Common Law Married in Colorado? IRS Filing Status, Joint Tax Liability and Bankruptcy

The brick, tile roofed Alamosa County Courthouse and its courtyard in Alamosa, Colorado

Nolan and June have lived together in Alamosa since 2013. There was no ceremony or license, but they bought their house in 2016 as joint tenants, she is on his health plan as his wife, they wear rings, and in 2014 they signed a lease application as husband and wife. Every April, Nolan, who runs a small well drilling business and has two children from a prior relationship at home, files as head of household. June, a school paraprofessional, files as single.

Now Nolan owes the IRS about $46,000 for 2022 and 2023, an IRS letter questions his 2023 head of household status, and they wonder whether they could file one bankruptcy case together. Under Colorado law they may already be married, and if so, the IRS treats them as married too.

Does a Colorado common law marriage change your IRS filing status?

Yes, if the marriage exists. Under Treas. Reg. § 301.7701-18(b)(1), a marriage counts for federal tax purposes if the state where it was entered into recognizes it. The IRS has applied that rule to common law marriages since Rev. Rul. 58-66, discussed in Rev. Rul. 2013-17, and IRS Publication 501 says a couple living together in a recognized common law marriage on the last day of the year is considered married.

Status is fixed at year end under 26 U.S.C. § 7703(a), and head of household status under § 2(b)(1) requires that the filer be “not married at the close of his taxable year.” The § 7703(b) exception needs the spouse out of the household for the last six months of the year, and June lives there. If they are married, his head of household returns and her single returns were wrong, and their only choices are married filing jointly or separately.

How does a Colorado court decide whether a couple is common law married?

This is Colorado law, and a contested case is a question for Colorado counsel. In In re Marriage of Hogsett & Neale, 2021 CO 1, the Colorado Supreme Court refined the test from People v. Lucero, 747 P.2d 660 (Colo. 1987): a common law marriage requires mutual agreement to enter the legal and social institution of marriage, followed by conduct manifesting that agreement. The older factors, including cohabitation, reputation and joint tax returns, still count as evidence, weighed in context. Under C.R.S. § 14-2-109.5, a common law marriage entered into on or after September 1, 2006 is valid only if both parties were at least 18 and the marriage was not otherwise prohibited.

Two newer developments matter. In In re Marriage of Lundin, 2026 COA 35 (May 7, 2026), the Court of Appeals upheld a finding of no marriage even though the couple had signed a sworn common law marriage affidavit to obtain health insurance. June’s enrollment is evidence, not proof. And House Bill 26-1218, approved May 5, 2026, recreated C.R.S. § 14-2-104(3), confirming that formal marriage requirements do not invalidate an otherwise valid common law marriage.

Their own returns cut against them: Hogsett discounted a couple’s failure to file jointly only because they could not legally marry then. I found no Tax Court or Tenth Circuit decision applying Colorado’s test to filing status. Elsewhere the Tax Court applies the state’s test; in Nicholas v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1991-393 (Utah law), it noted that the taxpayer had filed as head of household rather than claiming his partner as a spouse.

What happens when the IRS questions head of household status?

These usually begin as correspondence examinations. Form 886-H-HOH, the IRS document list, opens with a marriage test (single; divorced or legally separated, with the decree; or married with a spouse who did not live in the home during the last six months of the year), then asks for proof of a qualifying child and of paying over half the household costs.

That is the fork. If Nolan explains the household by saying June is his wife, he concedes that head of household was never available, for 2023 and every other open year. The IRS generally has three years from filing to assess under § 6501(a), longer in the cases § 6501(c) and (e) cover, and a 20 percent accuracy penalty under § 6662 can follow, subject to the reasonable cause defense in § 6664(c). Saying they are not married has to square with the deed, the insurance and anything later told a bankruptcy court.

Not Sure How the IRS Sees Your Marriage? Contact Us Now

Can common law spouses switch to a joint return, and what does that cost?

Where a spouse filed a “separate return,” § 6013(b)(2) bars a later joint return after three years from the original due date or after a notice of deficiency is petitioned in Tax Court. The Tax Court has held that a mistaken single or head of household return is not a “separate return,” so the limits did not apply in Camara v. Commissioner, 149 T.C. No. 13 (2017), and Knez v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2017-205. The Tenth Circuit has not ruled on that reading. And once a joint return is filed, Treas. Reg. § 1.6013-1(a)(1) bars switching back to separate returns after the filing deadline, extensions included.

The cost June may not see is § 6013(d)(3): liability on a joint return is “joint and several.” If she signs a joint 2023 return, she owes the whole 2023 balance. Relief under § 6015 exists only for joint filers. Subsections (b) and (c) address understatements and deficiencies and must be elected within two years after collection begins against the requesting spouse; § 6015(f) covers unpaid tax and may be requested while the § 6502 collection period is open. Our post on divorce, taxes and innocent spouse relief in Colorado covers the separation side. Today June is not liable on Nolan’s separate returns, and because Colorado divides property equitably under C.R.S. § 14-10-113 rather than as community property, the § 66 community income rules do not reach her.

A joint refund can also be offset against Nolan’s 2022 debt under § 6402, leaving June to file an injured spouse claim on Form 8379. Colorado’s 2025 income tax booklet requires the same filing status on the state and federal returns and an amended state return within 180 days after a federal adjustment is final. The same question drives the estate tax marital deduction, as our post on portability and Form 706 explains.

How do the numbers compare for an Alamosa couple filing jointly?

This illustrative example uses the 2026 figures in Rev. Proc. 2025-32. Assume Nolan has $118,000 of net business income and June earns $34,000. It ignores self-employment tax, the qualified business income deduction and child credits.

Filing as before, Nolan takes the $24,150 head of household deduction and owes about $13,548; June takes $16,100 as single and owes about $1,900, for $15,448. Jointly, $152,000 less the $32,200 deduction leaves $119,800 taxable and about $15,780 of tax, roughly $330 more. Separately, Nolan’s deduction drops to $16,100 and the pair owes about $19,030. The rate cost of filing jointly is small; the real cost is June taking on Nolan’s balance. If the IRS treats any return as a separate return, the § 6013(b) window for 2022 closed in April 2026, and the one for 2023 runs to April 15, 2027.

Can common law spouses in Colorado file a joint bankruptcy petition?

Under 11 U.S.C. § 302(a), a joint case is filed by an individual “and such individual’s spouse.” I found no D. Colo. or Tenth Circuit decision on point. In In re Cohen, No. 7-10-15616 JR (Bankr. D.N.M. Feb. 7, 2012), a New Mexico bankruptcy court started from the rule that only married couples may file jointly and looked to state law to decide who is married. In Colorado, that means Hogsett.

Marriage matters even if only Nolan files. The means test safe harbor in § 707(b)(7) combines the spouses’ current monthly income unless they are separated or living apart. In a joint case, § 522(m) applies exemptions to each debtor separately. Whether Nolan’s taxes can be discharged is covered on our discharging tax debt page. The trouble is the record: years of single and head of household returns, then schedules calling June his wife.

Issue If common law married If not married
Federal filing status Jointly or separately; no head of household while June lives there Single, or head of household if the tests are met
June’s liability for Nolan’s tax Joint and several for years she signs jointly None; a joint return without a marriage is not valid
Innocent spouse relief Available under § 6015 for joint years Not applicable
Refund offsets Joint refund can pay Nolan’s debt; June files Form 8379 June’s refund stays hers
Bankruptcy One joint case possible; June’s income counts in the means test Separate cases only

Frequently Asked Questions

Does living together for seven years make a couple common law married in Colorado?

No. The statute and decisions I reviewed set no minimum period; the question is whether the couple agreed to be married and acted on it.

Can a common law spouse file as head of household?

Not while the spouse lives in the home. Head of household requires being unmarried at year end, and the § 7703(b) exception applies only if the spouse was out of the household for the last six months.

Is my common law spouse liable for my old IRS debt?

Not for years when you filed separately. Liability is joint and several only for years you both sign a joint return.

Does the Colorado return follow the federal filing status?

Yes. Colorado requires the same status on both returns, and a final federal change generally requires an amended Colorado return within 180 days.

Can common law spouses file bankruptcy together in Colorado?

Only spouses may file jointly, and courts look to state law to decide who is married. A provable Colorado common law marriage should qualify, but past tax filings become part of the proof.

How North Star Law Firm Can Help

North Star Law Firm helps Colorado couples sort out filing status, handles correspondence examinations through its IRS audit defense practice, prepares innocent spouse relief requests, and evaluates joint and individual filings in Chapter 13 when tax debt is involved. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

If an IRS letter asks about your household and your marriage was never written down, contact North Star Law Firm.