A Colorado Springs warehouse worker is two years into a Chapter 13 plan when a delivery van runs a red light on Academy Boulevard. Within months she has an injury lawyer and a real claim, but nothing in her bankruptcy case mentions it. In Colorado, that gap has long handed the defense a judicial estoppel argument strong enough to end the lawsuit.
The Supreme Court changed how that argument is decided this June, and it named the Tenth Circuit’s rule as one of the two it was correcting. Here is what the Court held, why it matters more in Colorado than in most places, and what a debtor in the District of Colorado bankruptcy court with a pending or new claim should do now.
What did the Supreme Court decide in Keathley v. Buddy Ayers Construction?
Thomas Keathley was paying creditors in full through an Arkansas Chapter 13 plan when he was hurt in a 2021 Mississippi car wreck. He told his bankruptcy lawyer he planned to sue, yet nobody amended his schedules, and he disclosed the claim only after the defendant moved for summary judgment. The lower courts applied the Fifth Circuit’s rule that an omission is inadvertent only if the debtor didn’t know the facts behind the claim or had no motive to hide it.
In Keathley v. Buddy Ayers Construction, Inc., 608 U.S. ___, No. 25-6 (June 11, 2026), Justice Jackson wrote for a unanimous Court that “courts should look to the totality of the circumstances surrounding the omission.” The old rule was “too rigid and too broad,” because almost every debtor knows the facts of his own injury and almost any omission could theoretically help him. The holding is narrow. Working from the equitable framework of New Hampshire v. Maine, 532 U.S. 742 (2001), the Court assumed without deciding that judicial estoppel applies in bankruptcy, and it left open whether bad faith is required.
Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Gorsuch, concurred to question whether the doctrine has any sound footing. Justice Sotomayor doubted that equity ever calls for estoppel while the bankruptcy case is still open, since the bankruptcy judge can sanction the debtor, modify the plan, or convert the case.
Why does Keathley hit Colorado and the Tenth Circuit so directly?
Footnote 3 of the opinion cites Eastman v. Union Pacific R.R. Co., 493 F.3d 1151, 1157 (10th Cir. 2007), as the Tenth Circuit’s version of the rejected test. Eastman’s railroad worker told the trustee he had no injury suit pending, took a no-asset Chapter 7 discharge, and was estopped. The court called his later reopening “inconsequential.”
Queen v. TA Operating, LLC, 734 F.3d 1081 (10th Cir. 2013), went further: the debtors amended only after the defendant alerted the trustee, then valued their claim at $400,000 and called it fully exempt. The Colorado case is Anderson v. Seven Falls Co., 696 F. App’x 341 (10th Cir. 2017) (unpublished), a D. Colo. suit over an ankle injury at Seven Falls in Colorado Springs, where the panel refused to adopt the Ninth Circuit’s subjective-intent approach in Ah Quin v. County of Kauai. Keathley quoted Ah Quin with approval. The two-factor screen Colorado federal courts used for nearly two decades is gone, though the three New Hampshire factors still apply.
What does a Colorado bankruptcy debtor have to disclose, and when?
The estate takes “all legal or equitable interests of the debtor in property as of the commencement of the case.” 11 U.S.C. § 541(a)(1). That includes claims nobody has filed yet. Question 33 of Schedule A/B asks for claims against third parties “whether or not you have filed a lawsuit,” and question 9 of the Statement of Financial Affairs asks about lawsuits in the past year, personal-injury cases included.
Chapter 13 adds a wrinkle. Under 11 U.S.C. § 1306(a)(1), property acquired after filing and before the case is closed, dismissed, or converted is also estate property, so an injury in year two of the plan counts. Fed. R. Bankr. P. 1007(h) is often cited here, but its 14-day supplemental schedule reaches only § 541(a)(5) items like inheritances, not a new tort claim. Keathley flagged a split on whether any continuing duty to disclose exists and didn’t resolve it.
The practical answer is amendment. Rule 1009(a) permits amending a schedule “at any time before the case is closed,” with notice to the trustee. Colorado’s L.B.R. 1009-1 adds a notice substantially in the form of L.B.F. 1009-1.1 and a certificate of service. A closed case can be reopened under 11 U.S.C. § 350(b) “to administer assets, to accord relief to the debtor, or for other cause.”
Pending Lawsuit and a Bankruptcy Case? Contact Us Now
How are federal judges applying the new standard so far?
An early example from within the circuit is Gaines v. Halliburton Energy Services, Inc., No. CIV-25-661-R (W.D. Okla. Aug. 31, 2026). The judge set the two-factor screen aside and borrowed the Eleventh Circuit’s checklist from Slater v. United States Steel Corp., which weighs things like the debtor’s sophistication, how and when the filings were corrected, and whether bankruptcy counsel was told.
The plaintiff still lost. She had sworn “no” on question 33 while actively litigating, listed a different lawsuit elsewhere in her papers, and sought reopening only after defense counsel found the bankruptcy. Keathley lets a court hear the whole story, but a sworn denial followed by a late, unfinished fix is still a bad story.
Who owns the claim, the debtor or the bankruptcy trustee?
A Chapter 7 trustee must “collect and reduce to money the property of the estate.” 11 U.S.C. § 704(a)(1). Unscheduled property is not abandoned at closing and, under § 554(d), stays in the estate, which leaves the trustee, not the debtor, holding the claim. Fed. R. Civ. P. 17(a)(3) gives the trustee a reasonable time to step in before dismissal, and Eastman’s footnote 3 said estopping a trustee who hasn’t played games is likely inappropriate, at least as far as creditors need the money.
Anderson shows the cost to the debtor. The trustee substituted in, and recovery was capped at creditor claims plus fees: a $45,662.04 judgment on a claim pleaded at over $5 million. In Chapter 13, § 1306(b) generally leaves the debtor in possession of estate property, which is why Keathley sued in his own name, and 11 U.S.C. § 1329 lets the plan be modified once money comes in.
What should a Colorado Springs debtor with a new claim during Chapter 13 do?
Back to the warehouse worker. Say she filed in March 2024 with a 60-month, $410-a-month plan projected to pay about $9,000 on $61,000 of unsecured debt. The crash leaves $27,500 in unpaid medical bills, and her lawyer expects about $140,000. After a one-third fee ($46,667), $3,000 in costs, and the providers, roughly $62,800 remains.
Colorado opted out of the federal exemptions in C.R.S. § 13-54-107, and C.R.S. § 13-54-102(1)(n) exempts personal-injury proceeds “except for obligations incurred for treatment of any kind for such injuries or collection of such damages.” If that exemption fits, disclosure may cost her little, while concealment puts all $140,000 at risk. She should tell her Chapter 13 counsel in writing, amend Schedules A/B and C with the local notice, value the claim honestly rather than the way the Queens did, and talk to the trustee before signing any settlement. Keathley told his lawyer and stopped. A filed amendment is what protects her.
| Issue | Tenth Circuit before Keathley | After Keathley |
|---|---|---|
| Inadvertence test | No knowledge or no motive (Eastman, Queen) | Totality of the circumstances |
| Ah Quin approach | Declined (Anderson) | Quoted with approval |
| Correcting after being caught | “Inconsequential” (Eastman) | A factor, but late fixes still hurt (Gaines) |
| Telling bankruptcy counsel | No excuse | One circumstance among several |
| Trustee pursuing the claim | Likely not estopped, up to creditor needs (Eastman n.3) | Unchanged |
| Case still open | No distinction | Sotomayor concurrence doubts estoppel |
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Keathley mean a Colorado debtor can no longer be judicially estopped?
No. It changed only how courts decide whether an omission was inadvertent or a mistake. A debtor who denies a known claim under oath can still lose it.
Is a personal-injury claim exempt in a Colorado bankruptcy?
Colorado debtors use the state list, and C.R.S. § 13-54-102(1)(n) covers injury proceeds except amounts owed for treatment or collection. The claim still has to be scheduled and the exemption claimed.
Do I have to disclose an injury claim that arose after I filed Chapter 13?
Under 11 U.S.C. § 1306(a)(1), it is estate property. The Supreme Court left open whether a continuing duty to disclose exists, but a prompt Rule 1009(a) amendment is the safer course and is a circumstance courts weigh.
Can I reopen a closed Colorado bankruptcy case to list a lawsuit?
Yes, under 11 U.S.C. § 350(b). Eastman gave no weight to reopening after exposure, but after Keathley the timing and reason for the fix are part of the analysis.
Does a Colorado state court use the same judicial estoppel test?
Not necessarily. Estate of Burford v. Burford, 935 P.2d 943 (Colo. 1997), lists elements including an intentional effort to mislead and proceedings involving the same parties. How a Colorado court applies that to a bankruptcy omission is a state-law question.
What happens to my lawsuit if the bankruptcy trustee steps in?
The trustee gets a reasonable time to join or substitute under Rule 17(a)(3). If the debtor is estopped, the recovery may be limited to creditor claims plus fees, as in Anderson, leaving the debtor nothing more.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm handles bankruptcy matters including amended schedules in Chapter 13 cases, reopening closed Chapter 7 cases, and coordinating with injury and employment counsel when a claim touches a bankruptcy estate. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.
If you have an open bankruptcy case and a claim that never made it onto your schedules, the order of the next steps matters. To review your filings and timeline, contact North Star Law Firm.
