Lucas runs a ranch-supply and feed business in Montrose. In April 2026 the buyer of his 40-acre commercial parcel at the edge of town, where he stores hay and parks trucks, walked away before closing, and Lucas kept the $150,000 earnest money. In July his lender pulled financing for his purchase of a competing feed store in Delta, and he paid that owner $60,000 to terminate their letter of intent. His bookkeeper wants to net the two.
Short answer: the $150,000 is very likely ordinary income. The $60,000 is an ordinary deduction or a capital loss depending on what he signed, and as a capital loss only $3,000 of it offsets the deposit in 2026.
Is forfeited earnest money ordinary income or capital gain for a Colorado seller?
It turns on what the property is in the seller’s hands. 26 U.S.C. § 1234A says a gain or loss on the “cancellation, lapse, expiration, or other termination” of a right or obligation “with respect to property which is (or on acquisition would be) a capital asset in the hands of the taxpayer” is taxed as if a capital asset had been sold. A 1997 amendment, Pub. L. 105-34, § 1003, extended it from personal property to all property, including real estate.
But § 1221(a)(2) says depreciable property and “real property used in his trade or business” are not capital assets. Held over a year, they are § 1231 property, which gets capital gain rates on a net sale gain but is not a capital asset. In CRI-Leslie, LLC v. Commissioner, 147 T.C. 217 (2016), aff’d, 882 F.3d 1026 (11th Cir. 2018), a Tampa hotel owner kept a $9.7 million deposit after its buyer defaulted. The hotel was § 1231 property, so § 1234A did not apply and the deposit was ordinary income. The Eleventh Circuit called the result odd but not absurd.
Investment land is the opposite case: it is a capital asset, so a kept deposit is § 1234A capital gain. I found no Tenth Circuit decision on § 1234A or forfeited deposits. A Colorado individual’s Tax Court case goes to the Tenth Circuit under § 7482(b)(1)(A), and I expect the Tax Court to follow its own CRI-Leslie opinion.
Does the liquidated damages box in a Colorado real estate contract change the tax result?
Many Colorado commercial sales use the Real Estate Commission’s Contract to Buy and Sell Real Estate (Commercial), adopted August 5, 2025 and mandatory on and after January 1, 2026. Under § 20.1.2, which applies unless the § 20.1.1 box is checked, a seller facing a buyer’s default may cancel and keep the earnest money as liquidated damages, “SELLER’S ONLY REMEDY.” Checking the § 20.1.1 “Specific Performance” box instead lets the seller keep the deposit and seek more damages, or enforce the contract.
Which box to check is a contract question for the parties and their Colorado counsel. For tax purposes, it mostly decides whether a sale happens. If the seller compels the sale, the earnest money is part of the price on a § 1231 sale. If the seller cancels and keeps the deposit under either box, nothing is sold, and the CRI-Leslie analysis governs.
What did AbbVie v. Commissioner decide, and does it still stand in 2026?
In AbbVie Inc. & Subsidiaries v. Commissioner, 164 T.C. No. 10 (June 17, 2025), AbbVie deducted a roughly $1.635 billion fee paid to Shire after its board withdrew support for their combination, and the IRS called it a § 1234A capital loss. Judge Toro read the statute as reaching only contracts under which property would actually change hands, and not promises to do work that merely relates to property. AbbVie’s co-operation agreement was mainly services, like seeking regulatory approval and recommending the deal. Neither company owned the shares, so AbbVie could never compel a purchase of Shire stock, and the withdrawn recommendation, not a failed transfer, triggered the fee.
The court did not decide whether the fee qualified under § 162 or § 165, and it agreed § 1234A can reach conditional deals between parties with “complete authority” to buy and sell. The Tax Court docket (No. 2597-23) shows an IRS notice of appeal filed September 11, 2025, and a February 9, 2026 Seventh Circuit mandate dismissing it under Rule 42(b), the voluntary dismissal rule. As of October 30, 2026, the IRS action on decision list shows nothing on AbbVie. No court of appeals has reviewed it.
Kept or Paid a Forfeited Deposit This Year? Contact Us Now
Is a break fee under a small-business letter of intent a capital loss or a tax deduction?
Many letters of intent make the price terms nonbinding but the fee clause binding. If Lucas never had an enforceable right to buy the Delta store, he looks like AbbVie, and § 1234A should not apply.
A signed asset purchase agreement is different. The Delta owner owned the assets and could commit to sell them, so that contract is a right to acquire property, and AbbVie does not help. The statute still asks whether the property would be a capital asset in the buyer’s hands. Feed inventory is excluded by § 1221(a)(1); trucks, shelving and the building would be business property under § 1221(a)(2); and purchased goodwill is a § 197 intangible that § 197(f)(7) treats as depreciable. The rule that hurts sellers in CRI-Leslie may help a buyer of operating assets, making an ordinary loss under § 165(c)(1) the stronger position.
The capital loss risk is real when the deal was for LLC interests or stock, or included land he would have held as an investment. Pilgrim’s Pride Corp. v. Commissioner, 779 F.3d 311 (5th Cir. 2015) read § 1234A as covering contractual rights to buy or sell capital assets, which a terminated stock purchase agreement fits. No court has applied this to a small asset deal.
Deal costs follow Treas. Reg. § 1.263(a)-5. Costs to facilitate buying a business are capitalized, but investigatory costs before the letter of intent generally are not, unless “inherently facilitative,” like an appraisal (§ 1.263(a)-5(e)). Its examples let capitalized costs of an abandoned deal be deducted under § 165.
How does Colorado’s flat income tax treat walk-away money?
Colorado has no separate capital gains rate. C.R.S. § 39-22-104(1.7)(c) taxes federal taxable income at 4.40 percent, subject to TABOR-triggered reductions under § 39-22-627. Legislative Council staff’s September 2026 forecast reports no TABOR refund obligation for fiscal year 2025-26, so the 2026 rate is 4.40 percent. C corporations pay 4.40 percent under C.R.S. § 39-22-301(1)(d)(I)(K).
So the character fight is federal: a capital loss trapped by § 1211 cuts Colorado tax only in the year it is deducted federally. The capital gain subtraction in C.R.S. § 39-22-518 will not help: since 2022 it is limited to Schedule F filers selling Colorado agricultural land acquired between May 9, 1994 and June 4, 2009 and held five years, capped at $100,000. A kept deposit is not gain from selling land anyway.
What does the character mismatch cost a Montrose owner in 2026?
Illustrative example (hypothetical; 32 percent federal marginal rate assumed, ignoring self-employment tax and § 199A). Lucas is a sole proprietor, and the parcel, titled to him and used in the business for years, is § 1231 property, so the $150,000 is ordinary income.
If the fee is an ordinary deduction, taxable income rises $90,000: $28,800 federal and $3,960 Colorado. If it is a § 1234A capital loss and he has no 2026 capital gains, § 1211(b) allows $3,000, taxable income rises $147,000, and he owes $47,040 federal and $6,468 Colorado, $20,748 more. The other $57,000 carries forward under § 1212(b), short-term if he held the contract right under a year, usable against future gains plus $3,000 a year: 19 more years if he has none.
The twist: had the parcel been investment land, the deposit would be § 1234A capital gain and the $60,000 loss would offset it dollar for dollar. A C corporation is boxed in further: § 1211(a) allows capital losses only against capital gains, carried back three years and forward five under § 1212(a). See LLC vs. S corporation vs. C corporation in Colorado.
| Payment | Governing authority | Character and where reported | Colorado effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seller keeps deposit on business real estate | §§ 1221(a)(2), 1231, 1234A; CRI-Leslie | Ordinary income; IRS instructions name no specific line | Taxed at 4.40 percent |
| Seller keeps deposit on investment land or a residence | § 1234A | Capital gain; Form 8949 and Schedule D | 4.40 percent; § 39-22-518 does not apply |
| Buyer forfeits deposit on property that would be a capital asset | §§ 1234A, 1211, 1212 | Capital loss; $3,000 a year against ordinary income | Saves tax only when deducted federally |
| Buyer ends a binding deal for operating assets | §§ 1221(a)(1), (a)(2), 197(f)(7), 165(c)(1) | Likely ordinary loss; untested | Full 4.40 percent benefit if ordinary |
| Buyer pays a break fee under a services-type agreement | AbbVie; §§ 162, 165 | Ordinary deduction | Full 4.40 percent benefit |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is forfeited earnest money ordinary income for a Colorado seller?
If the property was used in the seller’s business, yes, under CRI-Leslie. If it was investment land or a residence, § 1234A makes it capital gain.
Can I deduct a fee I paid to back out of buying a business?
Often, as an ordinary loss, especially under a nonbinding letter of intent or for operating assets. If you were bound to buy stock or LLC interests, § 1234A may make it a capital loss.
Did the IRS appeal the AbbVie break fee decision?
It appealed to the Seventh Circuit in September 2025, and the appeal was voluntarily dismissed, with the mandate issued February 9, 2026. No action on decision had issued as of October 30, 2026.
Does choosing liquidated damages in the Colorado contract make the deposit capital gain?
No. A kept deposit on business real estate is ordinary income under CRI-Leslie whichever box is used.
What is Colorado’s income tax rate for 2026?
4.40 percent of federal taxable income. No TABOR refund obligation arose for fiscal year 2025-26, so no temporary reduction applies.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm advises Colorado owners on real estate tax strategy, business sale tax structuring, and IRS audit defense Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.
If you kept or paid walk-away money on a property or business deal this year and want the documents read before your 2026 return is filed, contact North Star Law Firm.
