Marisol owns an oilfield-services LLC in Grand Junction. After work slowed and a merchant cash advance covered payroll, the company owes about $1.9 million. The funder’s lawyer says the funding application overstated receivables, so its balance “will survive any bankruptcy.” Her question for me is narrow: if the company files under Subchapter V, does that one debt go away?
It depends on whether the plan is confirmed with creditor votes or over their objection. Three federal courts of appeals have ruled on the second situation, and so has a Colorado bankruptcy judge.
Does a Colorado LLC’s Subchapter V discharge cover a debt the creditor calls fraud?
Subchapter V, the small business track inside Chapter 11, has two discharge rules. If each impaired class accepts, the court confirms under 11 U.S.C. § 1191(a). A class accepts when creditors holding two-thirds of the dollars and more than half of the claims that vote say yes (§ 1126(c)). The discharge then comes at confirmation from § 1141(d)(1), and § 1141(d)(2) applies the § 523 exceptions only to “a debtor who is an individual.”
SBA borrowers should know the one carve-out. Section 1141(d)(6)(A) leaves a corporation, which under § 101(9)(A) includes an LLC, liable for a § 523(a)(2)(A) or (2)(B) fraud debt “owed to a domestic governmental unit,” or owed because of a False Claims Act suit. A private funder’s claim is not on that list.
If a class votes no, the debtor can still ask for confirmation under § 1191(b), a cramdown, if the plan is fair and equitable. Section 1181(c) then turns off § 1141(d), and the discharge comes from § 1192 after plan payments. Section 1192(2) excepts “any debt … of the kind specified in section 523(a),” but § 523(a) says a § 1192 discharge “does not discharge an individual debtor” from those debts. Whether an LLC is caught is the whole fight, and it only arises in a cramdown.
What have the federal appeals courts said about section 523(a) and corporate debtors?
Three circuits say the exceptions reach companies. In Cantwell-Cleary Co. v. Cleary Packaging, LLC, 36 F.4th 509 (4th Cir. 2022), an LLC owing a $4.7 million tortious interference judgment proposed to pay under 3 percent of it. The court read § 1192(2) as pointing to a kind of debt, not a kind of debtor, while conceding the statutory fit is “clumsy.”
Avion Funding, L.L.C. v. GFS Industries, L.L.C. (In re GFS Industries, L.L.C.), 99 F.4th 223 (5th Cir. 2024) is the cash advance case. Avion paid $190,000 for $299,800 of receivables after GFS said it did not anticipate a Chapter 11 filing; GFS filed two weeks later, and Avion’s § 523(a)(2)(B) claim was allowed to proceed.
In BenShot, LLC v. 2 Monkey Trading, LLC (In re 2 Monkey Trading, LLC), 142 F.4th 1323 (11th Cir. 2025), decided July 9, 2025, a jury had found the debtors acted maliciously in a false advertising case. The majority joined the other two circuits. Judge Luck dissented, noting that most bankruptcy courts had read § 523(a) as limited to individuals.
Those courts include In re Satellite Restaurants Inc. Crabcake Factory USA, 626 B.R. 871 (Bankr. D. Md. 2021) and the Ninth Circuit’s appellate panel in In re Off-Spec Solutions, LLC, 651 B.R. 862 (B.A.P. 9th Cir. 2023), which called its own result “vexing.” As of October 23, 2026, the Supreme Court’s docket shows no certiorari petition in any of the three.
Creditor Says Your Company’s Debt Survives Subchapter V? Contact Us Now
Has the Tenth Circuit or a Colorado bankruptcy court decided this?
The Tenth Circuit has not, and I found no Tenth Circuit BAP decision. But in 2021, in the Revelant Holdings case, Chief Judge Romero held that § 1192(2) reaches only individuals and denied creditors’ stipulated request for more time to sue as moot. Judge Sweeney reversed in Synergetic Oil Tools, Inc. v. Revelant Holdings LLC, No. 1:21-cv-02213-CNS (D. Colo. Mar. 28, 2023), finding the Fourth Circuit persuasive.
Then, in Marmic Fire & Safety Co. v. ETG Fire, LLC (In re ETG Fire, LLC), 670 B.R. 884 (Bankr. D. Colo. 2025), Judge McNamara refused to dismiss a competitor’s § 523(a)(6) trade secret complaint. He found Cleary and GFS “far more compelling and persuasive” than Off-Spec, and held that a company’s intent can be shown through managers and employees acting for it.
None of this binds the next Colorado judge or the Tenth Circuit, and the “individual debtor” text gives a debtor a serious appellate argument. Still, with three circuits, a Colorado district judge and the latest published Colorado bankruptcy opinion aligned, I tell owners to assume a cramdown leaves fraud-type debts open to challenge.
What does a creditor have to file to keep a fraud debt alive in a Colorado Subchapter V case?
Under § 523(c)(1), the debtor “shall be discharged” from a (2), (4) or (6) debt unless the creditor asks and the court rules. Fed. R. Bankr. P. 4007(c), restyled effective December 1, 2024, requires the complaint “within 60 days after the first date set for the §341(a) meeting of creditors.” Extensions require cause and a motion “filed before the time expires,” and Rule 9006(b)(3) allows nothing beyond that. A funder that sleeps past it generally loses the issue, and as Revelant shows, the date usually passes before anyone knows whether the plan will be consensual.
The creditor must then prove its claim by a preponderance of the evidence, Grogan v. Garner, 498 U.S. 279 (1991). Against a company, the usual theories are (2)(B), a materially false written statement about financial condition that the creditor reasonably relied on and that was made to deceive, and (6), willful and malicious injury. A receivables figure likely qualifies, because a statement about a single asset can concern financial condition, Lamar, Archer & Cofrin, LLP v. Appling, 584 U.S. 709 (2018). An oral version falls outside (2)(A) and fails (2)(B)’s writing requirement.
Does my company’s Subchapter V discharge protect me on a personal guaranty?
No. Under § 524(e), discharging the company’s debt “does not affect the liability of any other entity” on it. Cash advance agreements routinely include an owner guaranty.
If the owner files her own case, § 523(a)(2) applies to her directly in every chapter. A written statement about her LLC’s receivables is one “respecting … an insider’s financial condition,” since a company she controls is her insider under § 101(31)(A)(iv). That is how funders usually plead against owners: (2)(B), built on the application she signed. For EIDL collection and fraud referrals, see the earlier post on the SBA demand letter and Treasury offset.
How would this play out for a Grand Junction oilfield-services company in 2026?
Eligibility first. A case filed October 25, 2026 faces the $3,424,000 limit in § 101(51D), in effect since April 1, 2025 (90 Fed. Reg. 8941). H.R. 7730 would raise it to $7,500,000 for cases commenced on or after enactment; it passed the House September 16 and the Senate September 28, 2026, but as of October 23 the official record showed no signature.
Illustrative example (hypothetical facts). Marisol’s LLC owes a bank $620,000 on equipment, the SBA $430,000 on an EIDL loan, the funder a claimed $265,000, and trade creditors $555,000, about $1.87 million. It files November 2, 2026. The first date set for the creditors’ meeting is December 3, so the funder’s complaint is due February 1, 2027.
Say the funder sues on time under (2)(B). It holds about 32 percent of the unsecured dollars, so trade creditors can carry that class over its no vote. If every impaired class accepts, the plan is confirmed under § 1191(a) and the funder’s unpaid balance is discharged at confirmation. If the SBA’s class rejects instead, the plan becomes a cramdown, and a funder that proves deliberate overstatement keeps its debt past the § 1192 discharge. The other unsecured debt is still discharged after plan payments, and Marisol still owes whatever she guaranteed.
So Subchapter V usually remains the better route. Section 523(a) reaches only the debts a creditor proves, not the whole discharge, and the vote count often deserves more attention than the fraud letter.
| Question | Consensual plan, company (§ 1191(a)) | Cramdown plan, company (§ 1191(b)) | Cramdown plan, individual owner (§ 1191(b)) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Discharge section | § 1141(d)(1), at confirmation | § 1192, after plan payments | § 1192, after plan payments |
| Does § 523(a) apply? | Only the narrow § 1141(d)(6) exceptions | Split; recent rulings say yes | Yes, by its own terms |
| Who has ruled | Statute | Three circuits and ETG Fire vs. Off-Spec; no Tenth Circuit ruling | No dispute |
| What the creditor files | Government proves a § 1141(d)(6) debt | Complaint within 60 days after first date set for § 341 meeting | Same deadline |
| What the owner still owes | Any guaranty | Any guaranty | Her own surviving § 523(a) debts |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a cash advance funder block my Colorado LLC’s Subchapter V discharge?
No, only its own debt is at stake. Even under the circuit view, it must file a timely complaint and prove fraud or willful and malicious injury.
Does section 523(a) apply if my Subchapter V plan is consensual?
For a company, generally not. The discharge comes from section 1141(d), which reaches only the narrow government fraud, False Claims Act and fraudulent tax debts in section 1141(d)(6).
When must a creditor file a nondischargeability complaint in Subchapter V?
Within 60 days after the first date set for the meeting of creditors, under Rule 4007(c). The court can extend that only on a motion filed before the deadline runs.
Has the Tenth Circuit decided whether a corporate Subchapter V debtor is subject to section 523(a)?
Not as of October 23, 2026. A Colorado district judge and a Colorado bankruptcy judge have followed the Fourth Circuit.
What is the Subchapter V debt limit for a Colorado case filed in late October 2026?
It is $3,424,000 unless H.R. 7730 becomes law first. If it does, cases filed on or after enactment get $7,500,000.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm represents Colorado businesses and owners in Subchapter V reorganizations, Chapter 11 cases, and SBA loan and business debt problems, including discharge disputes. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.
The vote count and the complaint deadline both take shape early in a case. If a creditor says its debt will survive your company’s bankruptcy, contact North Star Law Firm.
