A retired engineer in Boulder has two things on her kitchen table: a statement for the brokerage account she inherited, and a listing for a house in Louisville. Her daughter and son-in-law found the place, and she would rather lend them $900,000 than see them take a jumbo mortgage. Her question to me is how to write it down so the IRS sees a loan and not a $900,000 gift.
The answer is a real promissory note charging the applicable federal rate, paid the way it reads.
Listen to this post
North Star Tax and Legal Briefing: Colorado Family Loans at the AFR: Gift and Estate Tax
A Boulder parent lends her daughter $900,000 for a house. We cover the applicable federal rate, what the Galli order did and did not decide, the Maxwell forgiveness trap, and the insider preference risk if the child files bankruptcy.
Download the MP3 · Episode page on Podbean
Show / hide the episode transcript
A retired engineer in Boulder wants to lend her daughter and son-in-law nine hundred thousand dollars toward a house in Louisville, Colorado, rather than watch them sign a jumbo mortgage. Her worry is simple. If she writes the check, does the I R S see a loan, or a nine hundred thousand dollar gift? The difference matters. A gift that size eats into her lifetime exclusion and requires a gift tax return. Get the paperwork wrong, forgive the interest the wrong way, or let the note sit unpaid, and the loan quietly turns into the very gift she was trying to avoid. A recent Tax Court case shows exactly how to get it right.
Here is the rule. Back in nineteen eighty-four the Supreme Court held that an interest-free loan to a family member is a taxable gift, because the free use of money has value. Congress answered that same year with a statute on below-market loans. For a term loan, the gift equals the amount lent minus the present value of the required payments, discounted at a rate the government publishes every month, the applicable federal rate. Charge at least that rate and the gap is zero. No gift. The rate depends on the length of the loan. For October two thousand twenty-six, the annual rates are four point two five percent for three years or less, four point six one percent for over three and up to nine years, and five point two two percent beyond nine. A term loan locks in the rate for the month it is made. And that rate is enough even when no bank would match it. The Tax Court held years ago that Congress replaced market valuation with this discounting formula.
Which brings us to the Galli case. In February two thousand thirteen, Barbara Galli lent her son two point three million dollars on an unsecured note at one point zero one percent, that month’s mid-term rate, with interest due yearly and principal due within nine years. He paid the interest every year until she died in March two thousand sixteen. Her estate reported the note at one million six hundred twenty-four thousand dollars, well under face. The I R S said the whole thing had been a partial gift back in two thousand thirteen, to the tune of eight hundred sixty-nine thousand dollars. In a March two thousand twenty-five order, the judge sided with the estate. The son produced the transfer record, the signed note, his interest payments, and his mother’s returns reporting that interest. Under the statute, the transaction was not a gift at all. Now the part that cuts the other way. Some commentators read Galli as blessing a date-of-death discount on the note. It did not. The order said the estate value was not before the court, and that case later closed on a private stipulated decision. It is an order, not a published opinion. A Colorado executor claiming a discount because rates went up should expect a fight, and an appraisal bill.
For most Colorado families, the estate side is modest. The federal exclusion is fifteen million dollars for two thousand twenty-six, and Colorado has no gift tax, no inheritance tax, and an estate tax tied to a federal credit that no longer exists. What Colorado does take is income tax on the parent’s interest, at a flat four point four zero percent. The real danger is forgiveness on a schedule. In the Maxwell case, a mother forgave twenty thousand dollars of her son’s note every year, no principal was ever paid, and the Tax Court held the note worthless because nobody ever intended payment. Then there is bankruptcy. If the child files, the parent is an insider, so payments made in the year before the filing can be clawed back as preferences, against ninety days for ordinary creditors. If the parent files, forgiveness by an insolvent parent can be unwound.
So, three things this week. First, write a real note. A fixed rate at or above the applicable federal rate for the month you fund it, a maturity date, and signatures, drafted the way a bank would draft it. Second, record a deed of trust on the house. Security is optional for gift tax, but without it the kids cannot deduct the interest as home mortgage interest. Third, make the payments real. From the child’s own account, on time, and reported on the parent’s return every year, even when part of the interest is forgiven within the annual exclusion. That’s what we do at North Star Law Firm. The initial consultation is free, and the full written analysis with citations is at c o dash legal dot net.
Is a loan to my child a gift if I charge the applicable federal rate?
Not under the statute. Dickman v. Commissioner, 465 U.S. 330 (1984), held that interest-free demand loans to family members were taxable gifts of the reasonable value of the use of the money. Congress responded that year with 26 U.S.C. § 7872. For a term loan, the gift equals the amount loaned minus the present value of the required payments, discounted using the applicable federal rate, or AFR (§ 7872(b)(1), (d)(2), (e)(1)(B)). Charge at least the AFR and that difference is zero.
AFRs are set monthly under 26 U.S.C. § 1274(d): short-term for three years or less, mid-term for over three and not over nine, long-term beyond nine. For October 2026, Rev. Rul. 2026-19 puts the annual rates at 4.25, 4.61 and 5.22 percent. A term loan uses the rate in effect the day it is made (§ 7872(f)(2)(A)), so a November closing needs November’s ruling, not yet posted as I write.
Is the AFR enough when no bank would match it? Frazee v. Commissioner, 98 T.C. 554 (1992), says yes: in § 7872, “Congress displaced the traditional fair market methodology of valuation of below-market loans by substituting a discounting methodology.” Neither the $10,000 de minimis rule in § 7872(c)(2) nor the § 7872(d)(1) income cap, which stops applying once loans exceed $100,000, helps with a house-sized loan.
What did the Tax Court actually decide in Galli?
Barbara Galli lent her son $2.3 million in February 2013 on an unsecured note at 1.01 percent, that month’s mid-term AFR, with yearly interest and principal due within nine years. He paid interest each year until she died in March 2016. The estate reported the note at $1,624,000; the IRS asserted an $869,000 gift in 2013.
In a March 5, 2025 order in Estate of Galli v. Commissioner, Docket Nos. 7003-20 and 7005-20, Judge Mark V. Holmes granted the estate’s motions. The IRS offered no facts showing more than a partial gift; the son produced the transfer record, the signed note, his interest payments, and his mother’s returns reporting that interest. Under § 7872 and Frazee, “this transaction was not a gift at all.” The gift-tax docket closed April 3, 2025, with a stipulated decision of no deficiency.
On the estate value, the order says: “There is a dispute about its reported value, but that’s not the subject of this motion.” Some commentary reads Galli as approving a date-of-death discount. It did not rule on one. The estate-tax docket ended March 25, 2026, with a stipulated decision of no deficiency and no overpayment, stated as a net amount, on terms that are not public. It is an order, not a published opinion.
How is a promissory note valued for estate tax when interest rates have gone up?
The note is in the lender’s gross estate under 26 U.S.C. § 2033. Treas. Reg. § 20.2031-4 presumes its value is unpaid principal plus accrued interest “unless the executor establishes that the value is lower,” names the interest rate and maturity date as reasons, and demands “satisfactory evidence,” in practice an appraisal.
A 1.01 percent note is worth less than face once rates rise. The IRS notices led with consistency: discount the note at death and the 2013 transfer must have been a partial gift. Their alternative discounted at the AFR alone and added $544,000 to the gross estate, about $2,168,000 by my arithmetic. Even the government’s fallback sat below the $2.3 million face.
I found no Tenth Circuit decision on either point and no published Tax Court opinion resolving the consistency theory, so a Colorado executor claiming a discount should expect a fight. For most families the stakes are modest. The basic exclusion amount is $15,000,000 for 2026 under 26 U.S.C. § 2010(c)(3), indexed after 2026. Colorado adds nothing: C.R.S. § 39-23.5-103 taxes an estate only “in the amount of the federal credit” for state death taxes, and Congress phased that credit, former 26 U.S.C. § 2011, down to zero for deaths after 2004 and repealed the section in 2014. Surviving spouses should also read our post on portability and Form 706.
How should Colorado parents document an intrafamily loan at the AFR?
Copy the Galli record: a signed note with a fixed rate and maturity, a traceable transfer, and payments on time from the child’s own account, reported on the parent’s return. A promissory note is a contract under Colorado law, so draft it as a bank would.
Security is optional for gift tax but not for the borrowers’ income tax. Interest is qualified residence interest only on debt “secured by such residence” under 26 U.S.C. § 163(h)(3), with acquisition debt capped at $750,000. A recorded deed of trust on the Louisville house can make most of the interest deductible.
Colorado is not a community property state, so a loan from one spouse’s separate account is that spouse’s note and lands in that spouse’s estate. Colorado taxes the interest at the flat 4.40 percent rate in C.R.S. § 39-22-104(1.7)(c); the Legislative Council’s September 2026 forecast reports no TABOR refund obligation for fiscal 2025-26, so no temporary cut applies for 2026.
What sinks these loans is forgiveness on a schedule. In Estate of Maxwell v. Commissioner, 98 T.C. 594 (1992), a mother forgave $20,000 of her son’s mortgage note yearly, no principal was ever paid, and the court held the note worthless because nobody intended payment.
What does a $900,000 family loan for a Louisville home look like in numbers?
Illustrative example (hypothetical facts; rates as of October 16, 2026): in November 2026 the Boulder mother lends $900,000 from her separate account to her daughter and son-in-law as co-borrowers, on a nine-year, interest-only note with a November 2035 balloon, secured by the house. Nine years is mid-term. Using October’s 4.61 percent in place of November’s unpublished rate, interest runs $41,490 a year and the gift at signing is zero.
Say she forgives $38,000 of each year’s interest and the couple pays $3,490. That is $19,000 to each co-borrower, the 2026 annual exclusion under 26 U.S.C. § 2503(b) and Rev. Proc. 2025-32, so 26 U.S.C. § 6019 requires no gift tax return. I would still have her report all $41,490 (about $1,826 of Colorado tax), since a planned forgiveness lets the IRS treat the interest as never payable and impute it under § 7872(a). Now she dies in November 2031 with four payments left and comparable rates at 7 percent; at that rate the remaining payments are worth about $827,000, roughly $73,000 under face. Claiming it takes an appraisal, and below $15,000,000 it changes no federal tax.
What happens to a family loan in a Colorado bankruptcy?
If the parent files, the note is estate property under 11 U.S.C. § 541(a)(1), and forgiveness by an insolvent parent within two years can be avoided under 11 U.S.C. § 548(a)(1)(B). Through 11 U.S.C. § 544(b) the trustee can also use the four-year reach of C.R.S. § 38-8-105 and C.R.S. § 38-8-110. If the child files, the parent is a relative and so an insider under 11 U.S.C. § 101(31)(A)(i), and payments within one year before the petition face preference recovery under 11 U.S.C. § 547(b)(4)(B), against 90 days for other creditors. See also our post on Kittrell and children’s trusts.
| How the parent helps | Gift at signing | Parent’s income tax | Value in parent’s estate | Bankruptcy exposure |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Outright gift | Taxable above the annual exclusion, using lifetime exclusion | None | Out of the estate | Avoidable if the parent was insolvent |
| Interest-free term loan | Present-value gap under § 7872(b)(1) | Imputed interest under § 7872 | Face presumed | Note is an estate asset; insider payments reachable for one year |
| AFR loan, paid as written | None | Interest taxed federally and at 4.40% in Colorado | Face presumed; discount needs an appraisal | Same as above |
| AFR loan with scheduled forgiveness | Each forgiven amount is a gift | Report the full interest | Note may be attacked as no real debt | Forgiveness can be an avoidable transfer |
Frequently Asked Questions
What interest rate do I have to charge on a loan to my child in Colorado?
At least the AFR for the note’s term in the month the loan is made. For October 2026, Rev. Rul. 2026-19 sets 4.25 percent short-term, 4.61 percent mid-term and 5.22 percent long-term.
Did Galli decide that a family note can be discounted in the lender’s estate?
No. The order said the reported estate value was not before the court, and the estate-tax case closed by stipulated decision on March 25, 2026.
Does Colorado have a gift or estate tax on family loans?
No. Colorado’s estate tax depends on a federal credit that no longer exists, and Colorado has no gift or inheritance tax. It does tax the parent’s interest at 4.40 percent for 2026.
Can I forgive the interest each year as a gift?
Forgiveness within the $19,000 per-person exclusion for 2026 is not a taxable gift. A fixed yearly pattern invites the argument from Maxwell that the note was never meant to be paid.
What happens to the note if my child files bankruptcy?
The parent is an insider, so payments within one year before filing can be recovered as preferences. Other creditors face a 90-day window.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm advises Colorado families on trust and estate tax planning and real estate tax strategy, handles gift and estate tax disputes in Tax Court litigation, and defends preference and clawback claims. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.
If you are lending a child money for a house, or an estate you manage holds a family note, contact North Star Law Firm.
