals court that covers the state. In April of this year, in the Liberty Global case, a divided panel ruled against the taxpayer. A four step plan had been built so that a two point four billion dollar internal gain could be offset by a dividend deduction, supporting a refund claim of close to one hundred ten million dollars. The majority held that the doctrine applies when a taxpayer uses tax code provisions mechanically to get a benefit Congress did not intend. The full court declined to rehear the case in August, and Liberty Global has until December fifteenth to ask the Supreme Court to take it. For now, the decision binds the federal courts in Colorado.
And this is not only a problem for multinationals. Years earlier, the same court threw out a loss of roughly sixty million dollars that an individual had claimed through his S corporation.
Now the other side. One judge dissented, worried about a business that uses a provision exactly as written. And the explanation prepared for Congress says the law was not meant to disturb basic choices, like financing with debt or with equity. An S election or a retirement plan contribution sits far closer to that list than a purchased deduction, though nothing is immune.
Back to Stella. Suppose she claims the one point two million dollars and the I R S disallows it. Using simplified math, that adds four hundred forty four thousand dollars of federal tax, plus fifty two thousand eight hundred dollars to Colorado, because the state return starts from federal taxable income. Then the penalty. Eighty eight thousand eight hundred dollars at twenty percent, or one hundred seventy seven thousand six hundred dollars at forty percent if the facts were not adequately disclosed on the return. Add the promoter’s fee, and the undisclosed version costs about seven hundred sixty nine thousand four hundred dollars before interest.
And the usual defense is gone. With most accuracy penalties, relying on professional advice can show reasonable cause. For this penalty, the law removes that defense. The opinion letter may help her argue for the deduction itself. It does not protect her from the penalty. And Tax Court probably offers no better rule. For a Colorado resident, it follows the Tenth Circuit.
So what do you do this week? First, make the promoter answer one question: if the tax benefit were zero, what changes in my company’s economic position? Second, ask what profit is expected before tax, and whether it is substantial next to the tax savings. Third, ask how many other people bought the same structure, and whether the fee is refundable if the deduction fails. A fee like that carries its own disclosure requirement. And if a strategy is already going on a return, know that adequate disclosure on a timely return drops the penalty from forty percent to twenty. It does not save the deduction.
That’s what we do at North Star Law Firm. The initial consultation is free, and the full written analysis with citations is at c o dash legal dot net.
What did the Tenth Circuit decide in Liberty Global, and is it final?
The economic substance doctrine lets the IRS disregard a transaction with no real effect apart from tax savings. Since 2010, 26 U.S.C. § 7701(o) says a transaction to which the doctrine is “relevant” passes only if it changes the taxpayer’s economic position in a meaningful way, apart from federal income tax effects, and the taxpayer had a substantial nontax purpose. The IRS requires both (Notice 2010-62).
Commentary from late 2025 called the Colorado case a pending appeal. In Liberty Global, Inc. v. United States, 174 F.4th 1208 (10th Cir. 2026), decided April 21, 2026, a divided panel affirmed the District of Colorado. A four step plan had created foreign earnings so that a $2.4 billion internal gain could be offset by a § 245A dividend deduction, supporting a refund claim of close to $110 million. Judge Murphy’s majority called the dispute over a separate threshold relevance test “a red herring” on these facts and held the doctrine relevant when a taxpayer uses Code provisions mechanically “to obtain a benefit not intended by Congress.” Judge Eid dissented.
The court denied rehearing en banc on August 17, 2026, with Judges Hartz, Tymkovich and Eid voting to rehear. On November 5, 2026 Justice Gorsuch extended the time to petition for certiorari from November 15 to December 15, 2026 (Application No. 26A628). No petition was docketed as of November 13, so the panel opinion binds the federal courts in Colorado.
Does the economic substance doctrine reach a Colorado business owner, or only multinationals?
It reaches owners like Stella. Sala v. United States, 613 F.3d 1249 (10th Cir. 2010) came up from the federal court in Denver, where an individual had won on a roughly $60 million loss from a currency options program run through his S corporation. The Tenth Circuit reversed for lack of objective economic substance. The statute excludes an individual’s personal transactions, but only those outside a trade or business or investment activity (§ 7701(o)(5)(B)), and a series of steps counts as one transaction (§ 7701(o)(5)(D)).
In my experience, what reaches a closely held business is the packaged product: one design sold to many buyers, each getting a deduction sized to their income. The microcaptive insurance case discussed below is one. Syndicated conservation easements are another; the IRS’s 2026 Dirty Dozen (IR-2026-30) flags inflated easement appraisals, and § 170(h)(7) now denies the deduction entirely when a partnership’s or S corporation’s easement contribution exceeds 2.5 times the owners’ relevant basis, with limited exceptions. Colorado has its own easement credit under C.R.S. § 39-22-522, with certificates from the Division of Conservation; the state credit and the federal doctrine are separate questions.
The Joint Committee on Taxation’s 2010 explanation (JCX-18-10, at 152 to 53) says the law was not meant to disturb basic choices like debt versus equity financing, a subchapter C reorganization, or a related party deal priced at arm’s length under § 482. An S election or a retirement plan contribution sits far closer to that list than a purchased deduction, though nothing is immune.
Why can’t an opinion letter stop the 40 percent economic substance penalty?
Section 6662(b)(6) imposes a 20 percent penalty on an underpayment from a transaction lacking economic substance, and § 6662(i) makes it 40 percent if the relevant facts were not adequately disclosed on the return. Under Notice 2010-62 that means Form 8275 or 8275-R, plus the Form 8886 statement under Treas. Reg. § 1.6011-4 for a reportable transaction. An amended return filed after the IRS first contacts you does not count.
Reasonable cause, often shown by relying on professional advice, is the usual defense to accuracy penalties. Section 6664(c)(2) removes it for this penalty, and § 6676(c) does the same for refund claims. An opinion letter may help on the merits but not on this penalty.
What remains is procedure: § 6751(b) requires written supervisory approval of the initial penalty determination, as the IRS manual repeats for these penalties (IRM Exhibit 4.46.4-4). The old executive signoff was reportedly dropped in 2022.
Would a Colorado taxpayer get a better rule in Tax Court under Patel?
Probably not. In Patel v. Commissioner, 165 T.C. 171 (2025), a reviewed opinion filed November 12, 2025, the Tax Court held that § 7701(o) requires a relevance determination drawn from the earlier case law, as § 7701(o)(5)(C) directs. It then found the doctrine relevant to the Patels’ microcaptive insurance arrangements, found both prongs failed, and sustained the 20 percent penalty for 2014 through 2016 and the 40 percent rate for 2014 and 2015. The Patels have appealed to the Fifth Circuit.
Under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), the Tax Court follows a court of appeals decision squarely in point when the appeal lies to that court. Golsen is itself a Tenth Circuit case, affirmed at 445 F.2d 985 (10th Cir. 1971), where life insurance loan interest was disallowed for lack of economic substance. An individual’s appeal goes to the circuit of legal residence when the petition is filed (§ 7482(b)(1)), absent a written stipulation. Stella gets the Tenth Circuit’s standard. Forum still matters for other reasons; see my post on Tax Court versus a refund suit.
The conflict is narrower than it sounds. The majority never cites Patel or expressly rejects a threshold step; relevance is met when a taxpayer pursues a benefit Congress did not intend. Patel requires a separate step but still applied the doctrine to a marketed product. For a purchased deduction, I would expect both tests to find relevance. The gap matters more for a business using a provision exactly as written, which is Judge Eid’s concern.
What would a disallowed year end strategy cost a Golden engineering firm owner?
Illustrative only, with simplified math. Stella claims the $1.2 million deduction on her 2026 return and files on April 15, 2027. The IRS generally has until April 15, 2030 to assess (§ 6501(a)). The six year rule in § 6501(e) targets omitted income, not an overstated deduction, but an undisclosed listed transaction stays open until one year after the information is furnished (§ 6501(c)(10)).
Treating the whole amount as taxed at the 37 percent top rate for 2026, which slightly overstates it, (IR-2025-103), disallowance adds $444,000 of federal tax. Colorado’s 4.40 percent tax for 2026 starts from federal taxable income (C.R.S. § 39-22-104), adding $52,800. The penalty is $88,800 at 20 percent or $177,600 at 40 percent, plus interest from April 15, 2027 under § 6601(a). With the $95,000 fee, the undisclosed version costs about $769,400 before interest. A notice of deficiency gives her 90 days to petition the Tax Court (§ 6213(a)), which tries Colorado cases in Denver; see choosing a Colorado place of trial.
What should a Colorado owner ask before signing up for a packaged tax strategy?
Make the promoter answer the statute. If the tax benefit were zero, what changes in my firm’s economic position? What profit is expected before tax, and is it substantial next to the tax savings? Section 7701(o)(2) counts profit potential only on that comparison and treats fees as expenses. Colorado savings do not help: § 7701(o)(3) treats related state tax effects like federal ones.
Then ask how many others bought it and whether it needs a Form 8886. A fee refundable if the deduction fails, or tied to the tax saved, makes it a reportable transaction with contractual protection under Treas. Reg. § 1.6011-4(b)(4). The Supreme Court framed the core question in 1935 in Gregory v. Helvering, 293 U.S. 465: what was done “apart from the tax motive.”
| Issue | Ordinary disallowed deduction | Economic substance disallowance |
|---|---|---|
| Penalty rate | 20 percent, if negligent or a substantial understatement | 20 percent of any underpayment; 40 percent if undisclosed |
| Reasonable cause | Available under § 6664(c)(1) | Barred by § 6664(c)(2) |
| Opinion letter | Can support reasonable cause | No penalty protection |
| Disclosure | Can reduce the understatement penalty under § 6662(d)(2)(B) | Avoids only the 40 percent rate |
| Forum for a Coloradan | Appeals, then Tax Court in Denver | Same, or a refund suit in the District of Colorado (Tenth Circuit law) or the Court of Federal Claims (Federal Circuit law) |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Liberty Global final?
The Tenth Circuit’s decision stands, and rehearing en banc was denied on August 17, 2026. Liberty Global has until December 15, 2026 to petition the Supreme Court.
Does Patel help a Colorado taxpayer in Tax Court?
Only where it does not conflict with the Tenth Circuit. Under Golsen, the Tax Court follows the circuit that hears the appeal, for a Colorado resident the Tenth Circuit.
Can reasonable cause excuse the economic substance penalty?
No. Section 6664(c)(2) removes that exception, so the defenses are that the transaction had substance, that the doctrine is not relevant, or that the IRS skipped a required step such as written supervisory approval.
Does disclosing the strategy on my return help?
Adequate disclosure on a timely return drops the penalty from 40 to 20 percent. It does not save the deduction.
How long does the IRS have to challenge a 2026 deduction?
Generally three years after the return is filed. An undisclosed listed transaction stays open until one year after the required information reaches the IRS.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm reviews proposed tax strategies for Colorado business owners before they sign, defends IRS audits of strategies already claimed, challenges penalties, and handles Tax Court litigation at the Denver trial session. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.
If a promoter is offering you a year end deduction, or the IRS is already asking about one, contact North Star Law Firm.
