Tomás runs a faith-based nonprofit in Pueblo that serves as the social services arm of a regional church body. It has a food pantry, a job-training program, a thrift store and 22 employees, and it has paid Colorado unemployment insurance premiums for years. After reading about a Supreme Court case out of Wisconsin, his board chair asked whether the organization ever owed those premiums and, if it does, whether there is a cheaper way to carry the risk.
Both questions turn on the Colorado unemployment tax religious exemption in C.R.S. § 8-70-140 and on how much Colorado case law survived the Wisconsin ruling.
Does Catholic Charities v. Wisconsin change Colorado’s religious exemption from unemployment tax?
It changes how the exemption may be applied, not its text. In Catholic Charities Bureau, Inc. v. Wisconsin Labor & Industry Review Commission, 605 U.S. 238 (2025), a unanimous Court held on June 5, 2025 that Wisconsin violated the First Amendment. The state had conceded that the Diocese of Superior controlled the charities, then denied the exemption because they did not proselytize and served people of every faith.
That, the Court said, is a denominational preference resting on “inherently religious choices,” so strict scrutiny applied under Larson v. Valente, 456 U.S. 228 (1982). Recasting the test as “distinctively religious activity” like worship did not help; that choice is theological too. The Court did not hold that every church-affiliated charity is exempt; it rejected one line Wisconsin drew. Justice Thomas added that the charities were an arm of the diocese however incorporated. Justice Jackson read the federal model language as asking what an organization does, not why, and called it “perfectly consistent” with the ruling for states to use that function test. On remand, the Wisconsin Supreme Court ordered the exemption granted on December 15, 2025.
Why does a Colorado 501(c)(3) owe unemployment premiums when it owes no FUTA?
Under 26 U.S.C. § 3306(c)(8), work for a 501(c)(3) is outside federal unemployment tax. But § 3309(a), enforced through the approval rules in § 3304(a)(6), makes each state cover those workers and offer nonprofits a reimbursement option. Every Colorado employer’s federal credit depends on that approval. Section 3309(b) then lets states exclude churches, church-controlled organizations run “primarily for religious purposes,” religious schools and ministers. Colorado copied that list into C.R.S. § 8-70-140(1), carving it out of C.R.S. § 8-70-118, which covers a 501(c)(3) with four or more workers in each of 20 weeks.
Federal payroll taxes are untouched: the organization still withholds and pays FICA under § 3121, thrift store clerks included. Ministers have dual status: ministry pay is outside FICA under § 3121(b)(8)(A), and they owe self-employment tax computed under § 1402(a)(8) unless they hold a § 1402(e) exemption. Intact 501(c)(3) status matters too; see the earlier post on automatic revocation and the Section 7428 deadline. A companion post this week addresses board exposure for unpaid payroll taxes.
What did Young Life, Samaritan Institute, Harbert and A Child’s Touch decide about C.R.S. 8-70-140?
The first major case involved a Colorado Springs ministry. In Young Life v. Division of Employment & Training, 650 P.2d 515 (Colo. 1982), the Colorado Supreme Court agreed Young Life was not a “church” because it had no membership, no congregation and no official tie to any denomination. It relied on Gillette v. United States and the absence of invidious motive. A footnote left the church-controlled organization clause undecided.
Samaritan Institute v. Prince-Walker, 883 P.2d 3 (Colo. 1994) then held that “the type of activity actually engaged in, rather than the motivation and impetus for the activity, is dispositive,” and noted the counseling network’s office did not “evangelize or proselytize.” Harbert v. Industrial Claim Appeals Office, 2012 COA 23, 272 P.3d 1190 applied that test to an Evergreen outreach founded by 21 churches. Its food bank, clothing help and resale shop were “not religious per se,” so the shop employee was covered.
A Child’s Touch v. Industrial Claim Appeals Office, 2015 COA 182, 411 P.3d 990 accepted that a Christian child care center had religious purposes and denied the exemption anyway. It was not “principally supported” by churches when it cut a maintenance worker in September 2013; the center had to show it “could not exist” without that support, and earlier audits finding it exempt did not help once its church closed.
Can CDLE still deny a church-affiliated charity the exemption because its work looks secular?
No published Colorado appellate decision has answered that since June 2025. The one later ruling I found, Christ’s Body Ministries v. Industrial Claim Appeals Office, No. 25CA0757 (Colo. App. Aug. 21, 2025) (unpublished), affirmed dismissal of a ministry’s appeal filed 24 days late. It had skipped the hearing on a former worker’s claim, believing its status settled since 2017. Appeals to the Panel must arrive within 20 calendar days under C.R.S. § 8-74-104(1).
My read: Harbert and Samaritan are the most exposed. Asking whether a church-controlled charity’s services are themselves religious, and counting the absence of proselytizing against it, is close to what the Supreme Court struck. Young Life leaned on Gillette, which the Court called “inapposite” when lines follow theology, so a church definition built on membership and rites is harder to defend.
The control and support prong is sturdier. Asking who appoints the board or whether the entity could survive without the church is structural, not theological. A Child’s Touch turned on it, and Young Life would likely still fail it. Justice Jackson’s function reading offers CDLE another path, but no majority has adopted it. The Tenth Circuit has no authority on § 8-70-140; these disputes move from a CDLE deputy to a hearing officer, the Panel and the Colorado Court of Appeals.
Can a Colorado religious nonprofit choose coverage or become a reimbursable employer?
Exemption is not a one-way door. Under C.R.S. § 8-76-107, an employer whose work is not “employment” may elect, with division approval, to be covered for at least two calendar years, so laid-off staff can draw benefits.
A covered 501(c)(3) can also choose under C.R.S. § 8-76-110 to reimburse the fund for regular benefits and half of any extended benefits its former workers draw, instead of paying premiums. The switch takes written notice at least 30 days before the calendar year and locks in for that year and the next. CDLE bills quarterly, due in 30 days, and may require a bond or deposit within 15 days, generally between 0.1 and 3.6 percent of prior-year covered payroll. Reimbursing employers sit outside § 8-76-102.5, home of the solvency surcharge. Whether an organization that opts in under § 8-76-107 may also reimburse is something I would confirm with CDLE in writing.
For past premiums, C.R.S. § 8-79-108 refunds amounts “paid erroneously,” without interest, but nothing paid before January 1 of the first of the five calendar years preceding the application. A November 2026 application reaches back to January 1, 2021. If CDLE refuses or sits on it for six months, the employer may sue in Denver District Court.
What would premiums, reimbursement and exemption cost a 22-employee Pueblo nonprofit in 2026?
Illustrative example (hypothetical facts, assumed rate). Payroll is $820,000: 18 full-time staff paid $750,000, each above the wage base, and four part-time thrift store clerks paid $70,000, each below it. The 2026 base is the first $30,600 per worker under C.R.S. § 8-70-103(6.5)(a)(VI), so chargeable wages are $550,800 plus $70,000, or $620,800. The 2027 base is indexed to average weekly earnings; I had not seen CDLE’s 2027 figure as of October 30, 2026.
Combined 2026 rates for positive-rated employers were reported at 0.72 to 4.58 percent. At an assumed 2.0 percent, premiums are $12,416, layoffs or not.
Under reimbursement, suppose two trainers are laid off when a grant ends, each drawing an assumed $560 a week for 20 weeks. CDLE bills $22,400, about $10,000 more than premiums. With no layoffs the bill is zero, so reimbursement rewards a stable payroll.
Exempt, the cost is zero and so is the coverage: the trainers would have no state claim on these wages.
| Question | Exempt religious organization (§ 8-70-140) | Covered 501(c)(3) paying premiums | Covered 501(c)(3) reimbursing (§ 8-76-110) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who decides | CDLE, often in a former worker’s benefit claim, subject to appeal | Default for a covered nonprofit | The organization, by notice at least 30 days before the year |
| What the organization pays | Nothing | Rate plus surcharges on chargeable wages ($12,416 in the example) | Benefits drawn plus half of extended benefits ($22,400 in the layoff year); possible bond |
| What laid-off employees receive | No state benefits based on those wages | Regular state benefits | The same state benefits |
| Risk if CDLE disagrees | Back premiums with interest and penalties | Low; if later found exempt, refunds reach back about five years | Election can be terminated for a missed bond or late payment |
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Catholic Charities v. Wisconsin apply in Colorado?
Yes. The First Amendment ruling binds Colorado agencies and courts, and C.R.S. 8-70-140 uses the same federal language. No published Colorado decision has applied it yet.
Is a church-run thrift store exempt from Colorado unemployment tax?
In Harbert (2012), the Colorado Court of Appeals said no for a church-founded outreach’s resale store. That activity-based reasoning is now in doubt, so church control and support facts matter more.
Can a Colorado nonprofit switch from premiums to reimbursement?
A covered 501(c)(3) can, by written notice at least 30 days before the calendar year. The election is locked for that year and the next, and CDLE may require a bond or deposit.
How far back can a Colorado nonprofit recover unemployment premiums it did not owe?
To January 1 of the first of the five calendar years before the refund application, under C.R.S. 8-79-108. Refunds carry no interest.
Does the unemployment exemption change FICA or federal withholding?
No. A 501(c)(3) still withholds income tax and pays FICA, and ministers follow their own self-employment tax rules.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm helps Colorado nonprofits and their boards with tax law questions, Colorado state tax matters, IRS employment tax audits and penalty abatement. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.
The reimbursement election and the refund lookback both run on calendar-year deadlines. If your Colorado ministry is sorting out its unemployment tax status, contact North Star Law Firm.
