Picture a Boulder software company, a Littleton family partnership fighting over the discount on a gifted interest, or a Western Slope ranch whose conservation easement the IRS values at a fraction of the deduction. Each of those disputes can land at the Tax Court’s Denver trial session, and each will turn on whose expert the judge believes. A precedential opinion issued September 2, 2026 changes how experts can be used before trial.
The opinion is Airbnb, Inc. & Subsidiaries v. Commissioner, 167 T.C. No. 9 (2026), Docket No. 12423-24, by Judge Emin Toro. It is a $4.2 billion transfer pricing fight, but its procedural rule applies just as well to a Colorado S corporation.
What did the Tax Court decide in Airbnb about expert declarations?
Both sides sought a discovery protective order under Rule 103 governing access to Airbnb’s source code. The Commissioner wanted the secured review room in Austin, Texas, where his software consultant worked, and attached two declarations from that consultant attacking Airbnb’s proposed terms. Airbnb moved to strike them as noncompliant expert reports.
The court refused. Rule 143(g)’s report requirements, it held, do not reach declarations filed to support a pretrial discovery motion. Rule 143 sits in the Title of the rules headed “Trials,” and subsection (g) is triggered only for a party “who calls an expert witness.” No trial had taken place, the IRS had not firmly chosen its trial experts, and the declarations dealt with discovery procedure rather than the merits. A footnote added that Rule 143(g)(3) can excuse a written report for testimony limited to industry practice, which described most of what the consultant said. Any legal opinion in the declarations, the court said, it would simply disregard.
What does Rule 143(g) require of a trial expert at the Denver Tax Court trial session?
At trial the rule is strict. Under Tax Court Rule 143(g), a retained expert must sign a written report containing every opinion with its basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, supporting exhibits, qualifications with publications from the past 10 years, cases from the past 4 years in which the expert testified, and the compensation being paid. The report is received as the expert’s direct testimony.
Timing is where Colorado petitioners get hurt. Once the case is calendared, reports must be served and submitted no later than 30 days before the call of the trial calendar. Late testimony is “excluded altogether” unless the party shows good cause and the opponent is not unduly prejudiced. And Rule 143(g)(3) says the court ordinarily will not excuse a report where the opinion rests on comparable sales or statistical data, which covers nearly every valuation or compensation study.
How far can an expert go on legal questions when appeal lies to the Tenth Circuit?
For a Colorado resident, or a corporation with its principal place of business here, 26 U.S.C. § 7482(b)(1) sends the appeal to the Tenth Circuit. Under Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970), aff’d, 445 F.2d 985 (10th Cir. 1971), the Tax Court follows controlling precedent of that circuit, and 26 U.S.C. § 7453 makes the Federal Rules of Evidence govern regular Tax Court cases.
The Tenth Circuit’s leading case is Specht v. Jensen, 853 F.2d 805 (10th Cir. 1988) (en banc). A lawyer-expert in a civil rights trial explained search and seizure law, then told the jury the searches were illegal. That exceeded Rule 702. The court drew a narrow line: an expert may refer to the law and use legal terms to explain facts, but “[i]n no instance can a witness be permitted to define the law of the case.” Since Rule 704(a) allows opinions on ultimate factual issues, a CPA can say a founder’s market pay was $150,000. Testifying that the pay “was reasonable under section 162” is a different matter.
Specht was a jury case, and the Tax Court sits alone. Airbnb quoted United States v. Brown, 415 F.3d 1257, 1269 (11th Cir. 2005): there is “less need for the gatekeeper to keep the gate when the gatekeeper is keeping the gate only for himself.” It also relied on Nationwide Transport Finance v. Cass Information Systems, Inc., 523 F.3d 1051 (9th Cir. 2008) and Torres v. County of Oakland, 758 F.2d 147 (6th Cir. 1985), which asks whether a witness’s word carries a legal meaning distinct from ordinary usage.
Does filing a consultant’s declaration give up the consulting-expert shield?
Rule 70(c)(4)(C) generally bars discovery of facts known or opinions held by a retained expert who is not expected to testify, absent exceptional circumstances. That lets a taxpayer test a position privately with a forensic accountant.
Airbnb did not rule on waiver. But a declaration on the public docket discloses exactly the opinions that rule protects, and the IRS will argue the door is open. If the consultant is later designated for trial, the declaration becomes cross-examination material, and Rule 70(c)(4)(B) already leaves discoverable any facts, data, or assumptions counsel gave a testifying expert. The safer course is to support a discovery motion with a fact witness or a second consultant and keep the trial expert off the motion papers. A Rule 103 order can then control how trade secrets, customer lists, or code are disclosed, including when and where.
| Issue | Trial expert report (Rule 143(g)) | Declaration on a discovery motion (Airbnb) | Consulting expert (Rule 70(c)(4)(C)) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Required contents | Opinions and reasons, data, exhibits, qualifications, publications, testimony list, compensation | No Rule 143(g) checklist | Nothing filed |
| Timing | 30 days before calendar call | With the motion or response | Any time |
| Discoverability | Drafts protected; counsel-supplied facts, data, assumptions are not | Public once filed | Generally barred absent exceptional circumstances |
| Impeachment risk | High on cross | High if declarant later testifies | Low while undisclosed |
| Who decides | Trial judge under Rules 702 and 143(g) | Motion judge, who may disregard legal opinion | Not offered as evidence |
What makes a forensic accountant’s Tax Court report hold up?
Since its 2023 amendment, Rule 702 requires the proponent to show it is “more likely than not” that the testimony rests on sufficient facts and reliable methods reliably applied. The Tax Court policed this before the amendment. In Boltar, L.L.C. v. Commissioner, 136 T.C. 326 (2011), a conservation easement case, it excluded the taxpayer’s appraisal entirely for skipping the before-and-after method, ignoring contiguous parcels, and assuming infeasible development, rather than admitting it and then giving it no weight.
From the accountant’s side, the reports that hold up list every assumption and say which came from counsel. Each number traces to a document the IRS can check. The writer applies the legal standard without arguing its meaning, and fees and prior testimony are disclosed plainly. Conceding a weak point openly often buys more credibility than any chart.
How would the pretrial calendar run for a Boulder S corporation?
Hypothetical. A Boulder software S corporation (call it the company) paid its founder no W-2 wages for 2023 and 2024 while distributing $420,000 each year. The IRS issues a notice of employment tax determination treating $195,000 a year as wages. The company petitions under 26 U.S.C. § 7436, which lets the court decide status and the proper amount of tax. Because the tax is under $50,000 per quarter, small case procedure is available, but § 7436(c) decisions cannot be appealed and need not follow the Federal Rules of Evidence. The company files as a regular case.
Say calendar call at the Denver session is Monday, June 7, 2027. The IRS demands every customer contract and the commit logs. Rule 70(a)(2) requires discovery motions at least 45 days before calendar call, so the protective order motion goes in by Friday, April 23, supported by the engineering manager’s declaration rather than the CPA expert’s. Reports are due 30 days out, a Saturday, so counsel serves Friday, May 7. The CPA puts market pay for the founder’s coding and management mix at $110,000 against the IRS expert’s $195,000, and stays on facts.
Tax Court Case With Expert Issues? Contact Us Now
For the earlier forum decision, see holding a Colorado notice of deficiency: Tax Court, refund suit, or bankruptcy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where does the Tax Court hold trials in Denver?
The court lists the Byron Rogers Federal Building, 1961 Stout Street, as its Denver place of trial. The notice of trial confirms the courtroom for each session.
Is a declaration attached to a discovery motion evidence at trial?
No. Rule 143(c) says ex parte affidavits and declarations do not constitute evidence, and Airbnb ruled that the Rule 143(g) report requirements do not apply to them.
Can my CPA testify that my position is correct under the tax code?
Not in that form. In a case appealable to the Tenth Circuit, Specht v. Jensen bars an expert from defining the law of the case, though the CPA can give factual opinions such as market compensation or value.
What happens if my expert report is served late?
Rule 143(g)(2) excludes the testimony altogether unless you show good cause and the delay does not unduly prejudice the IRS.
Can an industry practice witness testify without a report?
Possibly. Rule 143(g)(3) lets the court allow that for testimony limited to industry practice or rebuttal, but rarely for opinions built on comparable sales or statistical data.
Can a protective order keep my source code or customer list away from the IRS?
Rule 103 lets the court limit how a trade secret is disclosed and set the time and place of review, but it rarely blocks relevant discovery entirely.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm handles Tax Court litigation for Colorado individuals and closely held businesses, from the audit through expert discovery and trial, along with related tax defense work. The firm sees expert problems start well before trial, often when a consultant’s work gets filed without a plan, and Phillip’s forensic accounting and expert witness background shapes how reports are built and attacked. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.
If a valuation or compensation study will decide your Tax Court case, the deadlines run from the trial notice, not from when you feel ready. To review your calendar and expert plan, contact North Star Law Firm.









