For a Colorado business owner, a notice of deficiency opens a choice that is hard to reverse. The notice points to the United States Tax Court, yet federal law offers four trial forums.
The forum decides whether the tax must be paid first, whether a jury is available, whose precedent governs, and whether fees can shift to the government. Some of those consequences lock in the day a petition is filed.
What does the 90-day clock require, and what happens when it runs out?
Under 26 U.S.C. § 6213(a), a taxpayer has 90 days after the notice is mailed to petition the Tax Court, or 150 days if it is addressed to someone outside the United States. A weekend or District of Columbia holiday on the last day rolls it forward, and a petition filed by the last date the IRS prints in the notice “shall be treated as timely filed.” The IRS cannot assess or levy while the 90 days run or a timely case is pending; without a petition, § 6213(c) lets it assess.
The Tax Court long treated a late petition as fatal. Boechler, P.C. v. Commissioner, 596 U.S. 199 (2022), held the collection due process deadline in § 6330(d)(1) “subject to equitable tolling,” but the Tax Court refused to extend that to deficiency cases in Hallmark Research Collective v. Commissioner, 159 T.C. No. 6 (2022). Four circuits have since allowed tolling of the § 6213(a) deadline, most recently the Eighth in Maniktala v. Commissioner, No. 25-1366 (Aug. 11, 2026); three others still refuse it. The Tenth Circuit has not addressed the question, though an appeal docketed in January 2026, Dugan v. Commissioner, No. 26-9002, is reported to present it. Until it is decided, a late Colorado petitioner has no binding authority to set against Hallmark. Treat day 90 as a wall.
Holding a Colorado Notice of Deficiency? Contact Us Now
Why does Tenth Circuit law control a Colorado case in the Tax Court?
The Tax Court sits nationally but follows regional precedent. Under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), aff’d, 445 F.2d 985 (10th Cir. 1971), it follows the circuit to which appeal lies when that court “has already passed upon the issue.” Because § 7482(b)(1) routes an individual’s appeal by legal residence, a Greeley or Grand Junction petitioner gets Tenth Circuit law even where other circuits disagree.
The Tax Court lists Denver as a place of trial, in the Byron Rogers Federal Building on Stout Street. Its Fall 2026 schedule shows no Denver session; the Winter 2027 schedule lists one, the week of February 8, 2027. Smaller disputes can elect small tax case procedures under § 7463 when no year exceeds $50,000, though the decision cannot be appealed. The filing fee is $60 either way.
When does paying first and suing for a refund make sense?
The refund route starts with a check. Flora v. United States, 362 U.S. 145 (1960), requires payment of “the full amount of the assessment” before suit under 28 U.S.C. § 1346(a)(1). Then come a refund claim under § 7422(a) and, usually, the six-month wait in § 6532(a)(1).
A Colorado plaintiff may sue in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado or the Court of Federal Claims, but only the district court offers a jury, available “at the request of either party” under 28 U.S.C. § 2402. That matters to a Pueblo restaurant owner whose case rests on her credibility about cash receipts. Court of Federal Claims appeals go to the Federal Circuit under 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(3), the one path around Tenth Circuit precedent.
Refund plaintiffs also face a possible government counterclaim under § 7422(e). And C.R.S. § 39-22-601(6) calls for an amended Colorado return within 30 days of a federal “final determination,” which includes “the payment of any additional tax.” Paying in full may start that state clock early, a point for Colorado-licensed counsel.
Why can’t a taxpayer try the Tax Court first and keep a refund suit in reserve?
Congress closed that door. After a timely petition, § 6512(a) provides that “no suit by the taxpayer for the recovery of any part of the tax shall be instituted in any court” for that year, subject to narrow exceptions. The Tax Court becomes the only forum for the whole year. The reverse does not hold, since skipping the Tax Court forfeits only the chance to litigate without paying. The petition is the irreversible step.
Can the bankruptcy court decide the tax for an insolvent Colorado taxpayer?
Yes. Section 505(a)(1) of the Bankruptcy Code lets the bankruptcy court “determine the amount or legality of any tax,” assessed or not. In Colorado that court sits in Denver, with appeal under 28 U.S.C. § 158 to the district court or the Tenth Circuit Bankruptcy Appellate Panel.
A filing stays Tax Court proceedings over an individual debtor’s pre-petition years under 11 U.S.C. § 362(a)(8), and § 6213(f) suspends the 90-day clock during the stay plus 60 days. But § 505(a)(2)(A) bars relitigating a tax already adjudicated before the case began. Bankruptcy is no tactic for a solvent taxpayer, but it can fold the tax fight into a reorganization.
What does each path cost in interest, deposits, and fees?
The price of the no-payment rule is interest, compounding daily. The IRS has announced a 7 percent noncorporate underpayment rate for the quarter beginning October 1, 2026, about $1,050 a month on $180,000. Under § 6603, a deposit later applied to the tax is treated as paid when deposited, stopping interest while the Tax Court stays open.
Fee recovery under § 7430 requires exhausting administrative remedies and beating a position that was not substantially justified, with fees capped at $260 an hour for 2026 under Rev. Proc. 2025-32. Sharper still is the qualified offer: a written offer made in the statutory window, which closes 30 days before the case is first set for trial, makes the taxpayer a prevailing party if the judgment comes in at or below it.
How would the choice play out for a Colorado Springs business owner?
Consider a hypothetical. Marisol runs a commercial landscaping company in Colorado Springs as a single-member LLC. After an exam of her 2023 return, the IRS mails a notice of deficiency dated Monday, October 5, 2026, proposing $180,000 of tax. Day 90 falls on Sunday, January 3, 2027, so the deadline rolls to Monday, January 4. Interest since April 15, 2024, at 6 to 8 percent, reaches roughly $36,700 by mid-November, so her exposure nears $216,700 before penalties.
In the Tax Court she pays $60, requests Denver, and likely spends 2027 in Appeals while interest adds about $1,050 monthly unless she deposits. A qualified offer at, say, $120,000 sets up fee recovery if the result lands at or below it. For a jury, she lets January 4 pass, pays about $216,700, files a claim, and waits until mid-2027 to sue in Denver unless the IRS denies it sooner. If her business is failing anyway, a Subchapter V case filed in Denver before January 4 would pause the clock and let the bankruptcy judge fix the $180,000 figure.
| Forum | Pay first? | Jury? | Appeal to | Discovery and fees |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tax Court, regular case | No; $60 fee | No | Tenth Circuit | Rule 70 discovery; § 7430 and qualified offer |
| Tax Court, S case (§ 7463) | No; $50,000 per-year cap | No | None | Informal; not precedent |
| U.S. District Court, D. Colo. | Yes (Flora) plus refund claim | Yes, on request | Tenth Circuit | Full civil discovery; § 7430; counterclaim risk |
| Court of Federal Claims | Yes, plus refund claim | No | Federal Circuit | Court’s own rules; § 7430 |
| Bankruptcy Court, D. Colo. (§ 505) | No, but requires a bankruptcy case | No | District court or BAP, then Tenth Circuit | Bankruptcy rules; case costs |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a Colorado taxpayer still go to Tax Court after missing the 90-day deadline?
Probably not. The Tax Court treats the deadline as jurisdictional, and the Tenth Circuit has not ruled otherwise, though an appeal raising the issue is pending. A taxpayer who misses the date can still pay the assessment and sue for a refund.
Does filing a Tax Court petition stop IRS collection?
Yes, for the deficiency in the notice. The IRS generally cannot assess or levy that amount during the 90 days or while a timely case is pending. Interest keeps running. A section 6603 deposit can stop the interest.
Can I get a jury trial in a federal tax case in Colorado?
Only in a refund suit in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado, where either side may request a jury under 28 U.S.C. section 2402. The Tax Court, the Court of Federal Claims, and the bankruptcy court decide tax cases without juries.
Where are Tax Court trials held in Colorado?
Denver is the only Colorado place of trial, in the Byron Rogers Federal Building on Stout Street. The Winter 2027 schedule lists a Denver session the week of February 8, 2027, and the Fall 2026 schedule has none.
What is a qualified offer in a federal tax dispute?
It is a written offer, designated as qualified, made after the first letter offering Appeals review and at least 30 days before the case is first set for trial. If the judgment is at or below it, the taxpayer can recover later costs under section 7430, subject to net worth limits.
Does a federal tax adjustment affect my Colorado income tax?
Usually. Colorado income tax starts from federal taxable income, and state law calls for an amended Colorado return within 30 days after a federal final determination, which includes a final judgment or payment of additional tax. Colorado-licensed counsel should confirm the timing.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm represents Colorado individuals and business owners in federal tax controversies, from the response to a notice of deficiency through Appeals and trial. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado, so the firm can weigh the Tax Court, refund, and bankruptcy routes side by side. That work includes Tax Court litigation, IRS appeals and collection due process hearings, and resolving tax debt in bankruptcy. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.
The date printed on a notice of deficiency governs every other decision, so bring the notice to the firm early enough to compare the forums on the merits. To get started, contact North Star Law Firm.
