Author: Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA

  • Substantial Presence Test in Colorado: When Resort Workers and Vacation Homeowners Become U.S. Tax Residents

    Substantial Presence Test in Colorado: When Resort Workers and Vacation Homeowners Become U.S. Tax Residents

    Each winter the ski towns from Breckenridge to Vail fill with workers on foreign passports, and each summer foreign families open their houses in Aspen, Telluride, and Steamboat Springs. Few of them think of themselves as U.S. taxpayers. The tax code doesn’t care how they feel about home. It counts days, and a Colorado season that runs a little long can make a foreign national a resident alien.

    So when does the substantial presence test reach a Colorado resort worker or vacation homeowner, and what follows federally and under Colorado’s separate residency rule? That’s the question here.

    How does federal law decide whether a foreign national in Colorado is a U.S. tax resident?

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 7701(b)(1)(A), an alien is a resident for a calendar year only if he or she held a green card at any point that year, met the substantial presence test, or made the first-year election. Green card status lasts until revoked or officially found abandoned, so a cardholder who moved home to Monterrey years ago without surrendering it is still, on paper, a tax resident.

    The day-count test is pure arithmetic: at least 31 days this year, and current-year days plus one-third of last year’s plus one-sixth of the year before must equal or exceed 183. Any part of a day counts. Excluded are a regular commuter’s days crossing in from Canada or Mexico, layovers under 24 hours between two foreign points, and days a person can’t leave because of a medical condition that arose here. Treas. Reg. § 301.7701(b)-3(c) limits that last one: once travel is possible, days beyond a reasonable period to arrange departure count again.

    Why can a Colorado H-2B resort worker become a resident alien when a J-1 worker usually doesn’t?

    Days spent as an “exempt individual” are ignored, and § 7701(b)(5) includes teachers and trainees in J or Q status and students in F, M, J, or Q status who substantially comply with their visas. The State Department’s Summer Work Travel program lets post-secondary students enrolled abroad do up to four months of seasonal work during their summer break, which for Southern Hemisphere universities falls in Colorado’s ski season. The exemption runs out (teachers and trainees after two of the prior six years, students generally after five years) and must be claimed on Form 8843.

    H-2B workers come under 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(15)(H)(ii)(b) to perform “other temporary service or labor,” and that category isn’t on the exempt list. Every day counts. Say a worker arrives November 15, 2024, and works each winter through April 15: 47 days in 2024, then 152 days a year. For 2025 the total is 152 plus about 15.7, roughly 167.7, which falls short. For 2026 it’s 152 plus about 50.7 plus about 7.8, or 210.5. The worker never spent more than 152 days in a single year and is still a resident alien for 2026.

    How does the weighted-day math work for a foreign owner of a Colorado vacation home?

    Take a Mexico City homeowner with a Telluride house who spends 132 days in the U.S. in 2024, 132 in 2025, and 117 in 2026. Her 2026 total is 117 plus 44 plus 22, exactly 183, and the statute says “equals or exceeds,” so she’s in. One day fewer in 2026 gives 182, and she’s out.

    Because she was here fewer than 183 days in 2026, § 7701(b)(3)(B) still lets her be treated as a nonresident if she keeps a foreign tax home and a closer connection to that country. Treas. Reg. § 301.7701(b)-2(d) weighs where her home, family, belongings, and banking are, where she votes and drives, and whether she signs Forms W-8 or W-9. The exception is closed to anyone who has applied or taken steps toward a green card. She claims it on Form 8840, and under Treas. Reg. § 301.7701(b)-8(d) a late form forfeits it.

    Can a tax treaty override the day count, and what does it leave behind?

    When both countries claim a person as a resident, Article 4(3) of the 2016 U.S. Model Income Tax Convention breaks the tie by looking at permanent home, then center of vital interests, habitual abode, nationality, and finally mutual agreement. Actual treaties vary. A Colorado house kept available year-round can count as a U.S. permanent home, which pushes the analysis to vital interests.

    Under Treas. Reg. § 301.7701(b)-7, a treaty nonresident files Form 1040-NR with Form 8833 but generally stays a U.S. resident for other Code purposes. The Form 8938 instructions excuse that form for the 1040-NR period, but the FBAR rule borrows the § 7701(b) definition without mentioning treaties. For green card holders, a treaty claim plus notice to the IRS ends permanent resident status under § 7701(b)(6), and 26 U.S.C. § 877(e) treats a cardholder of 8 of the last 15 years who loses that status like a citizen who gave up citizenship.

    What does resident alien status trigger on the federal return, and what if filings were missed?

    A resident alien reports worldwide income on Form 1040; a nonresident generally reports U.S.-source and business-connected income on Form 1040-NR. The arrival or departure year is often dual-status, with no standard deduction and generally no joint return. Residency also triggers the FBAR under 31 U.S.C. § 5314, since 31 C.F.R. § 1010.350 defines a U.S. person to include a § 7701(b) resident. An H-2B worker whose home-country accounts top $10,000 at any point is likely covered, and 26 U.S.C. § 6038D adds Form 8938 above a $50,000 statutory floor, with a $10,000 penalty for not filing.

    Timing matters right now. The IRS FBAR page gives an automatic extension to October 15, so the 2025 FBAR is due October 15, 2026 (see the firm’s post on FBAR late-filing options). Someone who learns this fall that last year’s 183-day line was crossed has returns, an FBAR, and possibly a lost Form 8840 position to deal with.

    Behind on an FBAR or Form 8840? Contact Us Now

    Does Colorado use the same residency test for state income tax?

    No. Under C.R.S. § 39-22-103(8), a Colorado resident is someone domiciled here, or someone with a permanent place of abode in Colorado who spends more than six months of the tax year in the state. Visas, weighted days, and treaties play no part. An H-2B worker who is a federal resident but keeps a foreign domicile and spends five months in a Summit County rental may be a Colorado nonresident. The Colorado Department of Revenue still taxes wages for work physically done here, apportioned on Form 104PN. Flip it around, and a homeowner who wins a treaty tie-breaker but spends more than six months in her Aspen house could fit the state definition.

    A sale ties the tracks together. C.R.S. § 39-22-604.5 requires withholding of the lesser of 2% of the price or the net proceeds when a seller with a last-known address outside Colorado sells for more than $100,000, unless an affirmation applies. Federal withholding under 26 U.S.C. § 1445 (15%) reaches only a “foreign person,” so an owner who crossed the 183-day line can escape federal withholding and still face Colorado’s address-based rule.

    Rule Core test Federal result and forms
    Green card test Lawful permanent resident status on any day of the year Resident; Form 1040 on worldwide income, FBAR and Form 8938 if thresholds met
    Substantial presence test 31 days this year and 183 weighted days (1, 1/3, 1/6) Resident; Form 1040, FBAR, Form 8938; Form 8843 for exempt J-1 days
    Closer connection exception Under 183 days this year, foreign tax home, stronger foreign ties, no green card steps Nonresident; Form 8840, with Form 1040-NR if U.S. income
    Treaty tie-breaker Permanent home, vital interests, habitual abode, nationality Nonresident for income tax; Form 1040-NR with Form 8833; FBAR not clearly excused

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Does a J-1 Summer Work Travel participant in Colorado have to file anything with the IRS?

    Yes, if the participant wants those days left out of the count. Form 8843 explains the basis for the exclusion, and it goes with Form 1040-NR when the participant’s U.S. wages require a return.

    Do partial days in Colorado count toward the 183-day total?

    They do. A person is treated as present on any day he or she is physically in the United States at any time during that day. The main carve-out is a stop of under 24 hours while traveling between two foreign points.

    Can an H-2B resort worker use the closer connection exception?

    Only with fewer than 183 days this year, a foreign tax home all year, closer ties to that country, and a timely Form 8840. Tax home means the principal place of business, which is hard to place abroad when the main job is at a Colorado resort.

    Does owning a vacation home in Aspen or Telluride make someone a U.S. tax resident?

    Not by itself, because the substantial presence test counts days, not deeds. The house still matters in the closer connection analysis and can count as a permanent home under a treaty tie-breaker.

    If I am a resident alien for federal tax, am I automatically a Colorado resident?

    No. Colorado looks at domicile, or a permanent place of abode plus more than six months in the state. A federal resident alien can be a Colorado nonresident who still owes Colorado tax on wages earned here.

    What happens if Form 8840 is filed late?

    The person loses the closer connection exception and counts every day of presence. The regulation forgives the lapse only on clear and convincing evidence of reasonable efforts to learn the rule and significant affirmative steps to comply.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm helps foreign nationals and international owners of Colorado property with residency questions, late nonresident and dual-status returns, catch-up FBARs, and IRS disputes that grow out of a residency mistake. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Related services include unfiled tax returns, Colorado state tax, and exit tax and expatriation. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If you’ve been counting ski seasons and aren’t sure which side of 183 you landed on, it helps to sort that out before the October deadlines. To talk it through, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Colorado LLC Distributions in Bankruptcy: How a Trustee Recovers What Members Took After Weinstein

    Colorado LLC Distributions in Bankruptcy: How a Trustee Recovers What Members Took After Weinstein

    A creditor chasing a judgment against a Colorado LLC often learns two things at once: the company is empty, and its members took money out while the bills went unpaid. Colorado’s LLC statute makes a member repay money pulled out of a company that couldn’t afford it, if the member knew, but the Colorado Supreme Court held in 2013 that only the LLC can enforce it.

    Bankruptcy changes the analysis. Once the LLC is a debtor, whether the members file or a creditor forces the case, the question becomes what a trustee can recover. This post answers that for a Colorado LLC bankruptcy, with a Fort Collins example.

    What did Weinstein v. Colborne Foodbotics decide about Colorado LLC creditors?

    Colborne held an arbitration award of roughly $225,000 against a Boulder LLC that couldn’t pay. It sued the members and managers personally and lost on both theories in Weinstein v. Colborne Foodbotics, LLC, 2013 CO 33, 302 P.3d 263 (Colo. 2013).

    Under C.R.S. § 7-80-606(1), an LLC can’t make a distribution that leaves its liabilities above the fair value of its assets. Subsection (2) makes a member who knew of the violation “liable to the limited liability company for the amount of the distribution.” The court held that “absent express statutory authority, an LLC’s creditor may not assert a claim against the members of the LLC for unlawful distribution,” and it declined to carry the corporate rule on duties to creditors over to LLC managers. Subsection (3) adds a three-year cutoff.

    Why does a Colorado LLC bankruptcy put the distribution claim back in play?

    Weinstein decided who owns the claim, and the answer was the company. When the company files, 11 U.S.C. § 541(a)(1) pulls “all legal or equitable interests of the debtor in property” into the estate, including its claims against its own members. With the estate’s representative as plaintiff, standing stops being the problem.

    In Chapter 7 that’s an independent trustee charged by 11 U.S.C. § 704(a)(1) to “collect and reduce to money the property of the estate.” And if the three-year period was still open at filing, 11 U.S.C. § 108(a) gives the trustee until the later of its end or two years after the order for relief.

    Which bankruptcy avoidance claims reach distributions to Colorado LLC members?

    The LLC statute requires proof the member knew. Constructive fraud doesn’t. Under 11 U.S.C. § 548(a)(1)(B), a trustee can avoid a transfer made within two years before the petition if the debtor received less than reasonably equivalent value while insolvent or thinly capitalized. An equity draw gives the company nothing back.

    Separately, 11 U.S.C. § 544(b)(1) lets the trustee use state law available to an actual unsecured creditor. In Colorado that means the Colorado Voidable Transactions Act, the name S.B. 25-133 gave the old fraudulent transfer act effective August 6, 2025, for claims filed after that date. C.R.S. § 38-8-106(1) covers transfers without reasonably equivalent value by an insolvent debtor, and § 38-8-110 allows four years. The 2025 bill also stretched the insider preference claim in § 38-8-106(2) from one year to four.

    Preference law under 11 U.S.C. § 547(b) needs a payment on an antecedent debt, so it fits member loan repayments, not equity draws, and reaches back one year for insiders. Once a transfer is avoided, 11 U.S.C. § 550(a)(1) lets the trustee recover from the initial transferee or the party benefited.

    In Lewis v. Takacs (In re Stone Pine Investment Banking, LLC), No. 21-1423 (10th Cir. Dec. 19, 2023) (unpublished), the Tenth Circuit affirmed a Colorado LLC trustee’s judgment against the owners, manager, and a member-controlled entity under § 544(b) and the Colorado act, and allowed equitable tolling after evidence that insiders delayed filing because “the four year clock has run on several transactions.”

    How would a trustee plead $400,000 in distributions from a Fort Collins LLC?

    Picture a Fort Collins mechanical subcontractor run by its two members. After losing its biggest customer in early 2025, it paid $320,000 in owner draws between April 2025 and February 2026, $160,000 to each member, plus $80,000 repaying one member’s 2024 loan. It filed Chapter 7 on March 16, 2026. At the first draw its books showed about $1.15 million in liabilities against assets worth roughly $760,000, and a steel supplier had gone unpaid since January 2025.

    Count one is the company’s own § 7-80-606 claim for the $320,000, with the bank’s covenant default letters as proof of knowledge. Count two seeks the same draws under § 548(a)(1)(B), where knowledge drops out and the case becomes a valuation fight. Count three uses § 544(b), with the steel supplier as the creditor whose claim predates every transfer, to plead § 38-8-106(1) against the draws and § 38-8-106(2) against the loan repayment. Count four pleads that repayment as an insider preference.

    The loan repayment stays out of the fraud counts because § 548(d)(2)(A) treats satisfying a debt as value. Under 11 U.S.C. § 550(d) the trustee gets one satisfaction, so exposure is $160,000 for one member and $240,000 for the other. A voluntary petition is the order for relief, so 11 U.S.C. § 546(a) generally gives the trustee until March 2028 to sue. Because it’s a subcontractor, the members may also face Colorado’s contractor trust fund rules.

    If some draws were tax distributions paid directly to the IRS, United States v. Miller, 604 U.S. ___, No. 23-824 (2025), reversing the Tenth Circuit, holds that sovereign immunity still bars a § 544(b) claim against the United States that rests on state law. The trustee would turn to § 548, or to the members as the parties the payments benefited.

    Does it matter whether the LLC files Chapter 7, Subchapter V, or Chapter 11?

    Yes. In Chapter 7 an outside trustee controls the claims. In Subchapter V, 11 U.S.C. § 1184 gives the debtor in possession a trustee’s powers, so the company the members run decides whether to sue them.

    Under 11 U.S.C. § 1191(a), confirmation requires the 11 U.S.C. § 1129(a)(7) test, so a dissenting creditor must get at least Chapter 7 value, and that value includes what a trustee would recover from the members. A party can ask the court under 11 U.S.C. § 1183(b)(2) to have the Subchapter V trustee investigate, and 11 U.S.C. § 1185(a) removes the debtor in possession for cause, such as fraud or gross mismanagement. Chapter 11 is similar under 11 U.S.C. § 1107(a), with 11 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1) permitting a trustee for cause.

    Can a creditor force a Colorado LLC into bankruptcy to reach those distributions?

    Often. Under 11 U.S.C. § 303(b)(1), three or more creditors with noncontingent, undisputed claims totaling at least $21,050 (as adjusted April 1, 2025) can file. If the company has fewer than 12 qualifying creditors, § 303(b)(2) lets one creditor file, and insiders and recipients of voidable transfers aren’t counted, so the members who took the money don’t count.

    A dismissal other than by consent can bring costs and fees under § 303(i), plus damages for bad faith. Check what the members can actually pay first.

    What can a member do after receiving a trustee demand letter?

    Treat it as an opening position. Insolvency is usually the best ground, because a careful valuation at each distribution date can defeat every count that depends on it. Draws that paid for real work may support a value argument, and a loan repayment may fit the ordinary course or new value defenses in § 547(c)(2) and (c)(4).

    Got a Trustee Demand Letter, or a Debtor LLC That Went Dark? Contact Us Now

    Theory Who brings it Reach-back Knowledge needed? Fort Collins example
    C.R.S. § 7-80-606 The LLC, so in bankruptcy the trustee or debtor in possession Three years, extended by § 108(a) Yes $320,000 in draws
    11 U.S.C. § 548(a)(1)(B) Trustee or debtor in possession Two years No $320,000 in draws
    § 544(b) with C.R.S. § 38-8-106(1) Trustee, through an actual creditor Four years No $320,000 in draws
    § 544(b) with C.R.S. § 38-8-106(2) Trustee, through an actual creditor Four years Reasonable cause to believe insolvency $80,000 loan repayment
    11 U.S.C. § 547(b) Trustee or debtor in possession One year for insiders No $80,000 loan repayment

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can a creditor sue Colorado LLC members directly for an unlawful distribution?

    Not under the LLC statute. Weinstein v. Colborne Foodbotics, LLC held that § 7-80-606(2) liability runs only to the company. In bankruptcy the trustee or debtor in possession can pursue it.

    Does a bankruptcy trustee have to prove the members knew the LLC was insolvent?

    Only for the claim under the LLC statute. Constructive fraud claims under 11 U.S.C. § 548(a)(1)(B) and the Colorado Voidable Transactions Act turn on value and the company’s finances, not what the member knew.

    How far back can a trustee reach to recover distributions from a Colorado LLC?

    Section 548 reaches two years before the petition, and the Colorado act, used through § 544(b), generally reaches four. Insider preferences under § 547 reach one year.

    Is repaying a member’s loan to the LLC treated like a distribution?

    Usually not. Repaying a real debt counts as value, so trustees attack loan repayments under the insider preference rules in 11 U.S.C. § 547(b) and C.R.S. § 38-8-106(2).

    Can one creditor put a Colorado LLC into involuntary bankruptcy?

    Sometimes. If the company has fewer than 12 qualifying creditors, one creditor holding at least $21,050 in undisputed, noncontingent claims can file under 11 U.S.C. § 303(b)(2).

    What changes if the LLC files Subchapter V instead of Chapter 7?

    In Subchapter V the debtor in possession holds the claims against the members, so the members’ own company decides whether to sue them. Creditors can push back at confirmation or seek removal of the debtor in possession for cause.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents members facing trustee demands and creditors trying to reach money that left a failing company, in Chapter 7 and Subchapter V cases and in preference and clawback defense. Phillip Zagotti, an attorney and CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If you took distributions from a Colorado LLC now in bankruptcy, or one that owes you money has gone quiet, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Bitcoin Hard Fork Income Tax in Colorado: What Rogovy v. Commissioner Means for Forked Coins

    Bitcoin Hard Fork Income Tax in Colorado: What Rogovy v. Commissioner Means for Forked Coins

    Many Colorado bitcoin holders woke up on August 1, 2017 owning a second coin they never asked for. Whether that Bitcoin Cash, and the forked tokens that came after it, counted as taxable income is now before the U.S. Tax Court in Rogovy v. Commissioner, a hard fork income tax case that has been tried and fully briefed.

    This post covers how federal law treats a Bitcoin hard fork, what “dominion and control” means when an exchange never supported the new chain, and how the answer lands on a Colorado return. It also runs the numbers for a Boulder holder.

    Where does Rogovy v. Commissioner stand in the Tax Court?

    Benjamin Rogovy and Carol Castellon Miranda petitioned in November 2024, Rogovy v. Commissioner, Docket No. 17513-24. The notice determined about $23.6 million of tax for 2017 and $967,000 for 2018, with penalties at 20 percent of each. A small Colorado footnote: the petition says the notice came from the IRS Small Business/Self-Employed division at a Denver address, though the couple are Nevada residents.

    According to Judge Ronald L. Buch’s March 18, 2026 order, nine forks touched the couple’s holdings in 2017 and 2018. They claimed roughly 318 Bitcoin Cash and never acted on the other eight forks. The couple’s motion for partial summary judgment failed because the parties disputed realization and whether claiming the coins, or even knowing about them, was within the couple’s reach. Trial was held in Seattle in April 2026. The last brief went in on September 25, 2026, and no opinion has issued.

    When does the IRS say forked coins become income?

    26 U.S.C. § 61(a) reaches “all income from whatever source derived.” Commissioner v. Glenshaw Glass Co., 348 U.S. 426, 431 (1955), read that to cover “undeniable accessions to wealth, clearly realized, and over which the taxpayers have complete dominion.” The Rogovy summary judgment fight centered on the last two.

    Rev. Rul. 2019-24, 2019-44 I.R.B. 1004, says a fork with no new units reaching the holder is not income. An airdrop after a fork is ordinary income at fair market value when it is recorded on the ledger, if the holder has dominion and control then. The IRS later applied that to the Bitcoin Cash fork in CCA 202114020: a holder with private keys had 2017 income on the fork date, while a hypothetical customer whose exchange added Bitcoin Cash on January 1, 2018 had 2018 income. The memo is not precedent, but it shows the IRS position plainly.

    What does “dominion and control” mean if your exchange never supported the fork?

    The ruling is direct here. A taxpayer “does not have dominion and control” when coins are airdropped to an exchange-managed wallet and the exchange “does not support the newly-created cryptocurrency,” so nothing is credited. If the taxpayer later becomes able to sell or move the coins, receipt happens then, at that later value. A Colorado customer whose exchange never supported a fork has no income from it on the IRS’s own terms. The CCA notes Coinbase began supporting Bitcoin Cash on December 19, 2017.

    Self-custody is the hard case. Treas. Reg. § 1.451-2(a) treats income as received once it is “credited to his account, set apart for him, or otherwise made available,” but not when control is “subject to substantial limitations or restrictions.” A cold-wallet holder has keys on both chains, but claiming forked coins takes technical work that can expose the original bitcoin. Whether that is a substantial limitation is a fact question.

    How does a hard fork flow onto a Colorado income tax return?

    C.R.S. § 39-22-104 taxes individuals on “federal taxable income, as determined pursuant to section 63 of the internal revenue code,” with listed modifications. Whatever the IRS includes, Colorado taxes at its flat rate: 4.4% for 2025 and 2026 per the Department of Revenue, and 4.63% back in 2017 and 2018. Once a federal change is final, C.R.S. § 39-22-601(6)(a) requires an amended Colorado return within thirty days.

    Colorado also accepts crypto. Its cryptocurrency payment page lets individuals pay through the PayPal Cryptocurrencies Hub for $1.00 plus 1.83 percent. That payment is a sale. Under 26 U.S.C. § 1001, gain is the amount realized over basis, so paying a Colorado balance with low-basis forked coins creates new gain that comes back on next year’s federal and Colorado returns.

    What does the math look like for a Boulder holder of 10 bitcoin in August 2017?

    Say a Boulder resident kept 10 bitcoin on a hardware wallet when Bitcoin Cash split off, giving her 10 Bitcoin Cash. Early prices varied by venue, so value can be its own dispute. Assume she can document $400 a coin. On the IRS view that is $4,000 of 2017 ordinary income: $1,000 of federal tax in the 25 percent bracket that applied in 2017, and about $185 at Colorado’s 4.63 percent.

    Her basis is the $4,000 she included, so a later sale for $5,000 yields a $1,000 long-term gain. If she never reported the coins, though, the IRS virtual currency FAQs tie basis to “the amount you included in income,” which invites an argument for zero basis.

    Can the IRS still reach 2017? Usually not. 26 U.S.C. § 6501(a) gives three years from filing, which ran in 2021 for an April 2018 return. Section 6501(e) allows six years only if omitted gross income exceeds 25 percent of what was reported; $4,000 against $150,000 is far short. Even six years ended in 2024. No return, fraud, or a signed extension under § 6501(c)(4) changes that. For most holders, basis and later years are the live issues.

    What should a Colorado taxpayer do with a notice of deficiency over forked coins?

    26 U.S.C. § 6213(a) gives 90 days from mailing to petition the Tax Court. The firm’s post on notices of deficiency and forum choice in Colorado walks through the alternatives.

    Then look hard at penalties. Section 6662 imposes 20 percent for a substantial understatement, meaning the greater of 10 percent of the correct tax or $5,000, so the Boulder example falls under the line. Section 6664(c)(1) excuses the penalty for reasonable cause and good faith, a serious argument for 2017 and 2018 returns filed before Rev. Rul. 2019-24 existed. And § 6751(b)(1) bars assessment unless the initial determination was “personally approved (in writing)” by the examiner’s immediate supervisor or a designated higher official.

    Holding an IRS Notice Over Forked Coins? Contact Us Now

    Why does the Tenth Circuit matter to a Colorado Tax Court petitioner?

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1)(A), an individual appeals to the circuit of legal residence when the petition was filed, which for Coloradans is the Tenth Circuit. Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), has the Tax Court follow that circuit’s precedent when squarely on point. Searches for this post found no Tenth Circuit opinion on whether a fork or airdrop is income. The nearest thread is indirect: the Rogovy order cited Harrington, a Tax Court memorandum opinion, on substantial barriers, and the Tenth Circuit affirmed it in an unpublished 2022 order on fraud grounds, never reaching constructive receipt.

    A Colorado petitioner therefore faces the Tax Court’s own view, which Rogovy will shape. Any appeal there goes to the Ninth Circuit, whose ruling would not bind the Tenth.

    Situation When the IRS says income arises Basis in the new coins Colorado effect
    Fork, no new units reach the holder No income None Nothing flows through
    Self-custody wallet at the fork Value when recorded on the ledger, if dominion and control exists (the Rogovy issue) Amount included in income Taxed that year at that year’s flat rate
    Exchange adds support later Value when credited and usable Amount included in income Taxed in the year of the credit
    Exchange never supports the fork No receipt Not applicable Nothing flows through
    Forked coins sold through PayPal to pay Colorado tax Gain or loss under § 1001 Sets the size of the gain Gain returns on next year’s return

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Do I owe tax on Bitcoin Cash I never claimed?

    Under Rev. Rul. 2019-24 it turns on dominion and control, not on whether you clicked anything. If your exchange never credited the coins, the ruling says there was no receipt. Self-custody holders are the contested group in Rogovy.

    Has the Tax Court decided Rogovy v. Commissioner?

    Not as of late September 2026. It was tried in April, the final brief was filed September 25, and the March order denied summary judgment without reaching the merits.

    Does Colorado tax forked coins differently than the IRS?

    No. Colorado starts from federal taxable income, so whatever the IRS includes lands in the Colorado base at that year’s flat rate. After a final federal change, an amended Colorado return is due within thirty days.

    Can the IRS still assess tax for a 2017 or 2018 hard fork?

    For most people who filed on time, no. Both the three-year period and the six-year period for large omissions have closed for those years, unless there was no return, fraud, or a signed extension.

    Should I answer “yes” to the digital asset question for an airdrop?

    The IRS digital assets page lists “an airdrop as it relates to a hard fork” as a yes. The question first appeared on the 2019 Schedule 1, so 2017 and 2018 returns never asked it.

    Will Form 1099-DA report my forked coins?

    Form 1099-DA is a broker form reporting gross proceeds for 2025 transactions and basis for certain 2026 transactions. It will not show when you received forked coins or their value then, so your own records carry that weight.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents taxpayers in IRS examinations and penalty disputes over digital assets, including when forked coins became income and what basis they carry. Phillip Zagotti is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado, and as a CPA he can rebuild a wallet’s receipt and basis history from exchange and blockchain records. That work supports the firm’s Tax Court litigation and IRS audit defense, plus penalty abatement where reasonable cause fits. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If a notice about forked coins has arrived, the 90-day clock is already running. Gather your exchange statements and wallet records, then contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Undisclosed Lawsuits in a Colorado Bankruptcy: Judicial Estoppel After Keathley

    Undisclosed Lawsuits in a Colorado Bankruptcy: Judicial Estoppel After Keathley

    A Colorado Springs warehouse worker is two years into a Chapter 13 plan when a delivery van runs a red light on Academy Boulevard. Within months she has an injury lawyer and a real claim, but nothing in her bankruptcy case mentions it. In Colorado, that gap has long handed the defense a judicial estoppel argument strong enough to end the lawsuit.

    The Supreme Court changed how that argument is decided this June, and it named the Tenth Circuit’s rule as one of the two it was correcting. Here is what the Court held, why it matters more in Colorado than in most places, and what a debtor in the District of Colorado bankruptcy court with a pending or new claim should do now.

    What did the Supreme Court decide in Keathley v. Buddy Ayers Construction?

    Thomas Keathley was paying creditors in full through an Arkansas Chapter 13 plan when he was hurt in a 2021 Mississippi car wreck. He told his bankruptcy lawyer he planned to sue, yet nobody amended his schedules, and he disclosed the claim only after the defendant moved for summary judgment. The lower courts applied the Fifth Circuit’s rule that an omission is inadvertent only if the debtor didn’t know the facts behind the claim or had no motive to hide it.

    In Keathley v. Buddy Ayers Construction, Inc., 608 U.S. ___, No. 25-6 (June 11, 2026), Justice Jackson wrote for a unanimous Court that “courts should look to the totality of the circumstances surrounding the omission.” The old rule was “too rigid and too broad,” because almost every debtor knows the facts of his own injury and almost any omission could theoretically help him. The holding is narrow. Working from the equitable framework of New Hampshire v. Maine, 532 U.S. 742 (2001), the Court assumed without deciding that judicial estoppel applies in bankruptcy, and it left open whether bad faith is required.

    Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Gorsuch, concurred to question whether the doctrine has any sound footing. Justice Sotomayor doubted that equity ever calls for estoppel while the bankruptcy case is still open, since the bankruptcy judge can sanction the debtor, modify the plan, or convert the case.

    Why does Keathley hit Colorado and the Tenth Circuit so directly?

    Footnote 3 of the opinion cites Eastman v. Union Pacific R.R. Co., 493 F.3d 1151, 1157 (10th Cir. 2007), as the Tenth Circuit’s version of the rejected test. Eastman’s railroad worker told the trustee he had no injury suit pending, took a no-asset Chapter 7 discharge, and was estopped. The court called his later reopening “inconsequential.”

    Queen v. TA Operating, LLC, 734 F.3d 1081 (10th Cir. 2013), went further: the debtors amended only after the defendant alerted the trustee, then valued their claim at $400,000 and called it fully exempt. The Colorado case is Anderson v. Seven Falls Co., 696 F. App’x 341 (10th Cir. 2017) (unpublished), a D. Colo. suit over an ankle injury at Seven Falls in Colorado Springs, where the panel refused to adopt the Ninth Circuit’s subjective-intent approach in Ah Quin v. County of Kauai. Keathley quoted Ah Quin with approval. The two-factor screen Colorado federal courts used for nearly two decades is gone, though the three New Hampshire factors still apply.

    What does a Colorado bankruptcy debtor have to disclose, and when?

    The estate takes “all legal or equitable interests of the debtor in property as of the commencement of the case.” 11 U.S.C. § 541(a)(1). That includes claims nobody has filed yet. Question 33 of Schedule A/B asks for claims against third parties “whether or not you have filed a lawsuit,” and question 9 of the Statement of Financial Affairs asks about lawsuits in the past year, personal-injury cases included.

    Chapter 13 adds a wrinkle. Under 11 U.S.C. § 1306(a)(1), property acquired after filing and before the case is closed, dismissed, or converted is also estate property, so an injury in year two of the plan counts. Fed. R. Bankr. P. 1007(h) is often cited here, but its 14-day supplemental schedule reaches only § 541(a)(5) items like inheritances, not a new tort claim. Keathley flagged a split on whether any continuing duty to disclose exists and didn’t resolve it.

    The practical answer is amendment. Rule 1009(a) permits amending a schedule “at any time before the case is closed,” with notice to the trustee. Colorado’s L.B.R. 1009-1 adds a notice substantially in the form of L.B.F. 1009-1.1 and a certificate of service. A closed case can be reopened under 11 U.S.C. § 350(b) “to administer assets, to accord relief to the debtor, or for other cause.”

    Pending Lawsuit and a Bankruptcy Case? Contact Us Now

    How are federal judges applying the new standard so far?

    An early example from within the circuit is Gaines v. Halliburton Energy Services, Inc., No. CIV-25-661-R (W.D. Okla. Aug. 31, 2026). The judge set the two-factor screen aside and borrowed the Eleventh Circuit’s checklist from Slater v. United States Steel Corp., which weighs things like the debtor’s sophistication, how and when the filings were corrected, and whether bankruptcy counsel was told.

    The plaintiff still lost. She had sworn “no” on question 33 while actively litigating, listed a different lawsuit elsewhere in her papers, and sought reopening only after defense counsel found the bankruptcy. Keathley lets a court hear the whole story, but a sworn denial followed by a late, unfinished fix is still a bad story.

    Who owns the claim, the debtor or the bankruptcy trustee?

    A Chapter 7 trustee must “collect and reduce to money the property of the estate.” 11 U.S.C. § 704(a)(1). Unscheduled property is not abandoned at closing and, under § 554(d), stays in the estate, which leaves the trustee, not the debtor, holding the claim. Fed. R. Civ. P. 17(a)(3) gives the trustee a reasonable time to step in before dismissal, and Eastman’s footnote 3 said estopping a trustee who hasn’t played games is likely inappropriate, at least as far as creditors need the money.

    Anderson shows the cost to the debtor. The trustee substituted in, and recovery was capped at creditor claims plus fees: a $45,662.04 judgment on a claim pleaded at over $5 million. In Chapter 13, § 1306(b) generally leaves the debtor in possession of estate property, which is why Keathley sued in his own name, and 11 U.S.C. § 1329 lets the plan be modified once money comes in.

    What should a Colorado Springs debtor with a new claim during Chapter 13 do?

    Back to the warehouse worker. Say she filed in March 2024 with a 60-month, $410-a-month plan projected to pay about $9,000 on $61,000 of unsecured debt. The crash leaves $27,500 in unpaid medical bills, and her lawyer expects about $140,000. After a one-third fee ($46,667), $3,000 in costs, and the providers, roughly $62,800 remains.

    Colorado opted out of the federal exemptions in C.R.S. § 13-54-107, and C.R.S. § 13-54-102(1)(n) exempts personal-injury proceeds “except for obligations incurred for treatment of any kind for such injuries or collection of such damages.” If that exemption fits, disclosure may cost her little, while concealment puts all $140,000 at risk. She should tell her Chapter 13 counsel in writing, amend Schedules A/B and C with the local notice, value the claim honestly rather than the way the Queens did, and talk to the trustee before signing any settlement. Keathley told his lawyer and stopped. A filed amendment is what protects her.

    Issue Tenth Circuit before Keathley After Keathley
    Inadvertence test No knowledge or no motive (Eastman, Queen) Totality of the circumstances
    Ah Quin approach Declined (Anderson) Quoted with approval
    Correcting after being caught “Inconsequential” (Eastman) A factor, but late fixes still hurt (Gaines)
    Telling bankruptcy counsel No excuse One circumstance among several
    Trustee pursuing the claim Likely not estopped, up to creditor needs (Eastman n.3) Unchanged
    Case still open No distinction Sotomayor concurrence doubts estoppel

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Does Keathley mean a Colorado debtor can no longer be judicially estopped?

    No. It changed only how courts decide whether an omission was inadvertent or a mistake. A debtor who denies a known claim under oath can still lose it.

    Is a personal-injury claim exempt in a Colorado bankruptcy?

    Colorado debtors use the state list, and C.R.S. § 13-54-102(1)(n) covers injury proceeds except amounts owed for treatment or collection. The claim still has to be scheduled and the exemption claimed.

    Do I have to disclose an injury claim that arose after I filed Chapter 13?

    Under 11 U.S.C. § 1306(a)(1), it is estate property. The Supreme Court left open whether a continuing duty to disclose exists, but a prompt Rule 1009(a) amendment is the safer course and is a circumstance courts weigh.

    Can I reopen a closed Colorado bankruptcy case to list a lawsuit?

    Yes, under 11 U.S.C. § 350(b). Eastman gave no weight to reopening after exposure, but after Keathley the timing and reason for the fix are part of the analysis.

    Does a Colorado state court use the same judicial estoppel test?

    Not necessarily. Estate of Burford v. Burford, 935 P.2d 943 (Colo. 1997), lists elements including an intentional effort to mislead and proceedings involving the same parties. How a Colorado court applies that to a bankruptcy omission is a state-law question.

    What happens to my lawsuit if the bankruptcy trustee steps in?

    The trustee gets a reasonable time to join or substitute under Rule 17(a)(3). If the debtor is estopped, the recovery may be limited to creditor claims plus fees, as in Anderson, leaving the debtor nothing more.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm handles bankruptcy matters including amended schedules in Chapter 13 cases, reopening closed Chapter 7 cases, and coordinating with injury and employment counsel when a claim touches a bankruptcy estate. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If you have an open bankruptcy case and a claim that never made it onto your schedules, the order of the next steps matters. To review your filings and timeline, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Holding a Colorado Notice of Deficiency: Tax Court, Refund Suit, or Bankruptcy?

    Holding a Colorado Notice of Deficiency: Tax Court, Refund Suit, or Bankruptcy?

    For a Colorado business owner, a notice of deficiency opens a choice that is hard to reverse. The notice points to the United States Tax Court, yet federal law offers four trial forums.

    The forum decides whether the tax must be paid first, whether a jury is available, whose precedent governs, and whether fees can shift to the government. Some of those consequences lock in the day a petition is filed.

    What does the 90-day clock require, and what happens when it runs out?

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 6213(a), a taxpayer has 90 days after the notice is mailed to petition the Tax Court, or 150 days if it is addressed to someone outside the United States. A weekend or District of Columbia holiday on the last day rolls it forward, and a petition filed by the last date the IRS prints in the notice “shall be treated as timely filed.” The IRS cannot assess or levy while the 90 days run or a timely case is pending; without a petition, § 6213(c) lets it assess.

    The Tax Court long treated a late petition as fatal. Boechler, P.C. v. Commissioner, 596 U.S. 199 (2022), held the collection due process deadline in § 6330(d)(1) “subject to equitable tolling,” but the Tax Court refused to extend that to deficiency cases in Hallmark Research Collective v. Commissioner, 159 T.C. No. 6 (2022). Four circuits have since allowed tolling of the § 6213(a) deadline, most recently the Eighth in Maniktala v. Commissioner, No. 25-1366 (Aug. 11, 2026); three others still refuse it. The Tenth Circuit has not addressed the question, though an appeal docketed in January 2026, Dugan v. Commissioner, No. 26-9002, is reported to present it. Until it is decided, a late Colorado petitioner has no binding authority to set against Hallmark. Treat day 90 as a wall.

    Holding a Colorado Notice of Deficiency? Contact Us Now

    Why does Tenth Circuit law control a Colorado case in the Tax Court?

    The Tax Court sits nationally but follows regional precedent. Under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), aff’d, 445 F.2d 985 (10th Cir. 1971), it follows the circuit to which appeal lies when that court “has already passed upon the issue.” Because § 7482(b)(1) routes an individual’s appeal by legal residence, a Greeley or Grand Junction petitioner gets Tenth Circuit law even where other circuits disagree.

    The Tax Court lists Denver as a place of trial, in the Byron Rogers Federal Building on Stout Street. Its Fall 2026 schedule shows no Denver session; the Winter 2027 schedule lists one, the week of February 8, 2027. Smaller disputes can elect small tax case procedures under § 7463 when no year exceeds $50,000, though the decision cannot be appealed. The filing fee is $60 either way.

    When does paying first and suing for a refund make sense?

    The refund route starts with a check. Flora v. United States, 362 U.S. 145 (1960), requires payment of “the full amount of the assessment” before suit under 28 U.S.C. § 1346(a)(1). Then come a refund claim under § 7422(a) and, usually, the six-month wait in § 6532(a)(1).

    A Colorado plaintiff may sue in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado or the Court of Federal Claims, but only the district court offers a jury, available “at the request of either party” under 28 U.S.C. § 2402. That matters to a Pueblo restaurant owner whose case rests on her credibility about cash receipts. Court of Federal Claims appeals go to the Federal Circuit under 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(3), the one path around Tenth Circuit precedent.

    Refund plaintiffs also face a possible government counterclaim under § 7422(e). And C.R.S. § 39-22-601(6) calls for an amended Colorado return within 30 days of a federal “final determination,” which includes “the payment of any additional tax.” Paying in full may start that state clock early, a point for Colorado-licensed counsel.

    Why can’t a taxpayer try the Tax Court first and keep a refund suit in reserve?

    Congress closed that door. After a timely petition, § 6512(a) provides that “no suit by the taxpayer for the recovery of any part of the tax shall be instituted in any court” for that year, subject to narrow exceptions. The Tax Court becomes the only forum for the whole year. The reverse does not hold, since skipping the Tax Court forfeits only the chance to litigate without paying. The petition is the irreversible step.

    Can the bankruptcy court decide the tax for an insolvent Colorado taxpayer?

    Yes. Section 505(a)(1) of the Bankruptcy Code lets the bankruptcy court “determine the amount or legality of any tax,” assessed or not. In Colorado that court sits in Denver, with appeal under 28 U.S.C. § 158 to the district court or the Tenth Circuit Bankruptcy Appellate Panel.

    A filing stays Tax Court proceedings over an individual debtor’s pre-petition years under 11 U.S.C. § 362(a)(8), and § 6213(f) suspends the 90-day clock during the stay plus 60 days. But § 505(a)(2)(A) bars relitigating a tax already adjudicated before the case began. Bankruptcy is no tactic for a solvent taxpayer, but it can fold the tax fight into a reorganization.

    What does each path cost in interest, deposits, and fees?

    The price of the no-payment rule is interest, compounding daily. The IRS has announced a 7 percent noncorporate underpayment rate for the quarter beginning October 1, 2026, about $1,050 a month on $180,000. Under § 6603, a deposit later applied to the tax is treated as paid when deposited, stopping interest while the Tax Court stays open.

    Fee recovery under § 7430 requires exhausting administrative remedies and beating a position that was not substantially justified, with fees capped at $260 an hour for 2026 under Rev. Proc. 2025-32. Sharper still is the qualified offer: a written offer made in the statutory window, which closes 30 days before the case is first set for trial, makes the taxpayer a prevailing party if the judgment comes in at or below it.

    How would the choice play out for a Colorado Springs business owner?

    Consider a hypothetical. Marisol runs a commercial landscaping company in Colorado Springs as a single-member LLC. After an exam of her 2023 return, the IRS mails a notice of deficiency dated Monday, October 5, 2026, proposing $180,000 of tax. Day 90 falls on Sunday, January 3, 2027, so the deadline rolls to Monday, January 4. Interest since April 15, 2024, at 6 to 8 percent, reaches roughly $36,700 by mid-November, so her exposure nears $216,700 before penalties.

    In the Tax Court she pays $60, requests Denver, and likely spends 2027 in Appeals while interest adds about $1,050 monthly unless she deposits. A qualified offer at, say, $120,000 sets up fee recovery if the result lands at or below it. For a jury, she lets January 4 pass, pays about $216,700, files a claim, and waits until mid-2027 to sue in Denver unless the IRS denies it sooner. If her business is failing anyway, a Subchapter V case filed in Denver before January 4 would pause the clock and let the bankruptcy judge fix the $180,000 figure.

    Forum Pay first? Jury? Appeal to Discovery and fees
    Tax Court, regular case No; $60 fee No Tenth Circuit Rule 70 discovery; § 7430 and qualified offer
    Tax Court, S case (§ 7463) No; $50,000 per-year cap No None Informal; not precedent
    U.S. District Court, D. Colo. Yes (Flora) plus refund claim Yes, on request Tenth Circuit Full civil discovery; § 7430; counterclaim risk
    Court of Federal Claims Yes, plus refund claim No Federal Circuit Court’s own rules; § 7430
    Bankruptcy Court, D. Colo. (§ 505) No, but requires a bankruptcy case No District court or BAP, then Tenth Circuit Bankruptcy rules; case costs

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can a Colorado taxpayer still go to Tax Court after missing the 90-day deadline?

    Probably not. The Tax Court treats the deadline as jurisdictional, and the Tenth Circuit has not ruled otherwise, though an appeal raising the issue is pending. A taxpayer who misses the date can still pay the assessment and sue for a refund.

    Does filing a Tax Court petition stop IRS collection?

    Yes, for the deficiency in the notice. The IRS generally cannot assess or levy that amount during the 90 days or while a timely case is pending. Interest keeps running. A section 6603 deposit can stop the interest.

    Can I get a jury trial in a federal tax case in Colorado?

    Only in a refund suit in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado, where either side may request a jury under 28 U.S.C. section 2402. The Tax Court, the Court of Federal Claims, and the bankruptcy court decide tax cases without juries.

    Where are Tax Court trials held in Colorado?

    Denver is the only Colorado place of trial, in the Byron Rogers Federal Building on Stout Street. The Winter 2027 schedule lists a Denver session the week of February 8, 2027, and the Fall 2026 schedule has none.

    What is a qualified offer in a federal tax dispute?

    It is a written offer, designated as qualified, made after the first letter offering Appeals review and at least 30 days before the case is first set for trial. If the judgment is at or below it, the taxpayer can recover later costs under section 7430, subject to net worth limits.

    Does a federal tax adjustment affect my Colorado income tax?

    Usually. Colorado income tax starts from federal taxable income, and state law calls for an amended Colorado return within 30 days after a federal final determination, which includes a final judgment or payment of additional tax. Colorado-licensed counsel should confirm the timing.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents Colorado individuals and business owners in federal tax controversies, from the response to a notice of deficiency through Appeals and trial. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado, so the firm can weigh the Tax Court, refund, and bankruptcy routes side by side. That work includes Tax Court litigation, IRS appeals and collection due process hearings, and resolving tax debt in bankruptcy. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    The date printed on a notice of deficiency governs every other decision, so bring the notice to the firm early enough to compare the forums on the merits. To get started, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Colorado Taxes SaaS Starting January 1, 2027: A Guide for Sellers and Buyers

    Colorado Taxes SaaS Starting January 1, 2027: A Guide for Sellers and Buyers

    On June 4, 2026, Governor Polis signed House Bill 26-1223, ending a rule Colorado had used since 2012 under which the state taxed software only when it arrived on a disk or similar medium under a tear-open license. Beginning January 1, 2027, the 2.9 percent state sales and use tax reaches computer software however it is delivered, including programs reached over the internet.

    The change is simple to state and harder to apply. Denver, Boulder, and Colorado Springs already write their own software rules, an exemption for negotiated licenses may cover most business-to-business dollars, and the Colorado Department of Revenue had not proposed rules as of late September 2026.

    What did HB 26-1223 actually change in the statute?

    The key amendment is to C.R.S. § 39-26-102(15)(c). The enrolled act strikes the physical-medium and tear-open conditions and the “application service provider” definition that kept hosted programs out of the base. Tangible personal property now “includes computer software,” defined as coded instructions “delivered by any means, including compact disc, download, or remote access through the internet.” The words “software as a service” never appear, and they do not need to.

    The Legislative Council’s final fiscal note projects $44.4 million in added revenue for the first half year and $92.2 million for the 2027-28 state fiscal year, routed to a new refundable family credit. One quieter repeal matters to buyers: former subsection (15)(c)(IV), which let a Colorado purchaser allocate license fees between Colorado and other states, is gone.

    Which software stays exempt, and what counts as a negotiated license?

    New C.R.S. § 39-26-713(3) exempts software “either governed by a negotiable license agreement or developed for use by a particular user.” The license must be written, “individually bargained,” and signed by authorized representatives of both parties before or at first access. A boilerplate agreement offered on a “substantially nonnegotiable basis to multiple licensees” fails even if both sides sign. Acceptance by click-through, account creation, or browse-wrap does not count, though DocuSign-type signatures do.

    Notice the drafting wobble: the operative sentence says “negotiable,” the defined term says “negotiated,” and a contract can be open to negotiation without ever being negotiated. The agenda for the Department’s August 18, 2026 software workgroup asks what shows individual bargaining, so we would plan around the defined term.

    The fiscal note also reveals the exemption’s expected size. Staff assumed only 20 percent of downloadable software sales come from nonnegotiable agreements. On that assumption roughly four of every five software dollars stay exempt, which makes the contract file behind each enterprise deal the thing an auditor will test.

    Why doesn’t the state change settle the question in Denver, Boulder, or Colorado Springs?

    Self-collecting home-rule cities write their own tax codes, and these three reached SaaS years ago. Denver’s Tax Guide Topic No. 18 taxes software as a service regardless of delivery method, apportioned to use in Denver. Boulder’s code defines computer software to include “software as a service,” as its tax compliance guides explain, and Colorado Springs Tax Guide No. 167 lists online SaaS subscriptions as taxable. The city rules do not track the new state exemptions: Denver taxes custom software, Boulder exempts it only when modifications exceed 25 percent of the unmodified price, and none of the three guides mentions a negotiated-license exemption.

    The state-collected local layer is murkier. The final fiscal note says counties, municipalities, RTD, and SCFD may adopt the software change only “through approval during a local election,” reversing the initial note, which had RTD and SCFD following automatically. The enacted text does not say so, and the Department’s DR 1002 rate chart has not addressed software. Filing is easier than it was: SB 19-006 produced the SUTS portal for state and participating home-rule returns.

    How is a subscription sourced, and when must an out-of-state seller collect?

    Colorado sources to destination under C.R.S. § 39-26-104(3), meaning where the buyer receives the product. Where a Fort Collins company “receives” a cloud tool used by 40 employees working from home in Larimer and Weld Counties is unclear, and the Department has asked whether to adopt the Streamlined Sales Tax sourcing rules for software.

    Nexus is clearer. Under C.R.S. § 39-26-102(3)(c), a remote seller must collect for a year if its Colorado retail sales exceeded $100,000 the prior year, or starting the first day of the month after the 90th day after crossing $100,000 in the current year. Since HB 25B-1005 eliminated the state vendor fee beginning January 1, 2026, a seller keeps nothing for the effort.

    What does January 1, 2027 look like for a hypothetical Boulder SaaS company?

    Hypothetical: a Boulder analytics company expects $3,000,000 of Colorado subscription revenue in 2027, billed $1,200,000 to Denver, $600,000 to the City of Boulder, $500,000 to unincorporated Jefferson County (inside RTD), and $700,000 to Colorado Springs, all on its standard online order form. It is licensed in each home-rule city, and January 2026 DR 1002 rates apply.

    Today the state column is zero, but the cities already expect tax: Denver at 5.15 percent ($61,800), Boulder at 3.86 percent ($23,160), and Colorado Springs at 3.07 percent ($21,490), or $106,450 a year. On January 1, 2027, the state’s 2.9 percent adds $87,000. If the state-collected local taxes later conform (RTD, SCFD, Boulder, Jefferson, and El Paso Counties, and the Pikes Peak Rural Transportation Authority), another $51,420 follows, for combined rates of 9.15 percent in Denver, 9.195 percent in Boulder, 4.5 percent in unincorporated Jefferson County, and 8.2 percent in Colorado Springs.

    Now move the four largest Denver accounts, $800,000 of revenue, onto individually negotiated agreements signed before provisioning. If they qualify, $23,200 of state tax disappears. Denver’s $41,200 on the same accounts stays.

    What should a Colorado business that buys SaaS do?

    C.R.S. § 39-26-202 imposes 2.9 percent use tax when taxable property is used in Colorado without sales tax, reported on the DR 0252 return. From January 2027, accounts payable should flag software vendors that charge no Colorado tax and get the vendor’s exemption position in writing. With the proration paragraph repealed, a Grand Junction company splitting a 2,000-seat license between Colorado and Utah users has no statutory formula, so it should keep monthly seat-location data until a rule issues.

    How should sellers handle contracts and past exposure before 2027?

    On contracts, provision only after countersignature, document each signer’s authority, and keep redlines showing that price, liability caps, or service levels moved. Put the license grant, fees, and term in the signed document rather than in online terms the vendor can change, say whether later self-service seats are governed by the agreement, and add a tax clause for the case where the exemption fails.

    On past exposure, the risk is mostly municipal, since remotely accessed software sat outside the state base until 2027. A company that sold into Denver, Boulder, or Colorado Springs without collecting may already owe those cities. For state liabilities, the Department’s Voluntary Disclosure Program accepts anonymous requests and typically expects a three-year look-back, and where nexus is thin it prefers simple prospective registration.

    Quarter SaaS sellers Colorado business buyers Watch for
    Q4 2026 Map customers by address; confirm licenses; flag contracts that could qualify Inventory subscriptions; set up use tax accruals Proposed DOR rules
    Q1 2027 Charge 2.9 percent; file first returns by February 20 Accrue use tax where none is charged Transition rules for prepaid subscriptions
    Q2 2027 Reconcile collections by jurisdiction Track seat locations monthly July 1 local rate changes
    Q3 2027 Move eligible renewals to signed negotiated agreements Negotiate tax clauses at renewal Final sourcing rules
    Q4 2027 Review 2027 filings; revisit city exposure Year-end use tax true-up Local elections adopting the base

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is software as a service taxable in Colorado starting January 1, 2027?

    At the state level, yes, unless an exemption applies. HB 26-1223 defines computer software to include programs delivered by remote access through the internet and subjects it to the 2.9 percent state sales and use tax. Custom software and software under a signed, individually negotiated license remain exempt.

    Does a click-through or online order form qualify for the negotiated license exemption?

    No. The statute excludes click-through, browse-wrap, account creation, and other automated acceptance, and it excludes standard form agreements offered on a substantially nonnegotiable basis even when both sides sign. DocuSign-type signatures work only on an agreement actually bargained and signed before or at first access.

    Do Denver, Boulder, and Colorado Springs already tax SaaS?

    Yes. All three self-collecting home-rule cities publish guidance treating software as a service as taxable, and their rules do not mirror the new state exemptions. Denver taxes custom software, and none of the three guides recognizes a negotiated-license exemption, so city tax can apply where state tax does not.

    When does an out-of-state SaaS company have to collect Colorado sales tax?

    A remote seller must collect for a calendar year if its Colorado retail sales exceeded $100,000 in the prior year. If it crosses $100,000 mid-year, collection begins the first day of the month after the 90th day following that point. Cautious sellers count 2026 subscription receipts toward the test.

    Do sellers keep a vendor fee for collecting the new software tax?

    No. HB 25B-1005 eliminated the state sales tax vendor fee beginning January 1, 2026, so a software company collecting Colorado tax in 2027 remits everything it collects. Home-rule cities set their own vendor fee rules, so check each city separately.

    Has the Colorado Department of Revenue issued rules on the software change?

    Not as of late September 2026. The Department called a stakeholder workgroup for August 18, 2026, without draft rules, and sought input on the negotiated license exemption, custom software, sourcing, multiple points of use, and transition issues. Sellers should build systems that can adjust once rules appear.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm helps Colorado software companies and their customers with the tax accounting side of this change: modeling state and home-rule exposure, reviewing contract files against the negotiated license exemption, preparing voluntary disclosures, and handling Department of Revenue correspondence and audits. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is an attorney and CPA admitted to practice before the U.S. Tax Court who represents taxpayers before the IRS. Related services include Colorado state tax and DOR matters, entity selection for software businesses, and the firm’s broader tax law practice. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    To map where your 2027 Colorado software tax will land before the first January invoices go out, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Colorado Plan Releases After Purdue: What the Tenth Circuit Decided in 1990

    Colorado Plan Releases After Purdue: What the Tenth Circuit Decided in 1990

    When the Supreme Court decided Harrington v. Purdue Pharma L.P., 603 U.S. 204 (2024), commentators called it a rupture in Chapter 11 practice. For a Pueblo or Grand Junction company reorganizing in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado, the change was small. Since 1990 the Tenth Circuit has read 11 U.S.C. § 524(e) to stop a confirmed plan from permanently shielding a non-debtor from its own liability on the debtor’s debts.

    The live questions concern exculpation clauses and an August 2026 Voyager Digital ruling on post-confirmation conduct. Owners usually ask something simpler: can a Subchapter V plan deal with their bank guaranty?

    What did the Tenth Circuit decide in Western Real Estate Fund?

    In Landsing Diversified Properties-II v. First National Bank & Trust Co. of Tulsa (In re Western Real Estate Fund, Inc.), 922 F.2d 592 (10th Cir. 1990) (per curiam), an Oklahoma Chapter 11 debtor fired its litigation lawyer, and the bankruptcy court enjoined him from collecting his unpaid fee from a non-debtor in state court.

    The Tenth Circuit vacated most of it. “Congress did not intend to extend such benefits to third-party bystanders,” the court wrote, and “the stay may not be extended post-confirmation in the form of a permanent injunction that effectively relieves the nondebtor from its own liability to the creditor.” On rehearing in Abel v. West, 932 F.2d 898 (10th Cir. 1991), the panel limited the surviving injunction to the period “pending confirmation of a reorganization plan.”

    Did Purdue change the rules for Colorado Chapter 11 plans?

    Less than elsewhere. Purdue barred any plan release that “effectively seeks to discharge claims against a nondebtor without the consent of affected claimants,” and its circuit-split footnote grouped Western Real Estate Fund with the Fifth and Ninth Circuit decisions refusing such releases.

    Purdue did close one door. In In re Midway Gold US, Inc., 575 B.R. 475 (Bankr. D. Colo. 2017), Chief Judge Michael E. Romero read Western Real Estate Fund as “limited in scope” to co-debtor and guarantor releases and would have allowed others under 11 U.S.C. § 105(a) in “very limited” circumstances. Purdue forecloses that, reading the catchall in 11 U.S.C. § 1123(b)(6) to reach only debtor-focused provisions.

    Why can’t a Subchapter V plan release the owner’s personal guaranty?

    Here is a hypothetical. A Pueblo metal fabrication shop in Subchapter V owes $1.1 million to a local bank, which the owner guaranteed, and $400,000 to trade creditors. The collateral is worth $700,000, and the plan pays unsecured claims, including the bank’s $400,000 deficiency, 20 cents on the dollar. Ignoring interest, the bank collects $780,000. The owner wants the plan to release him on the remaining $320,000.

    That is the release Western Real Estate Fund forbids. Section 524(e) says discharge “does not affect the liability of any other entity on, or the property of any other entity for, such debt.” The Chapter 11 discharge in 11 U.S.C. § 1141(d)(1)(A) and the Subchapter V discharge in 11 U.S.C. § 1192 both run only to the debtor. Even Midway Gold said a guarantor release would be “expressly barred by § 524(e).” After confirmation the bank can sue him, and if he has $310,000 of equity in a Pueblo West house, the homestead exemption in C.R.S. § 38-41-201 ($250,000, or $350,000 for elderly or disabled owners) leaves part of it exposed.

    How is exculpation different from a third-party release?

    A release wipes out creditors’ claims against someone else. Exculpation sets a standard of care for estate fiduciaries during the case, excepting gross negligence, willful misconduct, and fraud.

    Midway Gold refused to exculpate secured lenders, who were not estate fiduciaries, struck an advice-of-counsel shield, and confined protection to acts during the case. In In re Rocking M Media, LLC, No. 22-20242 (Bankr. D. Kan. Aug. 2, 2024), a Kansas bankruptcy court noted that “[t]he Tenth Circuit has not addressed the validity of exculpation clauses,” followed Midway Gold, and refused to carve a liquidating trustee’s future conduct out of the clause.

    The Fifth Circuit reads Tenth Circuit law more strictly; in NexPoint Advisors, L.P. v. Highland Capital Management, L.P. (In re Highland Capital Management, L.P.), 48 F.4th 419 (5th Cir. 2022), it said it and “the Tenth Circuit hold § 524(e) categorically bars third-party exculpations absent express authority in another provision of the Bankruptcy Code.” One such provision is 11 U.S.C. § 1125(e), which protects good-faith plan solicitation and plan securities transactions.

    What does the Voyager ruling add about future conduct?

    Voyager Digital’s 2023 cryptocurrency plan required large coin trades before in-kind distributions and exculpated the people executing them. On an appeal by the United States and the U.S. Trustee, in In re Voyager Digital Holdings, Inc., No. 23-CV-2171 (LTS) (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 6, 2026) (amended opinion), Chief Judge Laura Taylor Swain vacated the clause, concluding that “[n]othing in the Bankruptcy Code or the doctrine of quasi-judicial immunity empowered the Bankruptcy Court to approve the Exculpation Provision.” She also held that 11 U.S.C. § 1142(a) displaces only nonbankruptcy law “relating to financial condition,” and that quasi-judicial immunity belongs in a later suit as a defense, not in an advance grant.

    Voyager does not bind Colorado courts, but it fits 28 U.S.C. § 959(b), which requires a debtor in possession to operate “according to the requirements of the valid laws of the State.” A Weld County oilfield service company in Subchapter V cannot use its plan to pre-clear future dealings with regulators. Voyager’s real addition is the government-enforcement limit.

    Does an opt-out ballot count as consent in Colorado?

    Purdue declined “to express a view on what qualifies as a consensual release,” and courts have split. In re Smallhold, Inc., No. 24-10267 (CTG) (Bankr. D. Del. Sept. 25, 2024), held silence is not consent, while In re Spirit Airlines, Inc., No. 24-11988 (SHL) (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. Mar. 7, 2025), approved an opt-out. We have found no Tenth Circuit appellate ruling. Midway Gold adds that consent “does not confer this Court with jurisdiction” over disputes among non-debtors. In Subchapter V, the guaranteed lender simply signs a release or does not.

    What options does a Pueblo or Greeley owner-guarantor have?

    A § 105(a) injunction protects the owner only until confirmation under Abel v. West. A gatekeeper clause fares no better: the Barton doctrine, which the Tenth Circuit applied to trustees in Satterfield v. Malloy, 700 F.3d 1231 (10th Cir. 2012), protects court officers, and an owner sued on a guaranty is not acting as one.

    The cleanest path is the owner’s own case. An owner holding 20 percent or more of the company’s outstanding voting securities is an “affiliate” under 11 U.S.C. § 101(2)(A), and Fed. R. Bankr. P. 1015(b) permits joint administration. He then gets his own stay and discharge, subject to the usual exceptions and Colorado’s exemptions.

    The other route is paying for consent. Suppose a Greeley HVAC contractor’s owner puts $150,000 of outside money into the plan, and the bank signs a release effective when plan payments finish. A signed agreement satisfies every court’s test for consent. Front-loading payments on the guaranteed debt also shrinks exposure.

    Plan provision What it does Status in the Tenth Circuit after Purdue Leading authority
    Nonconsensual guarantor release Ends creditor claims against a non-debtor Barred since 1990 Western Real Estate Fund; Purdue
    Signed or opt-in release Creditor affirmatively releases a non-debtor Permitted; Purdue reserved the issue Purdue; Midway Gold
    Opt-out “deemed consent” release Treats silence as consent Unsettled; no circuit ruling located Smallhold; Spirit Airlines
    Exculpation of estate fiduciaries Limits fiduciaries’ in-case liability Approved when limited to fiduciaries Midway Gold; Rocking M Media
    Exculpation of future conduct Pre-clears post-confirmation acts Vulnerable under § 959(b) and persuasive authority Voyager (S.D.N.Y. 2026)
    Section 105(a) injunction for the owner Stays suits against a non-debtor Temporary, until confirmation Western Real Estate Fund; Abel v. West

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can a Colorado Chapter 11 plan release my personal guaranty without the bank’s consent?

    No. The Tenth Circuit held in 1990 that Section 524(e) bars a confirmed plan from permanently relieving a non-debtor of its own liability on the debtor’s debt, and Purdue reached the same result nationally in 2024. A guarantor is released only by the lender’s agreement or in the guarantor’s own bankruptcy.

    Is exculpation the same thing as a release?

    No. A release extinguishes creditors’ claims against a non-debtor. Exculpation protects estate fiduciaries, such as the debtor in possession and its officers, for conduct during the case, excepting gross negligence, willful misconduct, and fraud. The leading Colorado decision limits it to true fiduciaries.

    Does the Voyager decision apply in Colorado?

    It does not bind the District of Colorado, because it is a Southern District of New York ruling. Colorado bankruptcy judges can still find it persuasive on shielding future conduct from government enforcement, and federal law already requires a debtor in possession to follow valid state law.

    Will not returning my ballot count as consenting to a release?

    It depends on the court and the plan’s wording. Some courts accept opt-outs with clear disclosure, while others require an affirmative act such as voting or checking an opt-in box. We have not found a Tenth Circuit appellate ruling, so read every ballot and notice carefully.

    Can the bankruptcy court stop my bank from suing me on the guaranty while the company reorganizes?

    Possibly, for a limited time. The Tenth Circuit has allowed a temporary Section 105 injunction protecting a non-debtor when it helps the reorganization, but on rehearing it limited that protection to the period before plan confirmation. After confirmation, the lender can generally pursue the guarantor.

    Should the owner of a small Colorado business file bankruptcy alongside the company?

    Sometimes. If the guaranty exceeds what the owner can pay, his own case provides a stay and a discharge the company’s plan cannot, and the cases can often be jointly administered. The answer turns on Colorado’s exemptions and what the lender will accept.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents Colorado businesses and their owners in Subchapter V reorganizations and Chapter 11 cases, including plan drafting and guaranty negotiations tied to SBA loans and other business debt. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. District Court and the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado and can weigh the tax side of guaranty settlements and debt forgiveness. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If your company is heading toward Subchapter V and you signed a personal guaranty, plan for it before the petition is filed. To discuss your situation, contact North Star Law Firm.


  • Estate of Rowland and Portability: Higher Stakes for Colorado Surviving Spouses

    Estate of Rowland and Portability: Higher Stakes for Colorado Surviving Spouses

    Billy Rowland’s estate claimed $3,712,562 of exclusion inherited from his late wife, Fay, and lost all of it on summary judgment. In Estate of Rowland v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2025-76 (filed July 15, 2025), Chief Judge Urda held that the Form 706 filed for Fay’s estate never made a valid portability election. The return named her assets. It never said what any of them were worth.

    Colorado families have more riding on that lesson. In a separate property state, the first death resets income tax basis only on the decedent’s share of jointly owned property, while a Texas or California survivor often gets a new basis on the whole community asset. That makes the deceased spousal unused exclusion (the DSUE amount) worth more here, because it lets a Colorado survivor hold appreciated assets until her own death without estate tax.

    What was actually missing from the Rowland return?

    Fay Rowland, of Lorain, Ohio, died April 8, 2016. Her trust made $950,000 of specific gifts, sent 20 percent of the trust estate to a family foundation, sized her husband’s share by reference to one-fourth of her gross estate, and left the residue to trusts for grandchildren. Her executor missed the extended deadline and mailed the Form 706 in late December 2017.

    The return claimed DSUE of $3,712,562 from an estimated $3 million gross estate. Its schedules listed real estate, family company shares, a note, and bank accounts with no date-of-death values. The recapitulation showed $0 in every category and put the full $3 million on the line reserved for assets estimated under the special rule.

    Why did the Tax Court hold the election invalid?

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 2010(c)(5)(A), no election may be made on a late return, so the statute alone defeated Fay’s election. The only rescue was Rev. Proc. 2017-34, which excused lateness for a return that was “complete and properly prepared” under Treas. Reg. § 20.2010-2(a)(7). Fay’s return met the timing test and failed the quality test. Paragraph (a)(7)(i) ties completeness to the Form 706 instructions, which require a value for each asset, and paragraph (a)(7)(ii) excuses values only for marital or charitable deduction property. The return stretched that relief to gifts for friends and grandchildren. Even the spouse’s and foundation’s shares needed values, because their size fixed the grandchildren’s residue, the exception in § 20.2010-2(a)(7)(ii)(A)(1).

    The court left open whether substantial compliance can ever save a DSUE election, holding only that this return fell well short, and refused to let audit-stage valuations cure it. The docket (No. 12736-22) shows partial summary judgment entered August 22, 2025, with the remaining issues set for trial in Cincinnati on November 30, 2026.

    When can a portability-only return use estimates instead of appraisals?

    Only when the gross estate plus adjusted taxable gifts is under the filing threshold in 26 U.S.C. § 6018(a), and only for assets that will go to the spouse or a charity. Those assets are still listed, with a good-faith estimate reported in bands from the Form 706 instructions under penalties of perjury. The relief disappears in four cases, the most common being when that property’s value affects what another beneficiary receives. The others involve special valuation provisions, partly qualifying assets, and partial disclaimers or QTIP elections.

    Why does separate property make portability matter more in Colorado?

    The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, Pub. L. No. 119-21, set the basic exclusion at $15,000,000 for 2026 deaths, indexed after 2026, and Rev. Proc. 2025-32 confirms the figure. A DSUE amount is fixed at the first death and does not index. Colorado adds no second layer: the Legislative Council Staff explains that the state estate tax effectively ended for deaths after December 31, 2004.

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 1014, inherited property takes its date-of-death value as basis, and § 1014(b)(6) also resets the survivor’s half of community property. Colorado is not a community property state. For spouses holding title as joint tenants, 26 U.S.C. § 2040(b) includes half the value in the first estate, and only that half is revalued. A deed creates a joint tenancy only when it says so under C.R.S. § 38-31-101; tenants in common get the same half-and-half result.

    Portability makes waiting for the second step-up affordable, and lifetime workarounds are weak: a gift carries over basis under 26 U.S.C. § 1015, and § 1014(e) denies a step-up when appreciated property given to a spouse who dies within one year passes back to the donor.

    What does the math look like for a Boulder County family?

    Hypothetical. Tom and Ellen Marsh of Louisville own their home as joint tenants; it cost $700,000 in 2003 and is worth $2.4 million. Tom’s revocable trust holds a Berthoud horse property worth $3.1 million. Tom has a $1.9 million IRA, Ellen a $1.2 million 401(k), and they share a $1.4 million brokerage account. Tom dies in February 2026; his trust leaves 10 percent of the trust estate to his daughter from a first marriage and the rest to Ellen.

    Tom’s $6.9 million gross estate requires no return. Assuming no lifetime taxable gifts and ignoring expenses, a correct portability-only return shows a $310,000 taxable estate (the daughter’s share) and DSUE of $14,690,000. The house, IRA, and brokerage account can be estimated. The Berthoud property cannot, because a percentage gift and a partial marital interest trigger two exceptions. That is Rowland in Colorado.

    Tom’s half of the house steps up to $1.2 million while Ellen’s half stays at $350,000. If she sells for $2.4 million within two years, while unmarried, her $850,000 gain is reduced by the $500,000 exclusion in 26 U.S.C. § 121(b)(4), leaving $350,000 taxable. A community property home would have had no gain, and the IRA gets no step-up under § 1014(c).

    If Ellen instead keeps the house and land and dies in 2040 with a $19.5 million estate, and her own exclusion is still $15 million (indexing will raise it by an unknown amount), the tax without DSUE is 40 percent under 26 U.S.C. § 2001(c) on $4.5 million, or $1.8 million. With the DSUE amount the tax is zero, and her heirs still get a new basis in everything outside the retirement accounts.

    What if the deadline has passed, and what will the IRS check later?

    Rev. Proc. 2022-32 replaced the procedure Fay’s executor used and gives an estate not otherwise required to file until the fifth anniversary of death, with a header statement on the return. The Rowland condition carries over: relief covers only a complete and properly prepared return. After five years, the remaining path is a private letter ruling request under Treas. Reg. § 301.9100-3. For the Marsh estate, the window closes in February 2031.

    Section 2010(c)(5)(B) lets the IRS examine the first spouse’s return whenever the DSUE amount is used, even after that return’s limitations period has run, and reduce or eliminate the DSUE amount. In Rowland, the examiner raised the issue more than five years after Fay died. A Colorado survivor should keep the filed return, its appraisals, and proof of mailing with her own estate plan.

    Filing path What the return must show Marsh DSUE preserved Main risk
    No Form 706 Nothing $0 $1.8 million of tax in the 2040 scenario
    Portability-only, estimates for everything Assets listed with one estimated total, as in Rowland $0 if disallowed Berthoud value sets the daughter’s share, so estimates fail
    Portability-only, special rule applied correctly Appraised Berthoud property; banded estimates for the rest $14,690,000 Estimates can be revisited when Ellen uses the DSUE
    Full return Date-of-death values on every schedule $14,690,000 Higher appraisal cost, strongest audit record
    Late return under Rev. Proc. 2022-32 Complete return plus header statement $14,690,000 if filed by February 2031 Void if a return was actually required

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Does Colorado have an estate tax or an inheritance tax?

    No. Colorado’s estate tax was tied to the federal state death tax credit and effectively ended for deaths after December 31, 2004, and the inheritance tax was replaced in 1980. A Colorado estate’s transfer tax exposure is federal only, which makes the portability election more important.

    Do we need to file Form 706 if the estate owes no tax?

    Not to pay tax, but a return is the only way to elect portability. A surviving spouse can use the unused exclusion only if the executor files a return that computes the DSUE amount. In 2026 that amount can reach $15 million.

    Can a portability-only return use estimates for every asset?

    Only in simple cases. Estimates are permitted for assets going to the surviving spouse or a charity when the estate is under the filing threshold. Property going to children needs a real value, as does marital property whose value affects another beneficiary’s share.

    How long does an executor have to file a late portability return?

    Under Rev. Proc. 2022-32, an estate not otherwise required to file can elect portability with a complete and properly prepared Form 706 filed by the fifth anniversary of death. After that, the remaining option is a private letter ruling request under Treasury Regulation section 301.9100-3.

    Does remarriage cost a surviving spouse the DSUE amount?

    Remarriage alone does not. The DSUE amount comes from the survivor’s last deceased spouse, and remarriage does not change that designation. If the new spouse dies first, though, that spouse becomes the last deceased spouse, and the earlier DSUE amount can no longer be applied.

    Does joint tenancy give a full basis step-up in Colorado?

    No. When spouses own property as joint tenants with right of survivorship, federal law includes half its value in the first spouse’s estate, and only that half gets a new basis. The survivor’s half keeps its original basis until her own death.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm works with Colorado executors and surviving spouses on the federal side of portability, from complete Form 706 portability returns and late elections to IRS examinations of DSUE claims. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is an attorney and CPA admitted to practice before the U.S. Tax Court, and co-author with Ashley Burdette of Trusted: The Essential Guide for Trustees. The firm’s trust and estate tax planning, real estate tax strategy, and Tax Court litigation practices cover these issues. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If a spouse died in the last five years and no portability return was filed, or the return that was filed looks thin, review it before the window closes. Contact North Star Law Firm to schedule a consultation.


  • Colorado FBAR Deadline October 15, 2026: Three Filers and Their Fixes

    Colorado FBAR Deadline October 15, 2026: Three Filers and Their Fixes

    The FBAR for calendar year 2025 (FinCEN Form 114, the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts) is due no later than Thursday, October 15, 2026. It goes to FinCEN, not the IRS, so a Form 1040 does not satisfy it. And this summer the IRS page describing its delinquent FBAR submission procedures, long the safe route for people with fully reported income, disappeared. The agency’s FBAR page now says filing late “is a violation and may subject you to penalties.”

    This post follows three Colorado filers whose facts come up often: a Denver software engineer on an H-1B visa, a Greeley petroleum engineer on an overseas rotation, and a Fort Collins retiree with a Canadian RRSP. Each faces a different best move after the deadline.

    Why does the regulation still say June 30 when the FBAR deadline is October 15?

    The duty to report comes from 31 U.S.C. § 5314 and 31 C.F.R. § 1010.350, and it applies when a United States person, a term that includes resident aliens under 26 U.S.C. § 7701(b), has foreign accounts whose combined maximum values exceed $10,000. The filing rule, 31 C.F.R. § 1010.306(c), still says June 30. Congress overrode it in Pub. L. No. 114-41, § 2006(b)(11), setting an April 15 due date with an extension to October 15, which FinCEN grants automatically. The statute controls.

    Does a Denver engineer on an H-1B visa owe an FBAR for her savings back home?

    Usually, because the substantial presence test makes her a resident alien. Picture an engineer who moved to the Denver Tech Center in 2021 and kept well over $10,000 in savings and fixed deposits in Pune. Her returns reported Colorado wages but left out the Indian interest, because she assumed the tax withheld in India settled it. The unpaid U.S. tax, not just the missing FBARs, decides which fix she can use.

    Her bitcoin on an offshore exchange is a closer call. Under FinCEN Notice 2020-2, an account holding only virtual currency is not reportable yet, but one that also holds a rupee cash balance is.

    What changes for a Greeley rotation worker paid into an account overseas?

    Consider a U.S. citizen in Greeley who works 28 days on and 28 off at a gas project in Western Australia. The privately held operator pays his field allowance into an Australian account in his name, and he can sign on a local supply account he does not own. Both go on the FBAR, because § 1010.350(f) treats the power to move money by instruction to the bank as enough. Its carve-outs for regulated financial firms and SEC-registered companies do not help him.

    The foreign version of the IRS streamlined procedures requires a year with no U.S. abode and 330 full days abroad. Half a year in Greeley fails that test, so he is a domestic filer. If his income was fully reported, his problem is FBAR-only.

    Is a Canadian RRSP reportable if the IRS no longer wants Form 8891?

    Take a retired teacher from Alberta who became a U.S. citizen and settled in Fort Collins, with an RRSP worth about CAD 310,000 and a chequing account in Lethbridge. Rev. Proc. 2014-55 made the RRSP tax-deferral election automatic and retired Form 8891, but section 5.01 says it does not change “the requirement to file FinCEN Form 114.” An RRSP also falls outside the regulation’s exception for U.S. retirement plans and IRAs. Her income reporting is clean; only the FBARs are missing.

    How large is the penalty exposure once October 15 passes?

    Under 31 U.S.C. § 5321(a)(5), a non-willful violation carries a $10,000 statutory maximum, waived for reasonable cause if the balance was properly reported. A willful violation can cost the greater of $100,000 or half the account balance. Indexed under 31 C.F.R. § 1010.821, those amounts are now $16,536 and $165,353. OMB Memorandum M-26-11 (Apr. 17, 2026) cancelled the 2026 inflation adjustments, as agency notices such as 91 Fed. Reg. 25936 (May 12, 2026) recite.

    In Bittner v. United States, 598 U.S. 85 (2023), the government sought $2.72 million for 272 unreported accounts over five years. The Court held the non-willful penalty accrues per report, not per account, capping exposure at $50,000. With a six-year assessment period under § 5321(b)(1), each late year can add up to $16,536.

    This review found no Tenth Circuit opinion on FBAR willfulness. In United States v. Wahdan, 325 F. Supp. 3d 1136 (D. Colo. 2018), Chief Judge Marcia Krieger held the IRS could not exceed the $100,000 cap then in 31 C.F.R. § 1010.820(g). The Fourth Circuit disagreed in United States v. Horowitz, 978 F.3d 80 (4th Cir. 2020), and FinCEN deleted paragraph (g) as obsolete in 86 Fed. Reg. 72844 (Dec. 23, 2021). Planning around Wahdan today would be a mistake.

    Missed a Colorado FBAR? Contact Us Now

    Which fix fits each profile now that the delinquent FBAR procedures are gone?

    All three should still file the 2025 FBAR on time; the earlier years are the problem.

    The Denver engineer fits the Streamlined Domestic Offshore Procedures. She amends three years of returns, files six years of FBARs, certifies on Form 14654 that her conduct was non-willful, and pays 5 percent of the highest year-end aggregate balance. The IRS then will not assert FBAR or accuracy-related penalties absent later findings of fraud or willfulness.

    The retiree cannot use that program, which requires unreported income. She files the late FBARs with a written explanation and leans on IRM 4.26.16.3.11, which says a penalty “will not be asserted” when the failure was non-willful, had reasonable cause, and the late report is accurate. IRM 4.26.16.5.2.1 lets an examiner send a Letter 3800 warning instead. Neither is a guarantee.

    The Greeley engineer takes whichever lane matches his income reporting, unless there is any sign someone knew of the FBAR and chose not to file. That calls for counsel first.

    What would the streamlined route cost the Denver engineer?

    Hypothetical: her Pune accounts held year-end balances of $61,000 (2023), $74,000 (2024), and $83,000 (2025), less in earlier years. Unreported interest totaled $15,800 across 2023 through 2025. At a 24 percent bracket, added federal tax is about $3,790 before foreign tax credits, plus interest. The offshore penalty is 5 percent of $83,000, or $4,150. Colorado tax on the added income is no more than about $700. The total is near $8,640 plus interest and fees.

    Outside the program, her four late FBARs (2021 to 2024) carry a non-willful ceiling of $66,144 before any tax deficiency.

    Does fixing the federal side start a Colorado clock?

    Yes, when federal taxable income changes. C.R.S. § 39-22-104 taxes “federal taxable income,” with state modifications. Under C.R.S. § 39-22-601.5(2)(a), amended federal returns trigger a federal adjustments report and payment within 180 days after the “final determination date,” which for an amended return is its filing date. The firm’s overview of Colorado state tax and DOR matters covers the state side.

    Factor Denver H-1B engineer Greeley rotation worker Fort Collins retiree
    Why a U.S. person Resident alien under 26 U.S.C. § 7701(b) U.S. citizen in Colorado Naturalized U.S. citizen
    What was missed FBARs and Indian interest income FBARs, including a signature-authority account FBARs only
    Non-willful ceiling $66,144 for 2021 to 2024 $16,536 per late year $16,536 per late year
    Best path after October 15 Streamlined domestic procedures Streamlined if income was missed; otherwise late FBARs Late FBARs with a reasonable-cause explanation
    Likely cost About $8,640 plus interest 5 percent of highest balance, or possibly nothing Nothing if reasonable cause is accepted
    Colorado follow-up Federal adjustments report within 180 days Only if federal returns are amended None

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is the October 15 FBAR deadline automatic, or must I ask for it?

    It is automatic. Federal law sets an April 15 due date with an extension to October 15 that FinCEN applies to everyone, with no form needed. For 2025 accounts, a report filed through the BSA E-Filing System by October 15, 2026 is on time, even though the Treasury regulation still mentions June 30.

    Do I need an FBAR if each of my foreign accounts is under $10,000?

    Possibly. The threshold adds together the highest values of all your foreign financial accounts during the year. Three accounts that each peaked at $4,000 total $12,000, which triggers the requirement, and every account must then be listed. Whether the accounts earned taxable income makes no difference.

    Does an H-1B visa holder living in Colorado have to file an FBAR?

    Usually. The FBAR rules treat resident aliens as United States persons, and most H-1B workers meet the substantial presence test. Once resident, they report home-country bank, deposit, and brokerage accounts whenever the combined maximum value tops $10,000 during the year.

    Is a Canadian RRSP or RRIF exempt from FBAR reporting?

    No. Rev. Proc. 2014-55 made the tax-deferral election automatic and retired Form 8891, but it expressly leaves the FinCEN Form 114 requirement in place. The FBAR retirement exception covers U.S. plans such as 401(k)s and IRAs, not Canadian ones, so an RRSP or RRIF belongs on the report.

    Can I still file late FBARs without a penalty now that the delinquent FBAR procedures are gone?

    Sometimes. The IRS took down those procedures in 2026 and now warns that late filing may bring penalties. The Internal Revenue Manual still says no penalty will be asserted when the failure was non-willful, had reasonable cause, and the late report is accurate, so a careful written explanation matters.

    Will fixing my FBARs require an amended Colorado return?

    Only if the fix changes federal taxable income. Late FBARs alone create no Colorado filing. Amended federal returns reporting foreign interest, as the streamlined procedures require, generally call for a Colorado federal adjustments report and payment within 180 days after the federal amendment is filed.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm helps Colorado individuals and families resolve missed FBARs and the income tax problems that travel with them, from streamlined submissions and reasonable-cause statements to FBAR penalty examinations. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is an attorney and CPA admitted to practice before the U.S. Tax Court, and he represents clients before the IRS on penalty abatement, unfiled and amended returns, and cross-border questions including expatriation and international tax. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    If October 15 is close, or already behind you, and it is unclear which of these profiles fits, sort that out before anything goes to FinCEN or the IRS. Contact North Star Law Firm to schedule a confidential review.


  • Colorado Contractors Short on Cash: Trust Fund Debts and Bankruptcy Choices

    Colorado Contractors Short on Cash: Trust Fund Debts and Bankruptcy Choices

    Builder insolvencies in Australia have roughly tripled in a few years, and commentary there focuses on insolvent trading rules that make directors pay personally. American law has no general counterpart. In Colorado, an owner’s personal risk arrives through a narrower door: progress draws owed to subs and suppliers, and payroll withholding owed to the IRS.

    A diverted draw can be nondischargeable, and withheld payroll tax, once converted into a penalty against a responsible person, is a priority tax no individual discharge reaches. Knowing how those debts behave lets an owner pick a path before a supplier’s lawsuit or a revenue officer sets the timing.

    Listen to this post

    North Star Tax and Legal Briefing: Colorado Contractors Short on Cash

    A five-minute audio version of this article. Trust fund draws, the Bullock intent standard, the payroll tax penalty that survives without it, and how a workout, Chapter 7, and Subchapter V compare.

    Download the MP3 · Episode page on Podbean

    Show / hide the episode transcript

    Builder failures in Australia have roughly tripled in a few years, and the commentary there is all about directors paying personally for trading while insolvent. American law has no rule like that. But if you run a construction company in Colorado and cash is getting tight, do not relax. Your personal risk arrives through two narrower doors. The first is the progress draw you spent on the wrong job. The second is the payroll tax you withheld from your crew and never sent to the I R S. One of those debts follows you out of bankruptcy only if a supplier can prove what you knew. The other follows you without anyone proving bad intent at all.

    Colorado has a trust fund statute for construction money. When an owner or general contractor pays a draw to a contractor or subcontractor, that money is held in trust for the subs, laborers, and suppliers who did the work that draw paid for. A draw on a Pueblo school remodel belongs to that remodel’s suppliers. The statute does not require a separate bank account for every job. It does require separate records of account for each project. Using a Loveland draw to pay Greeley invoices is the violation. And a violation is theft under Colorado law, which opens the civil theft remedy: three times actual damages, plus attorney fees. Here is the distinction to hold onto. The supplier’s claim is a state law trust claim. The I R S claim on withheld payroll tax is a federal priority tax. They behave very differently once you file.

    Start with the supplier. In a two thousand seven decision, the Colorado Supreme Court held that a trust fund claimant does not need a perfected mechanic’s lien, or even time left to file one. A supplier that let the lien deadline pass can still argue your draws were held in trust for it. The Tenth Circuit treats that statute as creating the kind of trust that lets the debt survive an individual’s discharge. The company form does not protect you either. Colorado courts hold anyone in complete control of the money personally liable.

    Now the point that cuts the other way. Since the Supreme Court’s Bullock decision in two thousand thirteen, the supplier has to prove you knew the money was trust money, or were grossly reckless about it. In the Cupit case, a roofing company owner who simply paid the oldest bills first did not have that mental state, until the day another supplier served him with a trust fund complaint. Everything diverted after that date was excepted from discharge and trebled as theft. In a second Colorado case the builder won outright: every vendor was paid, the records were adequate, and no culpable state of mind was proved. Records and notice decide these cases.

    Payroll tax works differently, and this is where owners get hurt. When you withhold income tax and the employee share of Social Security and Medicare, then use it to pay someone else, the I R S can assess a penalty equal to that withheld amount against every responsible person who willfully failed to pay it over. Willful does not mean evil. Paying other creditors instead is the evidence. And unlike the supplier, the I R S does not have to prove knowledge or recklessness at the discharge stage. That penalty is a priority tax that no individual discharge reaches, in Chapter seven, eleven, or thirteen. Owners pay suppliers first because the supplier is the one calling. The tax is the debt that survives anyway. The front end fix is boring: separate records for every job, and payroll deposits made before anyone else gets a check.

    So what does the company do? A workout has no automatic stay, so one civil theft lawsuit can unravel it. Chapter seven gives an L L C no discharge, and the company’s case does nothing for the owner personally. Subchapter Vee, for companies under the current cap of three million four hundred twenty-four thousand dollars, lets the company pay priority taxes over up to five years, and when the plan requires it, the court can send those payments to the trust fund taxes first, which shrinks the owner’s own penalty exposure. This week, pull the draw history and vendor payments for every open job and check that the money stayed with the project. Confirm your last two quarters of payroll deposits actually went in. If either number is off, get it reviewed before a demand letter or a revenue officer sets the schedule. That’s what we do at North Star Law Firm. The initial consultation is free, and the full written analysis with citations is at c o dash legal dot net.

    What does Colorado’s trust fund statute require when a contractor gets paid?

    Under C.R.S. § 38-22-127(1), funds disbursed to a contractor or subcontractor on a construction project “shall be held in trust” for the subs, laborers, and suppliers with lien or bond rights for the work that draw paid for. A draw on a Pueblo school remodel belongs to that remodel’s suppliers.

    Subsection (2) excuses a good faith dispute or setoff, and subsection (3) switches the statute off where the contractor posted a bond or the owner signed a written release. Subsection (4) requires “separate records of account for each project,” though not separate bank accounts. Using a Loveland draw to pay Greeley invoices is the problem. Subsection (5) makes a violation theft, which opens the civil theft remedy in C.R.S. § 18-4-405: three times actual damages plus attorney fees.

    A missed lien deadline does not end the exposure. On certification from the Tenth Circuit, the Colorado Supreme Court held that a trust fund claimant need not have a perfected lien or still be able to perfect one. Fowler & Peth, Inc. v. Regan, 151 P.3d 1281 (Colo. 2007). In the follow-on opinion, Fowler & Peth, Inc. v. Regan (In re Regan), 477 F.3d 1209, 1211 n.1 (10th Cir. 2007), the panel adopted the view that the statute “creates such a trust,” meaning the express or technical trust 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(4) requires. Colorado bankruptcy judges rely on that footnote.

    Can the owner of a Colorado LLC or corporation be personally liable?

    Yes, if the owner controlled the money. In Flooring Design Associates, Inc. v. Novick, 923 P.2d 216 (Colo. App. 1995), a vice-president who diverted trust funds to other corporate bills was held personally liable. Colorado bankruptcy courts apply the same rule to anyone in complete control of an entity’s finances. An LLC does not shield a member’s own handling of trust money.

    One boundary helps owners. In Yale v. AC Excavating, Inc., 2013 CO 9, an LLC manager’s own “survival loan” to his company was not trust money. Draws from an owner or general contractor remain trust funds, measured job by job, and a civil theft finding can triple the exposure.

    Colorado Contractor Behind on Suppliers or Payroll Tax? Contact Us Now

    How did Bullock change the discharge fight in Colorado?

    Before 2013, the Tenth Circuit BAP counted even a negligent failure to account as defalcation. In re Storie, 216 B.R. 283 (B.A.P. 10th Cir. 1997). Bullock v. BankChampaign, N.A., 569 U.S. 267 (2013), now requires “knowledge of, or gross recklessness in respect to, the improper nature of the fiduciary behavior.”

    In In re Cupit, 514 B.R. 42 (Bankr. D. Colo. 2014), aff’d, 541 B.R. 739 (D. Colo. 2015), a roofing company owner who paid the oldest bills first lacked that mental state until August 5, 2011, when another supplier served him with a trust fund complaint. Later diversions met Bullock: $47,775.56 was excepted from discharge and trebled to $143,326.68 as theft. In Fuller v. Clasby, Adv. No. 23-01212 (Bankr. D. Colo. Nov. 26, 2024), the defense won: the builder had paid every vendor, its cost breakdown satisfied subsection (4), and no culpable state of mind was proved. Records and notice decide these cases.

    Where do unpaid payroll taxes fit?

    Under 26 U.S.C. § 6672, the IRS can assess a penalty equal to unpaid withheld income tax and employee FICA against any responsible person who willfully failed to pay it over. IRS guidance says “no evil intent or bad motive is required,” and paying other creditors instead is evidence of willfulness.

    Unlike a supplier, the IRS need not prove knowledge or gross recklessness at the discharge stage. The penalty is a tax “required to be collected or withheld” under 11 U.S.C. § 507(a)(8)(C), and § 523(a)(1)(A) excepts it from an individual’s discharge. Owners often pay suppliers first, yet the tax is the debt that survives without proof of bad intent.

    How do a workout, Chapter 7, and Subchapter V compare?

    A workout has no automatic stay, so one civil theft lawsuit can unravel it. Chapter 7 gives a corporation or LLC no discharge under 11 U.S.C. § 727(a)(1); a trustee collects receivables and retainage and closes the company. Under § 524(e), the company’s case does nothing for the owner.

    Subchapter V eligibility runs through the small business debtor definition in 11 U.S.C. § 101(51D), which § 1182(1) adopts. Since the April 1, 2025 adjustment (90 Fed. Reg. 8941), the cap is $3,424,000; the temporary $7,500,000 limit sunset June 21, 2024. The Senate and House each passed bills in 2026 (S. 3977 and H.R. 7730) to restore $7.5 million, but neither is law at this writing.

    The plan is due within 90 days under § 1189(b) and can be confirmed without a creditor vote if it commits three to five years of disposable income under § 1191(c). Priority taxes must be paid within five years of the petition under § 1129(a)(9)(C), and United States v. Energy Resources Co., 495 U.S. 545 (1990), lets the court direct those payments to trust fund taxes first when the plan requires it, shrinking the owner’s penalty exposure.

    For a plan confirmed over objection, § 1192(2) withholds discharge of debts “of the kind specified in section 523(a).” The Fourth Circuit applied that to an LLC in Cantwell-Cleary Co. v. Cleary Packaging, LLC, 36 F.4th 509 (4th Cir. 2022), and the Fifth and Eleventh Circuits agree. The Tenth Circuit has not ruled.

    What might this look like for a Colorado Springs drywall subcontractor?

    Hypothetically, Quartzcrest Wallboard LLC (fictional) in Colorado Springs has one member, Dana. It received $640,000 in draws on three jobs near Briargate but owes its board and stud supplier $162,000 on them after Dana moved $118,000 to payroll and truck notes on a losing fourth job. It missed two quarters of Form 941 deposits totaling $84,000, of which $62,000 is trust fund tax. General contractors hold $71,000 in retainage, and the bank line is $260,000 with Dana’s guarantee.

    In Chapter 7, the LLC dissolves and Dana still faces $118,000 of trust fund exposure (up to $354,000 if theft is proved) and a $62,000 penalty that a personal Chapter 7 would not clear. In Subchapter V, the $84,000 runs about $1,400 a month over 60 months before interest, applied first to the $62,000 trust portion, while retainage and roughly $3,300 a month over three years retire the supplier’s $118,000.

    Debt Company in Chapter 7 Company in Subchapter V Owner’s personal exposure
    Diverted draws owed to supplier No entity discharge Paid through plan; § 1192(2) argument in a cramdown Liable if in control; nondischargeable only with Bullock intent
    Civil theft treble damages No entity discharge Plan treatment or settlement Nondischargeable with the base debt (Cupit)
    Withheld income tax and employee FICA Priority claim Paid within five years; can go to trust portion first § 6672 penalty; nondischargeable
    Employer share of FICA Priority claim Paid within five years Not part of the § 6672 penalty
    Bank line with guarantee Collateral liquidated Secured claim under the plan Guarantee generally dischargeable personally
    Retainage owed to company Collected by trustee Collected to fund the plan Held in trust for that job’s suppliers once received

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Does a Colorado supplier need a recorded mechanic’s lien to bring a trust fund claim?

    No. The Colorado Supreme Court held in 2007 that a claimant under C.R.S. § 38-22-127 needs neither a perfected lien nor time remaining to file one. A supplier that let the lien deadline pass can still claim that project draws were held in trust for it.

    Is putting all project money in one bank account a trust fund violation?

    Not by itself. The statute does not require a separate bank account for each project, so long as trust funds are not misspent. It does require separate records of account for each project, and without them a contractor struggles to prove where the money went.

    Can a trust fund claim be discharged in the owner’s personal Chapter 7?

    Sometimes. After Bullock v. BankChampaign, the supplier must prove knowledge or gross recklessness. Colorado bankruptcy courts have found that standard met after an owner was put on notice of trust fund duties, and not met where the owner lacked awareness or kept adequate records.

    Is the trust fund recovery penalty ever dischargeable?

    Not for an individual in Chapter 7, 11, or 13. It is treated as a priority tax the debtor had to collect or withhold. An owner can still dispute responsible-person status or willfulness, and a company plan can pay down the underlying taxes.

    Can an LLC in Subchapter V discharge a supplier’s trust fund claim?

    With a consensual plan, ordinary Chapter 11 discharge rules apply. For a plan confirmed over objection, three federal circuits hold that section 523(a) debts survive even for an LLC; the Tenth Circuit has not decided. The LLC’s discharge never releases the owner’s own liability.

    What is the Subchapter V debt limit right now?

    Since April 1, 2025, it has been $3,424,000 in noncontingent, liquidated debts, at least half from business activity. Bills to restore the lapsed $7,500,000 limit passed each chamber in 2026, so a contractor near the line should confirm the figure on the filing date.

    How North Star Law Firm Can Help

    North Star Law Firm represents Colorado contractors and business owners in Chapter 7 and Subchapter V cases in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to that court and to the U.S. Tax Court, so the firm can address the plan and the trust fund recovery penalty together. See the firm’s pages on Subchapter V reorganization, Chapter 7 bankruptcy, and discharging tax debt. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.

    The order in which draws, suppliers, and payroll deposits are addressed affects what survives a bankruptcy. To review the numbers before a demand letter or a revenue officer sets the schedule, contact North Star Law Firm.