Lorena owns two older apartment buildings in Pueblo through an LLC she owns alone: 46 units, one deed of trust to a regional bank, and an assignment of rents in the loan papers. The balloon came due in 2026, the bank would not extend, and the LLC filed Chapter 11 in Denver to buy time for a refinance. Rents run about $52,000 a month, and the gas bill, the manager’s payroll and the insurance premium are due before the bank calls back.
The bank’s first letter says every dollar of rent is its cash collateral. That is partly right, but a court can still let the LLC spend rents, and the answer turns mostly on what the LLC can prove in the first two weeks.
Can a Colorado landlord use rents in a Chapter 11 when the lender has an assignment of rents?
Only with consent from the bank or a court order. 11 U.S.C. § 363(a) puts encumbered “rents” inside the definition of cash collateral, § 363(c)(2) bars using them without consent or an order entered “after notice and a hearing,” and § 363(c)(4) requires the debtor to “segregate and account for” them meanwhile. Spending them anyway can be cause to convert or dismiss under § 1112(b)(4)(D).
Rents collected after the filing stay subject to the bank’s lien because of § 552(b)(2), added in 1994, which reaches them “to the extent provided in such security agreement” and “notwithstanding section 546(b).” Before that, Colorado courts asked whether the lender had perfected its rents interest under state law. Colorado is a lien theory state (C.R.S. § 38-35-117), and in Consolidated Capital Income Trust v. Colter, Inc., 47 B.R. 1008 (D. Colo. 1985), Judge Matsch called a mortgagee’s interest in apartment rents “an inchoate or passive lien.” In re RV Centennial Partnership, 202 B.R. 774 (Bankr. D. Colo. 1996) treated a receiver’s appointment, now governed by C.R.S. § 38-38-601, as the step that perfected it.
Now the loan documents carry most of the weight, read under Colorado law. As far as I can find, Colorado has not enacted the Uniform Assignment of Rents Act, and the Tenth Circuit has not construed § 552(b)(2). The court may trim the lien “based on the equities of the case,” but a debtor should not plan around that.
What does a cash collateral motion in the Denver bankruptcy court have to show?
Interim use is requested under L.B.R. 2081-1, for expedited motions in the first 21 days after the order for relief. The motion needs affidavits from someone with personal knowledge and must reach the U.S. Trustee within four hours after filing. Chambers tries to set a hearing within three days, and only an interim order issues.
L.B.R. 4001-2 requires a “line item budget for both the interim and final order periods.” Under Fed. R. Bankr. P. 4001(b)(2), the final hearing starts “no earlier than 14 days after” service, and until then the court allows only what is “necessary to avoid immediate and irreparable harm.” Section 363(p)(1) puts the burden of proving adequate protection on the debtor.
Lender Cutting Off Your Rents? Contact Us Now
Why did the Broadway Realty debtors lose, and should a Colorado landlord worry?
In In re Broadway Realty I Co., LLC, No. 25-11050 (DSJ) (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. June 29, 2025), 82 related New York apartment owners, each with its own Flagstar loan, asked to keep spending rents. Judge Jones denied the motion without prejudice. Some cushions were under 18 percent on the debtors’ own appraisals, the budget was consolidated though a property level version existed, and nobody could break down the professional fees.
Read it as a list of missing exhibits. The judge refused to wait for proof of harm, calling adequate protection “an explicitly prospective enterprise.” The cases ended in a liquidating plan confirmed in January 2026. A Colorado case with one lender and two buildings can close those gaps by building the numbers property by property.
How big an equity cushion does a Colorado bankruptcy judge need to see?
There is no Tenth Circuit percentage. In re O’Connor, 808 F.2d 1393 (10th Cir. 1987) treats adequate protection as a question of fact, decided “flexibly on the proverbial ‘case-by-case’ basis,” and reinstated an order letting debtors spend cash collateral backed by replacement liens. In In re Gallegos Research Group, Corp., 193 B.R. 577 (Bankr. D. Colo. 1995), Judge Krieger wrote that sufficiency “must be determined by the facts in each case,” and a small cushion or a long case can fall short.
The closest apartment case is In re Bluejay Properties, LLC, BAP No. KS-12-105 (10th Cir. BAP Mar. 12, 2014) (unpublished). A Kansas complex worth about $17 million secured a claim of slightly less than $14 million, and the panel held that “adequate protection” does not require “identical protection,” letting the debtor pay legal fees from rents. It persuades but does not bind. The familiar 15 and 20 percent figures come from cases the Broadway Realty opinion surveyed, not from any Colorado rule.
The CHFA Colorado Statewide Apartment Survey for the second quarter of 2026 puts Pueblo metro vacancy at 2.6 percent and average rent at $1,190, against 5.5 percent statewide, after vacancy rose across Colorado from late 2022 through 2025. That helps a Pueblo debtor.
What should the budget show, and can rents pay the lawyers?
As a forensic accountant, I want a rent roll for each building, a trailing twelve month operating statement, an escrow tied to actual bills, and a line for the U.S. Trustee’s quarterly fee under 28 U.S.C. § 1930(a)(6), which through 2030 is the greater of 0.4 percent of disbursements or $250 for quarters under $1 million. Professional fees go on a separate line, paid from other money unless the bank agrees.
Section 506(c) rarely rescues that line. It reaches reasonable, necessary costs of preserving the property only “to the extent of any benefit” to the lender, and lawyers hired to fight the lender do not benefit it. Property taxes qualify. Default interest and fees also shrink the cushion; see default interest and lender fees under section 506(b).
How would this play out for Lorena’s Pueblo apartment buildings?
This example is illustrative. Say the LLC filed Tuesday, November 3, 2026, the buildings appraise together at $4.9 million, and the bank is owed $4.1 million. The cushion is $800,000, about 16.3 percent of value, and $90,000 of asserted default interest and fees would cut it to about 14.5 percent. Alone, that proves little. Had the appraisal come in below the debt, United Savings Ass’n v. Timbers of Inwood Forest Associates, Ltd., 484 U.S. 365 (1988) would give the bank protection against decline only, nothing for delay.
Rents of $52,000, less $31,000 of operating costs including payroll and a $6,500 escrow, leave $14,500. At an assumed 4 percent nondefault contract rate, interest on $4.1 million is about $13,667 a month. A realistic offer under § 361 is that monthly interest, replacement liens on postpetition rents, and weekly reports. About $833 a month remains, before a quarterly trustee fee near $614.
The 46 units clear the “fewer than 4 residential units” carve out in § 101(51B), so the question is whether two buildings are “a single property or project.” If so, § 362(d)(3) requires a plan with “a reasonable possibility of being confirmed” or monthly interest at the “nondefault contract rate” within 90 days after the order for relief (February 1, 2027 here), or 30 days after a later SARE finding. Otherwise the stay lifts and the bank forecloses through the public trustee, as discussed in Colorado foreclosure after Obduskey.
Subchapter V is probably closed. The definition in § 101(51D) excludes “a person whose primary activity is the business of owning single asset real estate,” and the $3,424,000 debt limit in effect since April 1, 2025 (Federal Register notice of Feb. 4, 2025) is below the LLC’s debt. As of November 6, 2026, H.R. 7730, which would raise the limit to $7.5 million, had passed both chambers with no signature recorded, and it keeps the single asset exclusion.
Here is how the usual packages compare.
| Protection offered | What the debtor must prove | Typical interim result (general observation) | Risk to debtor and usual lender response |
|---|---|---|---|
| Equity cushion only | Current appraisal and stable value | Approved if wide; often denied when thin | Lender’s appraiser attacks the cap rate |
| Cushion plus monthly interest | Cushion and net rent to pay contract interest | Often approved when net rent covers it | Little cash left; lender disputes the rate |
| Replacement liens and reporting | Rents and occupancy will hold | Weeks at a time, tied to the budget | A shortfall reopens the fight |
| Consent with agreed budget | Terms that clear L.B.R. 4001-2 | Usually entered quickly | Lender seeks a § 506(c) waiver |
Frequently Asked Questions
Are apartment rents cash collateral in a Colorado Chapter 11?
Yes, if the deed of trust or a separate assignment gives the lender a security interest in rents. Section 552(b)(2) carries that interest into rents collected after filing.
Does my lender need a receiver before I file to claim the rents?
Generally not, after the 1994 amendment. Older Colorado cases turned on receivers and notice, but the security agreement now carries most of the weight, read under Colorado law.
How fast can the Denver bankruptcy court approve use of rents?
Chambers tries to hear an expedited motion within three days under L.B.R. 2081-1. That yields only an interim order; a final hearing waits at least 14 days after service.
Is a 20 percent equity cushion required in Colorado?
No Colorado or Tenth Circuit rule sets a number. Judges weigh the cushion with value trends, cash flow and the other protection offered.
Does the 90 day single asset deadline apply to my building?
Only if the property is single asset real estate, which excludes residential property with fewer than four units. Then the debtor needs a confirmable plan or monthly interest payments by day 90.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm represents Colorado property owners in Chapter 11 reorganizations, including cash collateral fights, and advises on Subchapter V eligibility and the tax side of a refinance or sale. Phillip Zagotti, JD/CPA, is admitted to the U.S. Tax Court and to the U.S. District Court and U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado. Phillip Zagotti is not licensed by the Colorado Supreme Court; for Colorado state-law questions the firm works alongside Colorado-licensed counsel.
A rents motion is won on proof. If your lender is trying to cut off the rents your buildings run on, contact North Star Law Firm.
